Biodiversity and focal species response-diversity to different management prescriptions following severe windblow caused by Storm Arwen.

Lead Research Organisation: University of Aberdeen
Department Name: Inst of Biological and Environmental Sci

Abstract

Storm Arwen was one of the most powerful and damaging winter storms of the last decade. Forest plantations on the eastern side of the UK have experienced significant damage from Storm Arwen, This offers a short-lived urgent research opportunity to lay the foundations for innovative work on both forest management for biodiversity and climate resilience and fundamental ecosystem processes.
Windthrow is a natural process creating gaps at various scales in natural and production forests by snapping or uprooting, trees in localised pockets or laying over entire stands. The process of decomposition of dead wood a large flush of available nutrients, are immediate and short lived. Tree decomposition then spans decades and can lead to arboreal cavity creation or treefall dens used as nesting sites or shelter by many vertebrates. Sunlight and nutrient inputs to the soil changes and accelerates ground vegetation that may then cascade through entire ecosystems.
Storm Arwen occurred at a time when Forestry England was already investigating new mechanisms to accelerate biodiversity restoration. In particular, developing resilience to expected increases in the frequency of extreme events, new pests and pathogens, and the acute need to increase carbon sequestration. Storm Arwen and the partnership underpinning this Urgency proposal, have catalysed Forestry England to commit to a potentially transformative landscape scale experiment involving the fate of windblown timber and dead wood.

The objectives of this Urgency grant are:
A. To co-design and implement, with Forestry England an experiment conducted at a landscape scale making use of the availability of vast areas with windblown timber to evaluate the long term biodiversity benefits of the following management prescriptions:
- Windblown areas will be harvested, fallen timber recovered, followed by replanting of diversified crop and deciduous tree species (including birch, aspen, spruces, firs, pines).
- Windblown areas will not be harvested, fallen timber left, with replanting (species as above).
- Windblown areas will not be harvested, fallen timber left, without replanting, allowing natural regeneration (non-intervention).
- Non-windblown control areas dominated by Sitka's spruce and Scot's pine.

Because the process of decay will start in spring, we will urgently design and implement a program of field sample collection to provide a crucial baseline. Sampling will be focused on documenting the rates, magnitudes and spatial extents of processes that arise from retaining fallen timber. They include the eventual release of nutrients currently locked in trees, following sequestration by fungi and invertebrates feeding on dissolved organic matter, then uptake by grasses and small bushes leading, over time, to changes in the vertebrate guilds responding to vegetation and structural changes in the forest (the plantations are presently devoid of significant understory higher plants).

Thus, the focus is on quantifying the magnitude and timing of the responses which remain largely unknown for coniferous trees in man-made forest plantations in an Atlantic climate.
Field sampling and analytical methods are largely standard and in use at the University of Aberdeen or long-standing collaborators institutions. They will include measuring precisely the amount of dead and standing wood, the baseline nutrients in wood and in soils, the rate of wood colonisation by fungi and the speed and rates of colonisation of beetles, grasses, shrubs and trees passerine birds and woodpeckers, small mammals (mice, voles, squirrels) and focal vertebrate predators (marten and owls) to dead wood and treatments will all be assayed at the plot-level.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Moyano J (2023) Predicting the impact of invasive trees from different measures of abundance. in Journal of environmental management

 
Description The main objective of this Urgency Grant was to design and establish the baseline for a long-term monitoring scheme to evaluate the impacts of Storm Arwen on Kielder Forest. As such, we report key findings from this baseline fieldwork:

