The Digital Documentation of Materiality in Painting: The Case of Contemporary Korean and British Abstract Art

Lead Research Organisation: University of the Arts London
Department Name: Camberwell College of Arts

Abstract

This research focuses on a dilemma faced by museums and cultural organisations is how they represent and disseminate artworks digitally whilst respecting their inherent qualities. A further consideration is how do they ensure they do not misrepresent artworks due to cultural insensitivities and biases inherent in digital visualization.

The digital realm is not in question. However, when sharing and disseminating paintings several problematic issues arise. This may be due to the material subtleties that act against simple photographic representation of such works. But it may also be because of a more fundamental imposition that has its roots in Western ocular-centrism and the primacy of the mind and the eye. Photographic representations of artworks stress a disembodied visual reading as opposed to an embodied and material experience. Visual documentation is dependent on ambient lighting (daylight, LED etc...) which again introduces other cultural presuppositions and biases. Even when moving images are employed to represent paintings, the model used is the cinematic scanning shot and close up and quite foreign to how we actually look and experience paintings.

We will consider the Dansaekhwa painters, Park Seo-bo (*1931), Chung Sang Hwa (*1932), Ha Chong-Hyun (*1935) Lee Ufan (*1936), who emerged in the 1970s and approached painting not only as a visual experience but also as a performative process and put special stress on addressing the properties of their physical materials (canvas, rice paper, oil, pencil) as tactile and vibrant grounds for embodied actions. Drawing on still culturally resonant traditions of literati painting and calligraphy, which reflected cultural values that highly regarded the importance of artistic practices as grounds for refining the self-discipline of mind and body, these painters pursued their own methods, adopting Western painting to redefine Korean philosophy and aesthetics, and extending the boundaries of modern art beyond those explored by Western artists. This will be supplemented by addressing the emergence in the UK, in the mid 1960s, of Op Art, a movement associated with artists Michael Kinder (1917-2009) and Bridget Riley (*1931) who were also engaged in ideas of visual and physical perception.

We will refer to a longer historical framework in which a Western 'imperialistic' vision set about compartmentalising and framing tactile, sequential, and material encounters with East Asian art. This can be exemplified in the convention of unfurling and framing of handscrolls that were designed to be looked at intimately, through touch and sequentially so that they conformed to Western conventions of interpretation and documentation.

Through engaging with contemporary Korean and European practices of documentation and dissemination we will consider the extent to which the cultural differences reflected in Korean art, compared to that of Europe and America, may no longer be as significant in an age of globalization and homogenization. But this may impact on the conventions established to record not just contemporary painting, but also, retrospectively, the paintings of an earlier periods.

We will also investigate how experimental and innovative forms of digital representation may be able to better capture the embodied and material reading of artworks. We will examine paintings from Museum of Modern and Contemporary Art, and by contemporary British and Korean artists, during workshops with computer engineers and students. We will discuss 'models' for new digital representations and virtual environments that are better able to disseminate the perceptual and embodied experiences of such paintings.

We will disseminate our research in collaboration with museums and scholarly associations. The PI, Co-Is, and 4 key participants will disseminate findings through a public conference at UAL.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title Anna Mossman film of Anna Mossman, ' Bathers (1)', 2023, watercolor on paper, 140 x 319 cm 
Description Digital Documentation of the painting Anna Mossman, ' Bathers (1)', 2023, watercolor on paper, 140 x 319 cm 
Type Of Art Artwork 
Year Produced 2023 
Impact The impact and reach and influence of this artwork will be monitored and assessed during the project. At the time the exhibition - Transfer at the KCC UK is just about to open and be presented. 
 
Title Kim Taek Sang with Kim Eun Sic, '?(Daam)', 2023, single channel video 
Description Digital Documentation of painting Taek Sang Kim, Breathing light-breeze 2, 2023, water acrylic on canvas, 196 × 191cm 
Type Of Art Artwork 
Year Produced 2023 
Impact The impact and reach and influence of this artwork will be monitored and assessed during the project. At the time the exhibition - Transfer at the KCC UK is just about to open and be presented. 
 
Title Kim Taek Sang with Park Myungrae, 'Work Process', 2023, single channel video 
Description Digital Documentation of painting Taek Sang Kim, Breathing light-breeze 2, 2023, water acrylic on canvas, 196 × 191cm 
Type Of Art Artwork 
Year Produced 2023 
Impact The impact and reach and influence of this artwork will be monitored and assessed during the project. At the time the exhibition - Transfer at the KCC UK is just about to open and be presented. 
 
Title Rafaël 'Lee Ufan, Dialogue (2014), oil on canvas', 2023. Colour. Stereo. 4'00 
Description Digital Documentation of the painting Lee Ufan, Dialogue, 2014, Oil on canvas 
Type Of Art Artwork 
Year Produced 2023 
Impact The impact and reach and influence of this artwork will be monitored and assessed during the project. At the time the exhibition - Transfer at the KCC UK is just about to open and be presented. 
 
