The Khayelitsha Comorbidity Cohort: Establishing a multimorbidity cohort with integrated clinical, genomic and epidemiological data in South Africa.

Lead Research Organisation: University of the Western Cape

Abstract

In the Western Cape Province of South Africa, there is a large burden of diseases including infectious diseases HIV and TB as well as chronic diseases like hypertension, diabetes and kidney disease. Often patients have more than one condition at the same time. The Provincial Health Data Centre (PHDC) at the Department of Health collects ongoing patient information about their visits to health facilities, medicines received and laboratory tests done, in order to provide health care. Where patients consent, these health data can be used for research to better understand health conditions.

Genes and DNA are unique to each individual and can affect whether they will get some diseases, how ill they will get with those illnesses, and how they respond to treatment. By understanding this relationship between DNA and diseases, individual patients will be able to receive better health care tailored to their own DNA sequence. Most of the research done on DNA and diseases until now has been done on Caucasian populations, and African patients have been poorly represented in research. This means that most health care is not optimised for Africans, even though African populations have rich genetic diversity which can provide many insights into the mechanisms of disease through biomedical research. In addition, research about genetic effects on disease have generally been conducted from the perspective of looking at a single disease and doing the analysis on who has the disease or not without taking into consideration other health conditions that the participant might also be experiencing.

Recently, the H3Africa Bioinformatics Network (H3ABioNet) developed the H3Africa Illumina genotyping chip, a tool that is specifically optimised for measuring DNA variation in Africans, across the whole human genome. With the consent of research participants, health data from the PHDC can be combined with genetic data generated using the H3Africa genotyping chip, making it possible to research the relationship between DNA and different diseases in African individuals. In the first instance, this project aims to collect 700 DNA samples from consenting participants and link their DNA data to their health data from the PHDC. In this first stage it will be possible to research the more common diseases - hypertension, diabetes and kidney disease; but as the number of research participants increases in the future it will also become possible to research the less common illnesses. Updated health information will be received from the PHDC twice a year, to document all health outcomes as they occur in participants going forward. An additional benefit to this research is that it will use a participant-based approach rather than a disease-based view, researching the whole health profile of the participant instead of only looking at whether they have a single disease or not. By working in collaboration with the Department of Health, a system will be set up to return useful findings from the research so that they can be used to provide better tailored health care by the Department of Health for individuals as well as the whole population. The information will also help to inform health care in other African countries, and well as providing research insights that can help improve our understanding of disease processes across the world.

Technical Summary

There is high multimorbidity in South Africa, consisting both infectious and non-communicable diseases. Elucidating diagnostic, therapeutic and prognostic genetic drivers of morbidities can help tailor preventative and therapeutic patient care at both population and individual levels, and requires research into associations between genetic factors, complex patient phenotypes, and how these factors work in concert to impact complex clinical phenotypes in African individuals. The Provincial Health Data Centre (PHDC) is a health information exchange collating routine health data on a daily basis from 6.6million health care clients in the Western Cape Province (South Africa), compiling a patient-centric longitudinal health profile for every individual, with daily updates available on an ongoing basis. This presents an opportunity to research complete, complex clinical phenotypes with prospective automated health data updates for consenting individuals. The H3Africa Bioinformatics Network has developed an African-specific 2.5million SNP genotyping chip including novel African variants, known disease markers and pharmacogenomic variants. With the appropriate informed consent from participants, individuals' genotypes generated with the H3Africa chip can be linked to complex, longitudinal clinical phenotypes from the PHDC to develop an infinitely-scalable comorbidity cohort. At the seed-stage of the project, nested case-control analyses and genetic epidemiology methods will be used to explore complex genotype-phenotype associations focusing on high prevalence morbidities - diabetes, hypertension and kidney disease - in conjunction with HIV and TB. As the cohort grows, going forward, other morbidities can be analysed. Clinical data will be updated from the PHDC biannually, growing the extent of the clinical profiles over time. Additionally, a framework will be developed for returning clinically actionable findings to the Western Cape government health service.

Planned Impact

The pilot project proposed here aims to establish a framework, with established sample and data workflows and analysis methodologies, for the collection and linkage of complex clinical longitudinal data from routine health records collated at the Provincial Health Data Centre to genotype data generated using the H3Africa Illumina genotyping chip. The pilot project will generate a seed-stage cohort of 700 consenting participants, demonstrating that it is feasible and economical to establish and develop such a cohort for conducting health genomics research. A mechanism will be established for the return of actionable, validated research findings to the PHDC to inform health care by the Department of Health for individuals as well as at the population and health policy level. The pilot study will pave the way to grow this infinitely-scalable research cohort to a sufficient size to investigate the genetic drivers of multi-morbidities in an African population. During the project, additional outcomes will include the training and skills development of two early career African researchers, and a workshop with other comorbidities researchers in the region will enable sharing the new methodologies as well as inviting collaboration in growing the cohort further for future research into the multi-morbidities affecting patients in the Western Cape. The pilot project will thus impact African healthcare clients, through improving the effectiveness of the healthcare they receive, and will benefit the Department of Health by generating a knowledge-base that can be used to provide more effective health care. The project will also impact the research community by providing a framework for an economical and feasible growing research cohort that can be used for extensive health research into the future.

