Feasibility, acceptability and impact of an innovative, tailored HIV prevention intervention for MSM at high-risk of HIV in Indonesia.

Lead Research Organisation: Chelsea and Westminster Hospital NHS Foundation Trust
Department Name: HIV Research

Abstract

Despite significant progress in HIV management and prevention, 1.8 million new HIV infections were recorded worldwide in 2016, with many settings observing increasing numbers of new HIV infections, predominantly in key affected populations. Despite the development of revolutionary evidence-based HIV prevention interventions, combating the HIV/AIDS epidemic still remains a major global health challenge. Key populations groups, namely, men who have sex with men (MSM), transgender people, people who inject drugs, prisoners and sex workers, are at greatest risk of being affected by HIV and they frequently lack adequate access to appropriate services. Stigma and discrimination are among the primary barriers to HIV prevention, treatment and support; key populations in particular face significant stigma in many settings.
Indonesia has the third largest number of people living with HIV (PLWH) in Asia and the Pacific; with 620,000 PLWH and 48,000 new infections recorded in 2016. Key populations are most affected and at greatest risk of HIV. In 2016, HIV prevalence estimates were 25.8% in MSM (compared to 8.5% in 2011), new infections are increasing significantly and rapidly in MSM in Indonesia but more reportedly stable in other key populations. In major cities Denpasar in Bali and Jakarta, nearly one in three MSM are infected with HIV.

Indonesia is observing worsening stigma and discrimination against MSM, transgender people and PLWH which is significantly slowing the country's HIV response. This rise in anti- LGBT rhetoric adds great challenges of allowing a human rights-based approach to sexual health care and HIV prevention to hard-to-reach key populations and counteracting HIV prevention and treatment targets. Innovative and sensitive methods of engaging at risk communities to improve access and uptake to services, without increasing their vulnerability to abuse, are greatly needed. Tailored mobile phone, internet-based programs may be a critical way to engage key populations like MSM who are understood to be a technologically/mobile smartphone literate population.

We propose a tailored, innovative HIV prevention model to strengthen HIV prevention services and accelerate the response to a growing burden of HIV in MSM, in Indonesia. A model appropriately adapted through at-risk population engagement, from one that has demonstrated success in dramatically reducing new HIV infections in MSM in London.
We propose assessing the feasibility, acceptability and impact of;
(1) a mobile-phone text-message based digital-health HIV risk-reduction intervention, tailored to the MSM population at high risk of HIV in Indonesia; developed through at-risk population engagement and needs assessment.
(2) integrating point of care/rapid HIV and HIV monitoring diagnostics in an existing sexual-healthcare service, to also determine the proportion of very early HIV acquisition in new HIV diagnoses to further guide HIV treatment and prevention.
(3) integrating evidence-based prevention interventions - immediate antiretroviral treatment as prevention to all individuals recently diagnosed/living with HIV and oral Pre-Exposure Prophylaxis provision (a proven HIV preventative medicine) to MSM at risk of HIV in an existing sexual-healthcare service.

Can the prevention model have an impact on; increasing HIV testing coverage in MSM at risk of HIV; reduce undiagnosed and late diagnoses of HIV infection in this at-risk population; have an impact on reducing new HIV infections and improve retention in HIV care and antiretroviral treatment (ART) adherence in people diagnosed and living with HIV. Ultimately to contribute to the UNAIDS/WHO goals in ending AIDS as a global public health threat in this region, to aid disease prevention and improve health in this population and consequently have economic benefits for the country as a whole.

Technical Summary

In Indonesia 620,000 people living with HIV (PLWH) and 48,000 new HIV infections were reported in 2016. Key populations are most greatly affected and at highest risk; HIV prevalence estimates were 25.8% in MSM (compared to 8.5% in 2011); new infections are increasing significantly and rapidly in MSM. Indonesia is observing worsening stigma and discrimination against MSM, transgender people and PLWH which is significantly slowing the country's HIV response. This adds great challenges of allowing a human rights-based approach to HIV prevention to these hard-to-reach populations. Innovative and sensitive methods of engaging at-risk communities to improve access and uptake to services, without increasing vulnerability, are greatly needed.
We propose a tailored, innovative HIV prevention model to strengthen HIV prevention services and accelerate the response to a growing burden of HIV in MSM.
We propose a mixed methods prospective observational cohort study to assess feasibility, acceptability and impact of;
(1) a HIV risk-reduction mobile-phone text-message based digital-health intervention, tailored to the MSM population at high risk of HIV in Indonesia; developed through at-risk population engagement and needs assessment.
(2) integrating & scaling up point of care (POC) HIV antibody/antigen testing; POC HIV viral load and RITA testing to detect diagnoses in primary infection in an existing sexual-healthcare service.
(3) integrating evidence-based prevention interventions-immediate ART as prevention to all individuals recently diagnosed/living with HIV and PrEP provision to at-risk individuals in an existing sexual-healthcare service.
Can the model have an impact on;(1) increasing HIV testing coverage in MSM at-risk of HIV; (2) reduce undiagnosed HIV infection and; (3) reduce late diagnoses of HIV in this at-risk population; (4) have an impact on reducing HIV incidence in this population, (5) improve retention in care and ART adherence in PLWH.

Planned Impact

The proposed intervention is designed to promote health, prevent disease and enhance the quality of the target population's sexual health and well-being, particularly at a time when the target population experiencing increasing discrimination, abuse and are affected by increasing HIV infections.
We will use focus-group sessions to engage the at-risk target population to better understand high risk behavior in the current environment in Indonesia and what increases vulnerability, social exclusion and dis-empowerment, and what information and additional support can reduce this - to develop a innovative digital and mobile phone/web based method to provide tailored, accepted HIV risk- reduction information and integrate at greater scale evidence based HIV prevention methods to accelerate the HIV response in Indonesia.

