COMPACT: The role of soil management in mitigating catchment flood risk

Lead Research Organisation: Loughborough University
Department Name: Architecture, Building and Civil Eng

Abstract

Flood risk is an increasing challenge in the UK, with 2.4 million properties being susceptible to fluvial flooding. This type of flooding is caused by the quantity of runoff being discharged by a river exceeding the capacity of the river channel. This results in water being transferred to the floodplain, which can have severe economic and social impacts. The quantity and speed of runoff from the landscape into rivers is a major factor in generating flooding. The way in which the landscape is managed therefore can have a significant impact on this process. The intensification of agriculture, through increasing the number of animals in pasture, and the use of larger, heavier machinery for arable farming, over the past 50 years or so is hypothesised to have had an impact on the severity and frequency of flooding. These land management practices cause soil compaction, which reduces the rate of rainfall infiltration and the volume of water that can be stored within the sub-surface. This results in more rainfall being partitioned into the faster surface runoff pathway into rivers and potentially causing flooding downstream.

However, the level of soil compaction is highly heterogeneous over space and time. This is because different animals i.e. cattle, sheep and horses, exert different loads on the soil and are kept at different densities. Furthermore, farm animals are known to exhibit behaviour whereby certain parts of the field are moved over more frequently than others. The same is the case in arable farming practices, whereby ploughing forms tramlines or wheelings, which are more compacted. Different forms of management practice ranging from zero-tillage to conventional cultivation exert different pressures on the soil at different times of year. However, very little is known about this variability of soil compaction levels at the sub-field level and land under different management practices.

This research aims to quantify this sub-field variation in compaction severity and depths through using novel Ground Penetrating Radar (GPR) technology, and assess the impact on the physical soil properties, how water interacts with the soil and ultimately how important this effect is on catchment scale flood risk. This will be achieved through using a multi-methods approach combining field experiments, laboratory tests on soil samples and numerical hydrological modelling. First areas of high and low compaction will be identified using GPR and validated using traditional field based approaches. These will be related to loadings through GPS spatial data on where animals and machinery have moved over. A wide range of field and laboratory tests will then be carried out to quantify properties such as bulk density, porosity, saturated hydraulic conductivity, and particle size. Furthermore, X-Ray CT scanning will reveal the fine scale impacts of compaction on soil structure. This data will form the input to a physically based, reduced complexity, spatially distributed hydrological model, CRUM3. Feasible "what if?" scenarios will be co-produced with the project partners, including the Environment Agency, Trent Rivers Trust, Sustainable Land Trust, Natural England, and National Farmers Union through the Soar Catchment Partnership. This will upscale local changes in land management and soil characteristics to catchment scale flooding.

This research will be undertaken with a group of catchment managers, land owners and local residents. This will both benefit the research scope and impacts of the findings. Recommendations and dissemination for industry, regulators, governmental bodies, charities and local land owners and residents will inform evidence based policy on Natural Flood Management. This will be achieved through steering group meetings, a British Hydrological Society national meeting, Project Away day, end of project riverside picnic, and the use of social media. Dissemination will also occur through more traditional academic routes.

Planned Impact

The vision for the impact of this research project is to engage with land owners and farmers (and their representatives and intermediaries) to increase their appreciation of the water storage and flood mitigation role soil can play, and the effect of different land management practices upon compaction and soil characteristics. Ultimately, this increased knowledge will initiate a change in farmers land management practices to manage localised runoff and catchment scale flood generation.

This will start in the Wreake catchment in Leicestershire, working with the Soar Catchment Partnership (Environment Agency, Natural England, Trent Rivers Trust) and local land owners (Buckminster, Stapleford Estates) (Natural England have shared database on land ownership, and I have already spoken to Tony Reynolds, Julia Hawley, about the research proposed). Representatives from these groups have agreed to sit on a project steering group to co-create the outputs which will be more aligned with being able to meet their needs. Through understanding more about environment policy and how land owners manage their land, the outputs of the research can be more readily applied to the real world problem of flood risk. Local residents and land owners may also benefit through more effective catchment management reducing flood risk and improving other ecosystem services. For example, farmers may benefit if recommendations can be made to reduce sediment erosion from their fields, as soil and nutrients will not be lost and crop yields will be higher for lower economic investment. Engagement meetings throughout the project will ensure partners are kept informed and can feedback on progress. Various forms of dissemination will also be used, including YouTube videos, newsletter (NFU Farmer and Grower) and social media.

