Development of two community-based interventions targeting inappropriate antibiotic dispensing and use behaviours in rural Vietnam

Lead Research Organisation: University of Oxford
Department Name: Tropical Medicine

Abstract

Between 2000 and 2010, worldwide antibiotic consumption increased by 35%, including large rises in the use of antibiotic drugs used as a last-resort, when other treatments fail. This rise was particularly apparent in middle income countries, with growing populations and increasing access to antibiotics. Rising levels of antibiotic consumption are associated high levels of antibiotic resistance, and increasing numbers of bacterial infections that are difficult or impossible to treat with antibiotics. Reducing inappropriate antibiotic use has been shown to reduce the level of antibiotic resistance at population-level in high income countries, but few population-level interventions aiming to reduce antibiotic use have been evaluated in low and middle income countries with higher burdens of infectious disease and antibiotic resistance.

This development grant will inform the design of two community-based interventions aiming to reduce inappropriate antibiotic use and related antibiotic resistance. One intervention will target the supply of antibiotics through private pharmacies, the major source of treatment for minor illness, and where antibiotics can easily be obtained without a prescription. Introducing a rapid diagnostic test in this setting would help pharmacists to differentiate between people with non-bacterial infections that do not require antibiotics, and those with likely bacterial infections that should be referred to a health professional. The other intervention will tackle the demand for antibiotics in communities by using participatory discussion in groups to improve understanding of the problem of antibiotic resistance, and develop appropriate strategies to address it in their community.

To assist intervention development, we will conduct a review of the literature to learn from other successful approaches using rapid diagnostic tests outside the formal healthcare system, and health behaviour change interventions in communities. We will collect information from providers and consumers of antibiotics in communities, to understand what drives inappropriate use, and we will also explore their views about the introduction of rapid diagnostic tests in pharmacies, and what price would be attractive for both. We will work with community members, using visual media to develop materials and messages that can be used to talk about antibiotic resistance with other communities.

On finalising the design of the interventions, a methodology will be developed to evaluate and understand the effect of these interventions, with input from experts and local partners. Funding sources will be identified to implement the interventions and research the effect of community-based interventions on antibiotic use and resistance in rural Vietnam. We will disseminate our learning from this process through international peer reviewed publications, briefing papers, and discussions with local partners and community participants.

Technical Summary

Between 2000 and 2010, worldwide antibiotic consumption increased by 35%, including large rises in use of last-resort antibiotics, and particularly in middle income countries. Reducing inappropriate antibiotic use has been shown to reduce the prevalence of antibiotic resistant bacteria at population-level in high income countries, but few population-level interventions aiming to reduce antibiotic use have been evaluated in low and middle income countries with higher burdens of infectious disease and antibiotic resistance.

This development grant will inform the design of two community-based interventions aiming to reduce inappropriate antibiotic use and resistance. One intervention will target the supply of antibiotics through private pharmacies, the major source of treatment for minor illness, where antibiotics can easily be obtained without a prescription. Introducing rapid diagnostic tests would help pharmacists to differentiate between bacterial and non-bacterial infections, and reduce inappropriate antibiotic dispensing. The other intervention will tackle the demand for antibiotics in communities by using participatory action research to improve understanding of the problem of antibiotic resistance, and develop appropriate strategies to address at community-level.

To inform the design of the interventions, we will conduct a literature review, and qualitative and economic interviews with providers and consumers of antibiotics. We will use a community-led media approach to develop messages and content for the community group intervention. During the development phase we will also develop a probabilistic mathematical model to explore the potential impact of community-based, pharmacy-based, and combined approaches.

Planned Impact

The aim of the main study is to test public health interventions with the potential to reduce exposure to antibiotics, carriage of resistant bacteria, and potentially the emergence and spread of untreatable bacterial infections. If successful, these could have population-wide benefits in reducing the burden of antibiotic resistance. These early phase studies will also have the following academic, economic and societal impacts:
1. Academic impacts
a. The ethnographic and social research will add to our understanding of the driving forces for inappropriate antibiotic use in communities, and consequently inform the design of appropriate interventions to reduce this.
b. The mathematical model will provide useful information for policymakers in Vietnam, and could easily be adapted to inform priorities and planning in other countries in the region and low and middle income countries elsewhere in the world.
2. Economic and societal impacts
a. Communities and providers involved in the research will gain increased awareness of antibiotic resistance and ways to reduce it.
b. Through interviews and community discussions, and the use of community-led, participatory visual media approaches, participants may gain an insight into the problem of antibiotic overuse, and consider making changes to their behaviour.
 
