Collective Quantum Thermodynamics
Lead Research Organisation:
University of Nottingham
Department Name: Sch of Physics & Astronomy
Abstract
Heat engines are the motors of our industrialised society. By converting thermal energy into mechanical work, they set cars, airplanes and ships in motion and drive the generators that deliver electricity to our computers and smartphones. None of these modern applications would be possible without one fundamental theory that emerged 200 years ago and has ever since enabled engineers to develop more and more powerful and efficient machines: thermodynamics. Equipped with only a few elementary concepts and laws, this theory lays down the basic rules that govern the performance of James Watt's 18th century steam engine and today's car engines alike.
During the past two decades, a new era has begun, in which scientists are exploring miniaturisation as a novel design principle for thermal engines. In a series of landmark experiments, smaller and smaller engines have been built and successfully operated. In 2016, this fascinating development led to the realisation of a functional heat engine with only one atom. Objects this tiny are no longer bound by the mechanical rules of our classical world; they can occupy two places at the same time, tunnel through barriers or influence each other at a distance without direct interaction. These counterintuitive phenomena are manifestations of the quantum laws of motion that govern the world at atomic scales. Heat engines operating in this realm can be equipped with features that no classical engineer could have imagined. The scientific discipline that describes this new type of machine and tries to harness their technological potential is still in its infancy and has been dubbed quantum thermodynamics.
Although likely able to overcome classical performance limits, quantum engines are still far from practical applications, not least due to their minuscule energy output; to move a car, one would need roughly as many single-atom engines as there are molecules in one liter of water. This number is absurdly large, mainly because it compares objects at radically different scales. Still, it is clear that, even to be useful for technologies on their own scale, quantum engines need to grow. But how can their size be increased when smallness is precisely the property that makes them quantum?
Quantum mechanics provides a solution to this dilemma: collective behaviour. Due to a strange interaction without a classical counterpart, objects like atoms can act in a coordinated way, like birds in a flock. This remarkable phenomenon has fascinated scientist for decades. Here, we propose to utilise it for the next generation of quantum machines. Imagine an engine working with a collective quantum gas containing millions of atoms instead of just one. Such a device could benefit from quantum effects while still producing significant power output. Moreover, the pistons of this engine could be perfectly synchronized with all the atoms they move around. Thus, an enormous level of control could be achieved, which would be impossible to realise with an ordinary gas, whose atoms follow unpredictable trajectories. Such unique features make collective quantum machines a fascinating yet unexplored subject of quantum engineering. Laying down the conceptual foundations for the design and implementation of this new type of device is the major goal of this project. The theory we will develop at the University of Nottingham will be the counterpart of thermodynamics in the world of collective quantum phenomena: collective quantum thermodynamics.
Quantum technologies are widely expected to shape our century in a similar way as the industrial revolution changed 19th and 20th century. Collective quantum machines have the potential to become the steam engines of this development. They will not move our future cars, but they might well provide the power for our quantum computers and encryption devices.
During the past two decades, a new era has begun, in which scientists are exploring miniaturisation as a novel design principle for thermal engines. In a series of landmark experiments, smaller and smaller engines have been built and successfully operated. In 2016, this fascinating development led to the realisation of a functional heat engine with only one atom. Objects this tiny are no longer bound by the mechanical rules of our classical world; they can occupy two places at the same time, tunnel through barriers or influence each other at a distance without direct interaction. These counterintuitive phenomena are manifestations of the quantum laws of motion that govern the world at atomic scales. Heat engines operating in this realm can be equipped with features that no classical engineer could have imagined. The scientific discipline that describes this new type of machine and tries to harness their technological potential is still in its infancy and has been dubbed quantum thermodynamics.
Although likely able to overcome classical performance limits, quantum engines are still far from practical applications, not least due to their minuscule energy output; to move a car, one would need roughly as many single-atom engines as there are molecules in one liter of water. This number is absurdly large, mainly because it compares objects at radically different scales. Still, it is clear that, even to be useful for technologies on their own scale, quantum engines need to grow. But how can their size be increased when smallness is precisely the property that makes them quantum?
