Urban Drinking Water and Health Outcomes - Early Phase Study for a Randomized Controlled Trial in Accra, Ghana

Lead Research Organisation: University of Southampton
Department Name: School of Geography

Abstract

Many sub-Saharan African cities struggle to provide their residents with safe drinking-water, both as a result of rapid urbanisation and in freeing up funding to increase water supply capacity. As a home-grown solution to this problem in parts of West Africa, a cottage industry has developed over the past ten years to sell water in plastic packets, known as sachet water. Existing evidence suggests that poorer households often buy these water sachets and - at least in Accra in Ghana - the water they contain is generally of acceptable quality. However, it is unclear whether the households who consume relatively small quantities of better quality water in the form of sachets are at reduced risk of diarrhoeal disease. These small bags, tied by the corners at the top, generally cost less than 4 pence (0.1 Ghanaian cedis) for a bag containing 500ml of water and the water they contain comes from the municipal piped supply system. Initially, hygiene remained an issue, as bags were generally filled by women and children with little attention to contamination risks. In the late 1990s, new Chinese machinery that heat-sealed water in a plastic sleeve effectively created the modern sachet that is currently sold on the streets of several West African nations. Filtration and chemical treatment processes were eventually built into some machines as well.
There is as yet no study of the health impact of sachet water, nor of the relative cost effectiveness of sachet water versus other forms of household drinking water provision in reducing disease burden. Sachets are cheaper than bottled water due to the substantially lower capital investment and packaging material required relative to bottling plants. Generally, little is known about the quantities of sachet water consumed, the main consumers and the ways the water is used, though it is often poorer households that purchase sachet water.
The proposed study aims to investigate the feasibility of providing subsidised sachet water use to children at risk of diarrhoea in Accra, Ghana. It will also assess the feasibility of studying the impact of a subsidised voucher scheme on child health. It will focus on neighbourhoods that lack access to a reliable piped water supply. To assess the safety of sachet water and its suitability for such a programme, we will test the microbial water quality of a sample of major brands of sachets drawn from across the city. Some members of a small pilot group of participating households will be provided with vouchers that will enable them to obtain sachets from local water vendors, either for free or at a 50% discount. Others will continue to consume water as usual. Diarrhoeal disease will be measured among children in participating households. We will use the pilot study to identify any potential problems arising from the sachet voucher system and issues in measuring diarrhoeal disease.
By looking at the difference in diarrhoea rates and growth between children receiving the vouchers and those who have not yet received them, we should be able to assess via a subsequent, larger study whether greater sachet use protects against water-borne disease. Supplying vouchers for both free and discounted sachet water in this follow-up study should enable us to see how people's use of sachets responds to changes in their price, for example through a subsidy. This information should enable us to assess how far the costs of sachet water regulation or subsidy are justified by the health benefits that may result. If successful, the study could show whether a well regulated sachet water industry can act as an interim means of providing poorer urban households with safer water. This in turn would help reduce diarrhoeal disease and child mortality in urban sub-Saharan Africa. Unlike some other methods of water provision, sachet water is a phenomenon that has emerged within sub-Saharan Africa rather than being an externally imposed solution.

Technical Summary

Background: Use of sachet water (small quantities of water sold in plastic bags) is growing rapidly in West Africa, yet its health impact and the proper policy response remain unclear. Reviewers of our 2013 Joint Global Health Trials application for a full-scale trial of subsidised sachet water (reference: MR/L004313/1) requested preliminary data on the topics discussed below.
Objectives: To quantify the effect of greater sachet water use on childhood diarrhoea (the primary outcome) and thus evaluate the cost-effectiveness of free or subsidised sachet water provision as a health intervention.
Subjects: Ghanaian children aged 6-36 months living in neighbourhoods lacking access to reliably treated piped water in Accra.
Early Phase Study Design: A feasibility study using the main study protocol among 80 households in 4 districts to assess contamination between intervention and control groups and unintended harm to sachet vendors. We shall also undertake a cross-sectional, city-wide sachet water quality survey to assess intervention safety.
Proposed analysis: For the early phase study, we shall assess retention, household behaviour and vendor sales in response to sachet provision and estimate sachet water microbial compliance.
Main Study Design: A three-arm randomised controlled trial of 3,600 households. Carers in the control group will receive education on diarrhoea prevention and treatment; the second arm will receive vouchers for 2 litres of free drinking-water sachets per day (value: $0.20) plus education, and the third arm will receive vouchers for 2 litres/day of subsidised sachets plus education. Child health outcome measures will include diarrhoeal disease, growth, and related proximate measures.
Engagement and Dissemination: We shall hold regular stakeholder meetings throughout the early phase project and a final dissemination event in Accra. Subject to early phase findings, we aim to submit a revised trial proposal to the Global Health Trials scheme.
 
Description Africa Exchange Programme
Amount £20,616 (GBP)
Funding ID SM150014 
Organisation The Royal Society 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 01/2016 
End 12/2018
 
Title Statistical code for water quality analysis in household survey 
Description Statistical code to support the analysis of water quality data in Wright et al, 2016. 
Type Of Material Data handling & control 
Year Produced 2016 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact The UNICEF Joint Monitoring Program team requested a copy of the statistical code associated with this paper, which we then provided. 
 
Description Southampton in Ghana presentation, University of Southampton 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Third sector organisations
Results and Impact Presentation on public health impacts of Ghana's sachet water industry to mixed audience of third sector organisations (e.g. Wessex Global Health Network; AuthorAid) and academics, including students. Stimulated debate on interim strategies to provide water and sanitation in unplanned urban neighbourhoods with high population densities.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://revl.world/event/southampton-in-ghana-lessons-and-opportunities/
 
Description Steering Committee meeting 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact 3 separate steering committee meetings, attended by representatives of the sachet manufacturers' association, the Ghana Standards Authority, The Accra Metropolitan Assembly Public Health Dept, and Ghana Health Services.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
 
Description Talk to MPH students at Ghana School of Public Health 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Thanks to subsequent Royal Society funding, Drs Dzodzomenyo and Wright presented the findings to a large group of MPH and PhD students at Ghana School of Public Health, including many health professionals from Greater Accra. Considerable extended debate on the safety of sachet water and related public policy issues ensued, as were some topics for follow-up dissertation projects.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017