Cessation of Volunteering in Later Life: Managing long-term impacts for volunteers and volunteer managers of cultural heritage organisations
Lead Research Organisation:
Newcastle University
Department Name: Sch of Arts and Cultures
Abstract
This study will explore how volunteers and volunteer managers negotiate moves out of a particular volunteering role and the impact that this can have in both the lives of older volunteers (aged 65+) and volunteer managers.
People engage in different forms of civic participation (including volunteering) across the course of their lives, often in response to other lifecourse transitions which affect the time and resources available to them. While the patterns of people's civic participation have been studied, the impact of moving on from a volunteering role and the factors which shape the decision to move on have not.
Civic participation is seen as an important aspect of successful ageing. There are different forms of civic participation, volunteering amongst them. Volunteers play an important role in delivering health, social and cultural services across the UK. Over-65s are proportionally the largest age-group of volunteers in Great Britain. However, many people in their mid-70s cease volunteering for a variety of age-related reasons though they may be moving onto other forms of civic participation.
Volunteering contributes to people's wellbeing and often provides a valued source of meaning and identity in later life. A small-scale study in the UK, led by the PI for this project, suggested that leaving volunteering can be experienced as a form of loss which has the potential to undermine the benefits accrued from volunteering. This is particularly the case when people feel that personal or contextual factors are obliging them to stop even though they do not wish to.
Furthermore, the study found that managing the cessation of volunteers created personal and professional challenges for volunteer managers which existing policies did not adequately address but the ways in which volunteers and volunteer managers handle this move out of volunteering can alter the impact of the move for both groups. Thus there is a need for evidence-based professional guidelines in this area.
The proposed project will focus on older volunteers in cultural heritage organisations. The project will explore volunteers experience of moving out of volunteering and will develop a rich understanding of their experience and how it relates to the wider context of their lives. The project will also explore the organisational context and practices which shape this move. We will work with volunteers and ex-volunteers to understand how moving out of volunteering impacted on their wellbeing in the longer term.
We will work with 8 case study organisations that capture the breadth of volunteer-involving heritage organisations in the UK. We will interview volunteers, ex-volunteers and staff. We will then carry out a national survey of volunteer managers across multiple sectors in the UK. This will enable us to test the findings from the case studies against the wider population of volunteer managers and establish the transferability of the findings to sectors beyond cultural heritage. We will use the findings of our work as the starting point for reflective conversation with our project partners with the aim of co-creating a toolkit of containing a repertoire of agreed good practice responses to commonly identified situations. We will share this will volunteer-involving organisations and agencies that work with older people.
The project will provide a rich understanding of the experiences of older volunteers, and the staff managing them, as they move out of one form of civic participation (and potentially into another). As a group, older volunteers are worth studying in their own right but the insights from this group will be relevant to other groups of people who are moving between different forms of civic participation. The learning from this study will also inform new volunteer management practices to improve volunteers' and volunteer managers' experiences across multiple volunteer-involving sectors in the UK and internationally.
People engage in different forms of civic participation (including volunteering) across the course of their lives, often in response to other lifecourse transitions which affect the time and resources available to them. While the patterns of people's civic participation have been studied, the impact of moving on from a volunteering role and the factors which shape the decision to move on have not.
Civic participation is seen as an important aspect of successful ageing. There are different forms of civic participation, volunteering amongst them. Volunteers play an important role in delivering health, social and cultural services across the UK. Over-65s are proportionally the largest age-group of volunteers in Great Britain. However, many people in their mid-70s cease volunteering for a variety of age-related reasons though they may be moving onto other forms of civic participation.
Volunteering contributes to people's wellbeing and often provides a valued source of meaning and identity in later life. A small-scale study in the UK, led by the PI for this project, suggested that leaving volunteering can be experienced as a form of loss which has the potential to undermine the benefits accrued from volunteering. This is particularly the case when people feel that personal or contextual factors are obliging them to stop even though they do not wish to.