Quantum mechanics provides a solution to this dilemma: collective behaviour. Due to a strange interaction without a classical counterpart, objects like atoms can act in a coordinated way, like birds in a flock. This remarkable phenomenon has fascinated scientist for decades. Here, we propose to utilise it for the next generation of quantum machines. Imagine an engine working with a collective quantum gas containing millions of atoms instead of just one. Such a device could benefit from quantum effects while still producing significant power output. Moreover, the pistons of this engine could be perfectly synchronized with all the atoms they move around. Thus, an enormous level of control could be achieved, which would be impossible to realise with an ordinary gas, whose atoms follow unpredictable trajectories. Such unique features make collective quantum machines a fascinating yet unexplored subject of quantum engineering. Laying down the conceptual foundations for the design and implementation of this new type of device is the major goal of this project. The theory we will develop at the University of Nottingham will be the counterpart of thermodynamics in the world of collective quantum phenomena: collective quantum thermodynamics.
Quantum technologies are widely expected to shape our century in a similar way as the industrial revolution changed 19th and 20th century. Collective quantum machines have the potential to become the steam engines of this development. They will not move our future cars, but they might well provide the power for our quantum computers and encryption devices.
Planned Impact
This proposal pushes for the development of a new line of basic research at the interface of quantum thermodynamics, quantum-many body and ultracold atom physics, three fields that are of strategical importance for the UK as a global centre for quantum technologies. Our major aim is thereby to lay the theoretical groundwork for novel thermal devices that utilise the collective properties of quantum fluids to enable efficient cooling, waste heat recovery and energy transport at small length scales and low temperatures. This vision has significant potential to create a large impact on economy and society, which will mostly develop over a longer time span, once our new concepts and ideas can be efficiently implemented. Since our research is of fundamental nature, short-term impact will primarily occur within the academic sector. In the following, we outline possible impacts and measures for their realisation.
Impact by knowledge. - To realise our ambitions, we will establish new connections between the pool of researchers working at the University of Nottingham in quantum many-body theory and experimental ultracold atom physics as well as the UK's rapidly growing quantum thermodynamics community, e.g. through contributions to regular seminars or national meetings. We will thus generate impact by fostering cross-disciplinary thinking maximising synergies and creating new communication channels. Moreover, we will further corroborate the international recognition of the scientific community in the UK as a world-leading player in quantum technologies by propagating our research in a targeted manner to key communities in the US, Europe and Asia through the extended networks of our collaborators.
People. - Our research programme offers excellent opportunities for all involved PDRAs and PhD students to acquire advanced knowledge in cutting-edge scientific methods, e.g. from statistical physics and dynamical control theory, hands-on experience in the development of new quantum technologies as well as a variety of transferable skills like project management and coherent writing. Our project will thus impact on the formation of the next generation of researchers and provide the community with highly qualified experts, who will also be strong candidates for specialist and leadership position in the UK's emerging quantum technologies industry.
Society and Economy. - The fundamental research proposed here will pave the way for practical thermal devices based on macroscopic quantum effects thereby underpinning the next revolution of "complex quantum technologies". This vision could lead to radically new commercialisation strategies for solid-state based quantum devices and thus has great potential to create strong and long-lasting economic benefit in the long run. While the time scales, on which marketable devices will become available, might well exceed the lifetime of this project, we will still create direct societal impact by helping to shape the next generation of research priorities and strategic goals.
Outreach. - Capitalising on the fact that thermodynamics is a topic of our everyday life, we will create public awareness for fundamental research and engage with the non-academic community by further strengthening established communication channels of the University of Nottingham and the School of Physics and Astronomy. Additionally, we will set up our own blog to promote our research to non-scientists in a targeted manner. Furthermore, the applicant will continue his strong track record in making cutting-edge research accessible to undergraduate and early graduate students through suitable teaching offers, thereby creating impact by attracting young talents to the rapidly growing area of quantum technologies.
Impact by knowledge. - To realise our ambitions, we will establish new connections between the pool of researchers working at the University of Nottingham in quantum many-body theory and experimental ultracold atom physics as well as the UK's rapidly growing quantum thermodynamics community, e.g. through contributions to regular seminars or national meetings. We will thus generate impact by fostering cross-disciplinary thinking maximising synergies and creating new communication channels. Moreover, we will further corroborate the international recognition of the scientific community in the UK as a world-leading player in quantum technologies by propagating our research in a targeted manner to key communities in the US, Europe and Asia through the extended networks of our collaborators.