People

ORCID iD

 
Description Presentation to Western Cape Department of Health and discussion on analysis of adherence to diabetes medications
Geographic Reach Local/Municipal/Regional 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
 
Title REDCap Informed consent template for tiered consent, human genomic research in the global South 
Description As part of this pilot programme to build a virtual genotyped cohort, we have built a REDCap template to effectively conduct, capture and store informed consent decisions by potential research participants. Whilst our study start was delayed by the COVID-19 pandemic and the discontinuation/reinstatement of funding, we continued building the necessary tools for this project, and this means the informed consent protocol, template and database is ready-to-go when the project starts on 1 June 2023 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact We made a generaliseable and customiseable template for anyone wishing to use tiered consent for health-related observational research. We know that researchers want to do informed consent correctly but often don't have the training or expertise to know how to construct informed consent processes or which questions to include. We therefore believe that this tool may be helpful to other researchers designing observational health studies for which they must recruit participants. The REDCap tool also ensures that participants' preferences are captured accurately and digitalised, so that their preferences may be easily respected in future re-use of data and samples. The publication has been accessed more than 1000 times since publication. 
URL https://bmcmedethics.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12910-022-00860-2
 
Description Collaboration: Dentistry Department, University of the Western Cape 
Organisation University of the Western Cape
Country South Africa 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The Dentistry Department of the University of the Western Cape runs dental clinics in the Western Cape Province, as a partner with the Western Cape Department of Health. These clinics provide services to a very large number of clients. We have set up a collaboration with the Dentistry Department which will facilitate recruitment of individuals into our study in a disease-agnostic approach, whilst also encouraging our partners in the dentistry department to work with us on their own dentistry-related studies.
Collaborator Contribution The contribution by our partners is to provide us an appropriate environment for recruitment of participants in a disease-agnostic environment. Whilst many people may have dental issues, and there may be a slight general enrichment of participants with underlying conditions, this is also an excellent avenue for us to recruit individuals who are otherwise healthy or are attending for dental checkups, ensuring we have sufficient control participants for the different types of nested case-control studies we will be conducting in the future.
Impact This is a new collaboration - no outputs yet.
Start Year 2024
 
Description Collaboration: Division of General Internal Medicine at Groote Schuur Hospital and University of Cape Town, South Africa 
Organisation University of Cape Town
Country South Africa 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The team is working directly with two specialist Endocrinologists in order to recruit participants from Diabetes clinics at Groote Schuur Hospital, in Cape Town, into the study; and to ensure clinical relevance of our analysis of the linked routine health data and genotype data from People Living with Diabetes who are recruited through these clinics.
Collaborator Contribution Our partners bring the clinical expertise and experience as highly skilled and experienced consulting clinicians for People Living with Diabetes.
Impact Please note that due to the disruption in the award process, these outcomes span the time from when the award was originally made in 2020 until when the funding was actually provided in 2023. The original grant was registered with the number MC_PC_MRT0377331; but the funding was withdrawn before any payments were made, and then was reinstated only in 2023. This is why some of the associated publications have dates prior to the current study period. With these collaborators we have published the following peer-reviewed papers during our ongoing collaboration: Tamuhla T, Dave JA, Raubenheimer P, Tiffin N. Routine health data describe adherence and persistence patterns for oral diabetes medication for a virtual cohort in the Khayelitsha sub-district of Cape Town, South Africa. 2023 PLoS Global Public Health. Dec 21;3(12):e0002730. doi: 10.1371/journal.pgph.0002730 Dave JA, Tamuhla T, Tiffin N et al. (2021) Risk factors for COVID-19 hospitalisation and death in people living with diabetes: A virtual cohort study from the Western Cape Province, South Africa. Diabetes Res Clin Pract. Jun 21;177:108925. doi: 10.1016/j.diabres.2021.108925 Tamuhla T, Dave JA, Raubenheimer P, Tiffin N (2021) Diabetes in a TB and HIV-endemic South African population: Analysis of a virtual cohort using routine health data. PLoS ONE 16(5): e0251303. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0251303 In addition, Profs Raubenheimer and Dave piloted our Tiered Informed Consent protocol, which was developed for this study (published as a RedCap Template): Tamuhla T, Allie T, Tiffin N. An e-Consent framework for tiered informed consent for human genomic research in the global South, implemented as a REDCap template. BMC Medical Ethics 2022 Nov 24;23(1):119. doi: 10.1186/s12910-022-00860-2. We also have a paper with these authors that is under a first round of revisions with peer-reviewed Genetics in Medicine, which is a 'proof of principle' publication - "Implementation of a genotyped virtual African population cohort: A feasibility study in the Western Cape Province, South Africa" - and demonstrates the effective linkage of genotype and routine health data from consenting participants who were the first participants recruited into the study through our collaborators Profs Raubenheimer and Dave.
Start Year 2021
 
Description Collaboration: Division of Nephrology, Department of Medicine, University of Cape Town 
Organisation University of Cape Town
Country South Africa 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We have initiated a collaboration with the Specialist Nephrologists working in this department in order to recruit participants into the study from their patient base.
Collaborator Contribution The specialist Nephrologists working in this department provide the clinical expertise for our analyses of kidney disease, ensuring that our work is clinically relevant and accurate, and to assist with appropriate interpretation of our findings for this study.
Impact Currently, we are working with the nephrologists to ensure good representation of participants living with kidney disease in our cohort. The cohort is intended to be disease-agnostic by design, but as we wish to demonstrate capacity to undertake nested case-control study analyses during this pilot phase, and to be able to demonstrate up front that this approach is effective, we opted at this pilot phase to enrich our sample set for individuals with some of our most commonly experienced NCDs in the Western Cape, specifically Diabetes, Kidney Disease and Hypertension. These patients also commonly experience multimorbidity and thus we can ensure in the pilot study that we can demonstrate effective analysis of multi-morbidity in the cohort design that we are piloting.
Start Year 2023