Hybrid Deterministic/Statistical Multi-scale Modelling Techniques for 3D Woven Composites

Lead Research Organisation: University of Bristol
Department Name: Aerospace Engineering

Abstract

Today, composite materials are at the forefront of an engineering revolution targeting lighter, more reliable, and more fuel-efficient aerospace structures. Advanced composites are made from layers of long fibres bound together using a matrix to form the structure. The most common fibre type used in aerospace applications are Carbon Fibres combined with an Epoxy matrix. More recently other types of fibres/matrix are being introduced, such as: ceramics matrix composites for high temperature applications and metal matrix composites for abrasion/ impact resistance. However, something common between all types of composites is that they are based on fibre layers. By definition, layers are 2D. As a result, all conventional composite materials struggle with direct loading in the third direction. While 2D composites provide designers with clear advantages coming from the superior properties of the fibres and the flexibility of tailoring fibre directions or combining different fibre types, through thickness performance remains an Achilles heel that have limited their full potential.

3D Composites is a viable solution to these issues as they are made from fibres woven in all three dimensions. These materials show a lot of promise as they can carry direct load through thickness and can resist impact events. However, there are a set of modelling challenges that come with using 3D composites, which have prevented engineers from taking full advantage of these materials. Traditionally, to understand a new material behaviour, engineers and scientists test samples of the material to characterise its behaviour. Then this characteristic behaviour is included in the mathematical models that can predict the behaviour of structures made from this material. These structure models are what is used as design tool. This conventional approach does not work for 3D composites. During manufacturing, the 3D network of woven fibres deforms around corners and other structural features to conform to the structure geometry. This in turn means that the fibre network will have a different architecture for each part of the structure and consequently will have its own characteristic behaviour. As a result, simple material testing is no longer descriptive of the material behaviour and an alternative approach is needed.

This project aims to train models to detected repeating patterns that exist in a 3D woven network of fibres across a structure. These repeatable patterns will be characterised using highly detailed models to understand how each pattern behaves under different loading conditions and as part of multiple structures. Using this approach, a parameterised database containing thousands of these repeatable patterns and their behaviour will be built using unsupervised machine learning. On the structure scale, the behaviour of a full structure can be assembled from the behaviour of the repeating patterns forming it regardless of its geometry. This approach will allow engineers, for the first time, to design both the structure and the 3D fibre network forming it simultaneously. Achieving this goal allows us to build aerospace structures that are lighter, consume less fuel to fly, cheaper and faster to produce. The concept of using statistical models for describing structural behaviour have been around for some time. However, these approaches have always been proposed as a black box solution that can give an answer regarding what will happen to a structural/material but not why it happened. In this project, a hybrid approach is used, which combines statistical models with physically based deterministic models. The hybrid approach provides information about the mechanical performance, as well as the underlying physical reasons regarding why a given behaviour happens. This will allow engineers and scientist to understand 3D composites behaviour at a much deeper level than is currently possible by the statistical or deterministic models alone.
 
Description This award was set to develop a modelling approach for 3D woven composites, which are a category of composites characterised by their complex internal architectures. These unique architectures give the material exceptional mechanical properties when compared to conventional composites. 3D woven materials have superior impact performance and high resistance to failure through thickness. This makes them ideal for numerous applications in the aerospace, automotive and energy sectors. However, the complex architecture behind the materials' unique performance is also one of the hindrances to its wide adoption in industrial applications, due to the complexity of their architectures and the lack of suitable modelling tools. This project set to employ 3D pattern recognition approaches to detect repeatable patterns within the architecture of these materials. These patterns called "material clusters" are stored in a database along how they behave under loading. This database is then used to train machine learning algorithms which can simulate the material behaviour in design and/or analysis problems. In the first year of this project, the team developed a novel technology to detect the material clusters and automatically populate the performance database. The team demonstrated that this technology can indeed be used to model the elastic response of 3D woven structures. In the second year, the team expanded the technology to cover damage initiation and progression. This was achieved through expanding the material cluster data-base to include history dependent response of the clusters. The research team is currently getting ready to finalise a structural scale simulation tool for 3D woven composites based on this technology.
Exploitation Route The outcomes of this award will be in the form of publications, software and modelling tools. The software and modelling tools can be transferred to industrial partners via knowledge transfer projects under the Impact Acceleration Account or KTP schemes. These tools are of relevance to wide the general advanced engineering industries.