In addition to the academic beneficiaries outlined, independent digital health companies may also benefit from this research with regards to whether digital methods can be tailored to different populations to improve disease prevention and promote health/well-being.
We are interested and keen to present data and outcomes to differing academic and relevant independent healthcare innovation forums including Digital Health and healthcare Innovation forums and non-infectious disease international conferences where appropriate.

Beneficiaries include all stakeholders, including the sexual health and HIV study clinic staff, and in general the local Balinese population, local ministry of health/Government, policy makers and Indonesian society as a whole and the national (Indonesian) HIV clinical community.

Translating an appropriately adapted and tailored model involving digital healthcare innovation by target population engagement, understanding risk behavior and complex drivers of risk behavior at this current challenging time of increasing HIV infections in MSM but within an increasingly stigmatized environment, can be used to inform local government and policy makers within Indonesia and Asia.

This research will in our opinion directly impact on Bali's and consequently Indonesia's health (accelerating the HIV response), wealth by creating health related savings (reduced HIV/AIDS mortality and morbidity/reduced late HIV diagnoses), and culture by empowering vulnerable at-risk groups to be better informed of their risk, access to HIV prevention, using innovative platforms they show existing high engagement in.
This research can also guide and inform researchers and industry on further developing tailored, digital health methods disease prevention.

We will also be training staff within the sexual health and HIV study site which will provide them with skills they can take forward when managing patients and offering HIV and sexual health prevention advice even after the end of the study. Having been a HIV clinician in diverse settings for over 10 years I believe the first consultation with a newly HIV diagnosed individual has paramount importance with regards to how they go on to perceive themselves, how empowered they are with information and hope for the future and how well they manage their condition, adhere to ART and to their general wellbeing.
Although working with an Indonesian team, I will myself be learning Indonesian as soon as I arrive in order to better and more effectively communicate with the target population subjects and with staff. We aim to share knowledge and skills that will benefit research teams from both countries after the end of the research project.
 
Title Bahasa animation for HIV prevention promotion (Generation Zero) translated via the 56 Dean Street Generation Zero campaign 
Description AN_DeanStreet_Indonesian_FInal_v2.mp4 (please access Bahasa Indonesia version of Generation Zero animation here). The URL below is for the same animation - however the logos are not updated on this URL. 'Generation Zero' now in Bahasa Indonesian is a dedicated, tailored HIV prevention animation that provides key, easy to understand and visualise information on how to prevent HIV and how we can move towards an AIDS free generation. This was created by the innovative HIV and sexual health specialist team at 56 Dean Street and adapted by the UTAMA project team to be applicable and appropriate to the highly at-risk and marginalised MSM population in Indonesia (not only Bali) but throughout Indonesia. "We can beat HIV by acting together. Introducing 56 Dean Street's 'Generation ZERO' project. Our commitment to creating an AIDS free generation" 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2020 
Impact This has not been released yet to the wider public. It will be incorporated within the project launch. We also plan to 'gift' this to UNAIDS Indonesia (at no cost to them) for greater HIV prevention purposes. The Bahasa translation version has been led by Keerti Gedela with the UTAMA Indonesian and 56 Dean Street team and Anatomy productions anatomylondon.com The Generation Zero animation (initially English version) was shown to a select group of Indonesian local Ministry of Health and district and provincial health officials at a joint UTAMA stakeholder meeting in Bali; some participants responded with a round of applause. We gained feedback including, 'visually great', 'simple but effective messaging', 'brilliant'. 
URL https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ib1x1oPv5RI&feature=youtu.be
 
Title Development of UTAMA logo 
Description Development of a unique UTAMA logo. The UTAMA logo is a 'wing' to denote 'rising', 'empowerment', 'strength'. The main logo is a red wing, a colour from the Indonesian national flag (1). We also have a square version (2) for differing media formats and a 'rainbow' coloured LGBT friendly version (3) for PRIDE events. After much scoping activities with MSM at-risk populations, LGBT community in Bali and Indonesia and sexual health services in Indonesia we understood that often the 'rainbow' colours can detract at-risk MSM/LGBT populations due to the very high rates of institutional stigma in Indonesia and the association of these colours. There are also members who may identify this with a 'friendly' service. Therefore as we aim to attract more hard to reach, vulnerable populations - we have two versions, including a 'rainbow'/PRIDE one. (1) file:///Users/keertigedela/Desktop/UTAMA-Logos/Primary%20Logo/UTAMA-Logo-Primary.svg (2) file:///Users/keertigedela/Desktop/UTAMA-Logos/Square%20Logo/UTAMA-Logo-Square.svg (3) file:///Users/keertigedela/Desktop/UTAMA-Logos/Pride%20Logo/UTAMA-Logo-Pride.svg 
Type Of Art Image 
Year Produced 2019 
Impact Unique, empowering brand symbol for the research. 
 
