Humour in Childhood: Pathways to Better Wellbeing

Lead Research Organisation: Cardiff University
Department Name: Sch of Psychology

Abstract

"A, B, C, D, E, F, R!" (Louise, age 6)
"H, I, J, K, L, M, N, O... PEE! Get it? Pee!" (Chris, age 8)

This interaction between siblings shows that humour is a central part of children's close, playful, and warm interactions. Humour may be related to positive outcomes later in development, as certain styles of humour are linked to better wellbeing across the lifespan. Humorous children may be better able to cope with stress and worries, be more able to build positive social relationships, and be better able to understand the thoughts and feelings of others. To date, there is no systematic study of the ways in which positive outcomes arise from humour in childhood, which is surprising considering there is good reason to suppose humour in childhood is associated with better wellbeing.
We aim to explore the relationship between humour and other core social and cognitive childhood abilities, and to understand pathways by which humour may attenuate the negative effect of stressful life experiences on children's wellbeing. This investigation will be conducted within the context of a new multi-method, multi-informant longitudinal study, where children between the ages of seven and nine will be assessed over three time points: At Time 1 (7-8 years) caregivers and teachers will complete online questionnaires about children's family circumstances, their wellbeing, and any recent stressful life events (e.g., the passing of a loved one, separation from a close family member). At Time 2 (6 months later) the children will be assessed at school with a battery of tasks that assess how well they get along with others, their understanding of others' minds, as well as their language and memory abilities. They will also be video-recorded with a classmate to examine how they spontaneously produce humour during free play. We will examine the quantity and the kinds of humour children produce within this interaction, such as nonsense words (e.g., gobbledegook), clowning about (e.g., silly dancing) and talking about disgusting or forbidden topics (e.g., bathroom humour). At Time 3 (6 months after Time 2), primary caregivers and teachers will be contacted again to complete more online questionnaires about children's later wellbeing.
This new study will provide a rich data set, within which we will answer the following questions: To what degree is humour in childhood related to (1) children's ability to understand the minds of others and (2) their social competence? 3) To what extent does children's humour alter the impact of stressful life experiences on their later wellbeing? To answer questions 1 and 2, we will harness data from the child assessments at Time 2. We will firstly investigate how children's humour is related to tasks that assess how they understand others' minds, and we will secondly investigate the links between children's observed humour and how well children get along with others. To answer the final question, we will investigate how children's humour at Time 2 is associated with children's later wellbeing at T3 (rated by caregivers and teachers). We will investigate pathways between children's stressful life experiences at Time 1, their humour at Time 2 and their wellbeing at Time 3.
Child wellbeing is a major topic of research, and is of considerable public and government interest, given that the UK is ranked amongst the lowest of developed and European countries for child wellbeing. This project will provide new and important knowledge of humour as a driver of positive or negative change in development. The findings from this study will benefit researchers in developmental psychology, they will inform policy and will provide new knowledge for the general public, educators and clinicians concerned with child development. As such, we plan an exciting and diverse series of impact-related activities to ensure the findings reach a range of academic and non-academic audiences.

