Once upon a time in a heatwave - exploring the power of stories to engage and empower people in climate change risk and resilience in Northern Ireland

Lead Research Organisation: University of Bristol
Department Name: Geographical Sciences

Abstract

Once upon a time there was a place called Northern Ireland (NI for short). Not too big or too small, it was just right as a test bed for exploring the power of stories for communicating climate science. NI needs better stories about the future urgently, as although there has so far been no local climate legislation, just like (hydrogen) buses there is now two climate bills going through the motions at the same time. Like a sleeping giant, NI desperately needs to start putting some stones in place to build a causeway - a vision - to a resilient future and to reduce the risks of the climate crisis. The right stories and storytelling, developed with people who know their place the best, can provide narratives which could shift behaviour. If researchers can find a way to inspire action through the understanding of the climate risks and adaptation options, they could build connections to other decision makers, researchers and storytellers elsewhere in the land and all live happily (or at least happier) ever after...

Storytelling can connect with people on a deep level and can move seamlessly from facts and emotions, through to values and positive examples of previous action. This connection using narrative, particularly to examples of previous action, is important for providing people with a sense of agency - an ability to enact change. "The stories that we tell ourselves about what climate change means, who is responsible for responding to it, and what this response should look like are just as important as the technologies, laws and policies that will usher in a more sustainable world" (Corner & Clarke, 2017, pp. 5).

In Once upon a time in a heatwave, story will be explored in three ways:
- The use of visual storytelling (through interactive figures, infographics and a local climate impacts checker)
- Narratives based on climate adaptation options (using novel results from the OpenCLIM project that expand upon the UK SSPs, shared through the medium of ArcGIS StoryMaps)
- Storyline climate analysis to communicate uncertainties in extreme summer heat events, such as the 2018 heatwave and drought (again using novel analysis from OpenCLIM and shared as ArcGIS StoryMaps)

Evaluation of the storytelling methods is vital and will be ongoing throughout the project. Stories will be evaluated with a range of audiences, including decision makers, stakeholders and wider priority audiences (expected to be agricultural/rural communities). Evaluation will take the form of surveys on users' preference and perceived ease of use and understanding, as well as a quantified assessment of whether the conclusions drawn by the users are factually accurate.

Through ongoing evaluation and a series of co-production workshops (D4), the final stories (D1, D2 and D3) will be produced iteratively. The stories will be maintained by Climate NI beyond the duration of the project where it is hoped they will influence public and policy opinion in a crucial year for climate action in NI. Although best practices in visual storytelling and the benefits of storyline approaches have been addressed before in the climate and science communication literature, populations vary spatially and temporally. This project will provide recommendations for Northern Ireland, specifically tailored to its unique situation. These recommendations on best practice from the evaluation will be incorporated into Climate NI's communication strategy (D6) and will be submitted to a peer reviewed journal at the end of the project (D7).
 
Title Time Travelling in the Northern Irish Countryside story 
Description A participatory arts-based workshop was held with 8 young people (ages 17-26) in rural/coastal Northern Ireland, prompting them to write short stories relating to their experience and knowledge of the countryside past, present and future, as well as the challenges it faces. These workshops were led by local storyteller Liz Weir, who then combined extracts from all the young people's stories into one narrative. An artistic map and typeset story was then produced by artist and designer Ellie Shipman. 
Type Of Art Creative Writing 
Year Produced 2022 
Impact The story has been shared with the climate research community at the Royal Geographical Society's annual conference, as part of the UK Climate Resilience Programme's webinar series and at internal University of Bristol meetings, where it has challenged assumptions about the role and value of arts in climate research (which is heavily science focussed) and raising interesting questions about eco-anxiety. Feedback from the Education Authority who helped recruit young people highlighted the value in this kind of research: "These young people are very used to a more standard based approach to research ... this was very different to anything they would have been involved with in the past which was hugely beneficial. The emphasis on stories demonstrated why a young person had the view they did on the topic." 
URL https://onceuponatime.blogs.bristol.ac.uk/2022/11/02/time-travelling/
 
Description There are three key findings from the project relating to the project's motivation for exploring the power of stories in communicating climate risk research:
1) The heat walking tour highlighted how creating a narrative through walking and being physically present in a space is a hugely beneficial way to understand issues relating to environmental risk. This event received solely positive feedback (e.g. "Seeing is believing and understanding complexity of the city is so important, you can only get that from getting out") and shows how this kind of activity adds a new layer of understanding beyond reports, maps or even interactive online content and is suitable for a wide range of audiences. The interest from other researchers and policy/professional practitioners to run similar events now also highlights the effectiveness and interest in this method.
2) Rural and agricultural Northern Ireland faces a range of challenges, of which climate is only one. There is good interest in the community (demonstrated by the high rates of attendance at our farm workshops) and farmers reported great value in having time to share ideas and discuss the challenges they face and potential solutions. The workshops allowed a lot of time and space for farmers to tell their stories, share their knowledge and shape the direction of discussion. As a researcher, I learnt so much from the farmers through this method of natural, informal storytelling.
3) The use and value of arts-based methods in climate research was demonstrated. Although of course scientific research is still of huge importance, the arts offer some extra value and personally has had a profound impact on my outlook as a researcher. This work has been included in a UK Climate Resilience Programme Insight Article on the value of the arts in climate research.
Exploitation Route These key findings have been shared on numerous occasions with UK Climate Resilience Programme, who have been very engaged with the project. I hope they can feed this back to UKRI so that future funding decisions allow space for research to explore these key findings alongside traditional scientific research - i.e. for stakeholder engagement to allow workshop time for open discussion and idea sharing between participants and greater two-way discussion with researchers, or for researchers and stakeholders to spend time 'in the field' physically experiencing the environment that they research, or encouraging inter-disciplinary collaborations with the arts.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Environment

