NSFPLR-NERC: Melting at Thwaites grounding zone and its control on sea level (THWAITES-MELT)

Lead Research Organisation: British Antarctic Survey
Department Name: Science Programmes

Abstract

The fate of the West Antarctic Ice Sheet (WAIS) is one of the largest uncertainty in projections of sea-level rise. Thwaites Glacier (TG) is a primary contributor to sea-level rise and its flow is accelerating. This faster flow is a response to reduced buttressing from its thinning, floating ice shelf, and is ultimately caused by ocean-driven melting. The degree to which costly and geopolitically-challenging sea-level rise will occur therefore hangs to a large extent on ice-ocean interaction beneath Antarctic ice shelves. However, the Thwaites system is not sufficiently well understood, exposing a significant gap in our understanding of WAIS retreat, its ocean-driven forcing, and the consequences for sea level.

The chief regulators of TG's retreat are ice and ocean processes in its grounding zone, where the ice flowing from inland goes afloat. Ice and ocean processes at this precise locale are central to our understanding of marine ice-sheet instability, yet key variables have not been constrained by observation. The problem is compounded because oceanic melt occurs preferentially in the deep, narrow cavity in the grounding zone, where physical descriptions of the processes driving melt are unverified.

These gaps in knowledge are damaging because model projections of TG's future display extreme sensitivity to melting in the grounding zone and how that melting is applied. Equally-credible melt rates and grounding-zone glaciological treatments yield divergent trajectories for the future of West Antarctica, ranging from little change to large-scale ice sheet collapse with a half a meter or more of sea-level rise. The enormous uncertainty in outcome stems from the lack of observations in this critical region.

This project will observe, quantify and model the Thwaites ice-ocean system in the grounding zone, to firmly establish the physics linking ocean forcing and ice-sheet response. The time-dependent cavity will be thoroughly surveyed and instrumented with ocean monitoring devices. Melting will be observed by a network of autonomous sensors and from space over an extended period. The response of the glacier will also be observed. Our enhanced understanding of melting beneath TG's ice shelf, its grounding zone and its connection with the glacier flow will be built into state-of-the-art coupled ice sheet and ocean models. These physics-rich, high-resolution models will allow the potential sea-level contribution of TG to be bounded with unprecedented fidelity.

We propose a suite of integrated activities: (1) multi-year oceanographic time series from beneath TG's ice shelf to quantify melting processes that need inclusion in ocean models, (2) analogous measurements on the glacier to validate processes governing grounding-line retreat, (3) coupling of these in situ measurements with novel, high-resolution space-borne observations, (4) building this new understanding into state-of-the-art ocean and ice sheet models to correctly simulate the TG system, (5) coupling the models and running with realistic present-day ocean forcing to project the state of TG basin over the next hundred years . The international team will consist of experienced marine and glacier scientists using a range of techniques, from the well-established through to the cutting-edge. The outcome of the project will be a thorough understanding of the TG system in the critical zone extending from a few kilometers inland of the grounding line, through the grounding zone, and out under the ice shelf.

Planned Impact

A robust assessment of the consensual view that ocean-glacier interactions at Thwaites Glacier (TG), particularly in the grounding zone, control ice-sheet collapse is of great societal relevance, as are quantified estimates of likely future rates of sea-level rise, and their uncertainties. The project will provide a major improvement in our understanding of near-term TG and WAIS vulnerability to ocean forcing in the grounding zone, and thus to its influence on global sea-level rise. We will fully engage graduate students and postdocs in the effort, affording them the opportunity to participate in data collection, analysis, model development, and data-model synthesis. These early career scientists will develop career-long skills in a number of cross-cutting disciplines in a cooperative international science setting. A vigorous program of media outreach and education will be pursued. We plan to actively engage the international modeling community to use our findings to produce more-realistic simulations of the ocean-glacier interactions of Thwaites, ultimately providing greater confidence in future projections.
 
Description As Thwaites Glacier approaches the ocean, it can be classified into two parts: the main trunk, which is flowing rapidly and transporting the vast majority of the ice into the ocean, and the Eastern ice shelf, which is flowing much more slowly. Both parts are in a state of retreat, in that the grounding line, where the glacier goes afloat, is heading southwards, into the continent. This is happening more quickly in the case of the main trunk, where the rate at which the ocean is melting the ice is thought to be very high. But the eastern ice shelf grounding line is also retreating.

