Genetic and epigenetic mechanisms involved in allopolyploid speciation in Senecio

Lead Research Organisation: University of Bristol
Department Name: Biological Sciences

Abstract

Hybrid speciation is one of the most important mechanisms of speciation in plants. Evolution is generally considered to be a slow process, but in plants, hybridization and changes in chromosome number (polyploidy) can generate new species (reproductively isolated from their parental species) in just a few generations. Genetic studies indicate that hybridization between two related species can lead to large-scale alterations in the hybrid genome, a phenomenon described as 'genome shock'. Such changes include rearrangement of chromosomes and alterations in levels of gene expression. We have been studying changes in the expression of flower genes arising as a consequence of hybrid speciation in the genus Senecio (ragworts). Senecio squalidus, commonly known as Oxford ragwort, because it was introduced into the UK (roughly 300 years ago) via the Oxford Botanic Garden, is a hybrid of two Senecio species native to Sicily, S. aethnensis and S. chrysanthemifolius, and since its escape from the Oxford Botanic Garden about 150 years ago, it has hybridized extensively with native groundsel, S. vulgaris, to produce three new hybrid species. One of these newly formed species, S. cambrensis (Welsh ragwort) formed from a sterile intermediate hybrid S. x baxteri by a doubling up of its chromosomes. S. x baxteri is sterile because it contains an odd number of chromosomes that cannot pair up properly during cell division. However a chance doubling up of these chromosomes in S. x baxteri during a faulty cell division led to the emergence of the fertile polyploid species S. cambrensis, which has become successfully established in Wales. Interestingly, these new hybrid Senecio species have all formed within the last 70 years. Our previous research has shown that following hybridization there is a dramatic change in the pattern of gene expression between the initial hybrid, S. baxteri, and its parents, S. vulgaris and S. squalidus, as well as between S. x baxteri and the fertile polyploid hybrid S. cambrensis (from which it differs only in chromosome number). Further experiments suggest that this change in gene expression can occur in a single generation. This suggests a dramatic 'shock' to the parental genomes, as a result of them coming together within a new hybrid, a phenomenon described as 'genome shock' by the geneticist Barbara McClintock. We are therefore interested in finding out how the different copies of these genes inherited from the parents are behaving in the hybrids and what factors may be causing the differences we observe. To do this we have selected small groups of genes with interesting patterns of expression and possible roles in flower development. These are: 1. genes affected by hybridisation, 2. genes affected by change in chromosome number (polyploidy), 3. genes that may regulate changes in flower structure and physiology between hybrids and parents, and 3. genes that appear to be inherited just from the mother plant, S. vulgaris (maternally inherited genes). To study the regulation of these subsets of genes we will use a technique that allows us to determine which parental gene copies are active within the hybrids. In theory, one parental gene copy will be switched off (gene silencing) allowing preferential expression of the other. This has been shown in studies of other polyploid hybrids, but has not yet been investigated in intermediate hybrids such as S. x baxteri. Secondly, we will use a variety of techniques to determine the mechanisms by which gene expression is altered in the hybrids, primarily studying DNA methylation, which has long been known to be part of the gene silencing process. Finally, we will look at the site of expression of genes we have identified as potentially involved in changes to flower form and physiology associated with the hybrid speciation process.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Hybrid speciation is one of the most important mechanisms of speciation in plants. Evolution is generally considered to be a slow process, but in plants, hybridization and changes in chromosome number (polyploidy) can generate new species in just a few generations. Genetic studies indicate that hybridization between two related species can lead to large-scale alterations in the hybrid genome, a phenomenon described as 'genome shock'. Such changes include rearrangement of chromosomes and alterations in levels of gene expression. We have been studying changes in the expression of flower genes arising as a consequence of hybrid speciation in the genus Senecio (ragworts). Senecio squalidus is a hybrid of two Senecio species native to Sicily, S. aethnensis and S. chrysanthemifolius, since its escape from the Oxford Botanic Garden about 150 years ago, it has hybridized extensively with native S. vulgaris, to produce three new hybrid species. One of these, S. cambrensis (Welsh ragwort) formed from a sterile intermediate hybrid S. x baxteri by a doubling up of its chromosomes. S. x baxteri is sterile because it contains an odd number of chromosomes. However a chance doubling up of these chromosomes in S. x baxteri during a faulty cell division led to the emergence of the fertile polyploid species S. cambrensis, which has become successfully established in Wales. Interestingly, these new hybrid Senecio species have all formed within the last 70 years.

