Is Lactoferrin more effective than inorganic iron in treating iron def anaemia in non-pregnant and if effective in pregnant women? 2 randomised trials

Lead Research Organisation: International Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease Research
Department Name: Maternal and Child Health Division

Abstract

Oral bovine lactoferrin is a novel, unconventional way to prevent low birthweight, preterm birth & neonatal deaths associated with maternal iron
deficiency in low income settings. Each year about 20 million low birthweight babies are born worldwide. Low birthweight is caused by either preterm delivery (babies born earlier than expected) or fetal growth retardation. In countries where perinatal health services are limited, low birthweight and preterm birth are a major cause of neonatal deaths. Low birthweight babies are 20 or more times likely to die than heavier babies, with much of this mortality burden due to preterm birth. The current paradigm of using iron supplements (and folic acid) targeted at pregnant women often fails, in part because of the side effects, which are a strong barrier to use of the supplements early in pregnancy, a period of vulnerability for iron deficient women and their fetus and future newborn. And also because maternal inflammation and micronutrient deficiencies block effective utilization of iron Our approach will provide a product that will efficiently deliver iron and that can be taken early in pregnancy during a critical intervention window, which offers the potential to prevent neonatal deaths.

Technical Summary

There will be 2 phase in the study.

Phase 1: Phase 1 will aim to establish that Lactoferrin is safe and equally effective to iron (ferrous sulphate) in treating iron deficiency anaemia in non-pregnant women of reproductive age. The study will also assess different doses of Lactoferrin to establish the dose that most effectively corrects iron deficiency. Volunteer women of reproductive age will be screened to identify 75 women with low haemoglobin (Hb < 12 g/L), and 75 with very low haemoglobin (Hb < 10 g/L). In each of these groups we will randomly allocate the women to receive 60 days of either 100 mg of bovine Lactoferrin, or 200 mg of bovine Lactoferrin, or 60 mg of ferrous sulphate. Blood will be collected at the start, and after one month of treatment, and after 60 days of treatment, to measure haemoglobin & serum ferritin. If Lactoferrin compared to iron is equally or more efficacious in restoring iron status, and no adverse side effects are reported, we will proceed to the next step.

Phase 2: In the second phase we will conduct a hospital-based randomized controlled trial in pregnant women reporting to a local hospital for antenatal care with three treatment groups: Lactoferrin alone (dose based on results of first study); Lactoferrin; and 60 mg of ferrous sulphate. We will recruit 204 women in their first trimester for intensive follow up who will be randomly allocated to receive daily till the end of pregnancy, one of the two treatments above.

The secondary outcomes will be the duration of gestation and birthweight will be monitored together with reports of side effects, compliance, episodes of maternal infections, and adverse perinatal outcomes. The interventions will be assigned to eligible women at individual level at different phases using a fixed randomization scheme.

Planned Impact

Iron-deficiency is the most common nutritional deficiency globally. It is highly prevalent and most severe in pregnant women and children, because of the additional requirements for child growth and pregnancy. Strong evidence about the importance of correcting iron deficiency in pregnancy comes from a recent community-based randomized controlled trial in China that reported a 54% reduction of early neonatal deaths amongst women who received iron supplements compared to those who received no iron (Zeng et al 2008). The iron supplements also reduced rates of low birthweight and early preterm delivery.This result combined indicate that iron supplements in iron deficient pregnant women can lead to decreased rates of low birthweight, preterm delivery & neonatal deaths.

The value of Lactoferrin, a natural safe product, to pregnant women will be its potential to rapidly restore iron status during pregnancy. Using lactoferrin to prevent iron deficiency anemia in pregnancy will make women feel better and less tired, and compliance will be higher because of the reduced side effects and the potential to reduce the frequency of supplementation. Improved iron status will reduce the rates of low birthweight and preterm delivery and improve the survival of the newborns, and issue of concern to women in low resource settings. The cost of this intervention for providers will be similar or less than standard iron because of the potential to reduce the frequency of supplements.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The haemoglobin and ferritin findings at the end of treatment indicate that ferrous sulfate had better efficacy than bLf for the treatment of iron deficiency anaemia in non-pregnant, non-lactating women of reproductive age in urban Bangladesh. Reported side effects such as abdominal pain, indigestion, diarrhoea and black stool were all significantly higher in the ferrous sulfate group. There were no significant differences for other side-effects across treatment arms.

