Global Income Inequality, c1880-1960

Lead Research Organisation: University of Sussex
Department Name: Sch of History, Art History & Philosophy

Abstract

This project will calculate new estimates of world inequality in the period from the end of the nineteenth century until the 1960s, based on the results of household expenditure surveys. The current consensus is that all of the post-industrial revolution increase in inequality amongst world citizens occurred before about 1950. This conclusion has largely been reached on the basis of the analysis of global measures of inequality derived from the national accounts in conjunction with various proxy measures. This project takes a different approach. We plan to investigate inequality in this period using much better, household level, data. There are strong arguments, advocated by the World Bank among others, for investigating inequality using evidence from household surveys suitably adjusted for cost of living differences. This has not generally been carried out for the pre-1950 period at a global level, possibly because the extent of recoverable household expenditure survey evidence has not been fully appreciated. Our investigations have located a vast cache of household expenditure surveys for the period. Thus far, we have identified around 800 household surveys from around the world, carried out between the 1880s and 1960s, of which around 381 are of sufficient scope as to be potentially useful for the investigation of inequality. The geographical spread of these surveys is truly global: 71 from Western Europe; 10 from Eastern Europe; 53 from South and Central America; 37 from Africa and the Caribbean; 88 from Asia; 7 from the Middle East, 110 from North America and 5 from Australia and Polynesia.

We will extract the reported demographic and expenditure data by income group from these reports and use them to estimate parameters of the income distribution. Using these estimates, we will investigate the changing nature of inequality within a number of key nation states, and also investigate the time path and geography of global inequality 1880-1960. In addition, we would use these data to estimate other indicators of living conditions, such as nutritional attainment, which may provide further insights into the impact of industrialisation on inequality. The research outlined in this proposal is likely to transform our understanding of the history of global living standards during the first half of the twentieth century and the distributional consequences of long-term economic growth. It has the potential, equally, to transform our understanding of policy designed to reduce inequality. The project will also bequeath a collection of data-sets with significant potential for future use.

Planned Impact

We plan a partnership with The National Archives Education Department to disseminate the results of our research to history secondary school pupils from the UK, with secondary school teachers acting as agents for knowledge transfer. In partnership with The National Archives Education Department, we have developed a Teacher-Scholar programme for History teachers for our earlier British Living Standards Project. Building on the success of this scheme (link to BLS website report) we plan a similar scheme. In year 4 of the project, a cohort of teachers will engage with the project's original databases, and the project's research findings, to develop lesson plans relating to world inequality. The analysis of inequality, and how that has changed since the end of the nineteenth century, could be adopted as part of the History National Curriculum 'World Study after 1900' module. These lesson plans will be available through the project's web page, the TNA Education webpage and will be freely downloadable to any school teacher in the UK.The TNA Education website currently has in the order of 9 million hits per annum. It will be possible to provide precise quantitative records of the number of lesson plans downloaded. The effectiveness of this scheme will be independently evaluated by an external academic evaluator.

The outreach project is targeted at Key Stage 3, 4 and 5 secondary school history students in the UK. In 2012, there were over 220,000 GCSE History candidates and 49,000 'A' Level History candidates. In our view, the most effective way of informing these students is through their teachers and History teachers' professional associations. The primary professional organisation for History teachers is the Historical Association, which has a membership of over 4,500 teachers in both primary and secondary education and a further 1,500 individuals in higher education and the wider history community. We plan a plenary session at the HA 2016 conference that will showcase the results of our Teacher-Scholar programme. The Head of Education at TNA, Andrew Payne, would act as internal advocate and provide liaison with the Sussex team.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description (i) Significant new knowledge generated. We have added significantly to the knowledge base on household expenditure surveys. To date, our archival research has located 1326 surveys from around the world carried out between 1880 and 1965 (348 Europe, 186 North America, 166 Central & South America, 455 Asia, 165 Africa, 6 Oceania), of which around 500 have data suitable for the analysis of inequality for 46 countries. Thus far, we have utilised the data extracted from these surveys to (a) estimate income inequality in the UK, Western Europe and Latin America. For the UK and Europe we have found little evidence of declining inequality across working households during the first half of the twentieth century. This is inconsistent with the Kuznets' hypothesis of declining inequality in advanced stages of industrialisation. Related to this, we find that the changing nature of survey design and implementation (the expansion of the target group from sections of the working class to all households and the application of random sampling methodology), accounts for most of the apparent rise in measures of income inequality derived from the survey data. Much of the increase in inequality during the first half of the twentieth century disappears when these changes are controlled for. (b) estimate nutritional attainment in Western Europe and the USA at the end of the nineteenth century and beginning of the twentieth century. We find that at the end of the nineteenth century, diets provided significantly less energy in Germany and France than they did in Britain, though unsurprisingly, British diets lagged behind those of US households at this time. During the first half of the twentieth century, estimates of energy availability from British working households diets increased significantly, driven by both changing fertility (and associated reduction in average household size) and rising real incomes. For those not in employment, and among female headed working households, however, there was no or little improvement in per capita energy availability until at least the onset of WW2. (ii) New or improved methods of skills developed. In order to undertake this research we faced several technical challenges, which we have overcome. (a) with respect to household income inequality the challenges have been developing methods of estimating a range of inequality measures from grouped data and making like-for-like comparisons across time and place as methods of survey investigation have improved; (b) developing methods of converting expenditures on foods into estimates of quantities of foods and hence nutritional availability. (iii) important new research questions opened up. Our research has created an historical platform from which the rise of the obesity epidemic can be analysed for some advanced industrial countries.
Exploitation Route We intend to create a chart book of historic income inequality and investigate integrating this with similar, but contemporary, web-resources (such as World Institute for Development Economics Research, who currently maintain a web-based data resource on world inequality post 1965). Our research thus far provide us with an historical platform from which it is possible to investigate changes in diet during the period in which obesity emerged. We have developed a network of researchers working on food, diet and nutrition in Western Europe over the last century, through a two-day workshop held at the University of Sussex in 2017. We have also found that this material works well for the teaching of comparative history in secondary school classes, through the Sussex Teacher-Scholar scheme in 2017 ( carried out in partnership with The National Archives Education Department). Later in 2018 the lesson plans devised by teachers using material from this project will be freely available from the TNA Professional Development portal.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Education,Environment,Healthcare,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL http://www.sussex.ac.uk/globalincomeinequality/
 