1. In collaboration with Forestry England partners and international forest ecologists, we designed a field monitoring scheme that balances the environmental representativeness of windblown and control sites with accessibility, the risk to field operators, and ease of implementation.
2. Our monitoring scheme comprised 12 windblown and 12 control sites, each including a 100-m transect for fallen timber, three 10x10-m plots to count standing and snapped trees, and three 2x2-m plots for assessing plant richness and cover, and 2-4 bird point counts for estimating bird abundance.
3. Fallen trees were ten times more abundant in windblown (mean and standard deviation: 23.8 ± 9.4 fallen trees/100-metre transect; n=12) than in control sites (2.3 ± 1.9 fallen trees/100-metre transect; n=12). Therefore, Storm Arwen caused a severe disturbance to the system.
4. Likewise, we found that standing trees were more common in control (6.8 ± 4.7 trees per 10x10-m quadrat; n=36) than in windblown sites (2.7 ± 2.3 trees per 10x10-m quadrat; n=36), reinforcing the finding that Storm Arwen was a significant disturbance event.
5. We detected a total of 29 bird species across all sites and, aggregated at the site level (n=24), bird richness was similar in windblown sites (13.2 ± 1.9 species per site) and control sites (12.7 ± 3.5 species per site).
6. Nevertheless, bird richness masks variations in the composition of bird communities. For example, some birds such as the Spotted flycatcher were more common in wind-blown (10 out of 13 sites occupied; 77%) than in control sites (two out of 12 sites occupied; 17%). Therefore, windblown has likely increased the diversity of habitats within Kielder Forest, leading to an increased ß-diversity of birds (i.e., variation in space at a landscape scale).
Exploitation Route the grant supported collection of baseline data. Its main value lies in future use of those baseline data.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Environment

 
Description Forestry England seeks to diversify the ecosystem services (e.g., biodiversity and cultural services alongside production) provided by the lands under their management and increase their resilience against extreme events that are forecasted to increase in the future due to climate change. Storm Arwen caused a severe disturbance at Kielder Forest, which provided a unique opportunity to establish a long-term monitoring scheme to evaluate the benefits to biodiversity afforded by the gaps created by the windblown in the forest and how to increase plantation resilience to these types of extreme events. Over months, we co-designed a sampling scheme together with Forestry England and the input of Aberdeen. The scheme sought to balance the environmental representativeness of windblown and control sites with accessibility, the risk to field operators, and ease of implementation to enhance the monitoring scheme's long-term viability. Based on this design, we conducted the fieldwork to establish the baseline data using 12 pairs of windblown and control sites for comparisons. Data included GIS layers, transects in the forest to estimate fallen timber volume, 10x10-m plots to assess forest structure, 2x2-m quadrats to obtain vegetation cover and plant richness data, and bird point counts to evaluate the response of bird communities to disturbance. The initial objective and vision involved continuing the monitoring scheme into the future, so the evolution of the system can be properly understood to inform management interventions. Unfortunately, we were faced with severe and unanticipated constraints beyond our control that have hampered the viability of this objective. Forestry England planners had to slowly develop the management plans for the windblown and related areas considering multiple competing goals and pressures. It wasn't until July-August that it was apparent that many of the sites initially chosen for surveying were going to be logged or salvaged. This will virtually render them unusable for long-term monitoring, and it was too late to seek alternative sites as the window of opportunity for studying birds and plants had passed. Uncertainty about the fate of the surveyed sites continued and remains unclear today. Accordingly, we decided to stop our fieldwork and surveys as it was too late, and it was impossible to assess whether the remaining sites would provide sufficient statistical power. The impact of this project will depend on the fate of our survey sites, which is unclear at the moment. However, we hope that enough sites will remain sufficiently untouched to provide the basis for a long-term study underpinned by our monitoring scheme and baseline data publicly available through the Environmental Information Data Centre. We are in the process of storing the data with the Environmental Information Data Centre and are engaging with researchers in the UK to analyse the data collected and consider further research proposals.
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink,Environment
Impact Types Societal,Economic

 
Description Collaboration with researchers at Imperial College 
Organisation Imperial College London
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We engaged and collaborated with a research group at Imperial College who were awarded a related Urgency Grant to study the effects of Storm Arwen on soil characteristics in forest plantations. They used our sampling and survey design to guide their own fieldwork and sampling scheme in Kielder.
Collaborator Contribution Contributed ideas, research, and collaboration.
Impact Multi-disciplinary collaboration to understand the multiple dimension of the disturbance caused by Storm Arwen.
Start Year 2022