Our observations of the grounding line region of the Eastern Ice Shelf show that the rate of basal melting appears to be surprisingly low, at about 2 meters per year, although in the second year of observations it was nearer 5 m per year, demonstrating significant interannual variation. Our oceanographic observations show us that the low melt rates are a result of very high stratification in the water column near the ice base. That is, there is a layer of relatively fresh and cold water up against the ice base, protecting it from the warmer water below. The water currents are also very weak - our measurements indicate a few centimeters per second - and that the turbulence a few meters beneath the ice is very weak. This explains how the stratification can survive, and the melt rates can remain low.

However, we also discovered the presence of steps in the ice base, so-called terraces. These are produced by melt processes, and have only ever before been seen at large scale, with steps tens of meters in size. Here we see them down to tens of centimeters in size. This shows that they are likely to be much more pervasive than first thought, and are likely to play a much bigger role in ice shelf-ocean interactions than we have assumed so far. Data we have recovered using ApRES (a deployed, precise, downward-looking radar) shows that the melt-driven lateral speed of one of the steps (the 5-10 m jump between terraces) is about ten times faster than the vertical melt rate of the terraces. This is broadly in line with observations made beneath Petermann Gletcher - an ice shelf in north Greenland.
Exploitation Route The outcomes of the study will take the form primarily of publications, so that others can formulate programmes of activity based on new understanding gained.

The project as a whole has as a key output a strategy that will enable models of ice shelf-ocean interaction to diagnose more accurately the melt rate in the grounding zones of ice shelves. This output will become available in due course.
Sectors Environment

 
Title Borehole transponder 
Description An RF transponder has been developed to be deployed within an ice column, via a borehole, which can be tracked using specially-modified ApRES instruments at the ice surface. This technique has the potential to indicate the integrated vertical shear from the surface to the depth of the transponder. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2020 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact None yet, as the transponder has been deployed too recently. 
 
Title Wireless monitoring of ice borehole properties 
Description The classification of the type of research tool or method is inappropriate as offered choice relates only to biological sciences. The tool is designed to measure propertie4s of an ice borehole at discrete points along its length. Specifically, temperature, pressure (for an instrument at the bed) and tilt. For tilt, there is a compass and tilt meter. A problem with deploying instruments through deep boreholes is the cost and weight of the cable used to communicate with the instruments when they are frozen into the ice. Use of wireless communications means that the instruments can be lowered on a lightweight rope. The additional disadvantage of the cabled option is that the risk of strong vertical strain rates damaging the cable can be significant. Again, the wireless option removes that as a problem. The instruments that we have designed communicate over a two-way link, using the license-free band at 433MHz. As the link is two-way, and as the instruments themselves are intelligent, in their behaviour can be modified over an Iridium link from the UK. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2020 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact None yet. The instruments have been deployed too recently. 
 
Title Phase-sensitive radar (ApRES) time series data from Thwaites eastern ice shelf, 2020 
Description The dataset comprises ApRES (Autonomous phase-sensitive Radio Echo Sounder) time series from four sites (G1-4) through the grounding zone of the eastern Thwaites ice shelf. The instruments were deployed in early 2020 and recovered in early 2021 as part of the International Thwaites Glacier Collaboration (ITGC) MELT project. The aim was to provide time series of basal melt rates and the vertical strain rate at each site. The ApRES DAT files were converted to netCDF for publication. Each burst in an ApRES file maps straightforwardly to a group in the corresponding netCDF file. This is a lossless, reversible process. The data were acquired under funding from ITGC: NE/S006656/1. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? Yes  
URL https://data.bas.ac.uk/full-record.php?id=GB/NERC/BAS/PDC/01641
 
Description Email interview with Vivian Lammerse for Scientias.nl 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Email interview to allow them to write an article for their science news website
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://www.scientias.nl/wetenschappers-krijgen-verbluffend-inkijkje-diep-onder-antarcticas-meest-wa...
 
Description Interview for Washington Post 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Interview with Chris Mooney, Washington Post
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://www.washingtonpost.com/climate-environment/2020/01/30/unprecedented-data-confirm-that-antarc...
 
Description Interview with Joe McCarthy for Weather.com, resulting in an article on the site 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact The article was about the Thwaites programme, specifically from the point of view of the PIs.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://features.weather.com/exodus/chapter/principal-investigators/
 
Description Interview with Sara Moraca for Corriere della sera 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Interview for Italian newspaper article.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020