Dating and modelling fast ice-sheet grounding-line retreat over the last 4000 years in the SW Weddell Sea, Antarctica
Lead Research Organisation:
Durham University
Department Name: Geography
Abstract
The threat the West Antarctic ice-sheet poses to sea-level is largely through retreat of the grounding line, the line that separates floating ice, whose effects on sea-level are played out, and grounded ice, which can affect sea-level. Geological evidence for the retreat of grounding line under the great Antarctic ice shelves, where the most substantial retreat took place, is scarce owing to poor accessibility. We are going to use a new technique which dates ice flow changes from stratigraphic anomalies in the small ice-rises which reside within the Ronne ice shelf. This will provide information about retreat of the grounding line there. Firstly, an established technique which looks at anticline geometry will be applied. A new feature is the application of a technique (the BAS-developed pRES) for the direct measurement of strain-rates in the ice, which will allow us to quantitatively constrain the development of the anticlines, rather than make assumptions about ice rheology. Our project will therefore investigate both the retreat and rheology (flow) of the Antarctic ice-sheet. We will go to several ice divides in the SW Ronne area - the Korff, Henry, Skytrain, and Fowler to apply these techniques and date the most recent flow changes associated with the divide. These will give information about the retreat of the Ronne grounding line between Berkner Island and the Ellsworth Mountains. There are many indications that this has happened in the past 4000 years, and represents some of the most recent response of the Antarctic ice-sheet to the deglaciation following the last glacial maximum.
Measurements of ice rheology have a general relevance to ice-sheet modelling. The rate at which ice flows into the sea from the large ice-sheets directly affects sea-level. The forces which drive this flow are controlled by the increasingly well-known geometry of the the ice-sheets, but the resistance to flow depends upon the viscous (rheological) properties of ice. Ice has the peculiar property that the the viscosity depends upon the rate at which the ice is deforming. This sensitivity is usually described with the Glen index. The Glen index can be measured in the laboratory or the field. Laboratory measurements diverge from field measurements, and are very difficult to make at the low strain-rates observed in the field. In many field measurements it is difficult to characterise the stresses very well and to know how the provenance of the ice has affected measurements. By going to divide locations, where the stress field can be characterised well and ice provenance is very well constrained, we will be able to measure the Glen index. The technique is based on the fact that radar layers provide markers within the ice, and their vertical displacement over relatively short time periods can be measured using interferometric phase-sensitive radar techniques. This will provide instantaneous vertical velocity fields and strain-rate fields in the upper third to a half of the ice field. The technique has been proven at Summit in Greenland.
Once we have obtained the data, we will have an idea of how quickly the grounding line retreated. We will then run ice-sheet models, to see what kind of situations could have caused this. Grounding line retreat rates are ultimately fixed by several variables; how the ocean pumps warm water under cavities, how sea-level is rising, how the land surface recovers as ice unloads, and how the ice softens as it warms. The mathematical model will be able to assess the influence of all of these factors. Our team has also collected a lot of other data about ice-sheet extent in the area, and we will be able to see if the model can predict ice-sheet geometry that matches all of these.
At the end of the project, with our new dates for grounding line retreat and our model that represents the past, we will have a much clearer idea of how and why the ice-sheet retreated as it did in the Weddell Sea area.
Measurements of ice rheology have a general relevance to ice-sheet modelling. The rate at which ice flows into the sea from the large ice-sheets directly affects sea-level. The forces which drive this flow are controlled by the increasingly well-known geometry of the the ice-sheets, but the resistance to flow depends upon the viscous (rheological) properties of ice. Ice has the peculiar property that the the viscosity depends upon the rate at which the ice is deforming. This sensitivity is usually described with the Glen index. The Glen index can be measured in the laboratory or the field. Laboratory measurements diverge from field measurements, and are very difficult to make at the low strain-rates observed in the field. In many field measurements it is difficult to characterise the stresses very well and to know how the provenance of the ice has affected measurements. By going to divide locations, where the stress field can be characterised well and ice provenance is very well constrained, we will be able to measure the Glen index. The technique is based on the fact that radar layers provide markers within the ice, and their vertical displacement over relatively short time periods can be measured using interferometric phase-sensitive radar techniques. This will provide instantaneous vertical velocity fields and strain-rate fields in the upper third to a half of the ice field. The technique has been proven at Summit in Greenland.
