UAS-Methane: An unmanned aerial system for the remote sensing of methane flux

Lead Research Organisation: University of Manchester
Department Name: Earth Atmospheric and Env Sciences

Abstract

The goal of this proof of concept project is to develop and test an integrated new unmanned aerial system (UAS) remote sensing platform for the measurement of 3-dimensional methane concentration fields and emission flux. Our technology approach is to integrate a rotary-hovering UAS with a scanning open-path tuneable-diode-laser absorption spectrometer (TDLAS) and use it to rapidly retrieve time-evolving methane plume concentration fields over local scales (1m to 1 km). A real-time measurement and visualisation of 3D plume advection would facilitate the calculation of hotspot emission flux and serve gas-leak applications - an application relevant to NERC greenhouse-gas source apportionment science with transferability for a range of industries.

There is an urgent technological need to meet this science and impact challenge. National anthropogenic methane inventories and industrial life cycle analyses are at present a best guess of fugitive emissions extrapolated for various component source-types. Natural (biogenic) sources of methane are also poorly characterised by measurement. As agreed at the 21st Conference of the Parties (COP-21) in Paris in 2015, currently estimated anthropogenic methane inventories must now include validation by measurement to meet and monitor ambitious 2050 emissions targets.

UAS-based measurement offers an appropriate technology ripe for development for this purpose. The vertical profiling, manoeuvrability, and viewing geometry of UAS offers unique sampling for local-scale remote sensing applications and site-wide monitoring. This proposal seeks to develop such a capability from concept to prototype and builds on the team's experience in development of UAS for other environmental science applications.

UK expertise and infrastructure in the use of UAS technology for environmental science lags behind an emerging international community that promises to revolutionize understanding of local scale processes across several NERC themes (see Figure 1). We build on our experience in developing and flying in situ UAS measurement systems to develop a new remote sensing UAS TDLAS scanning technology. The project develops a new flux concept and addresses practical challenges in sensor-platform integration. The integration of TDLAS with UAS is commensurate with TRL 3/4 (non-integrated components), while data telemetry and the tomographic inversion algorithms we seek to use to derive flux from concentration measurements are all conceptual (commensurate with TRL 2). We will develop and test this integrated technology to TRL 5/6 criteria (bench test and validation) such that a working prototype platform may be ready for field trial at the conclusion of the project.

To summarise, our concept is to retrieve methane flux by remote sensing on a UAS platform. The technology to address this concept is the development an integrated UAS-TDLAS platform with a scanning gimbal. And the proof required to validate the concept will be a validated dataset, which uses tailored tomographic algorithms to invert concentration measurements for methane flux.

Planned Impact

The new technology and concepts developed will create capacity for new directions in environmental science generally and those with specific interests in the measurement of greenhouse gases (and methane gas). It will add to a nascent national and international academic measurement community using UAS as a sampling platform. But just as importantly, this technology has transferability to a range of industrial and emergency end-users. The UK Fire Service are especially interested in our idea as a potential piece of safety equipment that could allow firemen and women to better determine safety (i.e. methane leak detection and concentration) before entering an area.

We shall ensure wide engagement and open access to our designs and concepts through data servers, websites, academic meetings, workshops and peer-reviewed journal articles. We shall also engage other potential end-users and technological developers through existing strong collaborations. To expedite this, we have already approached (or already work with) a very wide range of stakeholders; and the UK Environment Agency are formal project partners.

We have identified specific stakeholders who have expressed interest in our project. The following have expressed interest in a stakeholder workshop in the final month of our project. These comprise:

Industry: - British Petroleum Plc and other oil and gas facility operators - pipeline leak detection and emissions measurement); Cuadrilla Bowland Ltd - fugitive emissions measurement and air quality monitoring; Viridor Waste Solutions Ltd -required to monitor greenhouse gas fluxes from landfill; The Met Office - for the development of point forecasting tools and science understanding of microclimates.

Regulators and Government: UK public bodies are keen to exploit UAS potential for regulatory monitoring work (see letter of support -UK Environment Agency). Other stakeholders include the Department for Energy - tasked with GHG inventory reporting with regard to emissions targets, and DEFRA - tasked with monitoring and reporting of UK air quality.

