Agent-based Modelling for Ebola Risk Reduction: Understanding and Mitigating the Potential for Global Transportation-fuelled Epidemics (ABMERR)

Lead Research Organisation: University College London
Department Name: Centre for Advanced Spatial Analysis

Abstract

Outbreaks of Ebola have gripped the world's attention in recent years, from the Western Africa Ebola epidemic of 2013-2016 to the ongoing outbreak in Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC). The first outbreak of the Ebola virus was recorded in 1976 in what was then called Zaire (now the Democratic Republic of Congo); 318 cases were identified, of which 280 people died. Since that time, changes to infrastructure, travel patterns, population density, and climate have led to larger and more frequent epidemic outbreaks of the disease. The Western Africa Ebola epidemic saw cases spread as far as Italy, Spain, and the United States. The outbreak in DRC is now in its 11th month with no signs of abating and extensive disruptions and cost for local people. Humanitarian groups including Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF) and the British Red Cross (BRC) are organising local responses to the crisis, but the magnitude of the problem is so great that there are no established techniques for resolving it. Humanitarians are in urgent need of operational intelligence in order to fight increasingly large epidemics.
To that end, this fellowship aims to develop a simulation of the spread of Ebola through a region as a function of human behaviour and movement. I will undertake this work in conjunction with partners from MSF's Manson Unit for Innovation and BRC's GIS team. The project will create and make use of an agent based model (ABM) to simulate the interactions and choices of individual people living, working, and moving within Ebola-effected areas. By capturing the ways in which Ebola is transmitted between people through funerary practices, caring relationships, and the seeking of medical care, the simulation will help the project's humanitarian partners understand how different interventions may influence the spread of disease in these social contexts. The research will particularly focus on analysing and visualising the results in ways that are accessible to the humanitarian project partners.
The work will make use of open source data to estimate populations and recreate transportation networks. These synthetically generated datasets will be fed into the ABM, giving more insight into where outbreaks may flare up and where they may travel next based on appropriate local behaviours and choices. In turn, the software developed as part of the project will be made open source. By making the simulation software freely available, the research will be accessible to the humanitarian partners, but also government organisations and other researchers. The toolkits will be developed with the needs of non-specialists in mind, so that they are suitable for users with potentially sensitive datasets and without high-powered machines or constant access to the internet. The project aims to strengthen the ties between academics and humanitarians, and to make cutting edge methodologies available to non-specialists.
The fellowship will provide resources to help humanitarians and government to understand their options in the fight against Ebola. It will also make these new tools available to other researchers, propagating outward and facilitating new work. Finally, it will allow me to establish myself as an internationally recognised leader in the field of ABM for humanitarian modelling, allowing me to push this line of research forward in the future.

Planned Impact

By investing in British research capacity in agent-based modelling (ABM), the project would deliver substantial academic and social benefits across a range of disciplines and timescales.

ACADEMIC: The development of the simulation proposed here will have tangible benefits for a number of different parties, including:
Agent-based modellers: ABM researchers will benefit from the development of cutting edge behavioural frameworks, extensive engagement with simulation exploration, and publication of toolchains for research. The focus on open-source research will make the code developed immediately available to other researchers to extend for their own purposes. The state of the art of agent-based modelling will be pushed forward by this work. This funding of basic research excellence will cascade long-term.

Data scientists: The tools and techniques developed to populate the model with agents and transportation networks will be useful to simulators working with synthetic populations or transportation in underserved areas. Again, the open source nature of the project means that component parts can be spun off and used for distinct purposes with ease.

Public health researchers: Public health researchers and medical scientists often grapple with questions of the efficiency versus effectiveness of various interventions - the theoretical impact an intervention might have versus the reality in situ. By capturing the choices made by individuals within the epidemic context, public health researchers can better understand the options available to them.

Postdoctoral researchers: The two postdoctoral researchers funded as part of this project will further their training and be supported in their development into independent researchers. Their skills will give rise to the next generation of proposals in UK research. Their ability to develop collaborative research programmes with humanitarian partners will be enhanced by this experience.

SOCIAL: The project would serve the needs of both organisations and communities more broadly. In particular:

Humanitarians and governments: MSF and BRC are dealing with an outbreak of Ebola in the Democratic Republic of Congo, currently in its 11th month. This has led to a total of 1287 deaths confirmed by the DRC Ministry of Health at the time of submission. They also dealt with the Western Africa Ebola epidemic of 2013-2016, in which 11316 people were killed out of a total of 28639 cases reported by the WHO. The economic costs were staggering: World Bank estimates that $2.2 billion USD was lost in 2015 during the Western Africa Ebola epidemic, while the US, UK, and Germany spent more than $3.6 billion USD to help fight the outbreak. The scale and complexity of the problem are without precedent, and belie top-down solutions. By helping humanitarians and governments to target their interventions, the project aims to decrease the suffering associated with epidemic disease. The workshop and final symposium will facilitate this. The intelligence generated by this project is designed to be maximally accessible to nonspecialists, supporting government and organisations to realise and exploit the potential of ABM. Better informed policy can save lives and allow health spending to be diverted to the other issues which face these communities.

