COVID BAME Highlight: Religious community organisations' interventions around the impact of Coronavirus on Muslims in Birmingham in post-Covid Britain

Lead Research Organisation: Birmingham City University
Department Name: BLSS Sch of Social Sciences

Abstract

The research will focus on Muslim communities living in Washwood Heath, Bordesly Green, Sparkbrook and Handsworth, Birmingham, UK, and the responses to the COVID pandemic by religious community leaders, community organisations and Mosques within these communities. The UCL Institute of Health Informatics has shown that BAME individuals are two-three times more likely to die from Covid-19 than the white population (UCL 2020). Specifically, the risk of death from Covid-19 is: 3.29 times higher for Pakistanis than the general population; 3.24 times higher for Black Africans; 2.41 times higher for Bangladeshis; 2.21 times higher for Black Caribbean and 1.7 times higher for British Indians (UCL 2020). The above data clearly indicates that Muslims from BAME backgrounds are at significantly elevated risk. Furthermore, 73.7% Of Muslims in the UK are from South Asian groups and 88.5% are from BAME backgrounds (MCB 2015), with the Annual Population Survey documenting 301,000 Muslims living in Birmingham (ONS 2018). The research will focus on impacts on Muslims living in the wards identified around perceptions of vulnerability post-lockdown; state responses including the policing of social distancing measures and NHS responses to COVID-19; and responses by local Mosques to facilitate collective worship, rituals around burial and community connectedness. Data will be collected through online surveys with Mosques and semi-structured interviews and focus groups with community members and religious leaders. The research will develop applicable interventions based on responses by Mosques and other Muslim community organisations, deliverable in partnership with local government agencies in Birmingham and in the UK more widely.

Muslim communities in Birmingham have been among the most affected black and minority ethnic groups to be impacted by COVID-19. The proposed research covers a range of bases which will be integral to identifying areas of need and more pertinently, areas of limitation in local government responses and the ways in which these have been partially filled by community-led initiatives. Through documenting these areas of need and identifying desired and appropriate responses, the insights from the research will allow for effective strategies to be developed specifically to the needs of British Muslims as a particularly vulnerable group within the context of the pandemic. These strategies will be documented in practical terms through toolkits, a written report, and two proposed conferences (both to be delivered in person and live streamed) to facilitate access for Muslim communities, and black and minority ethnic communities across the country more generally. Impact will be focused on alleviating vulnerability within Muslim communities in Birmingham initially, and on the national level later on. The research is significant not least because we will gain an insight into the experiences of Muslims as one of the most vulnerable communities to include black and minority ethnic groups. But we will also gather insights into the implications of the pandemic for religious observance, collective worship obligatory rituals around burial, and the role of Mosques for the community in times of extreme need. We will also look at perceptions of state responses held within Muslim communities in Birmingham, including concerns around the rollout of vaccines. Understanding the complexities of how these factors are related is necessary in order to fully understand areas of need for Muslim communities within the context of COVID-19 Britain.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The project focused on community-led responses and interventions around the challenges of the pandemic for Muslim communities in Birmingham. The aims of the project were met and the findings provide insights in the following areas:
A number of participants experienced family members contracting Covid-19 which impacted on caring responsibilities in the home. In some cases, participants reported family members passing away from Covid-19 both in hospitals and at home. The main impacts were the inability to visit family members in hospital and experiences of family members passing away at home. Some participants felt that the transition to online/remote health service provision may have had a role in other medical conditions being mis-diagnosed which in one case resulted in death.
Lockdown measures had significant impacts on religious practice and this was distinctive to Muslims as a faith group where practice is a faith requirement. The inability to pray communally had negative impacts on wellbeing among many participants. There were also significant impacts on the ability to observe the religious practices and festivities around Ramadan and Eid, with the timings of national and local lockdowns being questioned by many participants as representing a double standard when compared with national responses around Christmas.
The most significant findings were around the proactivity of Mosques in engaging with national and local public health directives. Local public health worked with three of the most influential Mosques in the city collaboratively to set up a network including around 165 Mosques. This working group led to significant trust building between the local health authority and the Muslim community. Extensive consultation was undertaken by the local public health authority with faith leaders in a number of areas including around rituals, ablution of the body and funerals.
There were significant impacts for women around lockdowns and family dynamics. IT literacy among first generation parents posed challenges for home schooling, as did the requirement for access to laptops/tablets in order for multiple children in homes to engage in home schooling. It was reported indirectly that some women faced increased exposure to domestic violence and abuse during lockdowns, and the closure of public facing community organisations meant loss of access to respite which had previously been routine elements of some Muslim women's lives.
Documenting the findings above represents a significant achievement particularly given challenges around accessing the community and network building in the context of lockdowns and waves of Covid-19 throughout the duration of the award. We have compiled a substantive dataset comprising 72 responses for our scoping questionnaire at stage 1, 28 interviews at stage 2 and 5 focus groups at stage 3 of the data collection. We also hosted 3 group sessions with female participants specifically focused on Muslim women's experiences. Deliverables for the project were a report, to develop public facing toolkits, to host two research conference events, set up a webpage for the project and to have two articles under review at academic journals. These have all been achieved, the report and the first toolkit can be accessed via the project webpage (we are currently working on two further toolkits), and we are also currently awaiting feedback from journals on the submitted articles.
There are a range of areas for further enquiry, in particular how the kind of trust building captured could be applied in public policy development moving forward beyond the pandemic. An extensive network has been developed as a result of the project which has given access to some of the most influential Muslim organisations in the city as well as contacts in public health services and avenues for impact related activities and further research are currently in development.
Exploitation Route The research findings could be used by both policymakers and other academics to develop approaches to public policy development which place community engagement at the centre. The findings capture a number of areas of vulnerability for Muslim communities which have not been documented elsewhere. There are a range of areas identified in the findings which document that ways in which the pandemic amplified pre-existing inequalities as experienced by Muslim communities, a significant proportion of which are minority ethnic groups. There are implications for addressing a range of social issues around race and inequality which extend beyond health inequalities. Our findings also indicate significant impacts of the pandemic on mental health and wellbeing, which are also likely to extend beyond Muslim and minority ethnic communities. The research findings should be viewed as a valuable resource for policy makers to draw upon when developing initiatives around social inequalities and mental health beyond the pandemic. The findings are also valuable for national and local organisations looking to build partnerships and increase trust, engagement and representation of faith groups and minority ethnic groups in the process of developing policy and practice more widely.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Education,Healthcare,Government, Democracy and Justice

