Getting to the cause of Chronic Kidney Disease of unknown cause (CKDu)

Lead Research Organisation: London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine
Department Name: Epidemiology and Population Health

Abstract

There is an epidemic of primarily tubular-interstitial chronic kidney disease (CKD) clustering in agricultural communities in low-and-middle income countries (LMICs). Although it is currently unclear whether there is a common underlying cause, these conditions have been collectively termed CKD of unknown cause (CKDu). CKDu is estimated to have led to the premature deaths of tens to hundreds of thousands of young adults in LMICs over the last two decades. Thus, there is an urgent need to understand the aetiology and pathophysiology of these condition(s) and to develop preventive interventions.
We have now established that CKDu exists in Central America (Nicaragua) and South Asia (India, Sri Lanka), but not in some other tropical countries (Malawi, Peru). It is not clear yet whether the epidemics in Central America and South Asia have common causes or different causes, which is why is it important to conduct research using the same protocols and methods in these different regions.

Together with colleagues we have established prospective studies in affected communities in Nicaragua, South India, Sri Lanka to investigate the causes of the epidemics of CKDu, and factors which affect prognosis. We already have published striking findings from Nicaragua, where 10% of the community, who were apparently healthy when we started following them, have lost one-third of their kidney function in two years of follow-up - so something very alarming and striking is occurring.

The underlying hypothesis is that CKDu is caused by unknown factors to which the populations have become exposed due to the changes in agricultural practice, or other environmental changes (e.g. water supply), over recent decades.

The objectives of the proposed Programme Grant research are to investigate the environmental causes of renal decline in these high-risk populations, using both standardised instruments capturing occupational and environmental exposures. We will address four proposed causes of CKDu: (i) metals and metaloids; (ii) agrochemicals; (iii) infections by organisms that affect the kidney; and (iv) heat/dehydration. To achieve these objectives we aim to: (i) extend the follow-up to at least four years in each of the three studies (Nicaragua, India, Sri Lanka); (ii) expand each prospective study to a total of 1000 participants to increase the power of the primary analyses; (iii) use standardized questionnaires to capture self-reported exposures; (iv) directly measure exposures to metals, agrochemicals, infections and heat/dehydration; (v) identify potential biomarkers of early disease; and (vi) identify genetic factors which affect decline in kidney function.

Technical Summary

The underlying hypothesis is that CKDu is caused by currently unidentified factors to which the populations have become exposed due to changes in agricultural practice, or other environmental changes.
The objectives are to:
1. Investigate the environmental causes of renal decline in high-risk populations (Nicaragua, India, Sri Lanka), using standardised instruments for four proposed causes of the disease:
a. Metals and metaloids (using direct measurement in biological samples)
b. Agrochemicals (using direct measurement in biological samples)
c. Infection by nephrotropic organisms (using serological evidence and metagenomic analyses)
d. Heat/dehydration (using standardised questionnaires on work history, lifestyle, and climate data, combined with environmental measurements to create a heat-exposure-matrix)
2. Identify early biomarkers of disease and genetic risk loci
3. Provide a bioresource of urine and blood samples from these three robustly characterized prospective studies to allow the exploration of other causal hypotheses going forward.

To achieve these objectives we will:
1. Extend the follow-up to at least four years in each of the three prospective studies (Nicaragua, India, Sri Lanka).
2. Expand each prospective study to a total of 1000 participants to increase the power of the primary analyses.
3. Use standardized questionnaires to capture self-reported exposures
4. Using a nested case-control approach, directly measure urinary metal, agrochemicals and agrochemical metabolites in baseline samples in all three regions.
5. Using a nested case-control approach, to perform serial serology for several known nephrotopic pathogens.
6. Using a nested case-control approach, undertake proteomic studies to identify potential biomarkers of early disease.
7. Perform genome-wide association studies to identify genetic risk loci for decline in eGFR using the same array in the entire study sample from all three regions.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description DEGREE Study 
Organisation University College London
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Together with Dr Ben Caplin, University College, London, I have established the Disadvantaged populations eGFR epidemiology study (DEGREE). We have published the DEGREE protocol in BMC Nephrology, and we are now recruiting and registering DEGREE Study centres. This process has been facilitated by our MRC GCRF grant. The DEGREE Steering Committee has been established and comprises: Executive Neil Pearce (UK) (Chair) Ben Caplin (UK) (Co-chair) Jason Glaser (USA) Ricardo Correa-Rotter (Mexico) Kristina Jakobsson (Sweden) Ajay Singh (USA/India) Other Steering Committee members Antonio Bernabe-Ortiz (Peru) Emmanuel Burdmann (Brazil) Marvin Gonzales (Nicaragua) Vivekanand Jha (India) Rick Johnson (USA) Phabdheep Kaur (India) Pronpimolk Kongtip (Thailand) Hans Kromhout (Netherlands) Adeera Levin (Canada) Magdalena Madero Rovalo (Mexico) Dorothea Nitsch (UK) Moffat Nyirenda (Ugand/Malawi) Cristina O'Callaghan-Gordo (Spain) Pablo Perel (UK/Argentina) Dorairaj Prabhkaran (India) Narayan Prasad (India) Giuseppe Remuzzi (Italy) Rajiv Saran (USA) Liam Smeeth (UK) Vidhya Venugopal (India) Observers Nalika Gunawardenan (Sri Lanka)
Collaborator Contribution I have worked jointly with Dr Caplin to establish this study and the related international network. There are now 15 DEGREE Centres registered, another 5 which have done the survey and are about to register, and a number of more that are likely to register and undertake the study in the next year: https://www.lshtm.ac.uk/research/centres-projects-groups/degree-study#degree-centres The DEGREE Study Coordinating Centre is at LSHTM, headed by Dr Caplin and myself.
Impact We have published the DEGREE protocol in BMC Nephrology. We are about to submit a protocol for a CO-DEGREE study which can be developed after a DEGREE survey has been conducted and it is established that CKDu is endemic in an area.
Start Year 2017
 