People. - Our research programme offers excellent opportunities for all involved PDRAs and PhD students to acquire advanced knowledge in cutting-edge scientific methods, e.g. from statistical physics and dynamical control theory, hands-on experience in the development of new quantum technologies as well as a variety of transferable skills like project management and coherent writing. Our project will thus impact on the formation of the next generation of researchers and provide the community with highly qualified experts, who will also be strong candidates for specialist and leadership position in the UK's emerging quantum technologies industry.
Society and Economy. - The fundamental research proposed here will pave the way for practical thermal devices based on macroscopic quantum effects thereby underpinning the next revolution of "complex quantum technologies". This vision could lead to radically new commercialisation strategies for solid-state based quantum devices and thus has great potential to create strong and long-lasting economic benefit in the long run. While the time scales, on which marketable devices will become available, might well exceed the lifetime of this project, we will still create direct societal impact by helping to shape the next generation of research priorities and strategic goals.
Outreach. - Capitalising on the fact that thermodynamics is a topic of our everyday life, we will create public awareness for fundamental research and engage with the non-academic community by further strengthening established communication channels of the University of Nottingham and the School of Physics and Astronomy. Additionally, we will set up our own blog to promote our research to non-scientists in a targeted manner. Furthermore, the applicant will continue his strong track record in making cutting-edge research accessible to undergraduate and early graduate students through suitable teaching offers, thereby creating impact by attracting young talents to the rapidly growing area of quantum technologies.
Publications
Brandner K
(2025)
Dynamics of Microscale and Nanoscale Systems in the Weak-Memory Regime
in Physical Review Letters
Brandner K
(2025)
Dynamics of microscale and nanoscale systems in the weak-memory regime: A mathematical framework beyond the Markov approximation
in Physical Review E
Brandner K
(2020)
Coherent Transport in Periodically Driven Mesoscopic Conductors: From Scattering Amplitudes to Quantum Thermodynamics
in Zeitschrift für Naturforschung A
Brange F
(2023)
Lee-Yang theory of Bose-Einstein condensation
in Physical Review A
Carollo F
(2020)
Nonequilibrium Many-Body Quantum Engine Driven by Time-Translation Symmetry Breaking.
in Physical review letters
Eglinton J
(2022)
Geometric bounds on the power of adiabatic thermal machines.
in Physical review. E
Eglinton J
(2023)
Thermodynamic geometry of ideal quantum gases: a general framework and a geometric picture of BEC-enhanced heat engines
in New Journal of Physics
Martins W
(2023)
Rydberg-ion flywheel for quantum work storage
in Physical Review A
Martins W
(2025)
Quasiperiodic Floquet-Gibbs states in Rydberg atomic systems
in Physical Review A
| Description | Almost any physical system is open in that its accessible degrees of freedom are coupled to inaccessible ones, which cannot be directly observed or controlled; in thermodynamics, the accessible degrees of freedom typically belong to a working system performing a thermodynamic task like power generation or cooling, while the inaccessible ones form thermal reservoirs acting, for example, as heat sources; in quantum information processing, the relevant degrees of freedom are usually quantum bits, while inaccessible degrees of freedom in their physical environment, which may belong, for instance, to a solid-state substrate, cause noise and decoherence, two of the biggest obstacles for the development of large-scale quantum technologies. The theory of open quantum systems seeks to describe the time evolution of the observable degrees of freedom as accurately and with as little information about the inaccessible degrees of freedom as possible. To this end, a large variety of techniques has been developed over several decades, including a diverse range of so-called quantum master equations, which, due to their relative simplicity, are frequently applied in the description of open quantum systems. Most of the existing approaches rely at least in part on phenomenological or system-specific assumptions, the limits of which are not precisely understood. This lack of universality makes it difficult to reach general conclusions or to find the best method to describe a given system. Our recent results show that the validity of a large range of commonly used master equation can be rigorously traced back to a few physically transparent and mathematically well-defined conditions [DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.134.037101, DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevE.111.014137]. This key insight was derived within a comprehensive mathematical framework, which also provides systematic methods to construct an optimal, i.e., most accurate, effective dynamics of the open system and rigorous bounds on the errors of applied approximation. By further developing this framework, we seek to achieve both