Once we have obtained the data, we will have an idea of how quickly the grounding line retreated. We will then run ice-sheet models, to see what kind of situations could have caused this. Grounding line retreat rates are ultimately fixed by several variables; how the ocean pumps warm water under cavities, how sea-level is rising, how the land surface recovers as ice unloads, and how the ice softens as it warms. The mathematical model will be able to assess the influence of all of these factors. Our team has also collected a lot of other data about ice-sheet extent in the area, and we will be able to see if the model can predict ice-sheet geometry that matches all of these.
At the end of the project, with our new dates for grounding line retreat and our model that represents the past, we will have a much clearer idea of how and why the ice-sheet retreated as it did in the Weddell Sea area.
Planned Impact
We have identified three target groups whom we feel should or may want to learn more about our activities.
a) General Public: High-interest scientific papers will be communicated using the BAS media section. In addition, we will attempt direct engagement with sectors of the public with novel approaches that provide accessible background to our research activities and the considerations that surround and direct them.
i) Ice-rises in Antarctic exploration. We intend to commission an article for Planet Earth written by an Antarctic expert to outline the role of ice-rises in Antarctic exploration from Amundsen to the present-day, to publicise our work amongst the public through a more human-interest angle.
ii) Hands-on ice-sheet modelling. We believe that there is a sufficiently large world-wide technical audience to benefit from web-based simple ice-sheet modelling exercises. Our intention is to put Matlab-based programs on the web, so that interested people can use them to understand aspects of ice-sheet modelling.
b) Policy Makers: We will use the strong links within BAS to BIS and DEC to communicate our strongest and most policy-relevant findings.
i) Rates of grounding-line retreat and consequent rates of sea-level rise. Our results regarding maximum rate of sustained grounding-line retreat will be of interest to policy makers, those making decisions about flood defences, and insurance companies.
c) Interdisciplinary Impact: Promulgate by targeted attendance and conferences and workshops:
i) Raymond effect dating with geochronologists
ii) Rheological measurements and inversions with geodynamicsts and mechanicians
iii) Knowledge of Antarctic grounding-line movement data with Antarctic geologists
iv) Increased knowledge of grounding-line dynamics with glaciologists
v) Further field studies of ice-rises with Antarctic glaciologists
a) General Public: High-interest scientific papers will be communicated using the BAS media section. In addition, we will attempt direct engagement with sectors of the public with novel approaches that provide accessible background to our research activities and the considerations that surround and direct them.
i) Ice-rises in Antarctic exploration. We intend to commission an article for Planet Earth written by an Antarctic expert to outline the role of ice-rises in Antarctic exploration from Amundsen to the present-day, to publicise our work amongst the public through a more human-interest angle.
ii) Hands-on ice-sheet modelling. We believe that there is a sufficiently large world-wide technical audience to benefit from web-based simple ice-sheet modelling exercises. Our intention is to put Matlab-based programs on the web, so that interested people can use them to understand aspects of ice-sheet modelling.
b) Policy Makers: We will use the strong links within BAS to BIS and DEC to communicate our strongest and most policy-relevant findings.
i) Rates of grounding-line retreat and consequent rates of sea-level rise. Our results regarding maximum rate of sustained grounding-line retreat will be of interest to policy makers, those making decisions about flood defences, and insurance companies.
c) Interdisciplinary Impact: Promulgate by targeted attendance and conferences and workshops:
i) Raymond effect dating with geochronologists
ii) Rheological measurements and inversions with geodynamicsts and mechanicians
iii) Knowledge of Antarctic grounding-line movement data with Antarctic geologists
iv) Increased knowledge of grounding-line dynamics with glaciologists
v) Further field studies of ice-rises with Antarctic glaciologists
Publications
Bentley M
(2015)
Exploring the Last Continent - An Introduction to Antarctica
Bentley M
(2014)
A community-based geological reconstruction of Antarctic Ice Sheet deglaciation since the Last Glacial Maximum
in Quaternary Science Reviews
Bentley M
(2017)
Deglacial history of the Pensacola Mountains, Antarctica from glacial geomorphology and cosmogenic nuclide surface exposure dating
in Quaternary Science Reviews
Bradley S
(2015)
Low post-glacial rebound rates in the Weddell Sea due to Late Holocene ice-sheet readvance
in Earth and Planetary Science Letters
Ely J
(2019)
ATAT 1.1, the Automated Timing Accordance Tool for comparing ice-sheet model output with geochronological data
in Geoscientific Model Development
Hillenbrand C
(2014)
Reconstruction of changes in the Weddell Sea sector of the Antarctic Ice Sheet since the Last Glacial Maximum
in Quaternary Science Reviews
Hindmarsh, R.C.A.
