School Readiness: Connecting Viewpoints on Child and Family Well-being and Identifying Commonalities Across Diverse Groups

Lead Research Organisation: University of Cambridge
Department Name: Centre for Family Research

Abstract

Children's success in the early school years hinges on both cognitive (e.g., mental flexibility, over-riding impulses, holding information in mind) and social (e.g., understanding others' thoughts and feelings) aspects of 'school readiness', such that, for this age group, this concept overlaps with that of 'wellbeing'. Our project aims to investigate links between children's wellbeing and success in the first years of primary school. Our first objective is to compare information gathered from different sources (i.e., children, parents, teachers and direct observations), both with each other and over time (i.e., Reception and Year 1). By recruiting 500 children from two regions (East Anglia and the West Midlands) and dovetailing our analyses with a parallel study of primary school-aged children with Down syndrome, we will also consider effects of sample diversity.
Alongside recruiting a diverse sample of children, our recruitment strategy will target a wide range of schools. Our second objective is to examine school readiness and wellbeing in relation to classroom characteristics (e.g., classroom chaos, percentage of children from disadvantaged families, and teacher wellbeing). Our goal is to identify factors that have universal effects and factors that matter particularly for specific groups of children (e.g., those with special educational needs).
Effective interventions depend upon identifying factors that both matter for children's wellbeing and are malleable. Our third objective is to examine changes in family talk across the school year and the relations between family talk and children's school readiness and wellbeing. We will assess family talk via wearable 'talk pedometers' that provide automated analysis of child-directed family talk across a full day, as well as unobtrusive recordings of parent-child conversations at key times in the day that are likely to matter for children's wellbeing (e.g., meal-times, bed-time). Recent work has shown that giving feedback stimulates increases in family conversations that, we posit, are likely to benefit children's well-being. Prior to extending this intervention approach it is, however, important to assess how well automated talk measures reflect the quality of family talk (e.g., the degree to which conversational partners' utterances are connected to each other). By extending ongoing preschool work we will: (i) assess the validity of automated talk measures, and (ii) investigate links between family talk and both child and parental wellbeing. In addition, by using the same devices to gather full-day measures of talk for a parallel sample of families of children with Down Syndrome, we will be able to compare the conversational environments of families with neurotypical / neurodiverse children, and explore individual differences within each group.
Early identification is also crucial to the success of interventions. Our fourth objective is to consider how well early life measures of child and family wellbeing predict children's well-being and school readiness. To this end, we will draw on rich multi-time-point data (e.g., video-based ratings of parent-child interactions in infancy and toddlerhood for mothers and fathers, comprehensive assessments of maternal and paternal wellbeing, and tests of toddlers' early cognitive skills) gathered as part of an existing (ESRC-funded) study of 180 children followed from before birth. Assessing both maternal and paternal wellbeing across multiple time-points also enables us to break new ground by considering the impact of the transition to school on parental well-being.
We will share study findings with stake-holder groups through: (a) regular newsletters that will provide the foundation for an accessible book; (b) short video clips highlighting different viewpoints on school readiness; and (c) a variety of public engagement events held across different locations and aimed at diverse groups (e.g., practitioners, parents, children).

Planned Impact

Beneficiaries
Our research is designed to engage three key groups of beneficiaries:
1. Our first group of beneficiaries includes 4- to 6-year-old children and their families. Within this group we aim to be inclusive and to highlight the particular experiences of vulnerable children, such as those with Special Educational Needs (SEN).
2. Our second group of beneficiaries includes educational professionals (e.g., teachers, educational psychologists).
3. Our third group of beneficiaries includes policymakers and charities focusing on mental health in young children (e.g., Place2Be; Down Syndrome Association) and in families (e.g., One Plus One).

Over-Arching Goal
This project aims to enhance the well-being of children and their families by increasing awareness and understanding of the impact of starting school on child and family wellbeing and by fostering dialogue between schools and families of children with diverse needs.

Impact Objectives
1. To increase awareness and understanding of the relations between early school success and well-being among 4- to 6-year-old children, their teachers and their parents.

Benefits to young children and their families will come from opportunities to foster dialogue (a) within the home and in classrooms (as a result of our illustrated e-book focused on the emotional roller-coaster that can result from a day at school for a young child); (b) in the wider community, via public engagement events (see Pathways to Impact). By raising awareness of how the transition to school can impact well-being, we also hope that our research will improve dialogue between schools and parents. To this end, our brief video clips highlight distinct perspectives on the early school years (e.g., child's eye view, parental perspectives, issues of importance for families of children with SEN / eligible for pupil premium).