Title UTAMA HIV testing and study recruitment short film (UTAMA: testing for HIV is real love); Bahasa Version (another entry for English version) 
Description Film Synopsis: (featured when showcased at the Global Health Film Festival December 2019) - English and Bahasa versions available. Indonesia has one of the fastest growing HIV epidemics. Worsening discrimination against lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) individuals is significantly slowing the country's HIV response; deaths due to AIDS have never fallen and continue to increase year on year. Men who have sex with men (MSM) have become an increasingly vulnerable group with new infections increasing significantly and rapidly; in high burden districts such as Denpasar, Bali and Jakarta, one in three MSM are infected with HIV. The UTAMA project is run by a UK-Indonesia joint partnership aiming to translate a successful model of HIV prevention, including using media and digital innovation to accelerate the HIV response in a highly vulnerable population suffering from significant health inequality and social injustice in Bali. UTAMA: testing for HIV is real love promotes HIV testing among young MSM in Bali; co-produced by Global Health Film, this short film seeks to engage the local at-risk population and to offer positive imagery that counteracts some perceptions of stigma - as well as to inform and invite members of the target population to the UTAMA study. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2019 
Impact This film has an English and Bahasa version. The film brief was created collaboratively between a diverse multi-disciplinary, peer and commercial group including; expert HIV and sexual health physicians from Indonesia/Bali and London, led by Keerti Gedela; representatives from the Indonesian community including MSM and a participant living with HIV (over telephone contact); media expertise of CrossOver labs https://www.xolabs.co.uk/ and Global health film https://www.globalhealthfilm.org/. This pdf linked document outlines the initial incubation lab meeting invite. file:///Users/keertigedela/Desktop/UTAMA%20Incubation%20lab%20email_RISTEK.html This was an empowering and creative process for all involved. This film was showcased and premiered at the Global Health Film Festival in London, December 2019. Link to programme including UTAMA film and bio for Dr Keerti Gedela https://hubble-live-assets.s3.amazonaws.com/globalhealthfilm/attachment/file/2/GHFF2019_final_programme_27_November_2019.pdf This event was attended by large numbers of the general public including international commercial, film, media and health professionals. I as UK chief investigator was on the a panel discussing and providing awareness of the neglected HIV epidemic in Indonesia, the rising rates of stigma and the project; after main 5B film and our film were watched by a varied audience. Dr Hendry Luis one of the Indonesian investigators was meant to attend this festival to join me but unfortunately was unable to obtain his VISA to enter the UK in time. Due to the comprehensive project not starting yet, predominantly due to a lack of funds that we are actively applying for, it has not yet been released. We will widely release this via digital and physical outreach at the launch of the study. The film will sit on a webpage platform that will have information now how and where to test for HIV, links to the UTAMA study and ho w to join. The film has been piloted to a sample of the target population MSM in Bali; to study clinic donors and to peers within the study clinic. It was had a great reception with some Indonesian MSM deeply moved by a short film that is 'beautiful', 'caring' and 'empowering' 
URL https://we.tl/t-t8jU39Ti5d
 
Title UTAMA HIV testing and study recruitment short film (UTAMA: testing for HIV is real love); English Version (another entry for Bahasa version) 
Description UTAMA HP film_Video 2020-02-25 at 14.29.03.mp4. (please access the film here - we have a url for the Bahasa Indonesian version on another entry) Film Synopsis: (featured when showcased at the Global Health Film Festival December 2019) Indonesia has one of the fastest growing HIV epidemics. Worsening discrimination against lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) individuals is significantly slowing the country's HIV response; deaths due to AIDS have never fallen and continue to increase year on year. Men who have sex with men (MSM) have become an increasingly vulnerable group with new infections increasing significantly and rapidly; in high burden districts such as Denpasar, Bali and Jakarta, one in three MSM are infected with HIV. The UTAMA project is run by a UK-Indonesia joint partnership aiming to translate a successful model of HIV prevention, including using media and digital innovation to accelerate the HIV response in a highly vulnerable population suffering from significant health inequality and social injustice in Bali. UTAMA: testing for HIV is real love promotes HIV testing among young MSM in Bali; co-produced by Global Health Film, this short film seeks to engage the local at-risk population and to offer positive imagery that counteracts some perceptions of stigma - as well as to inform and invite members of the target population to the UTAMA study. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2020 
Impact This film has an English and Bahasa version. The film brief was created collaboratively between a diverse multi-disciplinary, peer and commercial group including; expert HIV and sexual health physicians from Indonesia/Bali and London, led by Keerti Gedela; representatives from the Indonesian community including MSM and a participant living with HIV (over telephone contact); media expertise of CrossOver labs https://www.xolabs.co.uk/ and Global health film https://www.globalhealthfilm.org/. This pdf linked document outlines the initial incubation lab meeting invite. file:///Users/keertigedela/Desktop/UTAMA%20Incubation%20lab%20email_RISTEK.html This was an empowering and creative process for all involved. This film was showcased and premiered at the Global Health Film Festival in London, December 2019. Link to programme including UTAMA film and bio for Dr Keerti Gedela https://hubble-live-assets.s3.amazonaws.com/globalhealthfilm/attachment/file/2/GHFF2019_final_programme_27_November_2019.pdf This event was attended by large numbers of the general public including international commercial, film, media and health professionals. I as UK chief investigator was on the a panel discussing and providing awareness of the neglected HIV epidemic in Indonesia, the rising rates of stigma and the project; after main 5B film and our film were watched by a varied audience. Dr Hendry Luis one of the Indonesian investigators was meant to attend this festival to join me but unfortunately was unable to obtain his VISA to enter the UK in time. Due to the comprehensive project not starting yet, predominantly due to a lack of funds that we are actively applying for, it has not yet been released. We will widely release this via digital and physical outreach at the launch of the study. The film will sit on a webpage platform that will have information now how and where to test for HIV, links to the UTAMA study and ho w to join. The film has been piloted to a sample of the target population MSM in Bali; to study clinic donors and to peers within the study clinic. It was had a great reception with some Indonesian MSM deeply moved by a short film that is 'beautiful', 'caring' and 'empowering' 
URL https://drive.google.com/file/d/1AUO5uclcLKNJNeHmZcTf_O-jpKF5pvDd/view
 