Individuals living in Ebola-affected areas: The use of the project findings are intended to shorten and proscribe the impact of epidemics; this will impact not only the individuals who are now not exposed to disease, but also those whose livelihoods depend on free movement. Individuals who are suspected to have been exposed to the disease are often quarantined for 48 hours, which can massively impact the wellbeing of families dependent on daily employment. Ending epidemics sooner will impact the health of individuals not only by decreasing the number of fatalities from Ebola, but by decreasing disruption and its associated dangers to their welfare.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Thus far, the work has produced a modular and flexible framework for the simulation of the spread of disease as a function of human behaviour at the level of individual actors. The code to support the running of this simulation, plus the analysis of its output, has been made available through a GitHub repository with a wiki to help support its use by others. It is still under development. On the basis of this simulation framework, we have begun to carry out experiments showing the importance of including spatial information in simulations of epidemic disease. In particular, models which exclude space produce larger epidemic peaks than do spatial models.
Exploitation Route The simulation we have created allows for other researchers to expand upon it, applying it either to specific regions or to specific questions of behaviour. Portions of the code could be repurposed for similar problems and issues. Either broken down for pieces or built up into something greater, the hope is that it will serve as a resource to others.
In addition to the tool we've developed, our latest publication contributes to the best practices of epidemic modelling. Our findings regarding the implications of including or excluding spatial information in epidemiological simulations will hopefully be taken up by other researchers trying to understand the development of epidemics. More precisely, they can utilise our findings to inform their choice of model parameters and explore these kinds of problems more efficiently. This has become an increasingly important question over the life of the project.
Sectors Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Healthcare,Transport

 
Description The work has been shaped and informed by the sudden explosion in simulations of human behaviour in disease contexts, which coincidentally began in the same year as the project was funded. The ABMERR project was created with the agent-based modelling (ABM) approach to simulation in mind, in particular with an understanding of the challenges and opportunities of an agent-based approach. Thus, our efforts proceed with a real understanding of the tools and their idiosyncrasies, allowing for a better understanding of the mapping between the real world and the simulated one. In practice, this means that we can begin to make suggestions about, for example, the appropriate scale at which a population might be simulated (how well does a representative 50% sample capture the dynamics? A 10% sample? Etc).
First Year Of Impact 2021
 
Title ABM disease modelling framework 
Description In accordance with Work Package 1, I have developed an agent-based modelling framework of the spread of disease using Java. Additional Python tools for data processing and analysis have been developed and are hosted within the same GitHub. The work represents a merging of my own project together with a team from the World Bank (see the section on collaborators), which has ultimately been shaped in the way I originally envisioned the work. It is openly available online. 
Type Of Material Computer model/algorithm 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Both myself and project partners at the World Bank have made use of this model to explore assumptions about the spread of disease. It is at the core of our research efforts. 
URL https://github.com/worldbank/Disease-Modelling-SSA
 
Description Medecins Sans Frontieres 
Organisation Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF)
Country France 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution The project was designed together with MSF, with the idea that the simulation would be applied to Ebola. I have attended a number of meetings with a subgroup within MSF called eHealth-Epidemiology-Public-Health Intelligence (eEPH, formerly EPHI) regarding the model and how it might be used to deal with Covid-19.
Collaborator Contribution At the encouragement of the eEPH team, I focused more intensively upon the application of the model to Covid-19 problems rather than questions of the spread of Ebola.
Impact N/a
Start Year 2021
 
Description World Bank Covid simulation 
Organisation World Bank Group
Country United States 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Joint development of an agent-based modelling framework for the simulation of epidemic outbreaks of SARS-Covid 19. This was undertaken in conjunction with researchers from the Bank.
Collaborator Contribution Provision of data, hardware for running the simulation.
Impact Development of modelling framework and processing pipeline.
Start Year 2021
 
Description Data for Policy 2022 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The Data for Policy conference series is a forum for multidisciplinary and cross-sector discussions around the theories, applications and implications of data science innovation in governance and the public sector. I attended in order to better understand how simulation results can be communicated to non-academics, in light of the challenges researchers had during the Covid-19 pandemic.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://dataforpolicy.org/data-for-policy-2022/
 
Description FLF Conference 2022 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The annual FLF conference is designed to bring together researchers who have been awarded the UKRI Future Leaders Fellowship to exchange ideas and information. I attended virtually, out of concern for a family member who was undergoing chemotherapy at the time, and submitted a poster.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description FLF Crucible Programme II 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact The FLF Crucible programme is a two-day residential event designed to form an interdisciplinary, cross-sector network that fosters collaborations between researchers who normally don't get the chance to meet. I took part in the Leeds-based event of 10-11 November, 2022. It was extremely useful to have a wider scale conversation with colleagues about their experiences with the research environment and administration as PIs. Further, I made a number of contacts which I might take forward to do future work, pending available time.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description GISRUK 2022 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The annual GISRUK conference brings together academics, industry professionals, and government representatives, as well as nurturing postgraduate students. Researchers discuss projects, funding schemes, and job opportunities. I attended and participated rather informally in panels.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL http://liverpool.gisruk.org/
 
Description MATSim/ABM workshop at Loughborough University 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Loughborough University hosted a workshop on 24-25 August, 2022. The workshop explored the current practice of MATSim/ABM in transport planning and its future challenges in broader adoption in real-world practice. The workshop featured academic speakers from across Europe as well as talks by industry/third sector organisations. I was invited to participate in the expert panel on the afternoon of the 25th.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Modelling to Support Resilience for Pandemics 2022 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact This two-day workshop allowed specialists to describe in detail their experiences modelling during the COVID-19 pandemic. The researchers were interested in how they can build systems that will strengthen resilience for the future. I found it very useful to hear this larger conversation.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://gateway.newton.ac.uk/event/tgm124