2. To increase awareness and understanding among early years educators of the relations between early school success and child and family well-being.

Benefits to educational professionals will come from the enriched understanding and more inclusive attitudes that we hope to foster via: (a) our regular newsletters and brief video clips (b) training workshop for educational psychologists and teachers at the University of Birmingham, (also made available more widely via lecture capture uploaded to widely accessed websites).

3. To increase awareness and understanding of how to measure children's well-being among policy makers and charity leaders.

Benefits to policy makers include a broader perspective upon well-being and school readiness (e.g., to what extent are these distinct or two sides of the same coin); a more nuanced understanding of measurement tools (e.g., informant effects); and increased awareness of the importance and feasibility of language as a focus for interventions (e.g., in contrast with changing dietary habits, improving children's linguistic environments has few cost implications). These benefits will be achieved via interdisciplinary knowledge exchange events (to be held in London to maximise participation), as well as via regular newsletters and features in relevant non-academic publications (e.g., Times Education Supplement, Nursery World).

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title Inclusive imagery for developmental research 
Description Gender neutral and ethnically diverse images to accompany a child self-concept measure that was shared with the research community via OSF. My aim was to improve the representation of children from minority groups and counter gender stereotypes in our own research. To this end I commissioned new gender-neutral ethnically diverse images (9 test trials and 3 practice trials, see below, RHS) that we have used in our own zoom-based research with children. 
Type Of Art Artwork 
Year Produced 2022 
Impact My main goal was to promote good practice. In February 2022 I uploaded the images to Open Sci-ence Framework (https://osf.io). A tweet about this from the Centre for Family Research in March led to a very large number of likes and re-tweets. As of last August, over 120 people have accessed this resource (45 from the UK). Two thirds are associated with universities, other users include staff in the NHS and the Lego Foundation. Access has been global, with users from Aus-tralia, Belgium, Canada, Chile,Czech Republic, Denmark, Ireland, Italy, Malaysia, Netherlands, Norway, Switzerland, Taiwan, Tehran, USA. To monitor impact, we asked users to give us their email address, affiliation, and a one-line description of the intended use of the images. To date, around 120 people have accessed the images - with usage being split between research (N = 60) and teaching (N =56), with an addi-tional 19 users specifying another non-profit reason (N =19). Examples of how the images have been used include (in alphabetical order): advertising research activities, assessing children's language skills, artistic workshops, counselling, eye-tracking task illustrating articles evaluating non-profit work on adolescents in crisis, posters for perinatal mental health study, spelling task for deaf children, social cognition research, teaching new vocabulary to refugee children, therapeutic support, visual memory task, 
URL https://osf.io/ynq9x/
 
Description We are in the early stages of data-analysis, but have already submitted one journal article, which reports - for the first time - that 4-year-old children are able to complete a simple measure of their feelings about school (How I Feel About My School - HIFAMS), with child and parent ratings showing similar stability from Reception Year to Year 1 - and a gradual convergence in views, indicating that parents do not have a good sense of children's feelings about school in Reception, but have tuned into these feelings by Year 1. Importantly, individual differences in how children feel about school in Reception predicted both later prosocial behaviour (as rated by parents) and children's self-reported cognitive self-confidence. Girls showed more positive responses than boys at both time-points and the link between feeling happy at school and being prosocial was significantly stronger for boys than for girls.

We are currently pre-registering our analyses to investigate the similarities and links in developmental changes in children's interactions with parents, their mentalizing skills, their self-regulatory skills, and their feelings about school.

Currently, we are examining links between our video-based ratings of the quality of parent-child interactions in a goal-directed activity. These highlight the importance of parental mind-mindedness (i.e., the propensity of parents to view children as individual agents with their own thoughts and feelings) for dyadic mutuality in these interactions.
Exploitation Route We have been road-testing a new online observation tool that is likely to prove very useful in enabling researchers to gather remote observations of family interactions. This is a method that we plan to use in a multi-site study involving low and middle income countries - and should prove useful for others too.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Education