The results of this research will also be applicable beyond the local case studied, at the, national and international scales. Nationally, improved knowledge of the mechanistic hydrological processes altered by compaction will inform evidence-based policy, including catchment flood management plans, and river basin management plans. DEFRA, Environment Agency, and Natural England all are relevant beneficiaries of this research and helped develop the initial aims of the proposed research. Flooding is an important environmental challenge for the UK to overcome in the 21st Century, with the Stern Report stating that annual losses could increase from 0.1% GDP to 0.4% GDP by the end of the century. Under economic austerity flood defence budgets have decreased, and therefore building higher flood defences is no longer an option everywhere, especially in low population density areas. This research will provide the evidence base to support the implementation of more natural flood management (which is a focus of the Environment Agency) which is a cheaper, more sustainable approach which complements existing hard engineering assets and river maintenance programmes. At the end of the project, a British Hydrological Society national meeting (usually attended by 50-100 people) will bring together industry and academics to discuss the issues and findings of the research.

Internationally, this research will provide increased knowledge of soil hydrology and the impact of land use on physical properties of soil and how water interacts with it. Much research in this area has been carried out in very different agricultural landscapes to those in the UK, particularly in New Zealand, Australia, USA and Canada. The results produced in this research would form more context specific evidence in the UK, while forming a contrast to other agricultural systems. Dissemination at different disciplinary international conferences (ICSMGE 2018 , WCCM 2018, AGU 2018) to ensure relevant stakeholders and researchers from soil science, materials science and hydrology engage with the findings of this research.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Different Land management practices effect soil compaction to different magnitudes and extents
Soil compaction has great spatial variability both within individual fields and at the catchment scale
This has consequences for runoff pathway generation and potentially flood generation
Exploitation Route Links with Environment Agency and Soar NFM project, which has funded a PhD student to work mon the catchment scale impacts of NFM scheme
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Environment,Government, Democracy and Justice,Other

 
Description Soar NFM DEFRA project
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Membership of a guideline committee
Impact On the technical steering group of the DEFRA funded Soar Natural Flood management Pilot Project. Providing advice on the locations for where NFM will be most effective and the types of interventions
 
Description Making Nature Based Solutions at the Landscape Scale A Reality: An investigation of the barriers and spatial disconnection between NBS Investments and Beneficiaries
Amount £157,000 (GBP)
Organisation Scottish Parliament 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2022 
End 09/2026
 
Description Restoring soil quality through re-integration of leys and sheep into arable rotations
Amount £769,325 (GBP)
Funding ID BB/R021716/1 
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2019 
End 10/2022
 
Description Soar and Swaton Natural Flood Management PhD Studentship
Amount £131,254 (GBP)
Organisation Environment Agency 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 01/2020 
End 12/2022
 
Title Grant Application STFC on GPR and other novel methods for detetcing sub-surface drainage 
Description Sub-surface drainage features such as pipes and compacted layers are unknown. We want to develop novel technology to see if we can map these more continuously over space. 20k pilot project grant application resulting from sandpit. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2020 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact COMPACT tested GPR, which resulted in this subsequent grant application 
 
Title Ground Penetrating Radar for Compaction 
Description Using Ground Penetrating Radar to detect soil compaction. A series of laboratory experiments were undertaken to form better relationship between gpr response and physical soil characteristics 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2018 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact None yet 
 
Description Soar NFM 
Organisation Leicestershire and Rutland Wildlife Trust
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Monitoring impact of NFM intervention on land managed by Trust, Narborough Bogs in Leicestershire
Collaborator Contribution Installed NFM intervention on land, engagement in research project and assisting in data interpretation (downloading data etc)
Impact Early stages of project
Start Year 2019
 
Description Trent Rivers Trust 
Organisation Trent Rivers Trust
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Discussion of field sites with TRT, moved to Soar to reflect their needs. Links to Soar Natural Flood Management DEFRA programme
Collaborator Contribution Co-production of knowledge in grant writing, field site selection, liaising with land owners and discussion of results.
Impact No tangible outputs yet
Start Year 2015
 
Description Workshops with EA, Catchment Managers 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Spatial variations in soil properties identified by project highlighted the importance of where NFM is implemented at different scales.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018,2019