Bottom boundary layer mediation of chemical fluxes from ocean margins

Lead Research Organisation: University of Oxford
Department Name: Earth Sciences

Abstract

Marine sediments are an important source of essential micronutrients to the ocean, but measuring these inputs is problematic. I aim to observe and understand the behavior of micronutrient inputs, in particular iron, close to the seafloor, where exchanges between sediments and seawater are thought to mediate the uptake of carbon via photosynthesis in the surface ocean. Refining this critical source to the ocean is needed to improved ocean-coupled models of the Earth's climate. A key aspect of this work will be to collect samples of dissolved and suspended particulate material in vertical transects close to the seabed, where the physical mixing and chemical exchanges in the ocean are completely different from the ocean interior.
Chemical processes in this 'bottom boundary layer' are largely unknown, because sampling it from the ocean surface is difficult; large distances from a research vessel propagates inaccuracy close to the seafloor and risks damage or loss of costly equipment. A novelty of this project will be to develop and optimize a free-falling instrument that can rest remotely on the seabed and collect bottom water and particulate samples across a 10 to 100 meter thick layer of the ocean using remote and autonomous controls. The instrument will be developed with support from the Ocean Technology and Engineering Group at the National Oceanography Centre, with additional funds from the Royal Society provided by Prof. Gideon Henderson at the University of Oxford.
The new instrument will be first used in conjunction with the NERC Shelf Sea Biogeochemistry Programme in the UK North Atlantic planned for late 2014. Observed conditions will be simulated in laboratory experiments to identify chemical exchange mechanisms between sediments and seawater. The fellowship will benefit from analytical expertise at the Marine Trace Element Laboratory of University of South Carolina, USA, through which newly developed metal isotope observations in seawater will be made.
Future deployments of the new instrument are planned within the lifetime of this fellowship through interaction with the international GEOTRACES program. A legacy of this work will be to refine estimates of micronutrient supply from ocean margins to improve ocean climate models, and to establish an operational platform for a broad range of chemical observations across an under-explored part of the Earth system. Potential research avenues for the future include refining chemical tracers of ocean processes; monitoring marine habitats and contaminant transport processes; and observing chemical processes at the seafloor in dynamic ice-covered or volcanic regions of the ocean over time.

Planned Impact

Marine sediments are an important source of essential micronutrients to the ocean, but measuring these inputs is problematic. I aim to observe and understand the behavior of micronutrient inputs, in particular iron, close to the seafloor, where exchanges between sediments and seawater are thought to mediate the uptake of carbon via photosynthesis in the surface ocean.

Refining this critical source to the ocean is now a priority in government-funded research in nations around the world (e.g. GEOTRACES and the World Climate Research Program's Climate Variability and Predictability Project); Results will improve the accuracy of ocean-coupled general circulation models (GCMs) of the Earth's climate, which are the fundamental basis of weather and climate prediction tools - on all resolution and time scales - used both operationally for day-to-day forecasting, and for the longer term seasonal, decadal and centennial modeling that underpins the work on the IPCC assessment reports. It's clear, therefore, that climate and meteorological agencies, such as the UK Met Office Hadley Centre, charged with the projection of future climate as well as the development of the next generation of coupled climate models, should be interested in the results. There is enormous public interest in climate change and the ocean is a key component in the earth's climate system. Whether through the frequency and magnitude of extreme weather events such as flooding, hot summers or the impact of the NAO on the likelihood of snowy UK winters, there is much in my Fellowship which could have an impact on UK public policy (e.g. the Met Office's current 'get ready for winter' programme), the insurance industry (extreme climate event attribution), or the quality of life of the UK public ('hot' summers, or 'snowy' winters). There is additional impact on sustainability of UK fishing and agriculture; Human activity has enhanced the discharge of harmful elements into the oceans and knowledge of the processes regulating trace elements will improve prediction of contaminant transport and fate of contaminants in the ocean; thereby helping to protect the marine environment.


