Particles to Planets: Unravelling the history of our magnetic field
Lead Research Organisation:
University of Liverpool
Department Name: Earth, Ocean and Ecological Sciences
Abstract
The geodynamo is the engine at the heart of our planet generating our protective magnetic field. Today, the geodynamo is powered by the freezing of iron onto the ever-growing solid inner core, but in the past the geodynamo is thought to have been driven by purely thermal energy, just like a pot of boiling water. The switching between these two power sources represents Earth's largest energy transition. When it happened, and what power source kept "the engine running" during the switch is not well constrained. Earth's magnetic field is generated by the geodynamo, so changes in Earth's ancient magnetic field may be the only way to detect this energy transition.
The geodynamo energy transition represents the dying thermal power source and should be marked by a period of extremely weak magnetic field. This weak field can be preserved in rocks because nanoscale magnetic particles found within them lock in memories of the ancient magnetic fields in which they formed. However, over time these magnetic memories fade, but for some particles, their memories fade much faster than we expect, giving rise to false records of the ancient Earth, which appear to be weaker than they really are.
Our best estimate for the geodynamo energy transition is during the Ediacaran, around 550-600 million years ago. Recent studies of this time period have revealed an extremely weak magnetic field, more than ten times weaker the field today, which may indicate a dying thermally driven dynamo just prior to the transition. The results from some of these studies, however, have characteristics that are typical of forgetful magnetic particles. This raises a critical question: Are weak signals from "forgetful" rocks being confused with a weak dynamo undergoing a major energy transition?
To address this, we are using a pioneering new approach to seamlessly integrate the laboratory experiments used to determine ancient field strengths with recent theoretical advances in simulating the behavior of magnetic particles. Taking samples that preserve a weak Ediacaran field, we will decompose them into their constituent magnetic particles. Then, using new micromagnetic models (models that predict magnetic behavior at the molecular level) we will reassemble the samples numerically and simulate their magneto- geological history.
With this approach we will determine if the weak field these samples remember is a faithful memory of the field half a billion years ago and the implications this has for Earth as it experienced a major transition of its internal power. Furthermore, with this new workflow for integrating experimental observations and emergent theory, it will be possible to apply our pioneering techniques to tackle key paleo-, rock and environmental questions spanning a diverse range of disciplines, from tectonics to archeology, or volcanology to the evolution of the Moon, Mars and other planetary bodies.
The geodynamo energy transition represents the dying thermal power source and should be marked by a period of extremely weak magnetic field. This weak field can be preserved in rocks because nanoscale magnetic particles found within them lock in memories of the ancient magnetic fields in which they formed. However, over time these magnetic memories fade, but for some particles, their memories fade much faster than we expect, giving rise to false records of the ancient Earth, which appear to be weaker than they really are.
Our best estimate for the geodynamo energy transition is during the Ediacaran, around 550-600 million years ago. Recent studies of this time period have revealed an extremely weak magnetic field, more than ten times weaker the field today, which may indicate a dying thermally driven dynamo just prior to the transition. The results from some of these studies, however, have characteristics that are typical of forgetful magnetic particles. This raises a critical question: Are weak signals from "forgetful" rocks being confused with a weak dynamo undergoing a major energy transition?
To address this, we are using a pioneering new approach to seamlessly integrate the laboratory experiments used to determine ancient field strengths with recent theoretical advances in simulating the behavior of magnetic particles. Taking samples that preserve a weak Ediacaran field, we will decompose them into their constituent magnetic particles. Then, using new micromagnetic models (models that predict magnetic behavior at the molecular level) we will reassemble the samples numerically and simulate their magneto- geological history.
With this approach we will determine if the weak field these samples remember is a faithful memory of the field half a billion years ago and the implications this has for Earth as it experienced a major transition of its internal power. Furthermore, with this new workflow for integrating experimental observations and emergent theory, it will be possible to apply our pioneering techniques to tackle key paleo-, rock and environmental questions spanning a diverse range of disciplines, from tectonics to archeology, or volcanology to the evolution of the Moon, Mars and other planetary bodies.