Title UTAMA research webpage/landing page (not a full research website) - for an academic/general public/stakeholder/funder audience 
Description https://utamaresearch.webflow.io/ This UTAMA research webpage/landing page (not a full research website) has been created to include user-friendly, clear snapshot of our project. It has been tailored for an academic, general public, stakeholder, funder audience specifically but also a target population audience where relevant. This has been developed with the whole UTAMA team and with the Manta Ray media company at low cost. 
Type Of Art Artefact (including digital) 
Year Produced 2019 
Impact this research webpage (not full research website due to limited funds) is not fully complete and will be released once the Bahasa version is inputted and once the UTAMA health promotion/study recruitment film and Generation Zero Bahasa animation are embedded (currently not embedded on this version). We have been able to use this draft to demonstrate the work to collaborators, stakeholders and funders at meeting stage. 
URL https://utamaresearch.webflow.io/
 
Description An incredible and valuable amount of data and information has been discovered from the work of this collaboration. The discoveries of this award, to date (and continues) have already contributed to many academic and non-academic impacts.

Academic:
Teaching, guidance and discussion of research, networking and communication skills to Indonesian study clinic staff and investigator team, specifically; creating data sets for complete anonymised longitudinal cohort data; article writing and submission to peer-reviewed journals; developing presentations of up to date HIV epidemiological and social science data to stakeholders, including ministry of health and policy makers (UNAIDS and WHO, Indonesia); engaging with potential commercial and academic funders; writing and submitting funding proposals; creating further collaborations with expert Indonesian organisations.
As a collaborative team we have been working equitably and harmoniously across different disciplines and agencies, encouraging mutual learning and also training/mentoring and research opportunities for junior Indonesian staff and enable organisational and institutional capacity and team building.
This collaborative understanding has led to submitted academic reviews, robust heath blogs (e.g. BMJ), further spin off research studies (study of creating an acute and early HIV algorithm involving UTAMA and the wider collaboration with the Oxford-Eikjman unit, Jakarta) and importantly to further grant applications from a wider, expert collaboration.

There have been many non-academic discoveries, examples include:
Greater in depth understanding of the inefficiencies and inequalities within the health systems providing HIV care in Indonesia that are contributing to large gaps within the HIV testing/treatment cascade, and what challenges need to be overcome to help improve the health system which allows a tailored, impactful HIV intervention.
We have gained greater depth in understanding of the diversity and complexity of driving factors of the HIV epidemic among key populations and the spill over to the general population in Indonesia.

Below is an example of a comprehensive review submitted to the Journal of the International AIDS Society. For all submitted publications, results are still pending.
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1fr1-eytqGREPUP_ASvDPVtSoxBhXTI7sGi8bNciQNkc/edit?usp=sharing

During the period here the conservative politic rhetoric impacting public health outreach to LGBT/marginalised populations has increased with the release of two draft laws. A proposed bill was passed, but since suspended, in national parliament to criminalise sexual relations outside marriage, affecting the privacy rights of all. A more recent proposed draft law is also calling to enforce families and individuals to report to the government for rehabilitation if they believe a family member or themselves to be homosexual. Some political groups are adding pressure to criminalise same sex relations specifically, which are already punishable under Sharia law in the Sumatra's Aceh Province.
However, within this time we have been able to continue discussions with local ministry of health and health offices to discuss the detriment impact these bills can have to public health outreach to LGBT and marginalised populations and further widen the unmet needs gaps.

As detailed within the submission we have developed and piloted a number for highly tailored media (film and websites) used to engage marginalised, at-risk populations within the HIV testing/treatment cascade and within our collaborative research.
We are using innovative methods of public and target population engagement within research and we are further developing this innovation.
Created early google drive to share certain information with investigator and R&D team in the UK. https://www.utama-research.com/home
Exploitation Route For greater health systems and social science research involving key social science sectors including anthropology - as has been submitted
(Greater funding needed to implement current protocol - due to challenges re initial fund as previously communicated)
Wider translation of a person-focused model of HIV care and prevention to other high burden areas such as Jakarta -(funding applications submitted). The stakeholder engagement work has already informed an interest regarding translating this research/implementation model across different key populations and general population to reduce unmet needs.
Spin off studies from longitudinal, cohort data set being created via this project/research and funding.
Development. For example we are collaborating with Cepheid to develop a research study utilising point of care quantitative viral load tests to understand is we are missing early and acute HIV infections among MSM testing negative on 3rd/4th generation Antibody testing. We are also using this as a platform to develop a wider study with the Oxford-Eikjman unit, Jakarta to create and understand the utility of an symptoms and risk behaviour based algorithm to diagnose acute and early infections in MSM testing for HIV. which may powerfully inform via impact and date acquired for modelling on how to effectively curb the fast growing HIV epidemic in MSM in Indonesia.

March 2021 submission
Via granular social science data, narrative data and data on key risk determinants - our study's outcomes with further and better understand how the lives of at-risk MSM drive increasing rates of HIV infection (and AIDS related deaths) observed in the population. This data will be presented and discussed within it's wider context and published for others to understand and use to improve policy; sexual health and HIV care services in this environment; support and mental health services; community and wider general community understanding to reduce social stigma. Via funding we are applying for, this data will specifically be used to inform the development of an evidence-based, engaging digital behavioural/HIV risk reduction tool.

