Probing Earth's deep interior with rapid changes in Geomagnetic field and Earth rotation

Lead Research Organisation: University of Liverpool
Department Name: Earth, Ocean and Ecological Sciences

Abstract

The geomagnetic field varies on time scales of milliseconds to billions of years, and has sources both inside the Earth, from the dynamo generating the main field in the highly conducting liquid iron core, and outside the Earth, from currents flowing above us in the ionosphere and magnetosphere, reflecting the interaction of the solar wind with our planet. In general, rapid variations (less than one year period) originate outside the Earth, while longer period variations come from inside. Separating signals from one to ten years is a challenge, but also has the potential to tell us much about Earth structure and processes. The most rapid variations generally identified as being of internal origin are so-called "geomagnetic jerks" - rapid changes in the rate of change of the magnetic field. Their structure and evolution can tell us not only about rapid changes in Earth's fluid core (such as waves and upwelling of core fluid) but also about the solid mantle in between. This rocky region is not as electrically conducting as the iron core, but it could still conduct weakly. A strong constraint on this property has recently been provided by another geophysical measurement, the rate of Earth rotation. We have found that sharp changes in the field are matched by almost contemporaneous sharp changes in the rate of Earth rotation. This both gives as clues as to what causes the events, but also strongly restricts the conductivity of the mantle - if this were higher, then the magnetic signal would lag the rotational signal as it would take time for the field to diffuse from its origin at the core-mantle boundary through the solid Earth to be observed at the surface. Mantle conductivity is also constrained by measurements of the induced magnetic field from varying external fields, so-called geomagnetic depth sounding. The combination of this constraint from above the Earth, and the new constraint from the deep mantle, will be used to give a detailed profile of conductivity as a function of depth, which in turn constrains the composition and mineral state of the solid Earth. For example, if a phase change of silicate rock were predicted which gives a sharp rise in conductivity, this phase change could be excluded by the geomagnetic data.

The bulk of the work in this study is detailed analysis of both geomagnetic and Earth rotation data to tease out more information as to the signals they contain. A six-year oscillation has been confirmed in both measurements, but more rapid variations are even harder to distinguish, as they overlap with other sources: for the magnetic field, from external current systems, and for Earth rotation from angular momentum exchange with the atmosphere. For example, variations in short period (atmospheric) variations in Earth rotation have been shown to have a strong link to the ENSO climatic signal. A successful outcome of the project will rely on successful separation of the signals.

We will construct detailed models of the magnetic field variation in space and time to investigate what is causing these changes. Recently, quantum mechanical calculations of the physical state of materials of the Earth's deep interior have revised our assumed value for the electrical and linked thermal conductivity of the core. These new values have changed our understanding of how the core works - we now believe that instead of full vigorous convection, it is highly likely that there is a stably stratified layer of fluid at the top of the core. This layer will support waves and instabilities rather than large scale convection, as is seen for our atmosphere and oceans, similarly stably stratified, rapidly rotating fluids. A recent simple model of these waves can explain the details of the variation of the dipole field in the Earth, and our preliminary results suggest that they may also explain the geomagnetic jerks. Thus our work should constrain both the structure of Earth's mantle, and the dynamics of its core.

Planned Impact

This research has direct potential to aid industrial and other practical uses of models of the geomagnetic field, by enabling the production of better models. Such models are used in many practical applications, for example in navigation. The Ordnance survey provides on its maps a value for the declination (the difference between true north and magnetic north), and importantly its change with time - in the UK currently about 1 degree per 5 years. Even with the advent of GPS, the magnetic field is still of fundamental importance, particularly for determining direction, and indeed GPS receivers will also return a magnetic bearing in addition to a fixed position. Airfields and airports are regularly surveyed for the local magnetic environment, and possible changes in magnetic field direction to aid magnetic bearing information for take-off and landing, particularly in poor weather conditions. Magnetic field is used in geophysical exploration; before interpreting an aeromagnetic survey, it is necessary to correct the data by subtracting a model of the main magnetic field. Probably the most significant current application of the geomagnetic field is in directional drilling, particularly in oil prospecting. Horizontal wells are becoming ever more common, for which navigation must be performed while drilling. Direct measurement of direction can be obtained with a gyrocompass, but this requires cessation of drilling, and removal of the drilling rig, which is hugely expensive. Instead, the most common technique is magnetically referenced Measurement While Drilling, which uses a measurement of the magnetic field to provide directional information. A substantial part of the activities of national geomagnetic agencies (for example, the BGS Geomagnetism group based in Edinburgh) focuses on providing industry support in this area (see, for example, p24-25 of http://geomag.bgs.ac.uk/documents/reviews/Geomagnetism_Review_2013.pdf).

