Inter-generational risk factors for obesity: a path to prevention in LMICs based on a modifiable epigenetic signature in the POMC gene

Lead Research Organisation: London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine
Department Name: MRC Unit The Gambia at LSHTM

Abstract

Obesity is a major global public health issue with increasing damaging effects in low and middle-income countries (LMIC) including The Gambia. Obesity interventions are generally expensive and ineffective; therefore, prevention is key. LMICs are predicted to be the hardest hit by the projected increases in obesity and T2 diabetes (T2D). Due to poorly resourced health care in LMICs the case-fatality rates for obesity and T2D are much higher than in affluent nations and constitute a major burden for health budgets now and more so in the future.
BMI (body mass index) is highly heritable (runs in families), though genetic variants account for a small proportion of individual body weight variability. Epigenetic mechanisms (e.g. DNA methylation) may explain much of the missing heritability. Variably Methylated Regions (VMR) are regions in the genome that show substantial variation between individuals in their methylation; this variation may contribute to variations in characteristics (e.g. body weight) between individuals by altering gene expression.
Obesity is a disorder of over consumption. A complex network of hormonal pathways regulates appetite and satiety, with POMC (pro-opiomelanocortin) hormone that mediates satiety responses in the brain. It is a key regulator of energy balance and obesity risk.
Increased DNA methylation at a variably methylated region (VMR) at the POMC intron2/exon3 boundary is correlated with BMI in children and adults. POMC methylation influences the amount of POMC gene expression, thus provides a link between POMC methylation and obesity. It has been shown previously that POMC methylation is established in the early embryo and is influenced by seasonal nutritional changes at conception in Gambians. It has also been shown that children's methylation at POMC VMR is associated with the father's methylation not the mother's.
It is therefore hypothesised that 1) POMC hypermethylation (by dampening satiety) will promote more rapid weight gain in the harvest season and protect against weight loss in the hungry season, 2) offspring POMC methylation is influenced by the mother's nutrition around time of conception and 3) offspring POMC methylation is correlated with father's, but not mother's, peripheral blood cell methylation.
We will exploit our well-established Gambian seasonal 'experiment of nature', whereby seasonal changes in rainfall (wet and dry seasons) creates profound contrasts in the availability and composition of food, in work patterns among adults, and in infectious disease and growth patterns in children. This leads to seasonally driven variations in individual's weight and body composition over the year e.g. in Gambian women on average weight fluctuates by nearly 4 kg between June and October.
The project will follow up 500 mother and child pairs monthly over a year to examine their weight, BMI and body composition in relation to their POMC methylation taken at the start of the study. A subset of 100 mother and child pairs will also have DXA (Dual energy X-ray Absorptiometry) scans and an ab libitum breakfast (participants are freely permitted to consume as much breakfast as they wish as a measure of satiety) at three time points (at peaks of seasons; April-October-April) over the year.
Understanding epigenetic regulation of POMC and how this influences body weight and susceptibility to obesity, could enable the design of nutritional interventions for women of child-bearing age that would mitigate obesity risk in their offspring. It is important to assess the effect of methylation at POMC VMR on BMI in diverse settings before considering future interventions in this LMIC. If it is found that these epigenetic marks are nutritionally modifiable and further that they influence weight regulation in infants and children, this would open a new chapter in directed interventions designed to optimise human foetal development and life-long health outcomes.

Technical Summary

Pro-opiomelanocortin (POMC) gives rise to melanocortin stimulating hormone (MSH) peptides that mediate the anorectic (appetite suppressing) action of leptin via melanocortin receptors (especially MC4R) in the hypothalamus. Mutations in the gene are associated with obesity.
There is evidence that POMC methylation levels are linked to obesity in adults and children; influenced by maternal nutrition around the time of conception; correlated with POMC methylation in paternal blood (but not maternal); stable at least over the period from birth to adulthood and influences POMC expression. POMC VMR methylation is correlated across tissues from 3 germ layers including peripheral blood cells (PBC) and hypothalamic tissue (where POMC neurons exert their effect), indicating that PBC are an appropriate accessible tissue to measure hypothalamic POMC VMR methylation.