Planned Impact

Conceptual Impact. This project will contribute new understanding and knowledge to the general public, educators, clinicians, and policy makers. Our investigation of the links between children's humour and other markers of healthy child development (e.g., understanding of minds, executive function, language ability) will provide new knowledge about individual differences in an important feature of children's daily interactions. Our longitudinal analysis of the effect children's humour has on the relationship between stressful life experiences and children's wellbeing will add to understanding of personal characteristics of the child that may contribute to better child outcomes. For the general public, educators and clinicians, we aim to increase awareness of humour as a key feature of child development. Understanding how humour fosters child wellbeing in the face of adversity will benefit society generally, enabling better education, wellbeing, and productivity, making our society better adjusted, more prosperous and harmonious. Educational and clinical psychologists' increased awareness of children's production of humour will inform their assessment of children's social and emotional development.
Instrumental Impact. Our investigation of the links between humour in childhood and children's wellbeing will generate findings that will contribute to the development of interventions and policy aimed at transforming children and young peoples' wellbeing. We plan both short and long-term change as a result of this project. In the lifecycle of this project, we aim to encourage the view that humour is considered within children's activities; this will be achieved both by sharing our findings with parents and teachers and by developing comedy sessions within the 'Little Lakesiders' theatre group on the University of Nottingham campus. In the longer term, our dissemination of findings within internal seminars both nationally (UK) and internationally (Canada) to educational and clinical professionals will contribute to how practice and service provision is shaped. Given that the Senate of the British Psychological Society voted for the psychological wellbeing of children and young people to be the top policy priority in 2019, a vital component of our plan for impact is to reach policy-makers; our communication with government officials and their representatives will be empowered by our partnership with CBBC presenter, Ben Shires, and with representatives from Comic Relief.
Capacity Building. The project will be a product of national and international collaborative relationships between academics at institutions within the UK and Canada. Our plans are to build links between our collaborators and our non-academic beneficiaries (e.g., students on doctoral programmes and nursery teachers) at an international level to increase awareness of the project and the findings globally. 'Little Lakesiders' and Oaklands Primary School will assist in the co-production of knowledge and co-design of the study in the early stages of the project. Our activities with these groups in the early stages will provide teachers, professionals, parents, and children with a voice to steer the project. They will provide an ongoing source of insight into how best to realise our plans for impact for the general public and they will have a key role in piloting our short-term instrumental impact.
This project will provide numerous opportunities for the PI and other researchers on the project to strengthen their existing collaborations and to create new partnerships with academics and non-academics. The PI will gain organisational, leadership, engagement, and research skills and the RA will benefit from support and mentoring from the PI. Broadly, this project will lead to the creation and maintenance of long-term partnerships both within and beyond research institutions on a national and international level.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description It has been theorised that shared humour in play may be associated with warm, intimate, and playful childhood relationships. Humour may also be one avenue by which children develop and demonstrate their understanding of the thoughts, feelings, and intentions of others, or, their 'theory of mind'. To share humour, a 'performer' must demonstrate some understanding of what their 'audience' may find to be amusing. However, whether a child's humour production may be a marker of close, positive relationships or their theory of mind has never before been empirically tested.

In one study achieved as a result of work funded through this award (Paine et al., 2021), we used existing data collected by colleagues at Concordia University. These data included video recordings of 72 sibling pairs; each sibling pair included a 5-year-old child as they played with their older (average age 7 years) or their younger (average age 3 years) sibling. From these video recordings, we developed an observational coding scheme to systematically code children's production of humour (humorous play with objects, sounds, words, physical play, banter, and play with taboo themes) and their talk about minds, for example, their references to thoughts, feelings, and intentions. The children were also all individually and privately interviewed about the quality of their sibling relationship. Children who produced more humour during play with their sibling were also more likely to talk about minds. We also found that humour was associated with the children's ratings of positive rapport in the sibling relationship. We found that some of these associations were stronger according to structural features of the sibling relationship (e.g., gender composition of siblings and birth order).

In another study (Paine et al., 2021), we wanted to examine change and continuity in children's production of humour when playing with siblings and friends from early to middle childhood. In another sample of 65 children, we observed children's humour production with their older or young sibling and with a close friend when they were approximately 4 years of age, and again when they were 7 years of age. We found that children who shared humour with their sibling at age 4 were also likely to share humour with their friend at the same time point, and three years later. At age 7, children's humour with a sibling was not related to their humour with a friend, suggesting that a child's humour may become specific to each social context across development.

In another recently published study (Paine et al., 2022), we harnessed data from the Cardiff Child Development Study to investigate 110 seven-year-olds' humorous play with their younger siblings as they played with dressing up toys in the home. Children also completed a battery of social, cognitive, and emotional tasks. We found that some types of children's humour when they played with siblings, including sound play (for example, talking in a very squeaky or gruff voice) and playful teasing (such as light-hearted, playful, mischievous behaviour) was associated with children's ability to understand the emotions and thoughts of other people. We also found that children's humour with siblings was associated with how they played pretend on their own (for example, making sound effects, animating toy figures) indicating both humour and pretend play are both ways children can be imaginative.

Our work so far shows that humour is an important aspect of children's social cognitive development and of their intimate, close connections with others in childhood. These findings form a foundation for new and important questions to be asked about the role of humour in childhood relationships. In the next stages of our project, we will investigate other aspects of children's development that could be associated with children's humour production. We are particularly interested in finding out whether sharing humour during play with friends could be connected with children's mental health over time.