URL https://islamophobiaproject.co.uk/?page_id=36
 
Title Religious community organisations' interventions around the impact of Coronavirus on Muslims in Birmingham in post-Covid Britain Master data file 
Description This is the master data file for the UKRI/ESRC funded project Council Ref: ES/W001039/1 UKRI Covid BAME Highlight: Religious community organisations' interventions around the impact of Coronavirus on Muslims in Birmingham in post-Covid Britain. The dataset has been uploaded to the Birmingham City University Open Access Repository. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2023 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact This dataset was generated as a result of the research activities undertaken for the UKRI Agile Response to Covid-19 - Special BAME Highlight Project Religious community organisations' interventions around the impact of Coronavirus on Muslims in Birmingham in post-Covid Britain. Outputs from the project so far have been documented here and further academic outputs authored by the Principal Investigator and Co-Investigator drawing on this data are currently under review at academic journals. 
URL https://www.open-access.bcu.ac.uk/id/eprint/14257
 
Description Blog article written for Everyday Society (British Sociological Association) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact In April 2021 I was invited to contribute a blog article as a guest author for Everyday Society, the British Sociological Association's online magazine. The invite was directly related to receiving the BAME Special Highlight Notice award, and discussed issues around the disproportionate impacts of Covid-19 on BAME communities more generally and Muslim communities specifically.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://es.britsoc.co.uk/covid-and-british-muslims-facilitating-voices-and-exploring-community-led-i...
 
Description Public facing institutional newsletter - News article on key project findings 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The press team at Birmingham City University published an article on the research project and some of the key findings on the 1st of March 2023. This is a public facing news article on the University's news website.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://www.bcu.ac.uk/news-events/news/new-research-reveals-covid-19-impact-on-british-muslim-commun...
 
Description Radio interview with Unity FM 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The PI was invited to give a radio interview on radio station Unity FM. The interview was pre-recorded on the 13th of February and broadcast on the 17th of February. Whilst the station is located in Birmingham and has a significant audience within the city, it also has national reach and the estimated audience given above takes account of this. The interview was focused on the research project and so this will have facilitated insights accessible to the general public around the key findings. Following the interview the PI was then invited to appear on a Podcast 'Higher Purpose', and arrangements are presently being made to appear on the programme.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
 
Description Research findings conference event 1 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact The deliverables for the project included delivering two research findings conference events and the event documented here was the first of these which took place on the 28th of January 2023. The event was hosted in one of the most influential Mosques in Birmingham, and whilst the audience was small, those in attendance included key stakeholders in the Muslim community in Birmingham. The purpose of the first event was to present findings to community members with a view to collecting feedback and offering an opportunity for stakeholders to comment on and subject the findings to evaluation based on their perspectives and experiences. We received some useful feedback on some of the findings which opened up opportunities to reflect on and reframe their presentation in forthcoming outputs. The event also led to further conversations with key stakeholders about opportunities for further research-based partnerships which will be explored and developed in due course.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
 
Description Research findings conference event 2 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact As part of the deliverables for the project we were required to deliver two research findings conference events. The event documented here is the second event which took place on the 22nd of February. Ahead of the conference we put out a press release as well as publishing an article via our institutional news webpages, and this led to an invitation to promote the event and discuss the research findings via an interview on radio station Unity FM. The interview was broadcast on the 17th of February at 6pm, and is likely to have impacted beyond the city of Birmingham owing to the station's regional and national reach. The conference itself was hosted at an Islamic Trust organisation which had had a pivotal role in mediating public health directives in the pandemic. The event was also live streamed with approximately 15 people in attendance online. Those in attendance included the director of Public Health Birmingham as well as individuals with senior roles in the Muslim Council of Britain, the Birmingham Muslim Burials Council and the Faith and Belief Forum. Plans for further impact related activity are in development following conversations with stakeholders at this event.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://islamophobiaproject.co.uk/?page_id=36