In addition, the partnerships and stakeholder collaborations developed will help to ensure better dissemination and use of the research outcomes from this funding.
Sectors Creative Economy,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Healthcare,Government, Democracy and Justice

URL http://www.helpbeathiv.org
 
Description This project involves a multi-disciplinary team of clinicians, academics and social scientists. Non-academic impacts include; - Discussing with local and national MoH and local district and provincial health offices how to manage existing rigid HIV care provision and the high levels of institutional and healthcare-related stigma against LGBT and people living with HIV populations. Through mixed but predominantly Indonesian led stakeholder discussions over time, we have discussed with those directly related to directing healthcare - how current rigid pathways prevent access to HIV testing and importantly prevent initiation of ART, retention in care and increase marginalisation for vulnerable populations. - Produced tailored film, media and website (created through engaging representatives of at-risk MSM populations and expert staff). Through pilot focus groups and discussions led by LGBT populations, these films/media have empowered and encouraged community members. These were held with local LGBT and people living with HIV advocacy groups. We have led discussions with Indonesian and study clinic staff following the release of draft laws (Family resilience law) that would enforce LGBT individuals and their families to report any LGBT member to the government for rehabilitation-also, discussing laws and political rhetoric preventing young and marginalised people from accessing sexual health care without fear of being reported to Police or Government service. We discussed this to challenge perceptions of stigma and promote feelings of wellbeing and a culture of no stigma within the healthcare setting despite the political environment. - We have fostered further research relationships with other academic and clinical partners; we have submitted research/reviews to journals; creating a longitudinal data set within the study clinic - the process has required teaching research and data collection and analysis skills to Indonesian physicians and research staff. March 2021: addition Completion of participant recruitment, data collection (first phase) of the research UTAMA social study. Via granular social science data, narrative data, and data on key risk determinants, our study's outcomes will further understand how the lives of at-risk MSM drive increasing rates of HIV infection (and AIDS-related deaths) observed in the population. This data will be presented and discussed within its broader context and published for others to understand and use to improve policy; sexual health, HIV care services in this environment; support and mental health services; community and broader general community understanding to reduce social stigma. Via funding we are applying for, this data will specifically be used to inform the development of an evidence-based, engaging digital behavioural/HIV risk reduction tool. This will be implemented alongside a robust, comprehensive clinical tool (identifying acute HIV infections in at-risk communities) and a streamlined HIV care pathway within a future project (funding allowing - this has already been submitted and at the last phase). The study and data have also inspired further anthropological work investigating increasing social stigma in Bali, Indonesia, to reduce the impact on individuals significantly impacted by it. In addition, the partnerships and stakeholder collaborations developed will help ensure better dissemination and use of the research outcomes from this funding. We advocated and were proactive in making progress to the ARV drug shortages and disruptions to HIV care due to the pandemic- via a number of communications to high impact factor journals and media forums. We believe this facilitated a reduction in the significant impact to HIV services for our study local area.
Sector Communities and Social Services/Policy,Creative Economy,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Education,Healthcare,Government, Democracy and Justice
Impact Types Cultural,Societal,Policy & public services

 
Description An opinion piece in the BMJ Opinion (by UK Chief Investigator) regarding health systems understanding within the current COVID outbreak (to highlight need for health systems understanding for all public health control interventions including and importantly the HIV epidemic within Indonesia)
Geographic Reach Multiple continents/international 
Policy Influence Type Implementation circular/rapid advice/letter to e.g. Ministry of Health
URL https://blogs.bmj.com/bmj/2020/02/25/keerti-gedela-coronavirus-outbreak-highlights-need-greater-supp...
 
Description Please see UTAMA stakeholder meeting in engagement section
Geographic Reach Asia 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
Impact Please see entry within 'Engagement'. The meeting enabled pathway of more person-focused care previously restricted by local Ministry of Health. The discussion/meeting enabled a contract between government health services and the study clinic NGO/focused HIV and sexual health service to allow; - Antiretroviral treatment (ART) initiation and administration within the point of access of HIV testing - hence allowing immediate access/initiation and provision of ART to individuals diagnosed with HIV in the dedicated service. - Enabled future work with government general medical outpatients - to reduce stigma and discrimination against LGBT members of the community, people living with HIV among healthcare workers, improving the culture of the service towards key populations; by addressing the high rates of institutional stigma in Bali and Indonesia and how this is driving HIV rates and poor health.
 
Description A targeted combination intervention approach for acute HIV infections to curb the explosive
Amount £700,000 (GBP)
Funding ID MR/V035304/1 
Organisation Medical Research Council (MRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 12/2022 
End 12/2025
 
Description Evaluation of Supportive Care Guidelines for Epidemics: Implementation Case Study: Viral Haemorrhagic fevers and Covid-19 guidelines in Uganda, Chikungunya guidelines in Indonesia
Amount £70,000 (GBP)
Organisation University of Oxford 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 08/2021 
End 03/2023
 
Title Research training to clinical staff and junior research members 
Description Training in research methodology, protocol, GCP, governance for safeguarding and confidentiality, study recruitment, workshop facilitation, data collection/transcription/cleaning. Training in report and publication writing. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2020 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Building research capacity within the study clinic and affiliated research centre. Fostering robust research understanding, skills and project implementation to junior researchers, academics and health practionners (doctors and nurses - with no prior research knowledge) to encourage continued, local research. Building on the existing research infrastructure. Global health GCP training also provided to all researchers and health professional involved in the study. 
 
