Evolutionary dynamics of vegetative agriculture in the Ethiopian Highlands: integrating archaeobotanical and genomic science
Lead Research Organisation:
UNIVERSITY COLLEGE LONDON
Department Name: Institute of Archaeology
Abstract
Almost half of food plants are vegetatively propagated including four of the ten most economically important species worldwide. Yet we know very little about vegetative crop history - for example, how long they have been cultivated, and where - because vegetative tissues rarely preserve in the archaeological record. In this project we will develop new methods combining phytoliths (silica microfossils that exist inside most plant cells) with macro-botanical archaeological methods, as well integrating ethnohistoric, genomic and biogeographical information to reveal the evolutionary history of vegetative agriculture in Ethiopia.
Ethiopia is potentially Africa's most important center of crop diversity, characterised by both the evolution and domestication of multiple vegetative species. We will specifically focus on the major food security crop enset, or "Ethiopian false banana" (Ensete ventricosum), a tree-like perennial banana relative. Enset supports some of the densest populations in sub-Saharan Africa and is the staple for 20 million people. It is cultivated over a wide elevational range and ecological gradients, exists at very high biomass densities and has a deep cultural association with multiple ethnic groups. As such enset offers an ideal model for studying long-term adaptation, diversification and interaction with culture.
Our major objective is to test whether vegetative landrace patterning (i.e. the distribution of enset crop diversity) is primarily evolved through:
i) Environmental adaptation - meaning that crop diversity is generated through adaptation to environmental diversity such as cooler and drier locations;
ii) Cultural mechanisms - for example management traditions and variety preferences such as taste, or;
iii) The antiquity of exploitation - in other words, enset could be most diverse where it has been cultivated the longest.
Long-term evidence for enset in agriculture will come from key archaeological sequences, already collected across a series of sites in the Ethiopian Highlands, and being processed by partners in Ethiopia, USA and Germany. But we must refine the methods to interpret these remains by undertaking a comparative study of phytoliths considered against phylogenetic position and potential plasticity due to growth environment. We will complement this with analysis of charred food remains recovered from macrobotanical assemblages using methods developed at UCL.
At Royal Botanic Gardens Kew, we will develop additional lines of evidence using herbarium collections, 50-200 years old, to build a dated phylogenetic tree using DNA data from ~ 900 contemporary landraces. These data will provide new hypotheses to explore archaeologically in terms of the cultural and adaptational history of this crop.
Finally, ethnobotanical fieldwork will document present-day diversity across different cultural regions in the southwestern highlands and the extent to which agricultural and cultural changes in recent decades have altered patterns of local landrace diversity. Accounting for these changes will help us distinguish the influence of introduced crops and the agricultural revolution from long term historical patterns.
This research addresses key issues at the interface of indigenous agrobiodiversity and its role in future resilience to climate change, through better understanding rates of knowledge and landrace loss, as well as drivers of change. The project will create a better understanding of both the past development and future potential of vegeculture from a global perspective. Vegetative species are amongst the least studied 'orphan crops', with major knowledge gaps about their biology, cultivation, processing and domestication. The project will specifically contribute to debates concerning food security and climate change resilience in the Ethiopian highland centre of diversity.
Ethiopia is potentially Africa's most important center of crop diversity, characterised by both the evolution and domestication of multiple vegetative species. We will specifically focus on the major food security crop enset, or "Ethiopian false banana" (Ensete ventricosum), a tree-like perennial banana relative. Enset supports some of the densest populations in sub-Saharan Africa and is the staple for 20 million people. It is cultivated over a wide elevational range and ecological gradients, exists at very high biomass densities and has a deep cultural association with multiple ethnic groups. As such enset offers an ideal model for studying long-term adaptation, diversification and interaction with culture.
Our major objective is to test whether vegetative landrace patterning (i.e. the distribution of enset crop diversity) is primarily evolved through:
i) Environmental adaptation - meaning that crop diversity is generated through adaptation to environmental diversity such as cooler and drier locations;
ii) Cultural mechanisms - for example management traditions and variety preferences such as taste, or;
iii) The antiquity of exploitation - in other words, enset could be most diverse where it has been cultivated the longest.
Long-term evidence for enset in agriculture will come from key archaeological sequences, already collected across a series of sites in the Ethiopian Highlands, and being processed by partners in Ethiopia, USA and Germany. But we must refine the methods to interpret these remains by undertaking a comparative study of phytoliths considered against phylogenetic position and potential plasticity due to growth environment. We will complement this with analysis of charred food remains recovered from macrobotanical assemblages using methods developed at UCL.
At Royal Botanic Gardens Kew, we will develop additional lines of evidence using herbarium collections, 50-200 years old, to build a dated phylogenetic tree using DNA data from ~ 900 contemporary landraces. These data will provide new hypotheses to explore archaeologically in terms of the cultural and adaptational history of this crop.
