Social integration in diverse societies: the importance of contact experiences in youth

Lead Research Organisation: University of Oxford
Department Name: Experimental Psychology

Abstract

Levels of integration barely keep pace with the growing diversity in modern societies. Today, more than 40 million people (about 10%) with an immigrant background live in the European Union and this development will most likely not slow down, as indicated by the recent waves of desperate people seeking asylum in the EU. Many immigrants lack social integration within the immigration country, which creates segregated societies in which immigrants and non-immigrants tend to coexist with little intergroup contact: a breeding ground for prejudice, discrimination, and intergroup conflict.

The key challenge is, therefore, to encourage positive intergroup contact, which successfully improves intergroup tolerance. Despite impressive progress in this field of research, a social-developmental perspective has rarely been applied, which prevents researchers (a) from studying long-term contact effects, (b) from identifying age-specific differences in contact effects, and (c) from exploring the complex parallel development of contact experiences and social, emotional, and cognitive skills that is expected to have positive long-term effects for developing adolescents.

The proposed research will change this by extending our previous work which launched a longitudinal study that followed more than 10,000 adolescents annually over three waves (from 2010 to 2012). We will, first, continue to study this sample that is now 19 years old: a highly interesting developmental stage that allows us to examine the transition to young adulthood, in which individuals become responsible citizens, enter the labour market, and gain their first political experiences. Moreover, we will also start to study a new cohort of 14-year-olds over three waves, which will-in combination with the older cohort-create a unique longitudinal dataset with two longitudinal cohorts covering almost ten years from early adolescence to early adulthood.

Findings will not only provide new data for the scientific community and valuable insights regarding the role and long-term effects of early intergroup contact experiences, but will also inform a broad non-academic audience about possibilities for increasing social integration and reducing prejudice among the future adults of tomorrow's societies. For this ambitious project we will make use of our close links to government departments (e.g., Department for Education, Department for Communities and Local Government) and charity organizations (e.g., The Challenge Network) that seek to build a more integrated society. Finally, we will put the new research findings into practice by designing an effective, age-appropriate, and evidence-based contact intervention in the school context.

Planned Impact

Who will benefit from this research?

- Government departments (e.g., Department of Work and Pensions; Department of Communities and Local Government; Department for Education) and NGOs (e.g., Equality & Diversity Forum; The Challenge)
- Scientific community (i.e., national and international scientists within and beyond our research field)
- Schools, teachers, social workers


How will they benefit from this research?

- Government departments and NGOs, with whom we are already working together (see "Pathways to Impact" for more details), will benefit from our research in the form of evidence-based recommendations and suggested policy updates based on our research. Within annual feedback sessions with all these parties, we aim to systematically disseminate the revealed knowledge of new findings to stakeholders for stimulating the exchange between both different stakeholders and stakeholders and other academics.

- Scientific community will benefit from our research given the academic impact that our revealed findings are likely to have. Given the lack of available data, we will produce novel insights regarding the role of early intergroup contact experiences for reducing prejudice and fostering civic engagement, which will be summarized as research papers in high-impact journals and as presentations at the leading academic conferences in our field. Moreover, the generated data, which will be shared with the international research community using a well-established data archive, will be of interest for national and international scientists within and beyond our field of research in order to study of integration processes among immigrants in Europe.

- Schools, teachers, and social workers can benefit from our research in the form of an age-appropriate and effective intergroup contact intervention designed for the school context. After having identified relevant factors that prevent or help to increase social integration during specific developmental periods, we will be able to make evidence-based recommendations that guide the design of a tailored contact intervention for secondary-school students that will be of value for both ethnically diverse schools and ethnically homogenous school contexts.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Research on intergroup contact between members of different groups (e.g., White British versus Asian British) demonstrated that positive contact leads to more positive attitudes towards the outgroup. Little is known, however, if this effect is associated with other (theoretically plausible) longitudinal side effects that are relevant for the social cohesion in modern societies, such as social integration, active citizenship or political interests.
Our main research question is inherently a longitudinal one, which requires the availability of all data from all waves to analyze our hypotheses, while we are currently conducting the final wave. Initial cross-sectional findings, however, are promising and indicate:
(a) satisfying psychometric properties of used psychological scales in all questionnaires (i.e., used items load, as expected, on the latent factors), which empirically validates our research;
(b) the presence of basic relationships and effects known from previous literature (e.g., intergroup contact is associated with intergroup attitudes), which conceptually validates our research; and
(c) social network structures that differ across settings with regard to their level of integration, which suggests an intriguing amount of variance in this outcome that will be investigated (and tried to be explained) in future research.
Exploitation Route The government departments and NGOs can benefit from our research in the form of evidence-based recommendations and suggested policy updates based on our research (e.g., promote interethnic mixing in ethnically diverse settings).
Schools, teachers, and social workers can benefit from our research in the form of an evidence-based and age-appropriate intergroup contact intervention tailored to the school context (explained in more detail in 'Research Databases & Models').
The scientific community will benefit from our research given the academic impact that our findings potentially have. Given the lack of available data, we - and other scientists, who use the generated data that we will be share with the international research community using the Open Science Framework Platform - can produce novel insights regarding the role of early intergroup contact experiences in youth for reducing prejudice and fostering civic engagement in young adulthood.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Education,Other