 
Description We have worked with two art galleries (Kettles Yard in Cambridge and Ikon Gallery in Birmingham) to create workshops about starting school - enabling parents and children to engage in creative activities that stimulate conversations about this important transition. We are now working with NESTA and the ArtFund to scale this work up. In addition, we are currently drawing on the findings from this study to create: 1) a parent-friendly book about starting school 2) an illustrated picture e-book for parents with young children starting school
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Communities and Social Services/Policy,Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal

 
Description ESRC Impact Acceleration University of Cambridge:Compensating for Covid-19's impact on parents' peer learning: Co-creating an ecologically valid online assessment - Knowledge of Early Every-day Parenting (KEEP)
Amount £18,284 (GBP)
Funding ID XJAG/101/G100969 
Organisation ESRC Impact Acceleration Account Cambridge 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 08/2022 
End 05/2023
 
Title Shared resource to improve the inclusiveness of developmental psychology research 
Description Feedback from a family made us realise that the child self-concept measure we have been using was not inclusive, in that the images were both ethnically homogeneous and clearly gendered - we have therefore worked with a local artist to create a new resource of images that show gender neutral and ethnically diverse children. These images can be used for the self-concept task or for other (not-for-profit) research and teaching - and are available via OSF: 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact So far 19 different researchers from across the world (Netherlands, Chile, USA, NHS UK) have registered at the OSF site to use the images. We will continue to monitor usage. 
URL https://osf.io/ynq9x/?view_only=05b2fef5f7f44094a300879b34a9272f
 
Description Continued Professional Development for Teachers to support Evidence Based Practice 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact We are holding twelve bi-monthly virtual events for teachers across the life of the grant - with 14 speakers so far contributing to 6 workshops.
These have covered a range of topics of interest to teachers. Titles for events held so far include:
Wellbeing, Worries and Mental Health in Childhood,
Mitigating the impact of the pandemic - A panel discussion,
Outdoor play and the importance of nature,
Ready for school, Ready for pupils? View from educational psychologists,
Tools for monitoring progress and wellbeing,
Ethnic diversity in the classroom
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.cfr.cam.ac.uk/cpd-events-teachers-and-parents
 
Description Family Friendly Kapla play event - Newnham College Cambridge, 18th February 2023 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact This event was designed to encourage families to engage in playful and constructive interactions with their young children (focal age group 4-6 years). The event was led by the UK's only Kapla play workshop leader, and held in Newnham College. Recruitment was both via local support groups for families with young children and university social media. We were over-subscribed (60 attendees, 35 children and 25 adults) and the event was a great success, with families reporting that their children had learned team-work and persistence and the parents had gained a renewed appreciation of the importance of play, and of letting children take the lead. Several parents said that they were now more motivated to engage in other community events as a result.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
 
Description Parenting Special Children 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact National event, organized by Department of Education and E-ACT, with invitations to all schools in the country. Expected audience size of 1000
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.e-act.org.uk/making-mental-health-part-of-our-everyday-conversations/
 
Description Podcast (Get a Grip Parenting) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Rory Devine was interviewed in a podcast recorded on 8th March 2022 for 'Get a Grip Parenting Podcast' hosted by Kathy Weston:
He spoke about children's theory of mind, executive function, and school readiness - all topics that are very relevant to the grant work
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://open.spotify.com/show/2VWjTMelnlcIUnsSvQWRqa
 
Description Theory of Mind: What is it, how can we support it and why does it matter? (Virtual lecture to pan-Asian audience) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The 90minute lecture was part of a CPD series - attendees were mostly based in Hong Kong, but also mainland China, Pakistan, Australia, Iran.
It was followed by a very full 30-minute Q&A in which the main focus of discussion concerned findings that, relative to their UK counterparts, children in Hong Kong did significantly less well on tests of theory of mind - and the pandemic appears to have widened the UK/HK gap (my team did similar work that was published in 2017). The organiser received lots of positive feedback and expressions of interest from the audience.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
 
Description virtual series of CPD workshops 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact During the life of the grant, we have been holding bi-monthly CPD events addressing a range of topics related to school readiness. These have covered a wide variety of topics, ranging from general themes (e.g., child wellbeing, anxiety) to specific activities (picture-book reading, outdoor play) or competencies (e.g., maths - positive effects of spatial talk and negative effects of maths anxiety) or practices (how teachers can best encourage children's expressive language). Each workshop includes two expert speakers and a 20 minute Q&A session - enabling the events to work as knowledge exchange, with students and researchers learning from practitioners as well as educators staying abreast of relevant research findings.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022,2023