The planned data collection activities in this project were delayed due to social restrictions necessitated by the COVID-19 pandemic. However, we have finished our planned data collection for the project for N=130 children. This includes online child assessment sessions, parent and teacher questionnaires and play observations in schools. We are now conducting the 1-year questionnaire-based follow up and we are processing our data to answer the key questions in this grant. During the delay brought about by the pandemic, we took the opportunity to begin to answer our questions using rich existing datasets with national and international collaborators. The network of colleagues who worked on this have included collaborators at King's College London, Concordia University, McGill University, and the State University of New York at Geneseo.

In addition to the published academic papers, the findings of this study have been disseminated at the Japan Society for Developmental Psychology conference in 2021 and 2022, at two invited interdepartmental talks at UK universities by the Principal Investigator, and at the Society for Research in Child Development Learning through Play and Imagination Conference in the United States in 2022. The work on sibling humour produced in this project is features in a new co-authored chapter in the Wiley Blackwell Handbook of Childhood Social Development.

In addition to the work on humour production, throughout this award the PI has continued to work in partnership with colleagues to investigate other features of children's play, such as imitation (Howe, Paine, et al., 2023), doll play (Hashmi, Vanderwert, Paine, et al., 2022), and video game play (Hashmi, Paine et al., 2022). The PI has also co-authored several book chapters and a Society for Research in Child Development Monograph (Hay, Paine, et al., 2021). The grant funding has also supported the PI as she is serving as Co-Investigator for the Neurodevelopment Assessment Unit and Wales Adoption Cohort Study at Cardiff University, enabling the continuation of work regarding the experiences and behaviour of adopted children in the context of family life, such as their sibling relationships (Meakings, Paine, & Shelton, 2022), trajectories of mental health problems (Paine et al., 2021a; 2021b), neuropsychological profiles (Paine et al., 2021c), and transdiagnostic factors such as facial emotion recognition (Paine et al., 2021d).
Exploitation Route Our findings from this project form a foundation for further research on humour as an important domain of child development. In this project we have further developed a novel observational coding scheme to systematically code how humour is used between children during play. This scheme will be used in our future work where we plan to investigate associations between children's humour production and other domains of their social, emotional, and cognitive development. This will also form the foundation of our investigations regarding whether humour, like play generally, could serve as a positive, protective factor against the development of mental health problems in childhood. These findings will form a platform for our own studies, but also for work by other researchers in developmental science, to further investigate the role and function of humour in childhood. These findings have relevance to the general public and to child practitioners. As such, through our programme of impact work in partnership with the national charity for children's play, Play Wales, we have disseminated the findings on the Playful Childhoods website and we have created new educational resources that emphasise the importance of humorous play in childhood. For more information please see the Narrative Impact section.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Education,Healthcare

URL https://www.cardiff.ac.uk/community/our-local-community-projects/case-studies/laughing-all-the-way-to-better-wellbeing-in-childhood
 
Description The findings from this project have relevance to the public, parents, and to child practitioners, for example, early years practitioners and clinicians. Particularly, as the UK lockdown in relation to the COVID-19 pandemic has affected child wellbeing and academic attainment, our study highlights the vital importance of providing children with opportunities to play and be humorous with their siblings and friends to support their social development. We have translated these findings into practice civic mission and public engagement projects that are connected to this award. For example, in 2021 the PI and her team were awarded an Innovation for All Civic Mission fund to work in partnership with Play Wales - the national charity for children's play - to harness our evidence base from this project and create new, freely available, and fully bilingual (English-Welsh) educational resources, called the Giggle Games. These new resources are designed for primary school teachers and children to engage in humorous play at school. We have distributed over 40 Giggle Games packs to schools and other organisations (children's wards, charity-run family centres, and teacher training programmes) in the UK and internationally. We delivered Giggle Games workshops in primary schools for STEM week and the Food and Fun Cardiff School Enrichment Programme in the summer holidays. The resources are freely available via the Cardiff University and Play Wales websites. We have evidenced that the resources increase children's happiness in the classroom and have had positive feedback from both children and teachers, e.g., "Lovely to have good quality resources also available in Welsh." The resources have been nominated for the International Play Association Award and contributed to the evidence base for Cardiff University's National Co-ordinating Centre for Public Engagement (NCCPE) Engage Watermark Silver Award. With new funding from the Welsh Government, we are currently partnering with academic colleagues at Concordia University (Montreal, Canada) and their associated teacher training programme and local French immersion primary schools to develop the educational resources to launch for primary school aged children in Quebec.
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Education,Healthcare,Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism
Impact Types Societal

 
Description ESRC-DTP Collaborative Studentship
Amount £90,000 (GBP)
Organisation Economic and Social Research Council 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2022 
End 09/2026
 