Impact related milestones and measures of success I intend to deliver during the tenure of this Fellowship include:

1) Publication of results in international peer-reviewed journals (as open access).
2) Presentation of results at international and national conferences.
3) Launching of a Fellowship and personal research website.
4) Incorporation of science outputs from my Fellowship research into outreach, education, and learning activities via the the University of Oxford and elsewhere.
5) Regular participation in local science blogs and news features on international websites.
6) Successfully attracting young Earth Science undergraduates into PhDs in NERC science areas related to the topic of my Fellowship.

No specific additional costs are requested or required. The routine impacts described will be delivered within the main fieldwork and analytical budget outlined in the justification for resources. Non-academic impacts will be provided at no additional cost to NERC.

Publications

10 25 50

publication icon
Bridgestock L (2018) Controls on the barium isotope compositions of marine sediments in Earth and Planetary Science Letters

publication icon
Bryan A (2021) Controls on the cadmium isotope composition of modern marine sediments in Earth and Planetary Science Letters

publication icon
Charette MA (2016) Coastal ocean and shelf-sea biogeochemical cycling of trace elements and isotopes: lessons learned from GEOTRACES. in Philosophical transactions. Series A, Mathematical, physical, and engineering sciences

publication icon
Hernandez-Sanchez M (2014) Occurrence of 1-O-monoalkyl glycerol ether lipids in ocean waters and sediments in Organic Geochemistry

publication icon
Homoky W (2017) Deep ocean iron balance in Nature Geoscience

publication icon
Homoky WB (2016) Quantifying trace element and isotope fluxes at the ocean-sediment boundary: a review. in Philosophical transactions. Series A, Mathematical, physical, and engineering sciences

 
Description Significant new knowledge was generated by this award; The seasonal accumulation of detritus from marine plankton in UK shelf seas was found to accelerate the dissolution and transport of iron - a key micronutrient - to the overlying UK shelf sea water. The detrital carbon was found to do two things: (1) Enhance the rates of iron reduction (iron dissolution) in the sediments; (2) inhibit natural iron oxidation (potential losses of iron) from the seawater, and thereby prolong the presence and potential transport of dissolved Fe in the shelf region. Transport of iron was quantified by novel analyses of a short-lived radioactive isotope (radium) and found to be driven by tidal forces intersecting steep slopes and canyons of the shelf slopes - the resultant fluxes of dissolved iron were far higher than previously realised for the region of the North Atlantic Ocean.

Through co-supervision of a NERC-funded PhD student (A. Lough, Southampton), 3 student led papers have deepend our knowledge of iron-isotope systematics and iron-stabilisation process in hydrothermal plumes, that help to explain how ocean biogeochemical processes are impacted by mid-ocean-ridge hydrothermal venting.

Through supervision of NERC-DTP studentship (S.Selzer, Oxford; Submitted: Selzer, Annett and Homoky In Review), a new, improved and faster method has been developed for processing the raw data acquired by RaDeCC instruments (Radium Delayed and Coincidence Counting - the same technique that was used for analysing short-lived radium described above). Further, this studentship has generated evidence to contest theories that hydrothermal vents are a source of radium to the deep-ocean, rather it is the parent isotopes of radium in the seafloor sediments themselves which impart short-lived radium isotopes to bottom water.

Important new research questions opened up; This award has enabled a consolidating body of iron-isotope evidence to be generated which underscores a previous discovery of the PI; oxygenated sediment in the ocean provides a major source of micro-nutrients to the ocean by silicate weathering and the formation of colloids (nano-metre sized minerals). Significant collaborations have developed from this work, first through leadership of international working group discussions on elemental exchange processes on the seafloor (Homoky et al., PTRS 2016), and secondly by forming new collaborative partnerships (e.g with ERC-funded studentship of Prof. Alessandro Tagliabue, Liverpool) to develop new ocean model parameterisations of seafloor exchange processes that can improve simulated ocean-coupled climate relationships and predictions.