a unification and an expansion of theoretical methods for the description of open quantum systems. We expect this ongoing research to eventually enable us to revisit our original objectives in greater depth, while also being of significant interest to wider community including the quantum technologies sector. Besides these academic outputs, this fellowship has enabled an expansion consolidation of our international network through jointly conducted research projects, jointly organized meetings and various bilateral research visits between our group and the groups of Keiji Saito (Kyoto University, Japan), Igor Lesanovsky (University of Tübingen, Germany), Anatoli Polkovnikov (Boston University, US) and Francois Parmentier (Université Paris-Saclay, France). The exchange of ideas enabled by this network has had a significant impact on both the progression of our research and the personal development of our team members, 3 of whom have acquired specialist positions in the UK's high-tech industry and public sector, while 1 has secured a prestigious personal fellowship to advance their academic career. |
| Exploitation Route | Since we are conducting fundamental theoretical research, practical impacts of our work can be expected to emerge only over a longer time frame, which will exceed the lifespan of this fellowship. Within the academic sector, our research on the non-equilibrium thermodynamics of weakly interacting quantum many-body systems is directly relevant to the quantum-thermodynamics community, from which it has received considerable attention over the last years. A key factor here is that our results contribute directly to the currently ongoing shift of focus in this field from systems with few degrees of freedom to more complex but physically richer many-body systems. Our recent research on universal characterizations of open-system dynamics, both classical and quantum, is likely to be of direct interest to the open-quantum-systems community. It is not implausible to expect that, via this route, our research will eventually have an impact on at least the academic branch of the wider quantum technologies sector, where accurate and universal methods to describe the influence of environmental degrees of freedom on certain systems of interest are routinely required. |
| Sectors | Other |
| Description | Novel non-equilibrium states of matter in periodically driven spin systems: from time crystals to integrated thermal machines |
| Amount | £1,065,118 (GBP) |
| Funding ID | EP/V031201/1 |
| Organisation | Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) |
| Sector | Public |
| Country | United Kingdom |
| Start | 08/2021 |
| End | 09/2025 |
| Description | Non-Equilibrium States in Periodically Driven Classical Spin Systems |
| Organisation | Boston University |
| Country | United States |
| Sector | Academic/University |
| PI Contribution | The collaboration with the group of Anatoli Polkovnikov (Boston University, US) was initiated during an earlier research visit of the PI to Boston University in 2018. Is major aim is to characterize the non-equilibrium dynamics of classical many-body systems and systematic patterns therein through numerical simulations. Our group has contributed substantial working time to this project, which was mostly delivered by a postdoctoral researcher (TV, University of Nottingham), who also spent a 3-month research visit with the collaborating group in 2021. We have further supplied code for numerical simulations and data generated from these simulations. |
| Collaborator Contribution | The group of Anatoli Polkovnikov (Boston University, US) has continuously made their expertise on non-equilibrium many-body physics available to our joint research. They have further hosted a member of our team (TV, University of Nottingham), for a 3-month research visit. |
| Impact | - not multi-disciplinary - output: DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevE.108.L042102 (publications) - output: DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevE.108.044147 (publications) |
| Start Year | 2021 |
| Description | Thermodynamics of Mesoscopic Quantum Systems |
| Organisation | Aalto University |
| Department | Department of Applied Physics |
| Country | Finland |
| Sector | Academic/University |
| PI Contribution | Our collaboration with the theory group of Christian Flindt (Aalto University, Finland) comprises several joint projects related to the thermodynamics of nano-scale devices and potential extensions of classical thermodynamic uncertainty relations to quantum systems. The PI has co-supervised one PhD student in the collaborating group (PM, Aalto University) during the early stages of this fellowship and spent a 1-month research visit at Aalto University in 2023. |
| Collaborator Contribution | Our collaborators have contributed to our joint projects with specialist expertise on nano-scale solid-state devices, especially regarding aspects of practical implementation. In addition, Chrstian Flindt has facilitated interactions with the experimental group of Francois Parmentier. |
| Impact | - not multi-disciplinary - output: DOI: 10.1088/1751-8121/ab435a (publications) - output: DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevX.11.021013 (publications) - output: DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevA.101.052106 (publications) - output: DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevA.107.033324 (publications) |