Description Innovation for All Civic Mission Fund
Amount £7,272 (GBP)
Organisation Cardiff University 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2021 
End 09/2022
 
Description Innovation for All Public Engagement Fund
Amount £7,494 (GBP)
Organisation Cardiff University 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2021 
End 09/2022
 
Description Quebec-Wales Collaboration 2022
Amount £4,678 (GBP)
Organisation Government of Wales 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2023 
End 03/2024
 
Description UKRI COVID-19 Grant Allocation (CoA)
Amount £4,856 (GBP)
Organisation United Kingdom Research and Innovation 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 06/2021 
End 09/2021
 
Description Welsh Government
Amount £30,000 (GBP)
Organisation Government of Wales 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 11/2022 
End 05/2023
 
Description Humour in Adolescents' Conversations with Mothers and Friends about their Angry Experiences 
Organisation Concordia University
Country Canada 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution - Our research team developed coding schemes for examining adolescents' humour production in conversations with mothers and friends about experiences that made them angry - Our research team (studying their MSc Child Psychological Disorders) conducted all observational coding, data entry, clean up, analysis and write up - I led supervision of the project - Continuing to work together with collaborators to prepare work for publication
Collaborator Contribution - Our collaborators, Monisha Pasupathi (University of Utah), Cecilia Wainryb (University of Utah), and Holly Recchia (Concordia University) were responsible for design and data collection for this study. - All collaborators contribute to progress of project and are working with our team to prepare work for publication.
Impact Two MSc dissertations: "Humour in Young Adolescents' Narrations to Mothers and Friends About Angry Experiences" by Lola Rogers "Associations between Humour Production and Emotional Problems in Adolescents" by Zahshane Shehryar
Start Year 2020
 
Description Humour in Adolescents' Conversations with Mothers and Friends about their Angry Experiences 
Organisation University of Utah
Country United States 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution - Our research team developed coding schemes for examining adolescents' humour production in conversations with mothers and friends about experiences that made them angry - Our research team (studying their MSc Child Psychological Disorders) conducted all observational coding, data entry, clean up, analysis and write up - I led supervision of the project - Continuing to work together with collaborators to prepare work for publication
Collaborator Contribution - Our collaborators, Monisha Pasupathi (University of Utah), Cecilia Wainryb (University of Utah), and Holly Recchia (Concordia University) were responsible for design and data collection for this study. - All collaborators contribute to progress of project and are working with our team to prepare work for publication.
Impact Two MSc dissertations: "Humour in Young Adolescents' Narrations to Mothers and Friends About Angry Experiences" by Lola Rogers "Associations between Humour Production and Emotional Problems in Adolescents" by Zahshane Shehryar
Start Year 2020
 
Description Humour in Children's Close Relationships 
Organisation Concordia University
Country Canada 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Conceptualising the research project, developing coding schemes for humour production, supervising the activities of the project, analysis and write up.
Collaborator Contribution Study design and data collection, data coding, reviewing study write up.
Impact This collaboration began before the start of this award, however, this award has directly enabled the activities of this collaboration to continue. Paine, A. L.et al. 2021. "Goosebump man. That's funny!" Humor with siblings and friends from early to middle childhood. Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology (10.1016/j.appdev.2021.101321)
Start Year 2017
 
Description Humour in Children's Close Relationships 
Organisation State University of New York at Geneseo
Country United States 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Conceptualising the research project, developing coding schemes for humour production, supervising the activities of the project, analysis and write up.
Collaborator Contribution Study design and data collection, data coding, reviewing study write up.
Impact This collaboration began before the start of this award, however, this award has directly enabled the activities of this collaboration to continue. Paine, A. L.et al. 2021. "Goosebump man. That's funny!" Humor with siblings and friends from early to middle childhood. Journal of Applied Developmental Psychology (10.1016/j.appdev.2021.101321)
Start Year 2017
 
Description 'Giggle Games' school workshops 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact We visited 3 primary schools (approximately 200 children) to deliver 'Giggle Games' workshops (Reception to Year 2; 4 to 7 years). We encouraged children to think about what makes them laugh and why it is so important to share humour in their relationships with activities. We then piloted our newly developed 'Giggle Games' resources based on our research on humour. These are new, freely available, and fully bilingual educational play resources for teachers and children to use in the classroom to share humour and laughter. We recorded children's feedback about the games, and their emotional states before and after the games. 72% felt happy before humorous play and this rose to 93% after play. We also asked children to draw 'What makes them laugh' to encourage them to communicate what they think developmental scientists like ourselves should be studying.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.cardiff.ac.uk/community/our-local-community-projects/case-studies/laughing-all-the-way-t...
 