As an IRF, the PI has acquired valuable new skills in grant writing, HEI and international leadership, and graduate research supervision and teaching. The PI has also developed new expertise in Uranium-series and radium isotope analyses during their time at Oxford, and secured a permanent academic research position at the University of Leeds.
Exploitation Route Understanding the controls of carbon and nutrient storage and exchanges in UK shelf seas is necessary for UK to understand and quantify it's commitment to CO2 emission reductions targets. Through the NERC and Defra funded UK-SSB programme, this award has and will continue to directly feed in to policy related discussion with government departments (e.g. Cefas and Defra). Future plans for terrestrial management of UK carbon cycling and storage coupled to agriculture and food security, may also benefit from linking to knowledge of the impacts of carbon and nutrient cycling in adjacent marine setting such as the UK's Exclusive Economic Zone.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Energy,Environment

 
Description A key finding from this grant has been to characterise the significant role of nano-minerals (or colloids) as carrier phases responsible for chemical exchanges between the ocean and seafloor (see Homoky et al., 2021 and references therein). These findings have been promoted by the Deep Ocean Stewardship Initiative, and Homoky et al's (2021) standard operating procedure to assess for the presence of suspended nano-minerals in the surface layers of the deep seafloor is now being used as the basis of industry-funded marine research, which seeks to satisfy recommendations of the United Nations' International Seabed Authority (ISA) while conducting impact assessments of experimental manganese nodule collection from the Equatorial Pacific, Clarion Clipperton Zone. New insights gained from these analytical methods of environmental monitoring will strengthen the evidence base from which Governments and Society at large via the ISA can make informed decisions about the regulation of emergent deep-sea mining industries and protection of the marine environment.
First Year Of Impact 2020
Sector Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Energy,Environment,Government, Democracy and Justice
Impact Types Societal,Economic,Policy & public services

 
Description Shelf Seas: The Engine of Productivity
Geographic Reach Europe 
Policy Influence Type Implementation circular/rapid advice/letter to e.g. Ministry of Health
URL https://www.uk-ssb.org/shelf_seas_report.pdf
 
Description NERC Anniversary Ambassador
Amount £2,000 (GBP)
Organisation Natural Environment Research Council 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 04/2015 
End 07/2018
 
Description NERC Responsive Mode (RoSES: Role of the Southern Ocean in the Earth System)
Amount £1,797,017 (GBP)
Funding ID NE/P021344/1 
Organisation Natural Environment Research Council 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 07/2017 
End 07/2021
 
Description Open Junior Research Fellowship
Amount £9,000 (GBP)
Organisation University of Oxford 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 05/2017 
End 04/2020
 
Title MAPs 
Description MAPs (or Minature Autonomous Pumps), are designed to sample radioactive tracers and suspensed particles from ocean waters near sediments. In teh future, the new equipment is expected to help resolve previoulsy missing chemical observations in the ocean that are needed to quantify the exchange of important chemical properties, like nutrients or toxins for life in the oceans. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2015 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact "MAPs" were discussed by an internatonal audience at the Royal Society, and considered this a promising tool to advance future ocean sciencetifc observations and understanding processes that impact a braod specturm of society, findings of which are in preparation for publication. 
URL http://www.uk-ssb.org/outputs_and_impacts/blog/search/label/Will%20Homoky
 
Title Radioisotope sampling by Stand Alone Pumping System (SAPS) 
Description Seawater radioisotopes (e.g. radium, actinium) are useful chemcial tracers of chemical inputs and thier physical disersions rates and pathways in the ocean. Sampling of radioisotope in sewater requires them to be chemically 'scavenged' by passing seawater over a specially impregnated fibre used for later analysis of radioactivity. We benefit from sampling the ocean with the use of an in situ pump and filter apperatus, which can be hung from a wire beneath a ship to target specific parts regions and depth of ocean. Stand Alone Pumping Systems (SAPS) 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2017 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Stand Alone Pumping Systems are already an integral part of the UK's National Marine Equipment pool. A member of my research team, has piloted the use of an improved cartridge filter design used to scavenge low abundance radioisotopes from large volumes of ocean water (Royal Research Ship James Cook; JC156). The bebenfit of this approach is that it enbales radium and actinium sampling of the open ocean without the need for very large volumes of water to be brought on to the ship by traditional water bottle sampling. Thus extensive and valuable ship time was saved because processing of large volume water samples on deck was not required, and the research ship capability to aquire more data was improved. 
 