We will determine how POMC methylation influences weight regulation and adiposity against a background of large seasonal fluctuations in energy availability in rural Gambia. Growth data and POMC VMR methylation (banked DNA from children aged 0-2 years, n=800) will be examined to establish any associations between weight changes and POMC methylation. A prospective study of 500 mothers and children (5-9 years) will include monthly anthropometry and bioimpedance and a measure of POMC VMR methylation. A subset will have DXA scans and measurement of an ab libitum breakfast. Dietary influence over POMC methylation will be examined by correlating circulating maternal one carbon metabolites and offspring methylation. Longitudinal stability of POMC methylation will be tested by measuring POMC methylation (subset) at multiple time points. All children will be genotyped using an array enriched for African-specific variants to assess potential genetic effects on POMC methylation. Intergenerational influences on offspring methylation will be assessed by measuring POMC VMR methylation in 100 mother-father-offspring trios.

Planned Impact

Obesity and its associated comorbidity type-2 diabetes (T2D) account for more than 4 million deaths per year, and low and middle-income countries (LMICs) are predicted to be the hardest hit by the projected increases in these conditions. A clearer understanding of the biological pathways that make individuals more or less susceptible to obesity could therefore have a substantial global health impact by contributing to the development of novel preventive and therapeutic approaches (including the identification of possible pharmacologic targets) to tackling obesity. This work will be of particular interest to public health scientists, nutritional epidemiologists and clinicians and could lead to exciting avenues in obesity prevention in LMICs and also in other settings (including the UK).

The Pro-opiomelanocortin (POMC) hormone, expressed in the hypothalamus, plays a central role in satiety, and it has been shown that increased DNA methylation in a region of this gene is a strong predictor of obesity. Importantly, from prior work, POMC methylation is established in the early embryo, and is sensitive both to maternal nutritional environment around conception and correlates with paternal, not maternal, methylation.
If successful, this work would contribute to advances in a surprisingly broad spectrum of science with a potential large impact on strategies for the prevention of obesity and associated comorbidities. In basic science, the proposed work can provide insights into nutritional and intergenerational factors affecting epigenetic regulation in the developing embryo by analysing the effects of one-carbon metabolites on differentiating pluripotent cells and exploring inter-generational epigenetic regulation in family trios. It may thereby add to our understanding of the heritability of human obesity and contribute to knowledge of how POMC and other environmentally-sensitive variably methylated regions (MEs) affect evolutionary fitness.
The proposed studies mapping the effects of POMC methylation on weight regulation, and appetite control offer a direct means of assessing the energy-regulating effects of this gene in a human population. Furthermore, by confirming and strengthening our understanding of how the maternal methyl donor metabolome influences POMC regulation and obesity risk, this work opens up the possibility of modifying obesity risk by changing parental periconceptional diet, for both natural and assisted conceptions.

Contribution to improving the health of people of The Gambia
Obesity has become an archetypal symbol of modern human development that is now threatening the health of populations in almost every region of the world. Moderate overweight and obesity predict meaningful increases in the risks of numerous other co-morbid conditions (including T2D) that together impose high costs to health services. Obesity is notoriously resistant to health interventions at both the individual and population levels. In the Gambian population, obesity is becoming an increasing public health concern even outside of urban centres. Understanding the role of a potentially modifiable epigenetic contributor to obesity could have widespread benefits to the people of Gambia and around the world. Obesity treatment is expensive and generally ineffective; therefore, development of preventative strategies is essential. This work would explore the mechanisms of early foetal programming leading to obesity and potentially inform maternal and paternal nutritional interventions to mitigate this risk for future generations. Equally gaining understanding of the early programming of hormonal control of energy balance and examining this under nutritional and infectious disease burden allows for greater knowledge of contributors to undernutrition across the life course. By understanding the relationship between the epigenome and health outcomes, interventions could be developed to minimize deleterious epigenetic programming.

