Optimisation of After-treatment Systems for Improved Tailpipe Emissions

Lead Research Organisation: CATAGEN Limited
Department Name: Main Office

Abstract

The impact of vehicle emissions on air quality is driving the automotive industry to seek new solutions for reduced tailpipe emissions whilst maintaining fuel economy. The industry is at a key juncture in the evolution of new solutions for reduced tailpipe emissions and, in particular, in the motorcycle industry, where emissions legislation is starting to have some impact. Until recently, motorcycle companies could readily meet emissions targets (Euro 4) by fitting a simple catalyst system and calibrating the fuelling to suit catalyst operation. The Euro 5 limits to be introduced in 2020 and 2021 require much more precise specification to ensure compliance with legislation whilst still achieving an affordable cost.

Our proposed research project will seek to develop an entirely new process for the design and specification of after-treatment systems for motorcycles, using a mix of the simulation and testing tools available within CATAGEN. The innovative process will take drive cycle data and calculate the CATAGEN proprietary ageing metrics for the proposed after-treatment over the life of the motorcycle. The CATAGEN after-treatment model will be used to determine the catalyst activity required to meet emission limits at the end of the useful motorcycle life. This activity level will then be used in conjunction with the ageing metric to specify the catalyst for the new component at the start of vehicle life.

However, the challenges in achieving these goals are substantial. For the virtual development of engines and emission systems, real, accurate, and repeatable measurements will be needed with high levels of precision to develop the required software and algorithms capable of predicting the varying response and performance of an engine in real life. Up to this point, this has been seen as an unobtainable need in the industry, but with further development and modification of the CATAGEN technology, this data will be produced to the high levels essential to create an accurate model.

As this process can then be further evolved to apply to other vehicle applications and other combustion engine applications, it is an extremely important research project with far reaching potential to improve emissions and resultant air quality.

Improved air quality has far reaching benefits for everyone in society and is currently the focus of many Government policies and strategies, both in the UK and beyond. The link between cleaner air and improved health, particularly in cities, is well documented.

This work is particularly relevant in the developing countries of the world, where motorcycles are in wide use and have a major contribution to poor air-quality. Low-cost small motorcycles are popular as more expensive forms of personal transportation is not affordable. This project will assist in the development of lower-cost, more-effective after-treatment systems for motorcycles for improved air quality. For example, India has major air-quality issues in cities such as Delhi and needs affordable, effective solutions urgently but this applies across the world in areas from China to Africa to South America where low-cost small motorcycles are widely used and are major sources of exhaust emissions.

Ultimately, this project has the potential to be a major contributor to the target of improving global air quality.

Planned Impact

The potential direct and indirect beneficiaries of this proposed research are wide ranging and include the following:

1. Motorcycle OEMs;
2. CATAGEN;
3. General public;
4. Policy makers within government - local (including city councils), national and international; and
5. Academia.

Motorcycle manufacturers will benefit from a potentially greatly enhanced emissions testing model that will lead to new motorcycle designs that not only comply and surpass new legislative requirements for emissions but that are also not over engineered and are therefore more cost effective to produce. We intend to work with the motorcycle manufacturers on vehicle development cycles, possibly by giving the tool to the vehicle developers, through the provision of a black box of mathematics through a licensed software arrangement. Emission drive cycles data could then be uploaded to a cloud-based service that could be used to collaborate and develop the best outcome. Ultimately, the more data that we can obtain from manufacturers, in conjunction with testing on CATAGEN reactors the more accurate we can make the algorithms. We expect this benefit to be realised within the four-year period of the Fellowship.

The potential benefit for CATAGEN will be a potentially new revenue generation stream for the business that will lessen our overall risk profile through a more diversified business model and resultant customer base, such increased revenues to commence in the final year of the research project.