Description Calibration of Paleo Proxies 
Organisation University of Oxford
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution I am providing samples, methodlogical advise, ancillary data and supporting interpreations to PDRA and PhD candidates at University of Oxford, Imperial College London and University of Bristol, who are developing chemical and isotopic proxies to understand past climate and ocean conditions.
Collaborator Contribution PDRA and PhD candidates are leading novel analytical measurements on a suite of samples I collected from the South Atlantic Ocean, and providing new perspectives to their interpretations.
Impact Four published outputs: 1. Controls on the barium isotope compositions of marine sediments. Earth and Planetary Science Letters. 2018; 481:101-10. 2. Tracing the Agulhas leakage with lead isotopes, Geophysical Research Letters 42, 8515-8521. 3. Further insights into how sediment redox status controls the preservation and composition of sedimentary biomarkers. Organic Geochemistry, 76, 220-234. 4. The occurrence of 1-O-monoalkyl glycerol ethers in ocean waters and sediments. Organic Geochemistry, 66: 1-13. Paper 1 has been cited 8 times, and forms part of the track-record and motivation for it's lead author, L.Bridgestock, to pursue a NERC-IRF in 2018/19. Paper 2 has been cited 4 times. Papers 3&4, are cited 6 and 17 times respectively and provide unique citations concerning the utility and reliability of preserved biomarker records in marine sediments. All of these collaborations were multi-disciplicary, combing either advanced stable isotope or organic biomarker analyses, with and low-temperature solid-aquoes geochemistry and marine sedimentology.
Start Year 2014
 
Description FRidge - Fluxes from hydrothermal ridge systems 
Organisation University of Liverpool
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution My reseach team (Mr Sean Selzer, Oxford DTP) have provided complementary radio-isotope sampling and analysis in collaboration with the NERC-funded FRidge grant. We have suppiorted the design and execution of fieldwork aboard the RRS James Cook (JC156) in a transect of deep Atlantic Ocean hydrotherm vent sites.
Collaborator Contribution UoLiverpool and UoSouthampton (joint award holders of the FRidge grant), have provided a ship's berth space, and met the costs of National Marine Facilities (NMF) technical support for a memeber of my research team to join the RRS James cook amd undertake sampling and analysis. UoSouthampton has further shared the costs of NMF equipment modifications and sampling and analytical materials attiruted to our research.
Impact 1. Research Student presentation at Ra-Rn workshop, Germany, June 2018. Selzer et al., RaDeCC Reader: An autonomous programme for the correction and error propagation of raw data outputs from RaDeCC Instruments. 2. Research Student presentation at the Challenger Conference, University of Newcastle, September 2018. Selzer et al., Radium isotope inputs and dispersion from Mid-Atlantic Ridge hydrothermal vents.
Start Year 2017
 
Description FRidge - Fluxes from hydrothermal ridge systems 
Organisation University of Southampton
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution My reseach team (Mr Sean Selzer, Oxford DTP) have provided complementary radio-isotope sampling and analysis in collaboration with the NERC-funded FRidge grant. We have suppiorted the design and execution of fieldwork aboard the RRS James Cook (JC156) in a transect of deep Atlantic Ocean hydrotherm vent sites.
Collaborator Contribution UoLiverpool and UoSouthampton (joint award holders of the FRidge grant), have provided a ship's berth space, and met the costs of National Marine Facilities (NMF) technical support for a memeber of my research team to join the RRS James cook amd undertake sampling and analysis. UoSouthampton has further shared the costs of NMF equipment modifications and sampling and analytical materials attiruted to our research.
Impact 1. Research Student presentation at Ra-Rn workshop, Germany, June 2018. Selzer et al., RaDeCC Reader: An autonomous programme for the correction and error propagation of raw data outputs from RaDeCC Instruments. 2. Research Student presentation at the Challenger Conference, University of Newcastle, September 2018. Selzer et al., Radium isotope inputs and dispersion from Mid-Atlantic Ridge hydrothermal vents.
Start Year 2017
 
