Sensitivity of post-storm surge dune recovery to geomorphological variability

Lead Research Organisation: Loughborough University
Department Name: Geography

Abstract

On 5th December 2013 the UK coastline was exposed to one of the biggest storm surges on record. In the past 60 years only two storms have been of comparable size. In 1953, water levels reached 5.6 m above Ordnance Datum (ODN), in 1974 they reached 4.7 m ODN and the 2013 storm reached 5.8 m ODN. The latter caused substantial erosion of dunes and beaches. As this is such an unusual event, there have been few opportunities for scientists to study how rapidly damaged sand dunes can recover following a storm of this magnitude. It would be interesting to know because dunes play an important role in coastal defence, forming a barrier to inland flooding and dissipating storm energy so reducing risk to lives and damage to infrastructure.

Planners have to decide how best to manage the coastline not only under present conditions, but also thinking ahead to what the environment might be like in future. Future climate change scenarios for the UK suggest sea level will rise at 4 mm per year rising to over 12 mm per year after 2055. At the same time, it is predicted that the frequency and severity of coastal storm surges will increase, and that storminess will have an important impact on coastal geomorphology. This research will study how quickly, and under what conditions, coastal dunes can recover their shape, ecological and defence functions following erosion by a storm event. It is exciting because we rarely get the opportunity to study the aftermath of large storm events around the UK, and we will be able to collect data that coastal planners can use to make better decisions about coastal defences.

Studies of the impacts of large storms on dunes suggest the shape of the dunes before the storm plays a key role affecting how severe the storm erosion is, and also how rapidly the dunes are rebuilt by wind-blown sediments. What has not been studied is how quickly dunes on a seaward-advancing (prograding) coast recover. This is a major gap in our knowledge given this type of coastline accounts for 30% of dune-backed beaches in England and Wales. It is also unclear how variability in the direction from which sand-transporting winds blow affects the rate of dune recovery. Although dunes are normally associated with strong onshore winds that blow sand from the beach to the dunes, research has shown that winds blowing offshore can also contribute to dune-building; the extent to which this occurs depends on the shape of the sand dune which can cause airflow to change direction.

Given the above, the fieldwork for this project will focus on three sites each of which had different pre-storm dune heights (from 5 to 8 m high) and slope gradients, and each of which was severely eroded by the December 2013 storm. The sites are located on the Lincolnshire coast which is advancing seawards at about 2 m per year, and which has seasonal winds blowing onshore, offshore and alongshore. By measuring the two- and three-dimensional shape of the dunes every two weeks at each site we can see how they change following the storm. We will also use data on wind speed and direction to work out patterns of wind-blown sediment transport between each set of topographic measurements. The measurements will be taken regularly for 12 months. We visited the field sites immediately after the December 2013 storm and then again two weeks later. During this time there was a prolonged period of very strong offshore winds, however even during this short time, the dunes at one site increased in volume by 3.21 m3.

The data we collect for this project will provide detail concerning post-storm dune recovery. Ideally we would also conduct continuous measurements of wind speed, wind direction and sediment transport at the site, but that is not possible given resource constraints. Instead, once we have collected the topographic data, we will seek additional support to use this data for three-dimensional modelling of airflow and sediment transport over the dunes.

Planned Impact

Dunes are a common feature of sandy coasts and occur worldwide. They play an important role in maritime nation's coastal defences as they are a barrier to inland flooding and dissipate storm energy reducing risk to lives and damage to infrastructure. An improved understanding of dune response to several storm erosion, and their subsequent recovery is therefore potentially valuable for planning coastal defence strategies and shoreline management.

This research project will quantify the rate of coastal dune recovery following one of the biggest storm surges in the UK historical record. The data will show how dune shape changes under the influence of winds from different directions and at different speeds as a result of the patterns of erosion and deposition of sediment across the dune. In the UK, where the study sites are located, 30% of dune frontages are prograding but these dunes are rarely studied. The results of this research will be of interest to:

- coastal managers and those involved in developing Shoreline Management Plans who are seeking to understand and better predict the potential impacts of storms on coastal dune systems.
- coastal planners and restorers who are considering using artificial dunes as a means of coastal defence
- the general public including those with an interest in landscape, ecology and students learning about coastal dune dynamics.

The Pathways to Impact document outlines our current involvement with Natural England and proposed involvement with The Lincolnshire Wildlife Trust to disseminate the results and help to educate people about coastal dynamics.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The rate of dune recovery immediately post-storm (1-2 years) is more rapid than the long-term average rate of recovery (over past 100 years) but the geomorphology of the recovered dunes differs from that preceding the storm.

Terrestrial laser scanning and SfM are useful tools for monitoring beach-dune recovery following storms.
Exploitation Route Data set has been lodged in data repository (NGDC) and could be used as part of long term monitoring of east coast geomorphological dynamics.
Sectors Environment

 
Description Enterprise Small Award
Amount £250 (GBP)
Organisation Loughborough University 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom of Great Britain & Northern Ireland (UK)
Start 05/2014 
End 06/2014
 
Title LincStorm Dataset 
Description The dataset contains on-average monthly terrestrial LiDAR surveys conducted on the Lincolnshire coastline following the 2013 storm surge, collected between December 2013 and April 2015. The approximate coordinate locations of the surveys are given as follows: -EmbryoDunes (ED) 53°22'03"N 0°14'54"E -MablethorpeNorthEnd (MNE) 53°21'43"N 0°15'03"E The data were collected to record the rate and nature of recovery of the geomorphology of the back-beach and foredune zones following a storm surge in December 2013. Users interested in nearshore coastal geomorphology dynamics will find the data useful. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2018 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Data are in NGDC and embargoed until end 2017. 
 
Description BBC Inside Science Radio Programme 22 May 2014 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact 9 minute 'article' within the BBC Radio 4 Inside Science Programme

None
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
URL http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b043xqcq
 
Description NERC Planet Earth Podcast 10 June 2014: Storm surges and their effect on coastal sand dunes 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact Podcast for Planet Earth (NERC)

The BBC asked us to do a radio interview for Inside Science
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
URL http://planetearth.nerc.ac.uk/multimedia/story.aspx?id=1697
 
Description Report to SANDS user conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact 30 people attended a user workshop for the software SANDs developed by Halcrow for handling coastal management data. Feedback from this project and the other participants will be used to refine and further develop the software.

Made contact with coastal management organisations many of which requested copies of grant summary report when it is completed.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014