Sudden elephant mortality in the Okavango delta: field investigation and effective monitoring of wildlife health under environmental change

Lead Research Organisation: Queen's University Belfast
Department Name: Sch of Biological Sciences

Abstract

A large and significant mortality event in elephants (Loxodonta africana) has developed in the Okavango Delta in Botswana, with 359 elephants found reported dead to date. Investigations are hampered by the rarity of such an event, remote and inaccessible terrain, lack of local capacity for pathology and laboratory diagnosis, and difficulties accessing international support due to covid-19. Despite laboratory testing, the cause remains unknown. This, and experience from other mortality events in ungulates, suggests that multiple interacting factors might be involved, requiring integrated multidisciplinary investigation. There is an urgent need to instigate this research while evidence remains accessible in the field, and to determine implications for this and other elephant populations. The event further provides an opportunity to better understand die-off events in wildlife, which seem to be increasing in frequency and could be linked to environmental change.

Botswana hosts the world's largest and expanding population of African elephants, which are under severe hunting pressure in surrounding countries. While specific infectious diseases have caused clusters of mortality in African elephants previously, large scale die-offs from disease are highly unusual, and are of concern given their vulnerable conservation status and role as a keystone species ecologically. Elephants are an integral part of the Okavango Delta ecosystem and play a pivotal role in its biodiversity, stability and functioning, such that a significant decrease in elephant numbers may have a detrimental effect on Botswana's economy. Moreover, similar mortality in smaller vulnerable elephant populations elsewhere could have larger consequences for population viability and it is important to work out the cause of the die-offs and the involvement of environmental factors. The emergence of disease in this shared use area is also of great concern for livestock-dependent communities and potentially for public health, given increasing appreciation of the role of pathogen host-switching in driving disease threats in people.

In this project a multidisciplinary team of scientists from Botswana and the UK will work together to undertake urgent field and laboratory investigations while evidence is still available, to determine the cause of the die-off. To help achieve this in such a challenging landscape, we will use advanced molecular biology methods to sample invertebrate (mosquito and tick) vectors, and bioanalysis to detect traces of toxins in environmental samples. Importantly, existing evidence including the location and timing of deaths will be compiled and assessed by an international network of experts to assist the Botswana government in their interpretation. A spatial model will evaluate the relative likelihood of environmental and infectious factors and their interaction. The capacity of partner laboratories in Botswana, and field workers, to investigate future events like this in the globally important Okavango ecosystem will be enhanced by this collaboration and by setting up new analyses there. Government, conservation organisations, local communities and other interested parties in Botswana and internationally will be engaged in the research throughout and come together in a stakeholder forum at the end of the project to discuss outcomes and plan for future responses to wildlife die-offs as well as engaged research in wildlife health in the area using a One Health perspective.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description A climate anomaly consistent with overgrowth of toxic algae was identified that fitted the time and place of the elephant die-off. This supports the hypothesis that toxicity from a harmful algal bloom was the cause of the mortalities. Direct evidence has proven elusive because samples from elephants and the environment at the time of the die-off have not been processed yet and are of doubtful quality after so long in storage. This was due to problems with sample curation and transport, including import-export permissions and logistics of transport. Projections of future likelihood of repeat events is also highly uncertain without this direct evidence. The lack of observed excess mortality from other animal species sharing the environment remains unexplained.
Exploitation Route Samples remain stored and analysis on biobanked samples could lead to relevant additional findings.
Sectors Environment

 
Description Findings were shared with HEI and NGO partners and local communities and provided reassurance that an outbreak transmissible disease was unlikely as a cause of the elephant mortality events. This decreased concern for livestock and human health. It also emphasised the need for participatory research to advance One Health understanding in the delta for benefits of all users of the landscape.
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Environment
Impact Types Societal,Policy & public services

 
Description KCL 
Organisation King's College London
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Provision of disease incidence data
Collaborator Contribution Expert input into climate anomalies linked to harmful algal bloom occurrence, and specific modelling expertise and analysis inputs
Impact None to date as work ongoing Multidisciplinary: KCL bring expertise in harmful algal bloom laboratory and spatial analysis
Start Year 2021
 
Description ORI 
Organisation University of Botswana
Country Botswana 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We worked closely with the University of Botswana Okavango Research Institute on the investigation funded by this award, building on an earlier relationship and extending it into One Health research in the delta. this included visits by our research team and participation in animal disease workshops.
Collaborator Contribution Logistical and scientific support from ORI was crucial to the research under this Urgency Award. ORI vehicles and guides were used for sample collection and ORI were the point of contact with Government of Botswana disease investigation teams. ORI have also assumed responsibility for sample processing, storage and shipment in support of our work.
Impact Outcomes were access to field sites for disease investigation; and expert evaluation of outbreak causation based on hypothesis formation tool.
Start Year 2021
 
Description Disease workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact Wildlife disease workshop including preliminary results sharing and co-production of a strategy for One Health research in the delta area
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022