People

ORCID iD

 
Title Gambian Visual Analogue Scale for Satiety 
Description 8 point visual analogue scale for satiety for Gambian mothers 5 point visual analogue scale for satiety for Gambian children 5-8 years 
Type Of Art Image 
Year Produced 2019 
Impact Used in satiety tests 
 
Description Epigenetic regulation of thyroid function: examining the potentially modifiable effect of differential PAX-8 methylation on thyroid function in children in The Gambia
Amount £10,000 (GBP)
Organisation Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health (RCPCH) 
Department British Society for Paediatric Endocrinology and Diabetes (BSPED)
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country United Kingdom
Start 11/2018 
End 10/2020
 
Title Developed a tool to measure appetite and satiety in Gambian mothers and children 
Description Baseline pilot study A baseline appetite test established the feasibility of assessing appetite using an ad libitum meal in our sample. An ad libitum breakfast of local Gambian porridge (Tiakere Churo) was given to children and mothers after an overnight fast (see protocol, appendix G) using similar methodology and food used as previous studies (109-114) Time taken to eat, and amount consumed were measured. Children were shown a five-scale VAS from Faith et al before eating and 10 minutes after they had finished. Participants were offered more porridge 5 minutes after stopping eating (same methodology as described previously). Revised appetite test for Midline and Endline study timepoints Following the experiences of the baseline appetite test and after consultation with Professor Blundell (on PhD advisory panel), the appetite test was amended to include a preload breakfast followed by an ad libitum lunch, as used in previous studies. This method has the advantage of standardising the amount eaten and assessing subsequent 'decay' in satiety response (using frequent VAS). The preload breakfast (after an overnight fast) was personalised to account for estimated resting metabolic rate (RMR), considered a key driver of appetite. RMR was estimated using the following equations i) Mother(kj/d)= 616.93-14.9(Age)+35.12(Wt)+19.83(Ht)- 271.88(Ethnicity*) (120) ii) Boys(kcal/d)= (16.6wt)+(77ht)+572 (121) iii) Girls(kcal/d)= (7.4wt)+(482ht)+217 (121) The porridge recipe gave an energy density of 3.4 kJ/g (NB 1 Kcal= 4.184 kj). The preload portion was calculated as 20% of the estimated RMR for mothers and 15% of the estimated RMR for children. An ad libitum lunch of a filled "tapalapa" sandwich was given 120 minutes after the breakfast. This reflects a typical meal typically consumed at that time of day. Developing a VAS A Gambian specific VAS was developed with an aim of improving the accuracy and acceptability of the tool. Normal weight volunteer mothers and children were used to develop a culturally typical silhouette. A scale of 1-10 was used for adults and 1-5 for children. 
Type Of Material Physiological assessment or outcome measure 
Year Produced 2019 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact This has allowed us to accurately measure appetite and satiety with a specific tool for measuring hunger and satiety for children and mothers in The Gambia. I aim to publish this in the coming year. 
 