Title Communicating the importance of proper antibiotic use for communties in Vietnam 
Description This is a short film depicting a mother with a sick child and her journey interacting with different health providers as she learns that her child has an antibiotic resistant infection and what it means. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2020 
Impact This film will initially be used as a communication and discussion tool for further community-based engagement and research. We will then release it for the general public through institutional websites and social media channels. 
 
Title Exhibition of photos from communities and farmers relating their perspectives on antibiotic use 
Description We conducted a community-led media study with 26 community members and farmers taking photos, selecting the best ones, and telling the stories behind them. These have been shown locally in their own communities, at a national public exhibition and are now accessible through an online exhibition. 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact The exhibitions are used as an opportunity to raise awareness about antibiotic resistance, and the photos will be used for developing a range of communication materials around antibiotic resistance for future interventions with the public. 
URL https://assets.artplacer.com/virtual-exhibitions/?i=3290
 
Description Research activities have been completed, one publication has been submitted, and two other publications are in progress. We have hosted two discussions with parents of pre-school children in a northern province of Vietnam, about healthcare seeking and the use of antibiotics. We have hosted a community-led media study culminating in two photo exhibitions about the use of antibiotics in communities and in farming. We have conducted interviews with 500 customers at community pharmacies to explore the feasibility, acceptability and willingness-to-pay for point-of-care tests as a means of reducing over-the-counter sales of antibiotics. To date we have learned a lot about community knowledge and practice regarding antibiotic use, as well as how communities organise and meet together. We will use these findings to inform the development of interventions to tackle inappropriate antibiotic use for humans and farming.
Exploitation Route We have used what we have learned so far to feed into our own future work developing community-based interventions, as well as to external groups discussing and learning best practice on community engagement for antibiotic resistance.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Communities and Social Services/Policy,Healthcare

 
Description We have held discussions and photo exhibitions in communities and with farmers in northern Vietnam to discuss antibiotic use and highlight issues related to over use of antibiotics, such as antibiotic resistance.
First Year Of Impact 2021
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink,Communities and Social Services/Policy,Healthcare
Impact Types Societal

 
Description Generating collective solutions to reduce unnecessary antibiotic use in Vietnam
Amount £257,270 (GBP)
Funding ID 213920/Z/18/Z 
Organisation Wellcome Trust 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2019 
End 03/2023
 
Title Community-led media study to explore perspectives on antibiotic use for humans and farming 
Description We developed a methodology based on Photovoice, whereby 26 community members and farmers in four groups were trained and given cameras for 2 weeks to take photos of healthcare behaviours and how antibiotics affect their lives. Groups then came back to discuss their photos and the meanings behind them. They have selected the best photos and will display them in a community exhibition, as well as a national dissemination event. We also used the opportunity when discussing photos to learn more about community knowledge and practice related to antibiotics. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact This method will be used to inform a One Health community intervention to tackle inappropriate antibiotic use. Results will be published once the cycle of community meetings has been completed in March and discussion transcripts have been analysed. 
 
Title Willingness-to-pay for point-of-care testing in pharmacies 
Description We developed a willingness-to-pay research design and survey tool to assess the feasibility of point-of-care testing in pharmacies to reduce antibiotic dispensing in Vietnam 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2019 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact None yet 
 
Title An agent-based model to explore the potential impact of different public health interventions on antibiotic use and colonisation with resistant bacteria 
Description An agent-based simulation model using the GAMA platform to explore the potential impact of different public health interventions on antibiotic use and colonisation with resistant bacteria. This model was calibrated using data from a community-based survey we had conducted previously in Vietnam. The model has not yet been published or made available, but will be soon. 
Type Of Material Computer model/algorithm 
Year Produced 2019 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Not yet achieved 
 
