Mental Health, Migration and the Chinese Mega-City

Lead Research Organisation: King's College London
Department Name: Social Science, Health and Medicine

Abstract

We have known, since at least the early twentieth century, that there is an association between living in a city and being diagnosed with a mental illness. But questions around the specificity of relationship between urban life and have continued well into the twenty-first century. We still don't know, for example, exactly why mental illness clusters in cities; we don't know how it relates to experiences of urban poverty, deprivation, overcrowding, social exclusion, and racism; and we don't know the precise biological and sociological mechanisms that turn difficult urban lives into diagnosable mental health conditions. What we *do* know is that migrants into cities bear a disproportionately large share of the burden of urban mental illness; we know that dense living conditions seem to exacerbate the problem; and we know that the general stress, tumult and precarity of urban living can, sometimes, create the basis for the development of clinical problems.

If there are unanswered questions around the relationship between mental health and the city, these questions are particularly acute in contemporary China: China has urbanised at an unprecedented rate in the last decade, and has now become a majority urban society. But whereas in nineteenth-century Europe urbanization came from a growth in population, in twenty-first century China the situation is different: most of the growth is from rural migrants coming into the cities. In China, then, the link between urban transformation and mental illness is a critical issue: (1) Development in China is related to migration from the countryside into the cities; (2) Unrecognized and untreated mental disorder is a key factor in casting individuals and families into poverty and social exclusion; (3) Effective development of urban mental health policu requires far greater understanding of the related problems of urban stress, precarious living conditions and mental disorder

This project is an attempt to understand the relationship between migration and mental health in one Chinese mega-city: Shanghai. Given what we know about the relationship between urban mental health and particular patterns of social life (poverty, migration, dense housing, and so on), it starts from the position that this question requires new input from the social sciences. At the heart of the project is an attempt to mix what we know about mental health in contemporary Shanghai with a new kind of close-up, street-level data on what the daily experience of being a migrant on Shanghai is actually life - especially with regard to stress, housing, and access to services. We will then connect these two forms of knowledge to produce a new kind of survey for getting a new sociological deep surveying instrument for mapping migrant mental health in Shanghai.

The project, which is split between researchers in the UK and China, asks: (1) How is mental disorder actually patterned in Shanghai, and how is that pattern affected by recent migration? (2) How are immigrants absorbed in Shanghai, and what is daily life actually like in Shanghai's migrant communities? (3) What policies, services, or laws might alleviate mental health among migrants in Shanghai? (4) What can be learned in Shanghai for similar problems in other developing mega-cities (such as Sao Paolo or Lagos).

This project should also us to also produce new data on two of the major research-areas that are prioritised under this join UK-China research-scheme: 'Migration and public services,' where we will look at the relationship between the welfare system and migration, and analyse the services that currently help to alleviate this problem, as well as migrants' access to those services; (2) 'Inequalities and everyday life,' where we will develop a close-up, street-level analysis of the lived inequalities of everyday migrant life in Shanghai, and try to understand how urban inequality might contribute to the development of mental health problems?

Planned Impact

This project has an impact on four key groups:

1. Impacts for migrant communities in Shanghai.
The project will have the sharpest impact on the urban migrant community in Shanghai, and in particular on the 200 individuals that we interview, as well on their close social networks, vis-à-vis the relationship between the reality of their lives, and policy interventions around mental health in Shanghai. Two impacts are sought here: (1) ThE project is committed to helping with the design of enhanced services, leading ultimately to improved better mental health, and opportunities for improved community relations among Shanghai migrant communities. (2) By creating realistic, accurate portrayals of migrant struggles, the project will contribute to the de-stigmatization of rural migrants in Shanghai. We will also undertake a 'respondent validation' exercise in the second round of interviews that we undertake with participants, a standard procedure in qualitative work whereby initial findings are shared with respondents who are invited to comment, correct and elaborate on our initial conclusions.

2. Impacts for the wider public in China.
The wider public will benefit through an enhanced public understanding of the life circumstances of migrant. Through carefully-targeted policy briefings, we will especially seek impacts on professionals concerned with health and social care, who will get a new understanding of the lived experience of being a migrant, details on the variety of migrant experiences and populations, data on the mental health of the migrant community, and opportunities for new training to enhance community based services. For professionals esepcially, we will provide papers summarizing our findings, and create modules for pre- and post-qualification professional staff integrated into their normal education and professional development structures.