Sensor developers: SPEC Inc., Alphasense Ltd, CrowCon Ltd, Focal Point Positioning, UAVE Ltd. Picarro Inc, Los Gatos Research Inc., Aerodyne Inc., Droplet Measurement Technologies Inc. These sensor development collaborators have worked closely with UoM academics in the past to drive sensor design in response to scientific needs and have expressed interest in developing sensors for UAS platforms for the research interests we follow in the School of Earth, Atmospheric and Environmental Science (SEAES).

Emergency Services: the UK Fire Service - interested in methane detection for safety of fire crews entering hazardous areas.

We are in contact with national and international academic partners and instrument developers through other collaborations. Our impact will be fertilised by existing lines of communication and by attendance at international conferences and workshops as this project complements many ongoing NERC projects and strategic programmes, with which we are well-integrated. These include the Greenhouse gAs Uk and Global Emissions (GAUGE) consortium, a large project tasked with the quantification of UK GHG emissions. Dr Allen is a co-PI and WP-lead for airborne measurement within GAUGE and sits on the GAUGE project management board. Co-I Hollingsworth is a partner within the Growing Autonomous Mission Management Applications (GAMMA) programme, funded by the UK Department of Business, Innovation and Skills, and Chair of AIAA's Value-Driven Design Programme Committee.

We expect our open designs to form the springboard for further and rapid development of UAS measurement platforms and drive the further adaptation of sensor technology for a wider range of science applications (beyond atmospheric), where autonomy is a key enabler.

Publications

10 25 50

 
Description We have designed and built a prototype drone (UAV) greenhouse gas measuring platform, which has been used in a validation study to quantify methane fluxes from greenhouse gas hotspots such as landfill sites and fracking sites. This platform and the flux method developed using data from it have been applied to operational settings such as diary farms, fracking sites and landfill sites (see publications associated with the project)
Exploitation Route An innovative and novel local scale GHG flux sampling platform has been developed, which may be used by others for atmospheric sampling and quantification of greenhouse gas emissions from emitting industries or natural emitters (such as wetlands). Flux software and technology/platform could revolutionize greenhouse gas emissions science and understanding at the local scale by allowing targeted sampling and quantification of high carbon emitters, thus allowing targeted policy interventions based on new data.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Electronics,Energy,Government, Democracy and Justice

URL https://www.research.manchester.ac.uk/portal/en/researchers/grant-allen(80dfa34f-09f9-46ed-af8d-7f54979087cd)/publications.html
 
Description This project has involved the UK Environment Agency as partners, as well as UK Environmental consultancy companies looking to roll out the technology and methods for regulatory and industrial monitoring, permit compliance, and measurement work, respectively. It has also been instrumental in monitoring work of the UK's first shale gas site, to quantify methane emissions during flowback.
First Year Of Impact 2019
Sector Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Agriculture, Food and Drink,Environment
Impact Types Policy & public services

 
Description Strategic Programme
Amount £5,000,000 (GBP)
Funding ID NE/N015835/1 
Organisation Natural Environment Research Council 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 04/2016 
End 04/2020
 
Title Unmanned aerial vehicle sampling techniques and flux quantification methods 
Description A paper detailing the sampling techniqies and operational practices has been published. This also describes the flux calcultion algorithm and publishes an example and software for others to follow. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2018 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Several international agencies and academic teams are now utilising the methods described. 
 
Description Environment Agency - UAV GHGs for Landfill flux 
Organisation Environment Agency
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Designed, built and operated a drone for greenhouse gas (CO2 an CH4) sampling in support of regulatory monitoring of GHG flux from UK landfills.
Collaborator Contribution Funding and guidance on development for regulatory uses and commercial roll-out to environmental consultancies.
Impact Allen, G., Pitt, J., Hollingsworth, P., Mead, I., Kabbabe, K., Roberts, G., Percival, C.: Measuring landfill methane emissions using unmanned aerial systems, Environment Agency, ISBN 978-1-84911-367-0, SC140015/R, 2015 Allen, G., Feasibility of aerial measurements of methane emissions from landfills, Environment Agency, ISBN 978-1-84911-329-8, SC130034/R
Start Year 2016