There are three possible explanations for our negative findings. The first explanation is that bovine lactoferrin has no efficacy to improve iron status and reduce anaemia in iron deficiency anemia in women. This is hard to accept as there are several trials that have reported an impact of bovine lactoferrin on iron status in pregnant and non-pregnant women of reproductive age. The second is that the lactoferrin product tested was biologically inactive. The regulations and manufacturing processes for bovine lactoferrin do not match those required for pharmaceutical drugs, and there are no widely accepted methods to test the bioactivity of bovine lactoferrin. The third, is that the women in the trial might have had very low dietary iron intake, so low that even with bovine lactoferrin facilitation of its absorption there was insufficient iron to improve the women's iron status.
Exploitation Route We think any future trials of bovine lactoferrin should document the bioactivity of the lactoferrin treatments before the trial starts, preferably by robust consensus methods. Future meta-analyses of bovine lactoferrin trials should need to identify the source and method of production and perform subgroup analyses based on these characteristics.
Sectors Healthcare

 
Description Saving Lives at Birth ( University of Sydney our partner in the trial has received this grant)
Amount $248,590 (USD)
Organisation United States Agency for International Development 
Sector Public
Country United States
Start 05/2015 
End 05/2017
 
Title Electronic Data Capturing through Comm Care 
Description We are currently in the process of developing an electronic data capturing system using CommCare which is technically advanced, and evidence-based mobile platform for low-resource settings. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact This would significantly improve the quality of data and increase efficiency of data management team for data processing and data analysis 
 
Title Lactoferrin-Bangladesh-study-database 
Description In total, we enrolled 555 patients in the study. We assessed 4511 women of reproductive age for eligibility. We informed the women about the study, the required number of visits to the clinic for haematological assessments. Out of the 4511 women, 843 women did not meet the inclusion criteria, and 132 women did not provide consent for further screening. We then registered the remaining 3722 women who were between 18 to 49 years of age, not lactating, not allergic to any milk product, not suffering from any chronic disease and TB and were not taking any iron supplementation at the time of registration. Upon receiving the consent and completion of the registration, the community health workers undertook Hb point-of-care testing with a HemoCue® 201+ System. The community health workers also measured the random blood glucose level with the glucometer. Out of the 3722 women, 1460 women were not anaemic, 281 women had a random blood sugar of more than 12 gm/dl, and three were severely anaemic. The remaining 1978 women were eligible for the next level of screening. We provided all eligible women with a screening card and invited them to visit the study clinic within next 48-72 hours for ferritin screening. Out of 1978 women, we did ferritin screening in 1337 subjects. Out of these subjects, 627 women had a normal level of ferritin, 78 women had beta thalassemia trait, and 50 women did not provide consent to join the trial. We enrolled the remaining 555 women, who had ferritin level of less than 30mg / dl, and provided their consent to join the study. For all 555 women we measured Hemoglobin, Serum ferritin adjusted with CRP, AGP, Serum hepcidin, Anaemia-related symptoms, adherence & treatment side effects. We also collected basic socio demographic information from the participants. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2018 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Based on these database, researchers within the team is planning to write several publications. Two of our abstracts have been accepted in American Society for Nutrition conference in Baltimore, in June 2019. 
 
Description Production of Lactoferrin 
Organisation Eskayef Bangladesh Limited
Country Bangladesh 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution We are working with Eskayef Bangladesh Ltd, one of the top pharmaceutical company of Bangladesh in developing the Lactoferrin, Ferrous Sulphate and placebo for our clinical trial
Collaborator Contribution Eskayef is working with the research team and will produce the products as per our requirements
Impact None so far
Start Year 2016
 
Title Bovine Lactoferrin for treatment of Anemia 
Description As part of the overall goal of the project we are measuring the effectiveness of bovine lactoferrin in correcting iron deficiency anaemia among non-pregnant women of reproductive age and pregnant women compared to standard iron supplements. We are currently in the production phase. We will soon start recruiting study participants for our clinical trial 
Type Therapeutic Intervention - Drug
Current Stage Of Development Initial development
Year Development Stage Completed 2017
Development Status Under active development/distribution
Impact None so far