3. Impacts for policy-makers, in China and elsewhere.
For policy-makers, our findings will promote evidence-based public-service effectiveness, by providing data on the mental health of the migrant community, empirically accounting for patterns discovered, so that better services can be developed by the Shanghai City Council and local health services. Additionally, the project has potential impact for policy-makers in cities such as Sao Paulo, Mumbai, and Lagos - for whom our data may also help to re-think urban mental health interventions. We will provide short briefing papers summarizing our findings, and invite Chinese policy makers to the final session of each of our workshops in Fudan, to discuss summaries of our interim ideas, as well as attendance at our final conference. For policy-makers in other countries, we will produce short, academic and policy publications in other languages, specifically drawing on the wider international lessons to be drawn from the Chinese case.

4. Impacts on the NGO and commercial sector in China.
The small but growing NGO and commercial sectors in China will benefit from new data, expert briefing, and new analyses of the social circumstances of migrants groups. We will provide briefing papers summarizing our findings, inviting their representatives to the final session of each of our workshops in Fudan, to discuss summaries of our interim ideas, and to invite debate about the issues as they emerge, and inviting attendance at our final conference.
 
Description We have discovered a lot about how mental disorder is patterned in cities like Shanghai, and especially how that pattern is affected by recent dynamics of migration. The literature provides mixed evidence as to whether migrants have worse mental health, but does convincingly demonstrate that migrants are socially excluded, and that this is associated with worse mental health. However ethnographic work by Lisa Richaud, working closely with Ash Amin, suggests that migrants have many strategies for managing the stress that is inherent in their precarious life situations, even, for example, when the very factories that employ them are razed to the ground as Chinese cities seek to 'move up the value chain'. While many migrants who experience mental distress may simply return to their home villages, these ways of managing stress may explain the relative lack of apparent mental ill health among many living in those situations. Strategies include the use of minor diversions for managing "dead" time; the acceptance of city interventions to clear out illegal dwellings and factories; their psychological orientation to home villages, for example paying only cheap rents so that they can save to send money to their home villages, their use of affordances in the city, such as libraries and bookshops as public space for personal rejuvenation. While Richaud found a complex mix of aspirations and hope in the coffee shops, where young migrants fear that they will become "salted fish", with few hopes for the future, her overall observation is the migrants do have difficult lives, but that they are very good at developing strategies of "endurance."

Nevertheless, there is evidence of mental ill health in other domains. For example, research by our colleagues at Fudan Universities School of Public Health found small but significant differences between migrants and locals in the prevalence of common mental disorders, with older migrants showing strikingly higher levels of depression measures on standardised scales. And while relatively few migrants present themselves for support at outpatient mental health clinics, our colleagues at the Shanghai Mental Health Centre presented suggestive findings from those that do present themselves to mental health professionals - who tend to be younger and better educated than the average among migrants - indicating, not surprisingly, that they report high levels of dissatisfaction with income and jobs, together with disappointed dreams.

It is also clear that government policies intersect with the experience of mental disorder in the city on many ways. First, of course, it is clear that social exclusion is intensified by the hukou system, which deprives those who have rural status from accessing some health and social benefits while they live in the city, and has consequences for housing, for secure employment, and for children's education. While the plans arising from China's new Mental Health Law focus on the development of community services and have many good ideas in principle, but (in common with cities in many parts of the world) there has been little concrete action to develop these. For example, there have been attempts to establish community services, and those that there are - such as a weekly clinic for people who experience mental health problems at one community hospital - are little used. Indeed in some cities outside Shanghai, such as Hangzhou, rather than an expansion of community services, new psychiatric hospitals are being built.