Title POMC Database 
Description A total of 493 children were recruited from a potential 572 from the ENID trial. A total of 513 mothers were recruited from a potential of 691 mothers from the ENID trial. A group of these mothers (n=118) and children (n=118) were recruited into a study subset. The study subset were recruited from the villages of Keneba, Jali, Kantong Kunda, Manduar and Tankular. The database includes measurements taken at study baseline, midline and endline and are detailed below: Study baseline (main cohort and subset): Participants attended Keneba field station from 16th April until 15th May 2018 (start of Ramadan). Five mls of fasted blood was taken. All children were measured in triplicate for weight, height, MUAC, skin fold thickness (MRCG@LSTHM SOP:NUTP.SOP.2009) and had a measurement of bioimpedance using TANITA BC-418 MA body composition analyser (MRCG@LSHTM SOP:NUTP.SOP.2018). Monthly Field visits (main cohort and subset): All participants had monthly (12 consecutive months from May 16th onwards) scheduled field visits for anthropometry including weight, height, MUAC, skin fold thickness and a measurement of bioimpedance. Two field teams visited participants in a fixed order to standardise the period between each measurement. 'Mopping' days were included to attempt to visit participants again if they were unavailable during a planned visit. During each encounter, the mother was asked if she was pregnant and offered antenatal care accordingly. If pregnant, she would exit the study. Field workers also asked 'During the past 30 days, how often did you go hungry because there was not enough food in your home? Never, Rarely, Sometimes, Most of the time, Always' (105) to try to ascertain fluctuations in household food security that may also influence weight. Subset activity: Three time-points were termed baseline, midline and endline and reflected peaks of seasons i.e. dry-harvest: April-May 2018; rainy-hungry: October-November 2018; and dry-harvest April-May 2019. The timing of peaks of season was an estimate of peaks of weight loss and gain informed by previous data in both women and children (figure 8). We would have preferred to use May and October as our timepoints, but the study started in Mid-April to avoid Ramadan (May 16th 2018). A full blood count (to assess influence of iron deficiency anaemia on appetite) was taken at baseline only after review of baseline results. At these time-points participants were scheduled a whole body DXA (Dual energy X-ray Absorptiometry) scan (Lunar Prodigy). Mothers had a urinary pregnancy test prior to scanning. A measurement of appetite and satiety was taken at baseline/midline/endline. A further 5 ml fasted blood draw was taken at midline and endline for leptin (biochemical assessment of adiposity) and POMC VMR methylation (to examine seasonal changes/age/body weight influence on DNA Methylation). 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2019 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Not analysed as yet 
 
Description Dr Peter Kuhnen, Charite Berlin, Germany 
Organisation Charité - University of Medicine Berlin
Department Paediatric Endocrinology Charité
Country Germany 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution PCR product produced in the Gambia and transported to Germany for pyrosequencing.
Collaborator Contribution We were experiencing difficulties with our pyrosequencer in The Gambia and therefore I collaborated with Dr Kuhnen to support the pyrosequencing in Germany. He is an advisory committee member for my PhD and therefore has contributed the expertise for this work in his lab.
Impact The results of the work will inform a large part of the analysis for the POMC study.
Start Year 2020
 
Description Professor Robert Waterland - Baylor College of Medicine, Texas. 
Organisation Baylor College of Medicine
Country United States 
Sector Hospitals 
PI Contribution Following the outcomes of a substudy of the award (PAX8 study), we collaborated with Professor Waterland to examine DNA methylation/Expression in thyroid and blood from the GTEx database.
Collaborator Contribution Pyrosequencing of DNA from GTEx database for thyroid and blood
Impact Submission of paper to Cell Metabolism "DNA Methylation at a nutritionally sensitive region of the PAX8 gene is associated with thyroid volume and function in Gambian children"
Start Year 2020
 
Description I am a Scientist Get Me Out of Here 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact I'm a Scientist is an online activity where school students connect with real scientists about real science. It's a competition between scientists, where students are the judges.

Students challenge the scientists over fast-paced online text-based live CHATs. They ASK the scientists anything they want, and VOTE for their favourite scientist to win a prize of £500 to communicate their work with the public.
This is taken from the website https://imascientist.org.uk/ and I am in the MRC 2020 section. This is due to start on 2nd March 2020 and run until 27th March 2020.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://mrc2020.imascientist.org.uk/
 
Description Keneba Community Open Day 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an open day or visit at my research institution
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Open day for West Kiang The Gambia community.
the event had over 1000 people visit the field station in one day. 10 stations with 15 minute presentations and discussions were shown to visitors. This included study participants.
The POMC team (focus of this grant) gave a presentation to the villages on the nature and scope of the study.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://www.mrc.gm/open-day-at-keneba-field-station/