High-Performance Heat-Powered Heat-Pumps (HP3)

Lead Research Organisation: University of Nottingham
Department Name: Faculty of Engineering

Abstract

The UK has made considerable progress decarbonising its power sector. However, decarbonising space-heating has been much more challenging. Currently, space-heating accounts for ~1/3 of the country's CO2 emissions. This must change to achieve Net Zero

Two main low-carbon heating solutions are being considered: 1) direct heating from hydrogen combustion in boilers and 2) electrically-driven heat-pumping. Although both are promising, there are serious challenges to overcome.

National Grid and other gas network operators have confirmed the technical feasibility of distributing hydrogen through the existing gas infrastructure, which connects >23 million properties. Hydrogen boilers are not commercially available yet, but they are well underway. Hydrogen can be made from renewable electricity; however, a big downside is that when combusted in boilers, the amount of energy we recover is only ~60% of what we spent making it. It is not a very efficient process.

Electric heat pumps have a much higher efficiency. The amount of heat they provide can be as much as 3x the amount of electricity they consume. So, for every 1kWh of electricity used, a heat pump will give 3kWh of heat. This in stark contrast to the 0.6 kWh that would be obtained if the same 1kWh of electricity was used to make hydrogen, and that hydrogen was combusted in a boiler.

Although it seems like using electric heat pumps is the way to go, there is a major problem. The electricity grid does not have the capacity to support their use in any significant fraction of UK homes.

The reason for this is the huge energy demand for heating purposes. During winter, the peak demand in the gas network is more than 4x than the peak demand in the electricity grid. But also, during the first few hours of each day, the gas network experiences power-ramps that are 10x greater than what the electricity grid sees. The electricity grid does not have the capacity to provide the same levels of energy and power as the gas network. The upgrades required to enable the electricity grid to take on the gas network's duty are too expensive to be viable.

It is precisely these challenges that are holding back the UK's transition to low-carbon heating.

This postdoctoral fellowship addresses this issue by investigating and developing a deep understanding of a novel set of technologies called 'High-Performance Heat-Powered Heat-Pumps (HP3)'. These innovative heating systems combine the best attributes of the two main low-carbon options being considered (hydrogen boilers and electric heat pumps) and at the same time, removes their drawbacks.

The widespread adoption of HP3 systems will enable the gas network to distribute hydrogen to homes across the country and therefore to continue to supply the enormous demand for energy during winter. HP3 systems deliver a greater benefit per unit of H2 consumed in comparison to hydrogen boilers. This will help the gas network to supply hydrogen to even more homes but also, consumers will enjoy reduced bills. By keeping the gas network in service, the use of HP3 systems will avoid placing an overwhelmingly large load on the electricity grid that would be created if the country adopted electrically-driven heat-pumping.

This fellowship will develop detailed computational models to simulate the operation of HP3 systems in order to understand the effect that different design and operational variables have on their performance. Special focus will be given to exploring ultra-high operating pressures at this can lead to reductions in the overall cost of the units. A laboratory prototype will be developed and tested to demonstrate the functionality concept.

This work has real prospects to be transformational in two different ways: (i) triggering a step-change in the UK 'boiler industry' towards more sophisticated and much higher-value products and (ii) accelerating the achievement of Net Zero by improving affordability.
 
Title GB Electricity Grid Model 
Description This is a set of MATLAB scripts that allow the user to model the electricity system in the UK The user can explore the effect of different shares of wind and solar power, different proportions of "over-generation" And more importantly, different percentages of adoption of HEAT PUMPS The model then calculates the energy storage capacity that the electricity grid needs and how this affects the cost per MWh of electricity The model uses a dataset compiled and processed by the researcher (B. Cardenas). This data was obtained from a number of sources, including Elexxon and Gridwatch The dataset contains 12 years of electricity demand , wind and solar PV data for the UK It also cotnains time-series of the heat demand of average property in the UK 
Type Of Material Computer model/algorithm 
Year Produced 2024 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact A paper which uses this dataset and model is under development This will be presented at the next UKES 2024 conference ( in April 2024). An abstract has been accepted The impact will be an increased awareness that electrical heat pumps may not be the miracle solution they appear to be as the electricity grid cannot support their widespread use This will help to introduce the audience to the HP3 concept 
 