Furthermore, the study found that managing the cessation of volunteers created personal and professional challenges for volunteer managers which existing policies did not adequately address but the ways in which volunteers and volunteer managers handle this move out of volunteering can alter the impact of the move for both groups. Thus there is a need for evidence-based professional guidelines in this area.
The proposed project will focus on older volunteers in cultural heritage organisations. The project will explore volunteers experience of moving out of volunteering and will develop a rich understanding of their experience and how it relates to the wider context of their lives. The project will also explore the organisational context and practices which shape this move. We will work with volunteers and ex-volunteers to understand how moving out of volunteering impacted on their wellbeing in the longer term.
We will work with 8 case study organisations that capture the breadth of volunteer-involving heritage organisations in the UK. We will interview volunteers, ex-volunteers and staff. We will then carry out a national survey of volunteer managers across multiple sectors in the UK. This will enable us to test the findings from the case studies against the wider population of volunteer managers and establish the transferability of the findings to sectors beyond cultural heritage. We will use the findings of our work as the starting point for reflective conversation with our project partners with the aim of co-creating a toolkit of containing a repertoire of agreed good practice responses to commonly identified situations. We will share this will volunteer-involving organisations and agencies that work with older people.
The project will provide a rich understanding of the experiences of older volunteers, and the staff managing them, as they move out of one form of civic participation (and potentially into another). As a group, older volunteers are worth studying in their own right but the insights from this group will be relevant to other groups of people who are moving between different forms of civic participation. The learning from this study will also inform new volunteer management practices to improve volunteers' and volunteer managers' experiences across multiple volunteer-involving sectors in the UK and internationally.
Organisations
- Newcastle University (Lead Research Organisation)
- Bradford District Museums & Galleries (Project Partner)
- Tees Cottage Pumping Station (Project Partner)
- The Devil's Porridge Museum (Project Partner)
- Science Museum Group (Project Partner)
- Heritage Volunteering Group (Project Partner)
- Amberley Museum & Heritage Centre (Project Partner)
- National Mining Museum Scotland (Project Partner)
- Volunteering Matters (Project Partner)
- Durham Cathedral (Project Partner)
| Description | At the time of writing (March 2025) we're just coming to the end of the first phase of data gathering and we've been interviewing staff, volunteers and ex-volunteers at the case study venues. The premise of the project was that volunteering provides older people with various benefits therefore leaving volunteering could negatively impact participants. Thus far, the findings suggest that life is more complex than we anticipated. Not all people who leave volunteering will find it challenging, the emerging findings are helping us to identify characteristics of people who might need more support as they leave volunteering and of those who might not. We've also found that, for some people, stepping back from volunteering can be a positive experience. For volunteer managers, the findings have begun to add enrich how we think about the later stages in the volunteering process and how they might support people during that. We're beginning to identify the decisions that volunteer managers might need to consider and the processes they could put in place to support older volunteers. |
| Exploitation Route | Non-academic users: The outcomes will be of use to volunteer managers in a wide range of volunteer-involving organisations, not just cultural heritage (which has been our focus thus far). The outcomes are not yet finalised but I anticipate that they will provide an outline process for supporting volunteers along with questions staff can consider and examples of practice. Together these should help staff identify who might need support as they step back from volunteering, what form that support might take and to consider whether their own policies and practices need to change in order to enable that support. Responses from volunteer managers at engagement events confirms that there is still a real need for the findings from this project within volunteer-involving sectors. Academic users: The findings from this work will contribute to work on volunteering and work on volunteer management. The gap in the literature around volunteers' experience of leaving was the key driver for the project. As the project has progressed, the need for more work on volunteer management has become increasingly apparent and the project may well provide new insights into the distinctive character of volunteer management (compared to staff management), the emotional labour of volunteer management and the volunteer managers' decision making processes. |
| Sectors | Communities and Social Services/Policy Culture Heritage Museums and Collections |