 
Description see section on: 'Influence on Policy, Practice, Patients & the Public'
First Year Of Impact 2019
Sector Education
Impact Types Societal

 
Description School Intervention
Geographic Reach Local/Municipal/Regional 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
Impact Schools, teachers, and social workers can benefit from our research in the form of an age-appropriate intergroup contact intervention tailored to the school context (explained in more detail in 'Research Databases & Models').
 
Title Longitudinal Follow-Up 
Description A longitudinal survey was a follow-up of participants of the CILS4EU survey conducted in 2010/11/12. The follow-up survey included 2000 participants, who were 20/21/22 years old during the data collection. The used measures collected longitudinal data on contacts with and attitudes to other groups, as well as about active citizenship, political interest, and social networks. The survey was conducted three times (beginning of 2018, 2019, and 2020), which now allows us to study the development of measured constructs over an entire decade. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2020 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Database that is of relevance for social research. 
 
Title New Longitudinal Survey in Schools 
Description A survey was an in-school survey of year 10 and 11 students, which took place in 10 schools across England with a total of 1,500 participants. Students were surveyed three times, roughly during the same time as the older cohort described above. Similar to the survey in the older cohort, the questionnaires collected data on contacts with and attitudes to other groups, as well as questions about their social skills and social networks. The survey was conducted in schools by trained researchers from Ipsos MORI, and was completed with paper and pencil during one lesson period (40-45 minutes), where the class teacher and trained Ipsos researchers assisted during the survey. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2020 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Database that is of relevance for social research. 
 
Title School Intervention Study 
Description We conducted an intervention ('Pro-Diversity Programme') over several weeks in one school, which aimed at promoting outgroup contact and intergroup relations. A total of N = 100 year 10 students across two classes (one control group and one intervention group) took part, both nested in one school that previously participated in the above described younger cohort survey. The intervention started with a pretest, which mainly asked about social relationships with other students in the school, as well as knowledge about, contact with and attitudes towards members of different ethnic groups. Thereafter, three 90-minute sessions were conducted in the intervention group, which aimed at improving (a) social skills, (b) outgroup knowledge, and (c) a more inclusive social identity, respectively. Finally, a posttest was conducted with all students from the intervention and control group in order to test the intervention-based changes in outgroup contact and intergroup relations. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2019 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Schools, teachers, and social workers can benefit from our research in the form of an age-appropriate intergroup contact intervention tailored to the school context. 
 
Title Intervention in School 
Description After identified relevant factors that prevent or help to increase social integration during specific developmental periods based on the two longitudinal surveys in the younger and older cohort, we developed, and are currently evaluating, an evidence-based and age-appropriate intergroup contact intervention ('Pro-Diversity Programme'; explained in more detail in 'Research Databases & Models') specifically designed for the school context that will be of value for both ethnically diverse schools and ethnically homogenous school contexts. 
Type Preventative Intervention - Behavioural risk modification
Current Stage Of Development Initial development
Year Development Stage Completed 2019
Development Status Under active development/distribution
Impact Schools, teachers, and social workers can benefit from our research in the form of an age-appropriate intergroup contact intervention tailored to the school context. 
 
Description School reports 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact Participating schools in the younger cohort were provided with a school report that summarized, aggregated and anonymized, the main findings of the study for relevant measures (e.g., social integration, friendship network social skills, class climate etc.) with regard to the particular school as well as the overall sample in order to reveal well-working and improvable aspects in the daily life of schools.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019