The research team has set two industrialisation projects based on multi-scale modelling technologies, with major Aerospace OEMs. The first project funded by EPSRC IAA aim to transfer multiscale modelling technologies for use in aero-engine components analysis and design. The second project is industrially funded and it aims to explore the transfer of the technology developed in this grant to design and analysis of airframe parts.
Sectors Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software)

Energy

Manufacturing

including Industrial Biotechology

Transport

 
Description The multi-scale modelling framework developed in this grant constitutes a breakthrough in complex materials modelling on the structural scale. The framework brings several benefits over previously existing modelling approaches: 1. The framework can scale-up the impact of materials architecture, such as weave style, to the structural scale. This is achieved with limited increase in the computational cost, due to the framework's ability to pre-compute the material cluster response offline. 2. The framework can operate in the non-linear regime, which is often a challenge for multi-scale models. This ability makes the framework a valuable tool for design, analysis and certification of 3D woven structures. 3. The clustering approach has eliminated the need to model the material scale as a periodic medium. This feature enables the material design space to be explored, even if the material architecture is non-periodic as is the case in 3D woven composites. These capabilities have led to considerable interest from industry resulting in several industrially funded technology transfer project. These projects aim to evaluate the framework on new categories of material or implement it in industrial applications. The currently ongoing impact project relating to this grant are: 1. An EPSRC Impact Acceleration Account grant valued at £150,000 with £80,000 industrial direct industrial funding. The project, in collaboration with Rolls-Royce plc, aims to integrate multiscale modelling in the design cycle of aeroengines. Expected completion date June 2024. 2. A multi-phase research project funded by Airbus, phase #1 started in January 2024 and is valued at £135,000. This project aims to implement the technology developed in this grant to Non-Crimp Fabrics. Expected completion date for phase #1 is December 2024, with phase# 2 scheduled to start early 2025. 3. A team of University of Bristol academics is currently working on a spinout aiming to bring woven materials simulation tools to the market, under the name SIMTEX. The team have successfully completed the InnovateUK ICURe pre-accelerator discover programme. An ICURe explore application is currently in preparation. The technologies developed in this grant forms a part of the technology behind this spinout.
First Year Of Impact 2023
Sector Aerospace, Defence and Marine
Impact Types Economic

 
Description A Demonstration Of Multi-scale Modelling Of Non-Crimp Fabrics
Amount £20,000 (GBP)
Organisation Airbus Group 
Sector Academic/University
Country France
Start 12/2022 
End 01/2023
 
Description EPSRC Doctoral Prize to Jagan Selvaraj on Multilevel data-driven methods for high-fidelity adaptive damage modelling
Amount £70,000 (GBP)
Funding ID EP/W524414/1 
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2022 
End 10/2024
 
Description Integration Of Data-Driven Multiscale Modelling in The Design Cycle of Aero-Engine Components
Amount £80,000 (GBP)
Funding ID A100419 
Organisation Rolls Royce Group Plc 
Sector Private
Country United Kingdom
Start 12/2022 
End 04/2024
 
Description Integration Of Data-Driven Multiscale Modelling in The Design Cycle of Aero-Engine Components
Amount £49,998 (GBP)
Funding ID A100419 
Organisation University of Bristol 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2022 
End 04/2024
 
Description Calibrating Macro-scale Models of 3D Woven Composites 
Organisation Chalmers University of Technology
Country Sweden 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution In this partnership, my team hosted a visiting PhD student from the University of Chalmers throughout 2022. Our role focused on developing high fidelity models of 3D woven composites under cyclic loading, and conducting experimental testing in the BCI labs. The experimental tests were conducted on 3D woven carbon fibre epoxy samples with Digital Image Correlation. The outputs from the testing campaign where use to calibrate a macro-scale material model for progressive damage in 3D woven composites developed at Chalmers.
Collaborator Contribution The Chalmers team (Carolyn Oddy, Magnus Ekh and Martin Fagerstrom) has developed a macro-scale progressive damage model for 3D woven composites. Carolyn Oddy, visited the University of Bristol several times to participate in the experimental testing and work with our team. Additionally, , the Chalmers group provided source codes for the macro-scale models and calibration tool vs experimental and modelling data.
Impact Carolyn Oddy, Ioannis Topalidis, Bassam El Said, Magnus Ekh, Stephen Hallett, Martin Fagerström, Calibrating Macro-scale Models of 3D Woven Composites: Complementing Experimental Testing with High Fidelity Meso-scale Models, Composites Meet Sustainability - Proceedings of the 20th European Conference on Composite Materials, ECCM20, Lausanne, Switzerland, June 2022.
Start Year 2021
 