Ultimately, the project has the potential to benefit the wider public on an international level through greatly reduced emissions and therefore cleaner air and an improvement in the nation's health. The immediate impact of this project will be felt in cities and countries with a high population of motorcycles (such as in India) but the longer-term benefits (beyond the four year period of the research project) could be felt by the general public in any city as the research has the capability of being extended into other areas beyond motorcycles, thus improving the general health of the public, particularly for more vulnerable groups such as asthma sufferers and those with chronic respiratory conditions.

This project has the potential to be a real game changer as a potential solution in delivering the Government's ambitious emissions improvement targets. At a local level, many city councils have published cleaner air policies and ambitious targets to improve air quality in and around cities. On an international level, and particularly in cities with high usage of motorcycles, the benefits are huge if motorcycle manufacturers can make significantly cleaner motorcycles with significantly lower emissions. Technical papers will be produced on the research and used to inform Government by the end of the final year of the project. Ultimately, cleaner air will benefit the NHS through lower incidence of respiratory conditions requiring possible hospitalisation and/or expensive medication, thereby relieving some stress on already stretched health service budgets.

Given the collaboration between CATAGEN and Queen's University, Belfast to date, it is intended through the development of Dr Stewart in the proposed project, to further collaborate with the University and other academic institutions (if necessary) as the project progresses. CATAGEN, having been born from academia, has developed and uses a strategy for publication that promotes openness whilst at the same time protecting the company's defendable IP and thus market position. Our strategy is to regularly publish articles on technical capability and performance whilst anonymising any sensitive data or methods that could be reverse engineered by a competitor. This same strategy will be employed for outputs of this project, such publications to be through industry relevant publications and social media channels such as LinkedIn.
 
Title Development of new motorcycle specific testing rigs 
Description A new specific motorcycle testing rig has been developed and built to allow for testing of unique motorcycle aftertreatment designs. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact This new research tool allows for more flexible testing on full motorcycle aftertreatment systems, from a range of unique and individual designs. This allows for catalyst and aftertreatment development works to take place, focusing on characterisation and catalyst ageing. This, alongside the WMTC development, offers a full capability of testing and development for new vehicle development within the motorcycle industry, preparing for optimisation around the aftertreatment system to ensure reduced tailpipe emissions as we approach new legislations in a cost effective manner. 
 
Title Development of new testing methodologies to recreate a worldwide motorcycle test cycle (WMTC) on a synthetic gas reactor. 
Description The new research methodology is to apply current CATAGEN technologies to replicate the transient engine out conditions, without the need for an engine. New advanced artificial intelligence techniques were developed to support the in-house developed OMEGA test vehicle control software. The AI framework is used to accurately tune and optimise to the required target drive cycle test profiles. This WMTC allows the catalyst performance to be measured and monitored throughout catalyst ageing and allows for catalyst optimisation at an earlier stage in the new vehicle development. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Conventional drive cycle testing is complete on a rolling chassis dynamometer, an expensive and time consuming process. The added impacts allow a more repeatable reliable test to focus specifically on the catalyst and aftertreatment system. This allows the catalyst development to begin at an earlier stage in the vehicle development and to focus on optimising the aftertreatment system to be as effective and cost efficient as possible. Initial testing was complete with a motorcycle OEM to recreate the WMTC in the OMEGA reactor, allowing data to be gathered and used to optimise and tune the kinetic model, allowing for more accurate predicted tailpipe emissions. This also aided with further testing to achieve heavily aged components close to OBD-II levels. 
 
Title CATAGEN Kinetic Model application to Specific Motorcycle Drive Cycle Data 
Description The CATAGEN kinetic model has been tuned and applied to simulate catalyst light-off, drive cycle performance and tailpipe emissions. Based on specific data measured from testing on catalyst samples within the new motorcycle rigs, light-off kinetics have been tuned and dispersion optimised to correlate to tailpipe emissions from vehicle measured data. 
Type Of Material Computer model/algorithm 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The notable impacts resulting from the development, after accurate correlation for a freshly aged catalyst, an ageing simulation can be carried out to understand the long term impacts on tail pipe emissions. Along with the simulation of ageing, the precious metal loading can then be investigated to understand what a change in that might have to impact the tailpipe emissions both at a fresh and aged point in time. Initial testing has been complete with a motorcycle OEM, using specific motorcycle data measured on a dynamometer. This data was used to recreate the WMTC on the OMEAGA reactor and also modelled with the CATAGEN kinetic model, allowing for more accurate tuning and correlation from measured to predicted data. This also allowed for some adjustments to the catalyst parameters allowing for some understandings on the impact of changing the catalyst, showing the potential value in being able to accurately optimise the catalyst aftertreatment systems through modelling activities. Additionally the development of the model has also been able to be applied to a study with the JRC, showing support of in-service conformity strategy and testing for automotive vehicles. 
 