Title Simon Eaves: Portrait of a Painting, , 2022 Digital Fim 
Description Digital Documentation of the painting - Daniel Sturgis, Studied Abandon 2, 2021, acrylic on canvas,152 x 152cm 
Type Of Art Artwork 
Year Produced 2022 
Impact The impact and reach and influence of this artwork will be monitored and assessed during the project. At the time the exhibition - Transfer at the KCC UK is just about to open and be presented. 
 
Title Simon Morley, 'After'L'Homme revolté(1951)', 2014', 2023, single channel video with sound, 11.06. 
Description Digital Documentation of painting Simon Morley,'L'Homme revolté(1951)', 2014, acrylic on canvas,30x40cm 
Type Of Art Artwork 
Year Produced 2023 
Impact The impact and reach and influence of this artwork will be monitored and assessed during the project. At the time the exhibition - Transfer at the KCC UK is just about to open and be presented. 
 
Description This award looked the theoretical implications associated with the digital documentation of paintings in today's 'infosphere', especially as it relates to painting's materiality, and cultural difference. As digital mediations are normalised as necessary, accessible, and adequate substitutes for embodied encounters in time and space, our research examines how artists, art historians and digital scientists can better understand the cultural and ethical dimensions to digitising paintings for remote viewing. Through a series a series of workshops with artist and students a number of new 'digital transfers' were created. The modes of transfer can be conceived as occurring along a spectrum. At one end there is transfer as translation. In this context, transfer involves making a general equivalency between the source and the target painting. At the other end of the spectrum of information transferral is transposition. This involves the substitution of distance for the immediacy delivered by translation. At this pole, the process of transfer is more arbitrary, and includes manipulation, repositioning, and substitution. The medium into which the information is transferred (the digital image) is now rendered more opaque - more visible - and therefore the information embedded in the source (the painting). Our research examines how for a viewer these different modes operate - and recognises the cultural specificity Western ocular-centrism, when digitising works were materiality of the painting is paramount.

Our findings have been realised in both exhibitions form at the Korean Cultural Centre London and will be presented at presented the Seoul Museum of Art in South Korea on May 13, 2023 and in the special issues of The Journal of Art Theory & Practice (Seoul: The Korean Association of Art Theories) and The Journal of Western Art History Association (Seoul: Western Art History Association).
Exploitation Route This research can be taken forward by others from the Museum and Cultural sector who are looking at how digital audiences engage with on-line exhibitions and collections and the richness, artistic quality and appropriateness of that experience.Further cross-cultural collaborations both on the level of research and art practice have been encouraged.
Sectors Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL https://kccuk.org.uk/en/programmes/partnership-programme/transfer/
 
Description ongoing - the use of creative digital documentation of artworks to ensure a richer engagement with the conceptual and theoretical underpinnings of artworks have been tested in public exhibitions inside and outside of academia and show potential for further dissemination and growth.The exploration of cultural differences and similarities in relation to the core research aims has been encouraged and directed.
First Year Of Impact 2023
Sector Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural

 
Description Art History Symposium: Painting in the Age of Digital Reproduction 
Organisation The Korean Society of Art Theories
Country Korea, Republic of 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Our research team is co-organizing an academic symposium in Seoul, with the partners.
Collaborator Contribution Our partners will distribute call for papers among their members and host the symposium in Seoul.
Impact During the pandemic, digital media and online devices came to permeate all aspects of life. In a period where movement and face-to-face interaction were limited, and isolation was mandatory, virtual spaces became the norm for socializing, working, and entertainment. Even museums thrived in the virtual world. For instance, during the 72 days that the National Museum of Modern and Contemporary Art of Korea (MMCA) was closed due to COVID-19 in early 2020, 14,000 visitors participated in real-time exhibition tours at its online platform, and the cumulative number of viewers quickly reached 70,000. Those who did not physically visit the museum could appreciate the works of art on a mobile screen or desktop monitor. This led to an increase in the number of museum visitors after the pandemic subsided. However, the digital reproduction of paintings does not provide the same experience as viewing actual artworks. The tactile nature of the painting materials is lost in the digitalization process, and the appreciation of paintings in the actual gallery spaces requires a fundamentally different mode of perception. The widespread distribution of photographic reproductions of paintings is based on the idea that paintings are primarily visual and art galleries are 'temples of the eye.' This idea has persistently presided over the thriving realm of digitization. However, encountering paintings in real exhibition spaces after viewing them on bright, smooth, and smaller digital devices can evoke emotions such as unfamiliarity, strangeness, and even a sense of betrayal. This quotidian experience leads to questions such as whether paintings can be reproduced faithfully in the digital age, whether their original characteristics can be preserved in digital circulation, and consequently, what is the quintessential nature of painting that cannot be delivered by reproduction and what are the sensorial dynamics of art appreciation. The symposium seeks to explore these questions and stimulate interest among researchers in a broad range of topics such as painting, perception, and digital reproduction. To coincide with the Painting in the Age of Digital Reproduction Symposium at Art Sonje Center in Seoul on May 13, 2023 and the special issues of The Journal of Art Theory & Practice (Seoul: The Korean Association of Art Theories) and The Journal of Western Art History Association (Seoul: Western Art History Association).
Start Year 2022