Title Using short engaging film to recruit to medical research 
Description Using the UTAMA health promotion film to study recruit. Please see the entry for this UTAMA film within creative product section. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2019 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Yet to be disseminated 
 
Title basic open google drive to disseminate certain research activities to UK team. 
Description As described 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2019 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Easily accessible tool UK investigators and R&D, not directly involved in the study, can access at leisure without increasing email load. Link needs updating. 
URL https://sites.google.com/view/utama-research/home
 
Description Collaboration with Oxford University, Atma Jaya University, Udayana University and Chelsea & Westminster NHS trust 
Organisation University of Oxford
Department Oxford Hub
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Through our existing partnerships in Indonesia, I have led a further collaboration with Oxford University (existing funded Wellcome Trust study) - I introduced the UK teams to local academic leadership in Indonesia to be involved in a multi national study looking at the implementation of supportive care guidelines for high consequence infectious diseases (HCIDs). This project involves the UK and Uganda and were looking to involve South East Asian settings. I led discussion for this study to involve Indonesian leadership and two Indonesian case studies with academic teams from Jakarta (Atma Jaya University) and Bali (Udayana University).
Collaborator Contribution Developing research infrastructure and Indonesian research leadership at the two academic sites to implement these research case studies within a wider multi-national study.
Impact Multi-disciplinary Project Indonesian case study development including pathways to fund Indonesian researchers. Submission to Wellcome Trust to include Indonesia. Partnerships not as yet formalised.
Start Year 2020
 
Description Indonesia Intervention Study to Test & Treat people with Acute HIV infection INTERACT A targeted combination intervention approach for acute HIV infections to curb the explosive epidemic among high-risk populations in Indonesia 
Organisation University of Oxford
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution I am one of the lead Primary investigators on this partnership. All Indonesian research members of the original UTAMA collaboration are part of the collaboration. The UTAMA Indonesian PI is a lead PI on this collaboration, which has UKRI MRC funding.
Collaborator Contribution Direct involvement from the outset on developing and leading this collaboration and the work involved. The work involves our study clinic in Indonesia because of the original UTAMA MRC grant work. The lead applicant, Raph Hamers, based at EOCRU, Jakarta was able to co-develop this partnership and grant because of the partnerships that existed via myself and partners work in Indonesia.
Impact MR/V035304/1 - due funding
Start Year 2020
 
Description Wider clinical, health systems and social science UTAMA partnership 
Organisation Eijkman Institute
Country Indonesia 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Through UTAMA's and my individual dedicated collaboration work and stakeholder engagement we have widened our partnership to include a multi-disciplinary and relevant/specialist multi-institution collaboration. Involving health systems researchers, social science including anthropology, and senior clinicians and academics from Indonesia in Bali and Jakarta, their work representing the whole of Indonesia. We are bringing together investigator disciplines including on-the-ground clinical and academics from fields of HIV and sexual health medicine, health systems and public health, socio and behavioural psychology and anthropology, with data science/statistical support from the Research organisations in Indonesia and the UK; including investigators with Government level influence and consultation roles in policy making and health systems in Indonesia and Asia. UK investigators come from a centre of clinical/academic excellence in HIV from the Chelsea & Westminster NHS Foundation trust, specifically 56 Dean Street clinic that was largely responsible for the reversal of the HIV epidemic in MSM in London from 2015 through initiating person-focused, innovative, comprehensive biomedical and behavioural models of HIV and sexual health care Due to our multidisciplinary, expert clinical-research team we have a unique understanding of the interconnectedness and bureaucracy of health systems and the people within those systems. This collaboration brings together senior social science perspectives and senior clinicians, academics and institutions directly engaged in delivering health services and informing health policy in Indonesia. Dr Pande Putu Januraga; Associate Professor/Health Systems analyst, Department of Public Health and Preventive Medicine, and Director of Center for Public Health Innovation (CPHI), Faculty of Medicine, Udayana University, Bali. Dr Raph Hamers; Senior Clinical Scientist at Eijkman-Oxford Clinical Research Unit, Jakarta. Dr Anom Kumbara; Professor in Anthropology, Udayana University, Bali Dr Frank Stephen Wignall; Founder and Executive of Globalindo Foundation/HIV and Sexual Health Clinics (NGO), Jakarta and Bali Peduli Foundation/HIV and Sexual Health Clinics (NGO), Bali. Senior Director FHI360 HIV programs, Cambodia. Dr Hendry Luis; Lead Physician and Executive Director Bali Peduli Foundation/HIV and Sexual Health Clinics (NGO), Bali. General Practioner/Community Physician, Puskesmas, Ubud. Dr Erik Sihotang; Lead Physician Globalindo Foundation/HIV and Sexual Health Clinics (NGO), Jakarta. Dr Robert Magnani; Visiting Scholar, AIDS Research Center, Atma Jaya Catholic University, Jakarta. Adjunct Professor, Faculty of Public Health, University of Indonesia. Senior Public Health and Health Systems Researcher and Consultant for HIV programming and policy across Asia. Dr Alan McOwan; Lead Clinician, 56 Dean Street, Chelsea & Westminster NHS Trust. Dr Gary Whitlock; Consultant Physician, 56 Dean Street, Chelsea & Westminster NHS Trust. We have already submitted 2 reviews as a collaboration for publication, submitted an MRC outline grant and due to submit another for funding.
Collaborator Contribution We have applied as a wider collaboration for further implementation and health systems research funding. Please see above
Impact Publications and grants applications submitted - will update on progress when available.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Wider clinical, health systems and social science UTAMA partnership 
Organisation Udayana University
Country Indonesia 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Through UTAMA's and my individual dedicated collaboration work and stakeholder engagement we have widened our partnership to include a multi-disciplinary and relevant/specialist multi-institution collaboration. Involving health systems researchers, social science including anthropology, and senior clinicians and academics from Indonesia in Bali and Jakarta, their work representing the whole of Indonesia. We are bringing together investigator disciplines including on-the-ground clinical and academics from fields of HIV and sexual health medicine, health systems and public health, socio and behavioural psychology and anthropology, with data science/statistical support from the Research organisations in Indonesia and the UK; including investigators with Government level influence and consultation roles in policy making and health systems in Indonesia and Asia. UK investigators come from a centre of clinical/academic excellence in HIV from the Chelsea & Westminster NHS Foundation trust, specifically 56 Dean Street clinic that was largely responsible for the reversal of the HIV epidemic in MSM in London from 2015 through initiating person-focused, innovative, comprehensive biomedical and behavioural models of HIV and sexual health care Due to our multidisciplinary, expert clinical-research team we have a unique understanding of the interconnectedness and bureaucracy of health systems and the people within those systems. This collaboration brings together senior social science perspectives and senior clinicians, academics and institutions directly engaged in delivering health services and informing health policy in Indonesia. Dr Pande Putu Januraga; Associate Professor/Health Systems analyst, Department of Public Health and Preventive Medicine, and Director of Center for Public Health Innovation (CPHI), Faculty of Medicine, Udayana University, Bali. Dr Raph Hamers; Senior Clinical Scientist at Eijkman-Oxford Clinical Research Unit, Jakarta. Dr Anom Kumbara; Professor in Anthropology, Udayana University, Bali Dr Frank Stephen Wignall; Founder and Executive of Globalindo Foundation/HIV and Sexual Health Clinics (NGO), Jakarta and Bali Peduli Foundation/HIV and Sexual Health Clinics (NGO), Bali. Senior Director FHI360 HIV programs, Cambodia. Dr Hendry Luis; Lead Physician and Executive Director Bali Peduli Foundation/HIV and Sexual Health Clinics (NGO), Bali. General Practioner/Community Physician, Puskesmas, Ubud. Dr Erik Sihotang; Lead Physician Globalindo Foundation/HIV and Sexual Health Clinics (NGO), Jakarta. Dr Robert Magnani; Visiting Scholar, AIDS Research Center, Atma Jaya Catholic University, Jakarta. Adjunct Professor, Faculty of Public Health, University of Indonesia. Senior Public Health and Health Systems Researcher and Consultant for HIV programming and policy across Asia. Dr Alan McOwan; Lead Clinician, 56 Dean Street, Chelsea & Westminster NHS Trust. Dr Gary Whitlock; Consultant Physician, 56 Dean Street, Chelsea & Westminster NHS Trust. We have already submitted 2 reviews as a collaboration for publication, submitted an MRC outline grant and due to submit another for funding.
Collaborator Contribution We have applied as a wider collaboration for further implementation and health systems research funding. Please see above
Impact Publications and grants applications submitted - will update on progress when available.
Start Year 2019
 