Description A Very Funny Summer! Cardiff Council Food and Fun School Enrichment Programme 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact Our team visited seven schools in Cardiff who were hosting Cardiff Council's Food and Fun School Holiday Enrichment Programme. Food and Fun is a school-based education programme that provides food and nutrition education, physical activity, enrichment sessions and healthy meals to children during the school summer holidays. We developed 'A Very Funny Summer!' holiday activity for 4 to 7 year olds. This workshop involved activities to support understanding about the importance of play, humour, and laughter in childhood, and to engage children in activities to support humour and laughter with their peers. The session was run by the Research Assistant on the project and a team of undergraduate and postgraduate students. Children played the 'Giggle Games' - new, free, bilingual (English-Welsh) educational resources that we developed from our evidence base of the importance of humour in childhood. Each school was gifted the resources after day of sessions. Images of the Food and Fun events can be found on the #GiggleGames on Twitter (see link below). One teacher emailed to say '"Just a quick message to say thanks so much for the session at Pen y Bryn yesterday. The children loved it! You were fab!'
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://twitter.com/search?q=%23gigglegames&src=typed_query&f=live
 
Description Japan Society for Developmental Psychology Workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact 44 education professionals and academics attended this pre-conference workshop, "Let's talk about our practice of developmental support: The cultural comparison of humour in Britain and Japan." In this workshop Dr. Amy Paine (PI) presented findings from this project and Dr. Charlotte Robinson (Postdoctoral RA) presented more findings and information about the project from a education practitioner perspective. This was followed by talks from Mr Kazushige Sunagawa, a TV writer, who spoke about improvisational comedy in Japan, and Dr Kazushige Akagi (Kobe University), who spoke about the merits of comedy for children with ASD. This was followed by a discussion between practitioners and academics about the importance of humour in educational settings, the challenges in studying humour, and cross-cultural differences in humour in the UK and Japan.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Play Wales: Humorous Play Website 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact Working with Play Wales, with education professionals, and primary school aged children, we developed new, freely available and fully bilingual educational resources, called the 'Giggle Games'. The aim of these resources is to promote children's humour in play and are based on our research evidence. These have been disseminated to primary schools and other organisations (i.e., children's wards, family centres, teacher training programmes) and have been embedded in a series of workshops (see other engagement activities). The resources are advertised on the Play Wales website which is accessed by education professionals, playworkers, parents, and community groups; in 2019-2020 they had 141,000 website hits and reached 5 million people on social media. This has led to more requests for Giggle Games resources from different organisations and internationally.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://playwales.org.uk/eng/playandhumour
 
Description Playful Childhoods Blog: Humour in Play 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The Principal Investigator wrote a blog for the Play Wales 'Playful Childhoods' website for parents and caregivers. The Play Wales website which is accessed by education professionals, playworkers, parents, and community groups; in 2019-2020 they had 141,000 website hits and reached 5 million people on social media.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.playfulchildhoods.wales/blog/humour-in-play
 
Description Primary school teacher workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact 6 primary school teachers attended the Cardiff University Centre for Human Developmental Science for a humour and play focus group and workshop. In the focus group we wanted to understand current implementation and value of play and humour in the classroom and how playful experiences in school might have changed during the pandemic. At the end of the focus group, the workshop session involved working with the teachers to co-develop new educational resources that draw on our research on childhood humour.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.cardiff.ac.uk/community/our-local-community-projects/case-studies/laughing-all-the-way-t...
 
Description Primary school visit (Cardiff) for STEM week 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact For STEM week at a local primary school in Cardiff, our team visited Foundation Phase pupils (Reception, Year 1 and Year 2 children, in total approx 170 children). We prepared a range of activities to demonstrate the importance of humour and play, including Giggle Games resources created from findings from the study, humorous story-telling, miniature experiments about humour and their own wellbeing, and discussions about what researchers do at University. Feedback was positive from teaching staff, e.g., "Great activities which really engaged the children and got them talking in an environment in which they felt free to be a bit silly." From feedback sticker boards for which we had 199 responses from children playing different games across year groups, 92.5% of children reported the Giggle Games made them feel positive/neutral.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022