Description Hydrothermal impact on trace element chemistry 
Organisation National Oceanography Centre
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution I co-superised a PhD candidate (Alistair Lough 2012-2016, now graduated) based at the Universty of Southampton. I have supported a variety mentoring aspects attributed to PhD student training, supported fieldwork, presentations at internatinal conferences, manuscript and thesis preparations and conucting laboratory work (e.g. at Diamond Light Source, UK).
Collaborator Contribution University of Southampton, and National Oceanography Centre host 2-additional student supervisors, and provide research facilities for teh student. Southampton will be the degree awarding institute.
Impact The PhD project has successfully led to funding for collaborative research at Diamond Light Source. Three student-led publications have resulted from this PhD project (2 are published, a third is submitted and in review) 1. Soluble iron conservation and colloidal iron dynamics in a hydrothermal plume. Chemical Geology. In press. 2. Opposing authigenic controls on the isotopic signature of dissolved iron in hydrothermal plumes. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta. 2017;202(Supplement C):1-20. 3. Diffuse hydrothermal venting: a hidden source of hydrothermal iron. Frontiers in Marine Science. In review.
Start Year 2012
 
Description Hydrothermal impact on trace element chemistry 
Organisation University of Southampton
Department Ocean and Earth Science
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution I co-superised a PhD candidate (Alistair Lough 2012-2016, now graduated) based at the Universty of Southampton. I have supported a variety mentoring aspects attributed to PhD student training, supported fieldwork, presentations at internatinal conferences, manuscript and thesis preparations and conucting laboratory work (e.g. at Diamond Light Source, UK).
Collaborator Contribution University of Southampton, and National Oceanography Centre host 2-additional student supervisors, and provide research facilities for teh student. Southampton will be the degree awarding institute.
Impact The PhD project has successfully led to funding for collaborative research at Diamond Light Source. Three student-led publications have resulted from this PhD project (2 are published, a third is submitted and in review) 1. Soluble iron conservation and colloidal iron dynamics in a hydrothermal plume. Chemical Geology. In press. 2. Opposing authigenic controls on the isotopic signature of dissolved iron in hydrothermal plumes. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta. 2017;202(Supplement C):1-20. 3. Diffuse hydrothermal venting: a hidden source of hydrothermal iron. Frontiers in Marine Science. In review.
Start Year 2012
 
Description Minature Autonomous Pumps (MAPs) 
Organisation National Oceanography Centre
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Through a NERC IRF I have conceived the specification and funded the design and assembly of 2-prototype "MAPs". I have undertaken real-world sea-trails with these new peices of ocean sampling equipment to evaulate their suitability for delivery research objectives outlined in the IRF award.
Collaborator Contribution Engineers in teh Ocean Enginerring and Technology Group at NOC, provided expert advise during design, assembly and prelimary testing of the equipment, as well as shore-based support by e-mail during sea trials on board the RRS Discovery.
Impact My efforts to improve the quantification for chemical measurements in the ocean resulted in my invited talk at a Royal Society Meeting (Dec, 2015), and sub-sequent nomination to lead and internaltional group of experts to publish present challneges and solutions to our field - the technology descibved herein forms a central argument as a solution for future research.
Start Year 2014
 