Description Research and Innovation Committee of the European Heat Pump Association 
Organisation European Heat Pump Association
Country Belgium 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Thanks to me having this EPSRC Fellowship I was invited to form part of the Research and Innovation committee of the European Heat Pump Association I have joined two of the consortium meetings since July 2023 with a third scheduled for the 4th of April During these meetings the group reviews new heat pump development (focusing on RD&I and projects). I have contributed with a brief technical assessment of what the different parties present. Listening to the community has been beneficial to my research as it keeps me up to date on what are the latest "real world" heat pump development and ongoing projects. Early this year I also joined as External Advisory Board of the BEST-storage project (Building Energy Efficient System Through Short And Long Spectrum Thermal Energy Storage), which is funded by Horizon Europe. (https://cordis.europa.eu/project/id/101096516)
Collaborator Contribution In one of the meetings I talked about the work I'm doing as part of the "High-Performance Heat-Powered Heat Pumps" Fellowship. This was a valuable opportunity for two reasons: 1) I received feedback and suggestions from experts in the field and 2) I raised awareness of the work being carried out in the UK. I consider the time of the several experts (academic /industrial) present during that meeting to have a value of £1000. The consortium has also helped me establish contacts with European stakeholders with a view to participate and /or apply to funded projects in the near future.
Impact There have not been any outputs our outcomes from this collaboration yet. One of the main expected outcomes is a partnership with European collaborators to apply and participate in a larger funded project. The HP3 project has not run long enough to have concrete results n this sense but progress has been made.
Start Year 2023
 
Description Attendance to Consortium Meetings of European Heat Pump Association 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact I introduced the concept of "HP3" in a meeting held by the European Heat Pump Association
In the meeting there were between 80-100 delegates of academia and industrial stakeholders across Europe
It sparked questions and discussion afterwards and I received valuable feedback
The outcome of this interaction is that the memberso f the EHPA are now aware of work being carried out in the UK (my research) and engaging with them in the future for potential collaboration will be easier
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
 
Description Presentation given to Scottish Power 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact The purpose of this meeting and presentation was to invite Scottish Power to join us (team at the University of Nottingham) and apply for a "Strategic Innovation Fund (SIF)" project based on HP3
I received very positive feedback from Scottish Power, which helped to steer my thinking
I also gained insight into what they are doing and what they see as the most likely future scenarios (in terms of heat decarbonisation)
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
 
Description Series of Meetings with Vital Energi 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact The purpose of these meetings was to convince Vital Energi to form a joint venture with the research team at the University of Nottingham and apply for a "Strategic Innovation Fund (SIF)" project.
During the meetings I spoke with different members of Vital Energi (at different levels) and gave presentations on my research
The presentations sparked Vital Energi's interest and we had positive and interesting discussion afterwards
I received valuable feedback and gained insight into what industry are doing.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
 
Description Series of meetings with SGN 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact The purpose of these meetings was to convince SGN to form a joint venture with the research team at the University of Nottingham and apply for a "Strategic Innovation Fund (SIF)" project.
During the meetings I spoke with different members of SGN (at different levels) and gave presentations on my research
The presentations sparked SGN interest and we had positive and interesting discussions afterwards
I received valuable feedback and gained insight into what industry are doing.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
 
Description Undegrad Projects 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Undergraduate students
Results and Impact I have been mentoring 2 undergraduate mechanical engineering students
They are dong their 4th year projects on the HP3 technology
The purpose of this was to disseminate the concept and teach them about the challenge of decarbonising heat , and the very specific situation of the UK
As a result of our interaction, they now have a much better understanding of the area and their interest in it has grown.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023