| Description | Thus far there have been 2 groups of beneficiaries: volunteer managers/organisations participating in the project and volunteer managers at engagement events. Project partners have used the process of being involved to reflect on their own practices and how these might be developed. Staff involved in research interviews often see it as an opportunity for reflection on their own experiences and on the efficacy of their processes. Participants at engagement events have used the project findings and implications in a variety of ways. Some participants have expressed how valuable it was to know that they are not alone in facing the challenges that can come with working with older volunteers. For example, "[I found it] valuable to connect with other people who understand the emotional weight that can come with working with older volunteers". The events also facilitated the sharing of resources and processes that have proven useful: this is an explicit goal for the project as it fits within the intention of developing a toolkit of resources and possible responses. For example, at the Make Your Mark Conference 2025, prompted by the talk and workshop, participants discussed strategies for working with older volunteers when they detect signs of cognitive changes. |
| First Year Of Impact | 2024 |
| Sector | Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections |
| Impact Types | Cultural Policy & public services |
| Description | Future of Museums: Engaging Volunteers |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | National |
| Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
| Results and Impact | Online event for volunteer managers in the cultural heritage sector organised by the Museums Association and the Heritage Volunteering Group which took place on January 24th, 2024. Event explored key issues relating to the future of volunteering. I discussed broad trends in volunteering and my current research. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2024 |
| URL | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y9TbjJVJ_mc |
| Description | Lecture - Volunteering in Museums & Heritage |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | International |
| Primary Audience | Postgraduate students |
| Results and Impact | Invited lecture for MA students in Critical Heritage Studies at Antwerp University on April 17th, 2024. The lecture was split between a general look at volunteers and volunteer management in the heritage sector (drawing on data from the UK, Netherlands and Belgium) and a presentation of the current research project. The goal of the lecture was to make students aware of the significance of volunteering for the sector, that they might end up being responsible for volunteers and that they might need to be mindful of the issues the project explores. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2024 |
| Description | Make Your Mark Volunteer Managers Conference 2025 |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | National |
| Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
| Results and Impact | The Make Your Mark* Volunteer Managers Conference took place on February 27th, 2025, in Stirling with some participants attending remotely. Participants represented cultural heritage and natural heritage organisations from across Scotland as well as Volunteering Scotland. Along with the RA on the project, Dr Yang Wang, I presented an invited lecture on the findings of our project and the possible challenges and solutions that we have (thus far) identified. This was followed by two workshops (one in-person and one on-line) for volunteer managers. We identified key topics of interest to participants and then encouraged discussion between participants to foster sharing of experiences, resources and strategies used to facilitate the management of older volunteers. The workshop was oversubscribed and informal feedback indicated that the content of the talk was useful to attendees in developing their own practices. The organisers have not yet finished gathering the feedback from participants so we have not yet received any formal feedback. * Make Your Mark is a Scottish campaigning and networking organisation for volunteer managers in the heritage sector. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2025 |
| URL | https://makeyourmark.scot/for-organisations/events/conference/programme |
| Description | Supporting Older Volunteers in the Museum and Heritage Sector - Symposium for Volunteer Managers |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | National |
| Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
| Results and Impact | The symposium on Supporting Older Volunteers was organised by Glasgow Museums & took place at The Burrell Collection on Wednesday February 28th, 2024. Attendees came from Museums Galleries Scotland, National Galleries Scotland, National Museums Scotland, National Trust for Scotland, Paisley Museum and National Museums Wales volunteer managers. Attendees also came from local, non-heritage NGOs. I was an invited key speaker, along with Tamsin Russell (Museums Association). We discussed issues around supporting older volunteers and presented the current research project, findings from the pilot study and suggested implications. I hosted discussions in the afternoon workshops and helped volunteer managers reflect on these issues and how they could be develop their practice to better support older volunteers. A report, based on the talks and workshops is planned. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2024 |