Finally, ethnobotanical fieldwork will document present-day diversity across different cultural regions in the southwestern highlands and the extent to which agricultural and cultural changes in recent decades have altered patterns of local landrace diversity. Accounting for these changes will help us distinguish the influence of introduced crops and the agricultural revolution from long term historical patterns.
This research addresses key issues at the interface of indigenous agrobiodiversity and its role in future resilience to climate change, through better understanding rates of knowledge and landrace loss, as well as drivers of change. The project will create a better understanding of both the past development and future potential of vegeculture from a global perspective. Vegetative species are amongst the least studied 'orphan crops', with major knowledge gaps about their biology, cultivation, processing and domestication. The project will specifically contribute to debates concerning food security and climate change resilience in the Ethiopian highland centre of diversity.
Organisations
- UNIVERSITY COLLEGE LONDON (Lead Research Organisation)
- Addis Ababa University (Collaboration, Project Partner)
- University of Florida (Project Partner)
- Stony Brook University (Project Partner)
- Goethe University Frankfurt (Project Partner)
- Free University of Brussels (VUB) (Project Partner)
- Addis Ababa College of Natural Sciences (Project Partner)
Publications
Castillo Cobo C
(2024)
Differentiating wild and domesticated enset (Musaceae) using phytolith analysis
Fuller D
(2023)
Plant domestication and agricultural ecologies
in Current Biology
White OW
(2023)
Maintenance and expansion of genetic and trait variation following domestication in a clonal crop.
in Molecular ecology
| Description | We have collected a large amount of ethnographic and oral information on changing values of enset in traditional communities of Southern Ethiopia, which largely indicate declining use as a result of "modernisation" despite clear recognition that enset as a crop is highly reloable and sustainable even under changing and unstable climatic conditions. In archaeological terms we have now documented in detail phytolith production and variability across enset plant parts and plants of different ages. This makes it much easier to find evidence for past use archaeologically, but it also makes it clear that separating wild use from cultivation is not straight forward, because phytoliths vary based on the age of plants and the age of particular leaves, i.e. on different parts of a single plant. This requires a more nuanced, and systematic, approach to collecting reference material. As this species is closely related to banana our results have implications also for the identification of bananas through archaeological phytoliths and call into question some identification claims that did not use such systematic sampling. Genomic analyses are ongoing but currently support a single regional original of cultivars followed by diversification. |
| Exploitation Route | Phytolith research has provided new criteria for identifying enset use in the archaeological record. This is already being applied by colleagues from Germany in other field projects in Ethiopia not connected to this project, and we are expected results of that spin-off application of our research to be presented at the Society of AFricanist Archaeologists (SAFA) conference in summer 2025. |
| Sectors | Agriculture Food and Drink Culture Heritage Museums and Collections |
| URL | https://www.kew.org/read-and-watch/ethnobotanical-insights-enset-ethiopia |
| Description | Our results have already reached an public audience of those interested in plant biodiversity through Kew Gardens public web presence. We have also presented our results in terms of the importance of enset biodiversity to agricultural and food security in Ethiopia to staff fomr the FDCO, in particularly a department concerned with landuse and food security, which may now be taken into account in their planning of development programs/aid in Africa. |
| First Year Of Impact | 2025 |
| Sector | Agriculture, Food and Drink |
| Impact Types | Cultural |
| Description | Fieldwork Collaboration with University of Addis Ababa |
| Organisation | Addis Ababa University |
| Country | Ethiopia |
| Sector | Academic/University |
| PI Contribution | Joint fieldwork- ethnobotanical in Ethiopia |
| Collaborator Contribution | Full collaboration in ethnogtraphic interviews and reference specimen collection |
| Impact | multi-disciplinary field work - Social sciences (ethnobotany) and sciences (botany). Specimens now under analysis in UK (Kew Gardens and UCL) |
| Start Year | 2022 |
| Description | Interdisciplinary approaches to crop diversity conservation and use |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an open day or visit at my research institution |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | National |
| Primary Audience | Policymakers/politicians |
| Results and Impact | Presentation to FCDO (Foreign and Commonwealth Development Office) from the Food Security, Agriculture, Land and Social Protection department visitors to Kew Gardens (for FCDO away day). |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2025 |
| Description | Kew garden read and watch public webpage |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | International |
| Primary Audience | Public/other audiences |
| Results and Impact | This was detailed web summary of our research, especially the ethnobotanical work package, was added to Kew Gardens public outreach pages under kew.org/read-and-watch, which reports research news regularly (about twice a week). This was posted on 24 January 2025. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2025 |
| URL | https://www.kew.org/read-and-watch/ethnobotanical-insights-enset-ethiopia |
| Description | Research seminar and Youtube video |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | Regional |
| Primary Audience | Postgraduate students |
| Results and Impact | We presented out research in the publically advertised UCL Institute of Archaeology seminar series, which was also filmed and posted to the institute Youtube channel. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2024 |
| URL | https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XYYVTkQJOUA |