The DOMINO Study: Measuring and mitigating the indirect effects of COVID-19 on TB and HIV care in Indonesia

Lead Research Organisation: London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine
Department Name: Public Health and Policy

Abstract

The disruption to TB and HIV health services brought about by the COVID-19 pandemic, if sustained over six-months, has been predicted to result in 1.4 million extra deaths from TB-related illnesses and over 500,000 from HIV (5,6). If correct, these predictions correspond to deaths rates for HIV and TB last seen globally more than a decade ago. Indonesia, the fourth most populous country in the world, has the highest number of COVID-19 infection cases in Southeast Asia (2). The country is also ranked third for TB burden globally (3) and one of few countries with an increasing number of new HIV infections (4). While Indonesia has recently strengthened efforts to control these diseases, the diversion of resources to the pandemic combined with social distancing policies is creating new vulnerabilities and exacerbating existing ones for people who rely on TB and HIV services. The country urgently needs to understand the wider impact of the pandemic on TB and HIV care to inform mitigation strategies. We will build on strong, existing collaborative research relationships to rapidly assess the impact of the COVID-19 outbreak (and policy responses to it) on the delivery of and access to TB and HIV care in Indonesia, with a particular emphasis on highly vulnerable sub populations. Our findings will be used to design strategies to safeguard the continuity of care for TB and HIV patients in the near and medium term, thereby ensuring the country does not lose ground on the major advances it has made towards the control of these diseases.

Technical Summary

The global health community has made urgent calls for countries to find solutions to minimising the impact of COVID-19 on programs targeting long-standing health problems such as TB and HIV (1). Indonesia, with a population of around a quarter of a billion people, currently has the highest number of COVID-19 infection cases in Southeast Asia, averaging 1000-1300 new infections each day since the 15th June and a case fatality rate of around 6.6% (2). It is also ranked third in TB burden globally (3) and one of a few countries where the number of new HIV infections is rising (4). In recent years Indonesia has strengthened its commitment to controlling these two important diseases. However, the diversion of health resources to the pandemic along with social distancing policies is creating new vulnerabilities and exacerbating existing ones for TB and HIV programs and affected populations. Our team is partnering with the Indonesian government and community organisations to conduct an observational cohort study across all TB and HIV facilities in the major cities of Bandung (N=62) and Yogyakarta (N=30) to assess clinical outcomes before and during the pandemic. We will analyse routinely collected data to measure linkage to care, retention in care and treatment outcomes along TB and HIV cascades of care. Qualitative methods will be used to explore the experiences of TB and HIV patients and their health care providers during the pandemic, including changes to treatment seeking and actions to minimise disruptions. Out-of-pocket health spending by TB and HIV patients and their families during the pandemic will be measured using structured diaries. Wider health system impacts of COVID-19 on stocks of medicines/tests and health facility funding levels will be assessed using facility records and interviews with health authorities and facility staff. Our findings will generate recommendations on how to minimise disruptions to HIV and TB services in the face of the pandemic.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Our secondary data analysis using routine data from the Indonesian TB and HIV information system illustrates the significant impact the COVID-19 pandemic has had on TB and HIV services. The COVID-19 pandemic has disrupted TB services, resulting in a decrease in TB testing, a lower number of patients starting TB treatment, and a higher likelihood of patients not completing treated. Similarly, the HIV continuum of care has also been disrupted. There was a decrease in HIV testing, fewer HIV patients linked to HIV care, a lower number of anti-retroviral therapy (ART) initiation, and retention in care.
We have also identified several barriers to accessing TB and HIV services. Our interviews with patients and health workers found difficulties in carrying out TB contact investigations and mobile HIV testing. Additionally, concerns over COVID-19 exposure, staff and patient mobility restrictions, patients moving to different locations (e.g. to find work), fear of being stigmatized, financial barriers, staff shortages, and medication supply disruptions were identified as barriers to maintaining TB and HIV treatment during COVID-19.
In addition to barriers to TB and HIV services, several mitigation strategies have been identified. The mitigation strategies implemented during COVID-19 included ART multi-month dosing, medicine home delivery, the use of telemedicine, and increased collaboration with stakeholders including NGOs, HIV peer support groups, and TB cadres.
One key objective of our study was to calculate patient costs of seeking TB and HIV care for 6 months and to calculate catastrophic health expenditure (CHE) during the COVID-19 pandemic. We found that most patients had used services subsidised through the national health insurance programs when accessing TB and HIV testing and treatment. However, we also found s mall number of patients and their families that experienced CHE during the pandemic.
Additionally, the COVID-19 pandemic has had an impact on the allocation of central funding for TB and HIV programs in Indonesia, resulting in a decrease in operational expenses for many puskesmas. This reduction in funding had wide-ranging impacts including a reduction in staff field visits, stock-outs of some tests and treatments, and closure of some services in primary health care and hospitals. However, there has been a rebound in domestic and foreign funding for TB and HIV programs in 2021.

In addition to the above, in 2021, the team commenced a systematic review of the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on HIV services. The article search, data extraction, and synthesis is underway. It is estimated that the first draft will be completed by June 2023 and submitted by September 2023.
Exploitation Route a. Stakeholders (Indonesian Ministry of Health, Provincial, and District Health Offices)
Our preliminary results have been presented in the stakeholder meetings with DHO and health facilities with TB and HIV services. During the meeting, the DHO and health facilities staff acknowledged our results and shared their point of view regarding the COVID-19 pandemic. One of the suggestions from the DHO and health facilities staff was to develop policy briefs that outline the findings regarding the disruption to TB and HIV health services during the pandemic, how to mitigate the impact, and what policies should be available in preparing for other pandemics in the future.
b. TB and HIV health information system
Our study also identified the potential of using TB and HIV surveillance system data at health facilities and the district health office level. The routine data collected by the health facilities have the potential to be used and inform stakeholders regarding the current situation of health services and the COVID-19 pandemic's impact on TB and HIV services.
c. Community
Based on our study results, we found the importance of strengthening the collaboration of health facilities with HIV peer support groups and TB cadres to reduce the staggering impact of the COVID-19 pandemic. This issue has been discussed during the stakeholder meeting, and there was an interest in the government to support the partnership between the health facilities and HIV peer support groups at the community level to mitigate the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on TB and HIV services.
Sectors Healthcare

 
Description As has been outlined in the key finding section, the findings from this study have been fed back to the stakeholders and there was an interest from the government to have the policy briefs outlining the study findings and potential policies and actions needed in preparation for future pandemics. Please see the details in the key-finding section.
First Year Of Impact 2023
Sector Healthcare
Impact Types Societal,Policy & public services

 
Title Patient cost diary 
Description The tool is used to measure out of pocket spending on HIV and TB care. This data is then used to calculate the incidence of catastrophic health spending during the COVID-19 pandemic. 
Type Of Material Physiological assessment or outcome measure 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact We are now using this tool in 2 other research projects in Indonesia - including the MENJAGA study, also funded by UKRI. 
 
Description Stakeholder planning meeting with the TB and HIV programmes in the Indonesian Ministry of Health. 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact This meeting was held with district and provincial health authorities in out study sites. The purpose was to discuss our planned research with them and to request their support and endorsement of data collection plans. Letters of support had already been provided but it was also necessary to meet with these stakeholders to discuss the project in more detail.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021