Description BMJ Opinion piece: Covid-19 highlights the need for greater support for global health systems 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact An evidence based BMJ opinion piece discussing how countries with weaker health systems must not be left behind in the global emergency response to covid-19, Specifically discussing the challenges and concern for Indonesia.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020,2021
URL https://blogs.bmj.com/bmj/2020/02/25/keerti-gedela-coronavirus-outbreak-highlights-need-greater-supp...
 
Description Cara melawan stigma pada pandemi COVID-19: belajar dari epidemi HIV di Indonesia; The Conversation Indonesia 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Shame and fear: lessons to learn as COVID-19 collides with a growing HIV epidemic in Indonesia

An evidence based article in The Conversation Indonesia - written in both English and Bahasa Indonesian language highlighting the growing HIV epidemic in Indonesia and the great impact of social stigma, that was also being observed during the COVID19 pandemic in Indonesia.
The English version was read by over 6,200 people from the general population (mainly Indonesia) and the Bahasa version was read by 1,564 people from the general population in Indonesia.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020,2021
URL https://theconversation.com/cara-melawan-stigma-pada-pandemi-covid-19-belajar-dari-epidemi-hiv-di-in...
 
Description Community and wider public engagement event - launch of media collaboration Safehouse on World AIDS Day 2020 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Event to mark World AIDS Day 2020, perform the song written and produced for our UTAMA research project, and provide a talk education and awareness to the HIV epidemic in Indonesia and managing stigma that is driving HIV.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020,2021
 
Description Musical-Community-Medical/Research collaboration for public engagement to the wider public 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact A collaboration between UTAMA (an Indonesian-UK research/community partnership) Kipper Eldridge and Kai Mata commemorate World AIDS day with the release of 'Safe House'

1-14th December 2020. To mark World AIDS Day 2020, the UTAMA Project invited Grammy and Emmy award-winning producer, songwriter and musician Kipper Eldridge and musician and songwriter Kai Mata to write and produce a song.

To inspire the community at large to help end AIDS in Indonesia.

https://youtu.be/UA_qh-6BJBk (English text)
https://youtu.be/2WZOBshDnys (Bahasa Indonesia text)

The UTAMA project involves an Indonesian-UK partnership run by HIV doctors, social scientists, community members and activists from Indonesia and the UK.
The diverse team come from the Yayasan Bali Peduli, Atma Jaya Catholic University, Jakarta and the 56 Dean Street clinic in London.
UTAMA's mission is to provide better health services and empower communities to beat HIV and end AIDS in Bali and other parts of Indonesia.

The lyrics to 'Safe House' were inspired by UTAMA's work to empower vulnerable communities at risk of HIV, reminding us all of the value in all of us, that we are all equal and that we all have the right to be safe, have love and thrive.

Although we have the tools to end AIDS across the globe, Indonesia is facing a fast-growing HIV epidemic and increasing numbers of AIDS related deaths.