Our previous research has shown that following hybridization there is a dramatic change in the pattern of gene expression between the initial hybrid, S. baxteri, and its parents, S. vulgaris and S. squalidus, as well as between S. x baxteri and the fertile polyploid hybrid S. cambrensis (from which it differs only in chromosome number). Further experiments suggest that this change in gene expression can occur in a single generation. This suggests a dramatic 'shock' to the parental genomes, as a result of them coming together within a new hybrid, a phenomenon described as 'genome shock' by Barbara McClintock. We were therefore interested in finding out how the different copies of these genes inherited from the parents are behaving in the hybrids and what factors may be causing these differences. To do this we selected small groups of genes with interesting patterns of expression and possible roles in flower development. These are: 1. genes affected by hybridisation, 2. genes affected by change in chromosome number (polyploidy), and 3. genes that may regulate changes in flower structure and physiology between hybrids and parents.

To study the regulation of these subsets of genes we developed an SSCP technique to identify silencing of parental specific alleles, as well as patterns of inheritance and mutation during hybridisation and genome doubling. This is the first time parental specific allele silencing has been investigated in intermediate hybrids such as S. x baxteri. Secondly, we used MSAP to study global patterns of DNA methylation, which has long been known to be part of the gene silencing process. This revealed small but significant levels of nonadditive methylation patterns both triploid and allohexaploid hybrids, at levels comparable to the nonadditive expression observed in our microarray experiments, while genome duplication appears to reduce the level of nonadditivity in the allohexaploids. Global changes in transposon activity were also investigated using a combination of southern blots and RT-PCR, and showed that nonadditive changes in genome size during hybridisation are largely due to changes in retrotransposon copy number. Finally, we looked at the site of expression of genes we previously identified as potentially involved in changes to flower form and physiology associated with the hybrid speciation process using in situ hybridisation. Particularly interesting patterns of expression were observed for 3 genes with putative roles in SI.
Exploitation Route The story of Oxford ragwort's invasion of the UK via railway lines during the industrial revolution and its subsequent hybridization with native groundsel to generate three new Senecio taxa in the UK is of pernnial interest to naturalists and anyone with an interest in the British flora. SJH has been invited to talk about the broad aspects of this research many times by local naturalist trusts and groups, e.g. Bristol Naturalists Trust, Avon and Somerset Wildlife Trust, Friends of the University of Bristol Botanic Garden. This work is primarily of interest to other academics, particularly those working on genetics of the Asteraceae, genetics of hybridisation and genome evolution.
Sectors Environment

URL http://openwetware.org/wiki/Senecio_Research_Network
 
Description Impact has been purely scientific.
First Year Of Impact 2008
Sector Environment
 
Description Use of NBAF Sheffield genotyping facility
Amount £8,000 (GBP)
Organisation Natural Environment Research Council 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start  
 
Description Epigenetic basis of speciation in African lake cichlid fishes 
Organisation University of Bristol
Department School of Biological Sciences
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution I am co-I on this EU Marie Currie Fellowship Award
Collaborator Contribution My collaborators are Dr Martin Genner (PI) and Tom Batstone (Bioinformatician). Both discuss and advise on my Senecio work and Tom continues to contribute to bioinformatic analyses of the Senecio genome
Impact Too early for outcomes
Start Year 2015