Description DEGREE Study in South India 
Organisation Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR)
Country India 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution I am working with colleagues in South India who have followed the DEGREE study protocol and are conducted the survey in two areas in Andhra Pradesh, South India. This is separate from the work in my MRC GCRF grant, but uses the same protocol, and the data will eventually be analysed together. The findings have now been published.
Collaborator Contribution I am working with colleagues in Sri Lanka who have followed the DEGREE study protocol and conducted the survey in two areas in Andhra Pradesh, South India. This is separate from the work in my MRC GCRF grant, but uses the same protocol, and the data will eventually be analysed together. I visited there in March 2018, and met with the State Minister of Health, and I have agreed to provide advice on CKDu research and policy.
Impact O'Callaghan-Gordo C, Shivashankar R, Anand S, Ghosh S, Glaser J, Gupta R, Jakobsson K, Kondal D, Krishnan A, Mohan S, Mohan V, Nitsch D, Praveen PA, Tandon N, Venkat Narayan V, Pearce N, Caplin B, Prabhakharan D. Chronic kidney disease of unknown aetiology in India: prevalence and risk factors. BMJ Open 2019;
Start Year 2017
 
Description DEGREE Study in Sri Lanka 
Organisation Ministry of Health, Nutrition and Indigenous Medicine
Country Sri Lanka 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution I am working with colleagues in Sri Lanka who have followed the DEGREE study protocol and conducted the survey in five areas of Sri Lanka. This is separate from the work in my MRC GCRF grant, but uses the same protocol, and the data will eventually be analysed together. The preliminary findings have been published.
Collaborator Contribution I am working with colleagues in Sri Lanka who have followed the DEGREE study protocol and conducted the survey in five areas of Sri Lanka. This is separate from the work in my MRC GCRF grant, but uses the same protocol, and the data will eventually be analysed together. The Sri Lanka work is being done by colleagues in the Ministry of Health and the WHO County office. I have visited and met with them three times to date. They have now worked with us to develop a cohort study protocol, based on a study that we are already doing in Nicaragua. This Sri Lankan cohort study is now under way, with funding from the Ministry of Health and the National Science Foundation, and the initial recruitment has been completed.
Impact Ruwanpathirana T, Senanayake S, Gunawardana N, Munasinghe A, Ginige S, Gamage D, Amarasekara J, Lokuketagoda B, Chulasiri P, Amunugama S, Palihawasana P, Caplin B, Pearce N. Prevalence and risk factors for impaired kidney function in the district of Anaradhapura, Sri Lanka. BMC Public Health 2019; 19: 763 [doi:10.1186/s12889-019-7117-2].
Start Year 2017
 
Description DEGREE Study in South India 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact I am working with colleagues in South India who have followed the DEGREE study protocol and are conducting the survey in two areas in Andhra Pradesh. This is separate from the work in my MRC GCRF grant, but uses the same protocol, and the data will eventually be analysed together. The South India work is being done with colleagues in the Indian Council for Medical Research National Epidemiology Unit. In March 2018, I visited and met with practitioners and policy makers, and also with the State Minister of Health. I agreed to provide ongoing advice on CKDu research and policy.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description DEGREE Study in Sri Lanka 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact I am working with colleagues in Sri Lanka who have followed the DEGREE study protocol and conducted the survey in five areas of Sri Lanka. This is separate from the work in my MRC GCRF grant, but uses the same protocol, and the data will eventually be analysed together. The Sri Lanka work is being done by colleagues in the Ministry of Health and the WHO County office. I have attended three meetings there, and a report on the surveys has been presented to the Ministry of Health.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017,2018