| Start Year | 2020 |
| Description | 5th Nottingham Workshop on Quantum Non-Equilibrium Dynamics Emergent and Collective Phenomena, Thermodynamics and Fluctuations: From Fundamentals to the Next Generation of Quantum Devices |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | International |
| Primary Audience | Other audiences |
| Results and Impact | The PI has co-organized a 3-day international workshop at the University of Nottingham with special focus on early-career and junior researchers. The workshop featured 21 speakers from the UK, Europe and Japan and was attended by about 30 members of staff, post-docs and post-graduate students in School of Physics and Astronomy / School of Mathematical Sciences. Seeking to highlight current trends in theoretical non-equilibrium physics of quantum and classical systems, it has helped to spotlight physical / mathematical research at the University of Nottingham and enhance its international visibility. The workshop was hosted by the Centre for the Mathematics and Theoretical Physics of Quantum Non-Equilibrium Systems (CQNE) at the University of Nottingham, of which the PI is co-director for Physics. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
| Description | International Workshop - Bridges Between Quantum and Classical Non-Equilibrium Physics |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | International |
| Primary Audience | Other audiences |
| Results and Impact | The PI has co-organized an international workshop in Stellenbosch (South Africa) in Nov 2022, supported by funding from the Universities of Nottingham and Tübingen. The workshop has featured 30 speakers from leading research groups in the UK, Europe, the US and South Africa and helped to enhance the international visibility of physical / mathematical research at the University of Nottingham. The broader aim of this workshop was to bring together leading researchers from the wider communities of non-equilibrium and many-body physics to find new avenues towards bridging the long-existing divide between quantum and classical concepts in these areas. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2022 |
| URL | https://www.nottingham.ac.uk/physics/events/2022/bridges-between-quantum-and-classical-non-equilibri... |
| Description | JSPS London Symposium - Non-Equilibrium Dynamics, Thermodynamics and Fluctuations: From Fundamentals to the Next Generation of Microscopic Thermal Machines |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | International |
| Primary Audience | Other audiences |
| Results and Impact | Together with their collaborator Keiji Saito (Kyoto University, Japan) the PI has co-organized a JSPS London Symposium at the University of Nottingham with financial support from JSPS London. The Symposium took place in late 2022 and featured about 40 invited and contributing speakers from Japan, Europe and the UK and all academic career stages from PhD students to senior PIs. Its major aim was to create new links between Japanese and British / Irish non-equilibrium physics communities. The Symposium has enhance the international visibility of physical / mathematical research at the University of Nottingham and offered wide-ranging opportunities for networking and open-ended discussions. We have received very positive feedback from our participants highlighting the interesting and broad range of topics discussed. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2022 |
| URL | https://www.nottingham.ac.uk/science/schools-centres-and-institutes/cqne/events/jsps-london-symposiu... |
| Description | JSPS Pre-Departure Seminar |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | International |
| Primary Audience | Other audiences |
| Results and Impact | As a former JSPS fellow, the PI has delivered an invited contribution to a JSPS pre-departure seminar, which was organized by the London office of JSPS to prepare new fellows for life and work in Japan |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2022 |
| Description | Special Module: Open Quantum Systems and Quantum Thermodynamics |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | Regional |
| Primary Audience | Postgraduate students |
| Results and Impact | The PI has developed a special theory module for post-graduate students on quantum thermodynamics and the theory of open quantum systems. The module contents cover basic principles, current developments and open questions with the aim to engage the next generation of researchers with quantum thermodynamics and non-equilibrium physics more broadly. The module is available through the Midlands Physics Alliance Graduate School (MPAGS), which is jointly hosted by the Universities of Nottingham, Birmingham and Warwick. It has been delivered three times so far and was attended by approx 5-10 students from all three universities on average. Lecture notes and recordings of the online lectures were made available online to the participating students. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2021,2024 |
| URL | https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/sci/physics/mpags/modules/theory/openquantumsystemsandquantumthermodynamic... |