 
Description A number of outputs will be used by Climate Northern Ireland in their future stakeholder engagement (for example, the farming workshop format developed was carried on for a further three workshops). Likewise, the heat walking tour was run again for NI Science Festival and there have been further inquiries about this. Furthermore, some key analysis (e.g. figures, headline results, infographics) of climate impacts in Northern Ireland were produced for Climate Northern Ireland for their future use, e.g. in presentations or in evidence reports such as the UK Climate Change Risk Assessment or the Northern Ireland Climate Change Adaptation Programme.
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Environment,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Policy & public services

 
Title Northern Ireland rural heat map app 
Description An app was created that allowed an expansion of the heat mapping carried out by the Met Office for the city of Belfast to cover all of Northern Ireland. This used the Met Office's UKCP18 data at 12km, as opposed to their mapping for Belfast which used 2.2km data. The app allows different thresholds to be set, showing where in the country exceeds these day time and night time thresholds at different levels of global warming. There is also a local postcode checker. 
Type Of Technology Webtool/Application 
Year Produced 2022 
Impact The figures from the app have been used in Climate NI reports and presentations. 
URL https://ukcrp.shinyapps.io/RuralHeatNI/
 
Title Summer heat and agriculture NI app 
Description A multi-page app was built using Shiny, allowing users to explore some of the agricultural impacts associated with summer heat extremes in Northern Ireland. The app includes interactive graphs and post codes checkers so users can find data relevant for a given area. This uses a combination of secondary data for historic heatwave impacts and novel data analysis for the future projections, using the Met Office's UKCP18 data. During the development phase of the app, invited stakeholders from Ulster Farmers' Union and Dale Farm (dairy co-op) provided feedback on the app and shared it with their members. 
Type Of Technology Webtool/Application 
Year Produced 2022 
Impact The app has been used to produce figures and summary statistics for use in Climate NI presentations and reports. Information from it has also been used to stimulate discussion at farmer workshops. 
URL https://ukcrp.shinyapps.io/AgricultureNI/
 
Description Farmer workshops across NI 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Four workshops with 74 attendees were run across Northern Ireland. These focussed on resilience of the agricultural industry to climate impacts and other pressures. The first was organised as part of this award, with a further three organised by Northern Ireland Environment Link following a similar structure. Of the 63 completed feedback forms, 90% rated the event excellent or very good. Findings relating to the priority of challenges and the range of climate impacts being faced across Northern Ireland are being included in an academic paper, currently in prep.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022,2023
 
Description Heat walking tour of Belfast 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact A walking tour highlighting heat risk in the city of Belfast was developed in Summer 2022 and run with a policy audience (e.g. attendees from Belfast City Council, Public Health Agency, Department for Health, Housing Executive). The tour was then re-run twice for NI Science Festival in 2023 with a 'general public' audience, with some attendees coming as the tour related to their undergraduate studies, or it was relevant for their work with third sector organisations. Approximately 25 attended across all 3 tours. Feedback on the tour was positive (7 out of 8 respondents rating it 5*, 1 rating it 4*). Since running the tours, I have received requests for advice and information from a group in Belfast and in London about running similar events, and have had discussions with colleagues about running similar events in Bristol, Newcastle-upon-Tyne and in Essex.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022,2023
URL https://nisciencefestival.com/events/feeling-the-heat-belfast-heat-and-climate-change-walking-tour
 
Description Interview with BBC Radio Ulster 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact Interview carried out with BBC Radio Ulster for the 'Farm Gate' morning news section with Elaine Mitchell, describing the work of the project to develop new apps highlighting climate risks to agriculture in Northern Ireland. However, there was no obvious change in app usage after the interview aired.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Presentation to Climate NI steering group 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact A presentation of the project's main outcomes was given to the Climate Northern Ireland steering group which includes academics, civil servants/policy makers and those in industry. This led to an invitation to give a talk at Ulster University, and follow on meetings with agricultural stakeholders to discuss the climate impacts they face relevant to the project.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Workshop with Castlederg summer school 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact A session was run with the Castlederg summer school in July 2022 (one year on from when the Northern Irish record temperature was broken in the town), exploring how comfortable the young people (aged ~9-13) felt in different temperatures, and discussing ways to keep cool in the heat - including free ice lollies. This was part of a day of semi-structured interviews with care providers in the town of Castlederg, exploring how locals adapt to the temperature extremes.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022