(2020)
Radars and Ice Cores Reveal Styles of Retreat of Greenland and Antarctic Ice Sheets
in ECO SI
Jones R
(2019)
Impact of glacial isostatic adjustment on cosmogenic surface-exposure dating
in Quaternary Science Reviews
Jones R
(2019)
iceTEA: Tools for plotting and analysing cosmogenic-nuclide surface-exposure data from former ice margins
in Quaternary Geochronology
Larter R
(2014)
Reconstruction of changes in the Amundsen Sea and Bellingshausen Sea sector of the West Antarctic Ice Sheet since the Last Glacial Maximum
in Quaternary Science Reviews
Description | The work showed a number of ice rises in the SW Weddell Sea can be used to track deglacial histories of the Antarctic Ice Sheet. Most findings to date have been published by Kingslake (due to illness of PI) but further outputs forthcoming. |
Exploitation Route | Input to, and constraints on, deglacial models of the Antarctic ice sheet. |
Sectors | Environment |
Title | Questions about ice dynamics formulated on the basis of newly acquired data |
Description | The large group of earth scientists involved in investigating the palaeo-Antarctic Ice-Sheet (p-AIS) and palaeo-British-Irish Ice-Sheet (p-BIIS) has quite naturally led them to think about ice dynamical explanations for their observations. Nearly all of their conjectures and questions are well thought-through, which ultimately create questions for ice dynamicists and modellers to answer. We are improving and amending models to focus on these questions. |
Type Of Material | Computer model/algorithm |
Year Produced | 2015 |
Provided To Others? | Yes |
Impact | There are several different groups working on the p-AIS and p-BIIS, all aiming to make use of the new data. These groups talk with each other, but are all interested in different aspects of the behaviour of the ice-sheet. |
Description | Durham LGM Antarctica |
Organisation | Durham University |
Department | Department of Geography |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | BAS have organised the data gathering, geophysical surveying of ice-rises by radar-techniques. We can use these data to date the retreat of the main Antarctic grounding line. These ice-rises are located within the Ronne Ice Shelf. |
Collaborator Contribution | The project is ongoing - Durham have committed to using the data to model the behaviour of the Antarctic ice-sheet since the Last Glacial Maximum. |
Impact | BAS have completed the geophysical surveys. The data are due to be shared; once this occurs, Durham will use the data, in conjunction with other data they have acquired and models, to constrain the behaviour of the West Antarctic ice-sheet in the Weddell Sea area. BAS will contribute by collaborating on the organisation of the modelling studies. |
Start Year | 2013 |
Title | BASISM - the BAS Ice Sheet Model |
Description | BASISM has been developed over the past fifteen years, and has achieved successes in formal model intercomparison projects (MIPs), as well as being used to settle some long-standing problems. |
Type Of Technology | Software |
Year Produced | 2013 |
Impact | This software (and its brethren) have been used in MIPs to validate theoretical advances in grounding-line motion/stability and ice-stream formation. |
Description | Antarctic Exhibition |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an open day or visit at my research institution |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | Regional |
Primary Audience | Schools |
Results and Impact | Antarctic Exhibiton with several 1000 visitors. and accompanying primary and secondary education programme focussed on ice sheets and sea level. Teachers reported changes in way they teach Geography and Science curricula (esp ice sheets and sea level ) |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2015 |
Description | Celebrating Charlie Raymond's 80th Birthday |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
Results and Impact | Charlie Raymond was a highly successful glaciologist who influenced a great number and variety of scientists. My field work post-2000 CE was organised around his ideas regarding ice flow near ice divides; these ideas are called the 'Raymond Effect' which lead to anticlines called 'Raymond Arches', which are detected by ice-penetrating radar. The event attracted a wide variety of scientists. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2019 |
Description | Modelling panel for BRITICE, for groups both internal and external to the main BRITICE project |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Postgraduate students |
Results and Impact | The new data acquired by BRITICE from the North, Norwegian and Celtic Seas shows very clearly that the British-Irish Ice Sheet (BIIS) was a marine ice-sheet. The stability of such ice sheets is a major concern, since Antarctica is a marine ice-sheet and its observed retreat threatens to raise global sea-level by between 0.5m and 2m by 2100 CE. The quantity of new data points means the the BIIS is the most well-described marine ice-sheet, and already these data are illuminating issues of marine ice-sheet stability. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2014,2015,2016,2017,2018 |