Despite migrants making up around one third of the population of Shanghai, their mental health is not a policy priority. Three possibilities emerged. The first would entail increasing access from migrants to the booming on-line 'psy complex' that is currently largely utilised by Shanghai's more affluent residents. Second, to address structural issues of exclusion, it is necessary to address the policies that mean that migrants are not treated as full citizens of the cities where they work, for the hukou system sustains dynamics of social exclusion that are not conducive to mental health. Third, that mega-cities like Shanghai, should join with the new international policy discussions as to how to make these cities "thrive", so that the challenges of mental health are fully integrated within the project to develop "healthy cities". This is relevant to ODA priorities.
Exploitation Route Academically, our findings will be taken forward by urban mental health researchers within and outside our group. We are pursuing research on the same topic with colleagues in Toronto and Sao Paulo and our findings will serve as a comparative reference to better understand migration and mental health problems in other contexts. One of our colleagues will continue to conduct research on leisure-oriented migration and its mental health impacts, which would take our current understandings further into different social groups and different form of migration. Non-academically, we will make efforts to put our findings to use for policy makers in healthcare, with the help of our colleagues at Shanghai Mental Health Centre. For policy-makers, our findings will promote evidence-based public-service effectiveness, by providing data on the mental health of the migrant community, empirically accounting for patterns discovered so that better services can be developed by the Shanghai City Council and local health services. Additionally, this project has potential additional impact for health policy-makers in cities such as Sao Paulo, Mumbai, and Lagos - for whom our data may also help to re-think urban mental health interventions. This is relevant to ODA priorities.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Healthcare

 
Description 1. Research findings have been developed into 1-hour lectures facing students and staff from all disciplines at King's College London. These lectures have made people more aware of migration and mental health issues in China. 2. Ethnography as a research method has been developed into lectures in China and made Chinese epidemiologists more aware of the use of social methods to investigate into the social situation in population health research. 3. Talks made by our team member have been developed into podcasts that are available to a wide range of audience (eg - https://www.policyforum.net/mental-health-migration-and-megacities/, https://soundcloud.com/lsepodcasts/migration-and-the-city-audio), which has potential impacts on public awareness and policy-making. 4. We have organized groups of students to undertake a 'social practice project' over the summer connected to our project. One group (10 students) disseminated the key findings to the general public through various activities. Another group (8 students), under the instruction of our team members, went to the field to observe migrant life in Shanghai and conducted survey and interviews based on our findings. Both activities increased the students', migrants' and the general public awareness of migrants' mental health issues. This is relevant to ODA priorities. 5. We have organised a workshop at Brocher Foundation and thus created a platform to communicate with three of the innovative 'Thrive' partnerships who are developing policies and practices for supporting mentally health cities - in New York (ThriveNYC), London (ThriveLDN) and Toronto (ThriveTO). Our findings have potential impacts on those 'Thrive' people in understanding China's situation and reflect back on the mental health policies and practices of their own country. This is relevant to ODA priorities. 6. Members of the Shanghai Mental Health Centre attended the Brocher Workshop to discuss the policy and health implications of our work for the ongoing implementation of the 2014 mental health law in China. This is relevant to ODA priorities. 7. We have stimulated related research to inform health policy in Sao Paulo and Toronto.
First Year Of Impact 2017
Sector Healthcare
Impact Types Policy & public services

 
Description Postgraduate methods module on ethnography
Geographic Reach Asia 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
 
Description Summer internships for postgraduate students - networking the Urban Mind app
Geographic Reach Asia 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
Impact This Urban Mind app is designed to engage with the general public in China to raise awareness of mental health issues, and to provide the public with the means to record their mental health state, and their lived experience of city through visual, auditory and questionnaire data.
URL https://www.urbanmind.info/#hometop
 
Description A study on the mechanism of cross-border multilocal dwelling on mental health and wellbeing in the Guangdong-Hong Kong-Macao Greater Bay Area
Amount ¥100,000 (CNY)
Organisation Guangdong Science and Technology Department 
Sector Public
Country China
Start 10/2020 
End 09/2023
 
Description Brocher Foundation Workshop
Amount SFr. 13,000 (CHF)
Organisation Brocher Foundation 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country Switzerland
Start 01/2019 
End 01/2019
 
Description ESRC Research Centre
Amount £6,000,000 (GBP)
Organisation Economic and Social Research Council 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 01/2020 
End 12/2024
 
Description King's - FAPESP APR
Amount £60,000 (GBP)
Organisation King's College London 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2017 
End 09/2018
 
Description King's Undergraduate Research Fellowship (KURF)
Amount £2,000 (GBP)
Organisation King's College London 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 07/2016 
End 08/2016
 
Description M3 Toronto
Amount $40,000 (CAD)
Organisation Wellesley Institute for Urban Health, Toronto 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country Canada
Start 01/2019 
End 07/2020
 