Description NERC Shelf Seas Biogeochemistry Programme 
Organisation University of Southampton
Department Ocean and Earth Science
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Co-author (and formerly intended to be Co-I-Researcher) of NERC's SSB Programme WP3 "The supply of iron from shelf seas". I waived opportunity to be funded through this grant to accept the NERC IRF. I have been closly involved as a Project Collaborator; planning, leading (Senior Scientist aborad RRS Discovery expedition DY030), supervising (2 PDRAs) and delivering (3 papers published, 3 more in prep.) the objectives of this programme.
Collaborator Contribution University of Sothampton have provided me with a permanent "visitor" status, and the Lead PI of the Work Package has welcomed my regular visits to help steer programmatic activies related to mutual research objectives, an he co-supervision the project's PDRAs.
Impact I have produced 3 publications thus far, and have a further 3 still in preparation.
Start Year 2013
 
Description Sediment transport in the Argentine Basin 
Organisation Los Alamos National Laboratory
Country United States 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution I have provided intellectual expertise on the behaviour of sediments in the ocean, to support ocean modelling efforts at Los Alamos National Laboratory (USA). I have further supported the successful organisation of session at Aquatic Sciences meeting, USA, led by the partner/collaborator, hosted their visit to Oxford, co-authored thier publication, and supported their grant proposal to Ntional Science Foundation,(USA).
Collaborator Contribution They have provided significant supercomputing time, and co-designed and performed approach to assess sedimentation dynamics in the South Atlantic Ocean. They led the write up for publication.
Impact One published out put: Eddy-driven sediment transport in the Argentine Basin: Is the height of the Zapiola Rise hydrodynamically controlled? The collaboration also led to the submission of new grant proposals to NSF. I attracted expertise from LANL to speak to students and faculty in the Department of Earth Sciences. A legacy of this collaboration is a constructive point of contact in the US Department of Energy to link with the UK's ocean science research community.
Start Year 2015
 
Description Sediment transport in the Argentine Basin 
Organisation Los Alamos National Laboratory
Country United States 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution I have provided intellectual expertise on the behaviour of sediments in the ocean, to support ocean modelling efforts at Los Alamos National Laboratory (USA). I have further supported the successful organisation of session at Aquatic Sciences meeting, USA, led by the partner/collaborator, hosted their visit to Oxford, co-authored thier publication, and supported their grant proposal to Ntional Science Foundation,(USA).
Collaborator Contribution They have provided significant supercomputing time, and co-designed and performed approach to assess sedimentation dynamics in the South Atlantic Ocean. They led the write up for publication.
Impact One published out put: Eddy-driven sediment transport in the Argentine Basin: Is the height of the Zapiola Rise hydrodynamically controlled? The collaboration also led to the submission of new grant proposals to NSF. I attracted expertise from LANL to speak to students and faculty in the Department of Earth Sciences. A legacy of this collaboration is a constructive point of contact in the US Department of Energy to link with the UK's ocean science research community.
Start Year 2015
 
Description Ocean Connections - Rush Common Primary School, Abingdon 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact Rush Common Primary School, Abingdon, Oxfordshire.
In support of a local primary school initiative to consider the ocean in many aspects of their curricula, I designed and delivered a 40 minute talk and 1 hour learning activity entitled "Ocean Connections" to two classes of Key Stage 2 (Year 4) pupils (60 pupils in total). I also designed supporting materials for two teaching staff to assist them in consolidating our learning outcomes later in the term. After which, I received updates from the teaching staff on the ways in which my visit had impacted student learning and their thoughts about connections with the ocean.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description RRS Discovery event in London 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an open day or visit at my research institution
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact I was an Anniversary Ambassador for NERC in 2015, and wen to London to engage the gernal public with UK ocean science, our infrastructure, aims, and achievements as part of NERC's celebration of their 50th birthday.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
 
Description UNIQ Summer school lecture 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an open day or visit at my research institution
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact Year 11 school students are selected from national applications to attend the UNIQ summer school from under-representated regions of the UK. I gave a lecture entitled "Life and Death in the Oceans" which expsosed students to the sort of work we undertake at the university, why it matters and what it is like to perform fieldwork exploring the deep ocean. This stimulated many questions about natiural science careers, problems facing teh oceans, and geberal inquizitiveness about 'how our oceans work'.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017