In all applications, it is important to access a model not only of the main field at a particular epoch, but of how this field changes with time. The international standard for this procedure is to use the International Geomagnetic Reference Field, or IGRF (http://www.ngdc.noaa.gov/IAGA/vmod/igrf.html). This model is defined every five years with a main field model for the starting epoch, and a constant secular variation model (allowing linear change in time) as a predictive model for the five years ahead. The field does not change linearly in time, but no better predictive accuracy has been established. As noted in the main proposal, some workers have argued that the geomagnetic field is inherently chaotic, and thus not predictable after more than a very short time. However, we believe that this is an over-simplistic view of the field. Many features of the field are clearly predictable - for example, the average steady decay of the dipole, a 60-year oscillation superimposed on top, and a 6 year variation, along with jumps in field rate of change, all of which we consider. The aim of the work described in this proposal is to obtain a better model of the temporal evolution of the field, therefore a better model for users at any particularly time, and so better navigation, more effective drilling, and safer aeroplane operation, particularly landing.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description This grant has had two foci. The first has been considering variations in length of day. This component has been substantially enhanced by the provision of a new data set of lunar occultations extending the available time series back hundreds of years (from the decades studied so far). (Stephenson FR, Morrison LV, Hohenkerk CY. Proc. R. Soc. A 472: 2016). This has allowed extension of the 6-year period associated with geomagnetic jerks back to 1800. A poster has been presented at the SEDI meeting in Nantes, July, 2016. Further development is being provided through undergraduate projects. In particular, the noise in recent data shows a previously unnoticed 18.6 year modulation, correction for which will substantially denoise the data.
The second focus concerns geomagnetic data. Some results have been negative - the initial optimism concerning a global contemporaneous jerk has turned out to be associated with external rather than internal field. Results relating to this (slightly negative) result are to be presented at the IAGA meeting in South Africa, 2017. Implications related to the modelling of the IGRF (our noted impact related to this meeting) will also be considered. An open-source software for processing and cleaning geomagnetic data has been developed . It implements a novel method for removing external noise from the data and automates several data processing techniques that are currently done by hand.
Exploitation Route Length of day results will influence current discussions on the retention of discarding of leap seconds, Magnetic modelling information will be communicated to the global community at the IAGA meeting. The software will be freely available to members of the community, information will be given at the IAGA meeting and in an upcoming publication.
Sectors Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software)

 
Title Python tool for analysing geomagnetic data 
Description A computing tool for detailed consideration of geomagnetic secular variation, particularly for separation of internal and external sources. Open access publication with associated links. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2018 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Not yet! 
URL https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/2018GC007714
 
Description BGS 
Organisation British Geological Survey
Department Geomagnetism Group
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution The PDRA on this grant is working with Dr Laurence Billingham and Dr Will Brown on a piece of open-source software designed to process and denoise geomagnetic observatory data. This project started through her work as a PDRA on this grant - she has designed the software from scratch, written all of the code to process data and implemented a novel method to remove noise from the data. She is the lead researcher on this collaboration.
Collaborator Contribution BGS Edinburgh supply the data used by the software. The collaborators have provided information about how the data have been treated before their release and potential issues remaining in the data. They are also directly contributing to the software by designing code to pull data from the BGS web servers, rather than needing to email a particular person at BGS to obtain data (as is currently the case).
Impact The main output of this collaboration is a novel software to process geomagnetic observatory data. The software is now complete. The PDRA has presented the software, resulting datasets and their applications to research on Earth's magnetic field at several conferences, including the IAGA assembly in Cape Town, 2017, and an invited talk at EGU, Vienna, to be presented in 2018. A paper on this work is to be submitted to G-cubed and awaits a contribution from our collaborators.
Start Year 2017
 
Description Chinese collaboration 
Organisation Nanjing University of Information Science and Technology (NUIST)
Country China 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Held a visit from two Chinese visitors. who are visiting me for a year from Nanjing University of Information Science & Technology. Dr Yan Feng has returned to China. A publication from his work concerning Chinese records of geomagnetic change has been resubmitted to Physics of the Earth and Planetary Interiors, 13/3/2018. Mr Jiang Yi, after some time in China, has returned to Liverpool for a year as a student working in the team.
Collaborator Contribution Dr. Feng is working on Geomagnetic jerks, now focussing on incorporating a previously unavailable data set from Chinese observatories. This is contributing directly to the aims of the grant. Mr Yi, a student, has been working on examining satellite data for extra information relating to Chinese crustal fields. He is applying for a fellowship to visit next year officially as a student, when he will work directly with the grant. He is also working on merging satellite and aeromagnetic models of Chinese data to better understand other sources of field which act as "noise".
Impact Two papers (one for each visitor) are in preparation
Start Year 2016
 
Title Python tool for geomagnetic data analysis 
Description A new tool for analysis of geomagnetic data to separate sources and remove "noise" from data. Developed in Python to be publicly available. 
Type Of Technology Software 
Year Produced 2018 
Impact Publication and reports detailing application to grant aims is pending. 
 
Description IOP talk, Newcastle 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Talk: Waves in the Core
Presentation to the North East England chapter of the Institute of Physics, entitled
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015