Title Estimating the potential impact of interventions to reduce antimicrobial resistance: Application to a commune in Vietnam. 
Description This was a statistical modelling project to investigate the potential impact on antibiotic resistance when community behaviours are changed. We used a dataset from a previous pilot study in a rural community, which included a household behaviour survey coupled with stool and nasal samples. Stool and nasal samples allowed us to identify antibiotic resistance among commensal bacteria, and relate the prevalence of resistance to risk behaviours. Intervention programs are being utilised widely to combat the spread of AMR. For many resource limited countries, this is an expensive exercise with limited funding. Therefore, before any intervention is implemented, it is crucial to estimate its impact because it enables investigators to inform policy and planning. This can also provide information on what risks/protective factors are significant for the region and have the intervention tailored to the population. We used a novel method using weighted likelihood (WL) that provides estimates of the impacts of proposed interventions as well as confidence intervals. Our research was divided into three parts, first we conducted a literature study to find out what models are currently used in estimating impacts of intervention studies, then we used simulation to test our model and finally we applied the model to data from a baseline study from a commune in Ha Nam Province, Vietnam. Most intervention studies use applied time series analyses or two-group tests to evaluate complete data. For proposed interventions, the standard method is a mathematical model which provides only estimates, without a way to quantify precision. To test our proposed methods, we simulated 2000 data to generate and estimate the impact of an intervention. Subsequently, we applied the model to the data from Vietnam. Calibration was applied to the model using auxiliary information in order to gain efficiency. The model performed well in estimating the impact of the intervention variable on the outcome. It also provided results for protective/risk factors that agree with other published studies. This shows that, our methodology works well and can be used to estimate the impact of intervention programs. 
Type Of Material Data analysis technique 
Year Produced 2020 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact This model will be used on a larger population-based dataset from Vietnam, as well as household survey data from other low- and middle-income countries. Results from this initial model-building exercise will be published. 
 
Description Department of Statistics, University of Auckland 
Organisation University of Auckland
Country New Zealand 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We provided data from a pilot study and local epidemiological insights to inform the analysis.
Collaborator Contribution A lecturer and MSc student in the Department of Statistics worked on the data to simulate and test a statistical model.
Impact Currently a MSc thesis entitled "Estimating the potential impact of interventions to reduce antimicrobial resistance: Application to a commune in Vietnam." This will be written up as an academic paper.
Start Year 2019
 
Title Antibioship - a serious game about antibiotic resistance 
Description Antibioship is a serious game about antibiotic resistance aimed at secondary school students. Students play the role of a "ship" inside the human body. They meet different types of microbes, including viruses, pathogenic bacteria, and "good bacteria". They have the option of using antibodies or antibiotics to shoot the microbes. As the game progresses, bacteria may develop resistance depending on how much antibiotics are used. 
Type Of Technology Webtool/Application 
Year Produced 2019 
Open Source License? Yes  
Impact This has been presented and shared at conferences. We will test the impact of playing the game on students' knowledge in an upcoming study. 
 
Description Co-design of communication materials about antibiotic use and antibiotic resistance for parents of pre-school children 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact Parents of pre-school children were invited to attend two focus group discussions to learn about their knowledge and understanding of illnesses among children and the role of antibiotics. Gaps in knowledge were identified and used to inform the development of communication materials and posters. These materials will be shown to the parents, the impact on their knowledge assessed, and their suggestions for further improvements will be sought. A final set of resources will be distributed in communities through local channels.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
 
Description Community-led media study to explore perspectives on healthcare and antibiotic use among rural communities and farmers 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Community members and farmers (26 participants) from four communities, participated in initial training and discussions, and were given cameras to take home. Over a period of two weeks, they were asked to document topics related to healthcare or antibiotic use. They then brought the photos back to the group and discussed why they had taken the photos and what they mean to them. The group selected the best photos to be displayed in local community exhibitions and a national photo exhibition to raise awareness about the issue of overuse of antibiotics.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Development and evaluation of a serious game about antibiotic resistance for secondary school children 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact A serious game about antibiotic resistance was developed by a research student in computer sciences in our team. We tested this game among secondary and high school students, and evaluated the impact on their knowledge and understanding of antibiotic resistance, as well as getting their feedback on how they enjoyed the game and what could be improved.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020