Description The Global Income Inequalities Teacher Scholar Programme September-December 2017 The University of Sussex & The National Archives Aims of the Programme The primary aim is to challenge, inspire and support secondary school teachers in the development and your use of original source material to teach about the income and living standards of working families around the world between 1850 and 1960, and to do so through building an online community of professionals who will continue to work with us and with each other beyond the life of the programme. We hope that teachers on this programme will share their experience and expertise with colleagues within their own school communities and beyond, and encourage them to develop their own professional practice in recognising the value of archival collections for education. In short we aim to build a network of teachers in the UK who become advocates for the programme and for the source-based, enquiry led approach to History which The University of Sussex and The National Archives are so passionate about. The collection of resources developed by the programme group will bring a fresh perspective to the subject of global living standards between the mid-19th and 20th centuries. Findings of researchers at The University of Sussex and archival collections held by The National Archives provide a truly outstanding collection of sources. Finally, we aim to support teachers in their own professional development by working with some of the best historians and teaching professionals in the field. Some of the latest research and perspectives on the subject of global living standards will be provided by: ? Prof. Ian Gazeley - Professor of Economic History at University of Sussex ? Dr Rose Holmes - ESRC Research Fellow, University of Sussex ? Dr Kevin Reynolds - ESRC Research Fellow, University of Sussex ? Dr Cecilia Lanata Briones - ESRC Research Fellow, University of Sussex In addition to this, the seminar weekends in October and the online programme will be led by: ? Andrew Payne - Head of Education & Outreach, The National Archives ? Ben Walsh - one of the leading thinkers, researchers and trainers in History education. Ben has worked extensively with The National Archives over the past decade and we are indebted to his support for this programme.
First Year Of Impact 2017
Sector Education
Impact Types Societal

 
Title Global Income Inequality 1880-1965 Database 
Description This database provides a bibliographic listing of all known household expenditure surveys from over eighty counties from around the world. We have extracted the data from a sub-section of these surveys and calculated measures of inequality for about fifty countries 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2018 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact This database was only made live in april 2018, so it is too early to fully assess its impact. However, these data have resulted in a number of discussion papers and through these we have already received media and data access inquiries. 
URL http://www.sussex.ac.uk/globalincomeinequality/surveys/database
 
Description Sussex Teacher Scholar Scheme 2 
Organisation The National Archives
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution In partnership with The National Archives Education Department, we developed a Teacher-Scholar programme for History teachers. A 'teacher scholar' could be defined as a teacher who becomes expert on a particular topic through academic activities, such as attending lectures, reading, and examining primary 'evidence' (such as documents, statistics, etc), and then uses this knowledge to inform the lessons they write. The lessons developed by the teacher scholars would be shared with other teachers who did not attend the programme by being made available to download online. The The Global Income Inequality Project developed a Teacher-Scholar scheme, which built on our experience with a similar scheme undertaken for the ESRC British Living Standards Project. Through the autumn of 2017, a cohort of eight teachers engaged with the project's original databases, primary documents held at TNA and the project's research findings, to develop lesson plans relating to inequality, poverty and affluence around the world during the period 1880-60. These lesson plans will be available through the project's web page and TNA Professional Development pages, and freely downloadable to any school teacher in the UK. The selected teachers received five pre-recorded lectures and attended two virtual seminars, a two-day workshop and a two-day fieldtrip. At the workshop the teachers received training on how to use the datasets and developed lesson plan ideas. On the fieldtrip/seminar weekend the teachers grounded and explored some of the academic questions about living standards. The teachers developed 19 lesson plans with resources (such as PowerPoint slides and worksheets) on a variety of topics using the datasets developed by the Sussex team. The lessons catered for students aged between 11 and 18, in Key Stage 3 through to A-level stage.
Collaborator Contribution The TNA Education Department has acquired experience of running these schemes with a range of UK and US Higher Education establishments. They also have also established a network of school teachers who have participated in one or more of these schemes. TNA also provided an experienced facilitator to work with teachers in developing their classroom resources.
Impact (i) Knowledge transfer to UK school children through teachers classroom activities devised in collaboration with the Global Income Inequality team. (ii) professional development for UK school teachers on the scheme.
Start Year 2017
 
Description Food and Nutrition in 19th and 20th Century Europe Conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact International workshop on food and nutrition in 19c & 20c Europe, concentrating on evidence from household expenditure surveys
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
URL https://food-and-nutrition-conference.uk/
 
Description Inequality article in The Conversation 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact This was an invited article on the recent historical background to the rise in economic inequality within the western countries. Some correspondence with financial journalists ensued. The main thesis of the article was informed by the results of the Global Income Inequality project.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL https://theconversation.com/thatcher-reagan-and-robin-hood-a-history-of-modern-wealth-inequality-756...
 
Description Workshop on Household Budgets & Historical Living Standards,Clio-infra, Amsterdam 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The Dutch Clio-infra/Clariah project organized a small workshop, where experts from all over the world discussed which household Budget datasets they are building, and how they approach the methodological issued raised by the use of historic household budget material
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016