Publications
Cych B
(2024)
Magnetic Domain States and Critical Sizes in the Titanomagnetite Series
in Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth
Devienne J
(2023)
Magnetic Recording Stability of Taenite-Containing Meteorites
in Geophysical Research Letters
Devienne J
(2024)
From Disorder to Order: Inheritance of Magnetic Remanence in Tetrataenite-Bearing Meteorites From Multi-Phase Micromagnetic Modeling
in Journal of Geophysical Research: Planets
Donardelli Bellon U
(2024)
Coupling nanoscopic tomography and micromagnetic modelling to assess the stability of geomagnetic recorders
in Communications Earth & Environment
Nagy L
(2024)
Micromagnetic Determination of the FORC Response of Paleomagnetically Significant Magnetite Assemblages
in Geochemistry, Geophysics, Geosystems
| Description | Rocks that record Earth's magnetic field contain magnetic minerals from the titanomagnetite series. The behavior of endmember magnetite is well understood, the remaining compositions have not been extensively studied. We have use numerical models of particle scale magnetism to look at the magnetic configuration (domain state) of the entire titanomagnetite series. This is the first major step towards understanding how these mineral can record magnetic signals and how we can interpret these signal to unravel Earth evolution. Reference: Cych et al. (2024). |
| Exploitation Route | This work can aid in the interpretation of paleomagnetic signals |
| Sectors | Education Environment |
| Description | NSFGEO-NERC: The history of the Earth's magnetic field strength over the last five million years: Filling in the southern hemisphere gap |
| Amount | £148,935 (GBP) |
| Funding ID | NE/Y005686/1 |
| Organisation | Natural Environment Research Council |
| Sector | Public |
| Country | United Kingdom |
| Start | 01/2024 |
| End | 01/2026 |
| Title | Efficiency of thermoremanent magnetization acquisition in vortex-state particle assemblies: Dataset and Codes |
| Description | When magma cools, crystallized magnetic minerals can record the ambient magnetic field. If these mineral grains are sufficiently small, they may retain that magnetic record for billions of years. This phenomenon enables paleomagnetists to study the direction and intensity of ancient magnetic fields on Earth and other planets. A key task is determining the number of magnetic particles required to reliably record such a field, as well as understanding the influence of grain size and shape on this process. Here, we present a dataset from the study titled "Efficiency of Thermoremanent Magnetization Acquisition in Vortex-State Particle Assemblies," which integrates micromagnetic modeling and probabilistic magnetic state partitioning to address these questions. The dataset includes codes for the micromagnetic simulations and data from all the simulations conducted. |
| Type Of Material | Database/Collection of data |
| Year Produced | 2024 |
| Provided To Others? | Yes |
| URL | https://zenodo.org/doi/10.5281/zenodo.14051068 |
| Title | Efficiency of thermoremanent magnetization acquisition in vortex-state particle assemblies: Dataset and Codes |
| Description | When magma cools, crystallized magnetic minerals can record the ambient magnetic field. If these mineral grains are sufficiently small, they may retain that magnetic record for billions of years. This phenomenon enables paleomagnetists to study the direction and intensity of ancient magnetic fields on Earth and other planets. A key task is determining the number of magnetic particles required to reliably record such a field, as well as understanding the influence of grain size and shape on this process. Here, we present a dataset from the study titled "Efficiency of Thermoremanent Magnetization Acquisition in Vortex-State Particle Assemblies," which integrates micromagnetic modeling and probabilistic magnetic state partitioning to address these questions. The dataset includes codes for the micromagnetic simulations and data from all the simulations conducted. |
| Type Of Material | Database/Collection of data |
| Year Produced | 2024 |
| Provided To Others? | Yes |
| URL | https://zenodo.org/doi/10.5281/zenodo.14051069 |
| Title | The magnetic recording stability of vortex state irregularly shaped natural iron oxides: raw data, processing and micromagnetic modelling results |
| Description | Magnetic minerals, especially those existing within the vortex domain state, serve as the primary natural archives of ancient magnetic fields. In this investigation, we introduce an innovative method to examine the magnetic stability of remanence-bearing minerals. This method involves integrating Synchrotron-based Ptychographic X-ray Computed Nano-tomography (PXCT) with micromagnetic modelling. PXCT, a tomographic technique, is a non-destructive resource, which enables its application to valuable (unique) samples. When applied to a microscopic sample of weakly magnetic carbonate rock, PXCT revealed numerous nanoscopic grains of magnetite/maghemite, each exhibiting diverse morphologies, alongside various non-magnetic minerals present in the rock matrix. Subsequently, micromagnetic models were employed to predict the properties of these grains and investigate the potential impacts of irregular morphologies. |
| Type Of Material | Database/Collection of data |
| Year Produced | 2024 |
| Provided To Others? | Yes |
| URL | https://zenodo.org/doi/10.5281/zenodo.10837481 |
| Title | The magnetic recording stability of vortex state irregularly shaped natural iron oxides: raw data, processing and micromagnetic modelling results |
| Description | Magnetic minerals, especially those existing within the vortex domain state, serve as the primary natural archives of ancient magnetic fields. In this investigation, we introduce an innovative method to examine the magnetic stability of remanence-bearing minerals. This method involves integrating Synchrotron-based Ptychographic X-ray Computed Nano-tomography (PXCT) with micromagnetic modelling. PXCT, a tomographic technique, is a non-destructive resource, which enables its application to valuable (unique) samples. When applied to a microscopic sample of weakly magnetic carbonate rock, PXCT revealed numerous nanoscopic grains of magnetite/maghemite, each exhibiting diverse morphologies, alongside various non-magnetic minerals present in the rock matrix. Subsequently, micromagnetic models were employed to predict the properties of these grains and investigate the potential impacts of irregular morphologies. |
| Type Of Material | Database/Collection of data |
| Year Produced | 2024 |
| Provided To Others? | Yes |
| URL | https://zenodo.org/doi/10.5281/zenodo.10837480 |
| Title | Titanomagnetite Size Hysteresis |
| Description | Data and example merrill scripts for the paper Magnetic Domain States and Critical Sizes in the Titanomagnetite Series |
| Type Of Material | Database/Collection of data |
| Year Produced | 2024 |
| Provided To Others? | Yes |
| URL | https://zenodo.org/doi/10.5281/zenodo.10471806 |
| Title | Titanomagnetite Size Hysteresis |
| Description | Data and example merrill scripts for the paper Magnetic Domain States and Critical Sizes in the Titanomagnetite Series |
| Type Of Material | Database/Collection of data |
| Year Produced | 2024 |
| Provided To Others? | Yes |
| URL | https://zenodo.org/doi/10.5281/zenodo.10471805 |