Description Industrial Partners Contribution - BAE-Systems 
Organisation BAE Systems
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The project team conducts cutting edge research on material clustering and disseminates the results to industrial partners .
Collaborator Contribution BAE - Systems support the research programme and participates through provision of end-use industrial steer, guidance and participation progress reviews . Designated experts from our Manufacturing & Materials Technology team support and monitor the programme. They also help identify further exploitation and collaboration opportunities as the project advances.
Impact No outputs from this partnership in the 1st year of the grant
Start Year 2021
 
Description Industrial Partners Contribution - National Composite Centre 
Organisation National Composites Centre (NCC)
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution The project team conducts cutting edge research on material clustering and disseminates the results to industrial partners .
Collaborator Contribution Staff time and access to the key specialists at the NCC to guide the research and maximise the industrial impact through selection of possible applications. This includes an active contribution to the project steering board/review panel, as part of the governance structure . Promote dissemination of the research results and output to a wide range of industrial and academic stakeholders by inviting the team of researchers to deliver through the NCC up to two seminars on the latest research progress.
Impact Support from the NCC for further UKRI funding through an ongoing proposal (submitted).
Start Year 2021
 
Description Industrial Partners Contribution - Rolls-Royce 
Organisation Rolls Royce Group Plc
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution The project team conducts cutting edge research on material clustering and disseminates the results to industrial partners .
Collaborator Contribution Rolls-Royce is supporting this project by making available staff time for their technical experts to attend and actively participate in review meetings, and to provide advice and industrial relevance throughout the project. Rolls-Royce provides examples of real applications to be used in the project as case studies. In particular, relevant experimental data from a previous composite research project made available to assist in development and validation of the numerical models within this proposal.
Impact Support from Rolls-Royce for further UKRI funding through an ongoing proposal (submitted).
Start Year 2021
 
Description Multi-scale Modelling And Characterisation Of Non-Crimp Fabrics 
Organisation Airbus Group
Department Airbus Operations
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution The team at the University of Bristol will conduct multi-scale characterisation using modelling and experiments for the material of interest. The novel modelling techniques developed in the main grant are applied to this new material to support its industrial use.
Collaborator Contribution The industrial partner provided £135,000 cash contribution, in addition to material samples, manufacturing and design technical know how. And insight into the industrial use cases of the materials.
Impact The collaboration is still ongoing
Start Year 2024
 
Description Airbus Toulouse - University of Bristol workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact In November 2023, a team from Airbus Toulouse and Airbus Filton visited the University of Bristol. Our team gave a workshop on multiscale modelling of 3D Woven composites. The event lead to a demonstration study funded by Airbus, see the further funding section. Further discussions are taking place at the moment to secure additional longer term funding.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description D-Standart First Technical Workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact D-Standart is an EU funded consortium brining a wide range of academic and industrial partners together from across the EU and UK. The project aims to develop rapid methods to characterise fatigue damage in composites and sustainability of composite supply chains ; and thereby model the durability and sustainability of large-scale composite structures with arbitrary layups under realistic conditions (loads, environment, manufacturing imperfections).The Third General Assembly of the D-STANDART Project took place on the 07th of February, followed by the First Consortium Technical Workshop. Both events were hosted by TUD, in Delft (Netherlands), and AB members were invited as special guests to join the second day. This unique and special gathering was a great opportunity for the 35 participants to provide a deeper and common understanding of the main aspects addressed by the project. The workshop triggered important discussions on how to perform data analysis, interfaces between work packages. Dr. Bassam El Said gave a talk on multi-scale modelling of composite structures which lead to discussions and plans for future collaboration between the D-Standart. HSD-Multiscale and CerTest programme grant.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2024
URL https://d-standart.eu/third-general-assembly-first-technical-workshop/
 
Description Engagement with Composite Smart Industrial Control (CoSInC) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact An engagement event with National Composites Centre team from work package 4 of Composite Smart Industrial Control (CoSInC), an ATI programme, took palace in April 2022. The two research teams exchanged ideas about their future research plans and directions. The participants have identified a clear are of overlap with regards to the industrial application of multi-scale modelling of composites. The teams are currently in discussion to set-up a joint research activity.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Partner Engagement Meeting 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact As part of the award, dissemination meetings are held with the industrial partners to update on the award progress. The first meeting was attended by representative from BAE-Systems, Rolls-Royce plc and the National Composites Centre. Industrial partners recognised the importance of our research and its potential industrial impact. The attendees agreed to continue engagement with the research project to guide the future development direction.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022