Title 'deep' epidemiology 
Description A major objective for this project was to use ethnographic findings to create and to develop to pilot stage, a richer and more detailed survey instrument for research on the link between city-living experience and elevated rates of mental disorder. This wide spread observation has eluded explanation for more than 100 years, and causes considerable debate and disagreement for the research community, and for policy makers and health practitioners. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2019 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Jie Li, Nick Manning, Andrea Mechelli 'Digging deeper in Shanghai: towards a 'mechanism rich' epidemiology' in International Health (under review) 
 
Title Urban Mind (Mandarin) 
Description It is a smartphone app that collect real-time data on people's mental wellbeing and their surrounding environment. Three times a day, it sends notifications to users to collect such data. It asks users where they are, what they are doing, whether they feel relaxed, happy, or depressed, etc, and how they perceive the neighbourhood (e.g. clean, safe, green) and people (e.g. friendly, share same value) surrounding them. It's also got the function to take a picture of the ground they are standing in and record the sound. At the end of assessments, it generates individualised reports to the user on their mental well-being in relation to the environment. It was a collaborative effort to develop the app and our group particularly contributed to the development and localisation of the Mandarin version that could be used in China. The app is now being trialled and is available to the public soon, and we are receiving data back in the UK. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2018 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The app could potentially make its users more aware of their surrounding environment and how it impacts on their mental wellbeing. It will inform urban planners and designers to build healthier and more liveable cities. 
URL https://www.urbanmind.info/
 
Description Common research project with Institute for Health Communication, School of Public Health, Fudan University 
Organisation Fudan University
Department School of Public Health
Country China 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution This is our main partner for the Newton Grant. We originated the whole project design from start to finish.
Collaborator Contribution They were able to contextualise the aims and methods for the project suitable for the Chinese context.
Impact All the 15 publications listed under the publications section.
Start Year 2016
 
Description THRIVE London 
Organisation Thrive London
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Common work at a workshop funded by the Brocher Foundation, to link our research the growing worldwide development of urban initiatives for urban mental health. We are now represented on Thrive London's advisory Board.
Collaborator Contribution Common work at a workshop funded by the Brocher Foundation, to link our research the growing worldwide development of urban initiatives for urban mental health. A common commitment to research and evaluation development.
Impact None yet
Start Year 2019
 
Description This is a research partnership funded by the Wellesley Institute, Toronto, to extend M3 to Toronto 
Organisation Wellesley Institute for Urban Health, Toronto
Country Canada 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Research background and research questions; methodological design,
Collaborator Contribution Contextual data for Toronto; research resources in kind (research assistance funded by the Wellesley Institute)
Impact None yet
Start Year 2018
 
Description This is a research partnership funded for £60,000 by FAPESP to extend M3 to Sao Paulo 
Organisation Universidade de São Paulo
Department Section of Psychiatric Epidemiology
Country Brazil 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We made intellectual contribution on the research idea, research design, and contributed our expertise in doing migrants' mental health research in a mega-city
Collaborator Contribution They made intellectual input and access to data in Sao Paulo
Impact See publication, 'Migrants and mental health in São Paulo in the 21st century: a narrative review' International Health (under review - Luciana de Andrade Carvalho, Yuan-Pang Wang, Camila Silveira, Geilson Lima Santana, Janir Batista, Erica Siu, Nicholas Manning, Nikolas Rose, Laura Helena Andrade
Start Year 2017
 
Description Urban Mind - a mobile app for data gathering on mental health 
Organisation King's College London
Department Economics
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Intellectual input in research design, access to data in China, and financial input
Collaborator Contribution Intellectual input in research design, technical input in developing tools for data collection, expertise in data analysis
Impact See publication, 'Digging deeper in Shanghai: towards a 'mechanism rich' epidemiology', International Health (under review - Jie Li, Nick Manning, Andrea Mechelli)
Start Year 2017
 
Description M3 Workshop at Brocher Foundation, Hermance, Switzerland 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact We brought together 30 key urban mental health researchers from London, Shanghai, Sao Paulo, Toronto, Berlin, Lausanne, Amsterdam and 'Thrive' partnerships who are developing policies and practices for supporting mentally health cities - in New York (ThriveNYC), London (ThriveLDN) and Toronto (ThriveTO). Our aim was to share findings and methods, and explore pathways for durable impact - how might one build on research on urban mental health to shape mental health friendly cities. The focus was on new data, ideas and discussions arising from the M3 project's work in Shanghai and Sao Paulo, and elsewhere, and discussing what policy developments must be prioritised to secure and improve mental health of migrants in contemporary megacities.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL http://www.brocher.ch/event/336