Description A webinar on the challenges of meeting the new Euro 5 legislations 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact A live webinar was held to discuss the impact of the new emissions legislations, the intended purpose was to raise awareness to the industry about the upcoming challenges to achieve OBD-II and the importance of early development and optimising the aftertreatment system. Specific information was shared around the FLF project and the application of that to help achieve an efficient cost effective aftertreatment system. Follow up meetings were arranged and specific outreach was achieved with India and follow up meetings have been complete to understand how the project can help in areas with poorer air quality.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Presenting to motorcycle OEMs 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Presented to senior engineers within the motorcycle aftertreatment sector. The purpose of the presentation was to detail the FLF award and outline the main project outcomes. There are current industry challenges to overcome new emissions legislations and improve air quality. The main discussion points were to develop and optimise the aftertreatment system at an earlier stage in the overall vehicle development, ensuring reductions in tailpipe emissions in a cost effective manner. Presented to seven leading OEMs. Further outcomes resulted in face to face meetings in both the USA and Italy.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Several blog posts for the motorcycle industry around new emissions legsilations and the impacts 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Several blog posts were written for specific industry professionals and the general public to raise awareness on the new emissions legislations and the importance of early development. The outcomes have been interactions with additional motorcycle OEMs to understand how this project can help with aftertreatment development in a more efficient way and ensure that tailpipe emissions can remain below the legislative requirements, therefore, improving air quality.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022,2023
URL https://catagen.com/2021/06/15/cold-start-emissions-motorcycles/
 
Description Visit to companies in the Italy 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact A trip to Italy to visit several companies, including three motorcycle OEMS, two automotive OEMs and the Joint Research Institute (JRC). This allowed a multitude of conversations and discussions around current air quality issues and challenges with tail pipe emissions. The main discussion points were to develop and optimise the aftertreatment system at an earlier stage in the overall vehicle development, ensuring reductions in tailpipe emissions in a cost effective manner. Also discussed was the capabilities and opportunities arising from the FLF project and new testing methodologies.
Meeting with and discussing the topic with another research institute, JRC, allowed a more detailed conversation around specific research topics and allowed an understanding of what current research is ongoing elsewhere.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Visit to companies in the USA 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact A trip to America to visit several companies, including motorcycle OEMS and the South West Research Institute (SwRI). This allowed a multitude of conversations and discussions around current air quality issues and challenges with tail pipe emissions. The main discussion points were to develop and optimise the aftertreatment system at an earlier stage in the overall vehicle development, ensuring reductions in tailpipe emissions in a cost effective manner. Also discussed was the capabilities and opportunities arising from the FLF project and new testing methodologies.
Meeting with and discussing the topic with another research institute, SwRI, allowed a more detailed conversation around specific research topics and allowed an understanding of what current research is ongoing elsewhere.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Visit to small catalyst manufacturer for motorcycle industry. 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Presented to senior engineers and the R&D director, who focus on aftertreatment systems for the motorcycle industry. The intended purpose of the meeting and presentation was to detail the FLF award and how the project is working on optimising aftertreatment systems and catalysts within the motorcycle industry. The current industry challenges to overcome the new emissions legislations while maintaining an optimised cost efficient catalyst was discussed during this visit. The main discussion points were to allow for an earlier development of the aftertreatment system to ensure the catalyst would be sufficient in reducing tailpipe emissions within the required legislative requirements.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022