We join hands with communities and policy makers in the effort towards ending AIDS in Indonesia.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://youtu.be/UA_qh-6BJBk
 
Description PODCAST: HIV endemic in Indonesia: Are we there yet? BMJ Talk Medicine 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Podcast - STI BMJ journal interviewed myself and Indonesian co-investigator Dr Hendry Luis regarding the current situation of the HIV epidemic in Indonesia; discussing epidemiology, HIV programmes, challenges (context and institutional), education and the impact from the COVID19 pandemic.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020,2021
URL https://soundcloud.com/bmjpodcasts/hiv-endemic-in-indonesia-are-we-there-yet?in=bmjpodcasts%2Fsets%2...
 
Description Patient group workshops 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Patients, carers and/or patient groups
Results and Impact Following research workshops involving hard to reach community members - 5 requested to be community 'champions' to discuss how to engage hard to reach and vulnerable people into important HIV implementation research and through public engagement.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020,2021
 
Description Shame and fear: lessons to learn as COVID-19 collides with a growing HIV epidemic in Indonesia; Article in The Conversation Indonesia 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Shame and fear: lessons to learn as COVID-19 collides with a growing HIV epidemic in Indonesia

An evidence based article in The Conversation Indonesia - written in both English and Bahasa Indonesian language highlighting the growing HIV epidemic in Indonesia and the great impact of social stigma, that was also being observed during the COVID19 pandemic in Indonesia.
The English version was read by over 6,200 people from the general population (mainly Indonesia) and the Bahasa version was read by 1,564 people from the general population in Indonesia.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020,2021
URL https://theconversation.com/shame-and-fear-lessons-to-learn-as-covid-19-collides-with-a-growing-hiv-...
 
Description Showcased UTAMA health promotion and study recruitment film at GLOBAL HEALTH FILM FESTIVAL 2019 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Our UTAMA health promotion film created/produced by the UTAMA project, directed by an Indonesian film company Matahati (http://matahatiproductions.com/) was selected and showcased at the Global Health Film festival in London December 2019 (https://www.globalhealthfilm.org/pages/4-global-health-film-festival). Our UTAMA one minute film premiered prior to the screening on 5B.
The film brief, design and content was developed via an incubation lab including sexual health experts from London and Indonesia (project chief and co-investigators), expert media (CrossOver https://www.xolabs.co.uk/ and Global Health Film https://www.globalhealthfilm.org/pages/4-global-health-film-festival), representatives of Indonesia MSM living with HIV.
Over 100 members of a varied audience were present to watch the film and discuss it along with the main screening of 5B and 2 other empowering, HIV and sexual health related short films. Thus created empowered and relevant discussion around; HIV and sexual health; stigma, discrimination; the HIV epidemic in Indonesia; driving factors for HIV; and importantly using film and a method of empowering and engaging marginalised populations within needed research activity. This was to a wide and varied international audience.
https://twitter.com/DrKeertiGedela/status/1203601602063585280
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://www.globalhealthfilm.org/pages/4-global-health-film-festival
 
Description Stakeholder and partnership meetings with UNAIDS, Cepheid, Elton John AIDS foundation, Udayana University, Oxford-Eikjman centre for research and different agencies for knowledge sharing, engagement and funding scoping - different scheduled meetings over period 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Supporters
Results and Impact Stakeholder meetings with UNAIDS, Elton John AIDS foundation, Udayana University, Oxford-Eikjman centre for research and different agencies for knowledge sharing, engagement and funding scoping - different scheduled meetings over period
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Trouble in Paradise; Accelerating the HIV response in Bali and Indonesia 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact A talk given to general public (mix of Indonesia and expat professionals) and high school teachers- held at a local school in Bali. Audience invited to attend where interest within the topic.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://drive.google.com/file/d/1OycIJzZYATVZRU5qAHnOH3bEd1ePQXuv/view?fbclid=IwAR291aftZw-bnhPPo8Sr...
 
Description UTAMA research Social media sites - Facebook, Instagram and Twitter 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact Facebook (URL below), Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/utama2021_official/) and Twitter (https://twitter.com/UtamaIndonesia) accounts created to spread awareness, research aims, educate and empower at-risk/marginalised communities. One specific aim was also to recruit hard to reach groups to our research.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020,2021
URL https://www.facebook.com/UTAMAIndonesia
 
Description UTAMA social study recruitment website (disseminated via targeted social media and physical and clinic outreach) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact UTAMA (health promotion film), anonymised survey and and study recruitment website www.helpbeathiv.org
This website was designed and developed using commercial (web design), creative, research and community member involvement. It has a version in Bahasa Indonesia and also in the English language.
This website featuring our multi-disciplinary co-created health promotion/HIV testing film - was developed to be released bu targeted social media dissemination to reach as wider and hard to reach population as possible - to engage in our research.
Details within the Project protocol.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL http://www.helpbeathiv.org
 
Description UTAMA stakeholder engagement meeting: Provincial, District Ministry of Health officials, Provincial and District Senior Health Practitioners 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact 20 representatives from the Provincial Ministry of Health, Republic of Indonesia, Provincial and District Health offices attended a stakeholder meeting to discuss the current up to date epidemiology and social science understanding of the HIV epidemic throughout Indonesia and focusing on the Bali Province and greater understanding of the UTAMA project and the health systems development required to tackle the growing epidemic in Bali. Guided presentation and detailed discussion on how health systems improvement can occur and enabling the UTAMA project.

Twitter coverage and photo:
https://twitter.com/DrKeertiGedela/status/1188844376253796352

please see presentation slides below:
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1HcnYtkoeAbEgSJza6sKMYIjV2bbBJEMW/view?usp=sharing
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://drive.google.com/file/d/1HcnYtkoeAbEgSJza6sKMYIjV2bbBJEMW/view?usp=sharing