The Multi-float WaveSub Wave Energy Converter
Lead Research Organisation:
University of Bath
Department Name: Mechanical Engineering
Abstract
Marine Power Systems (MPS) WaveSub Wave Energy Converter (WEC) addresses the energy trilemma by providing sustainable, cost effective, low carbon renewable energy by capturing the sub-surface orbital energy nature of waves. The patented device is tuneable to all sea states through a unique single / multi float power take-off system. Securing over £3M in grants and £2M in private investment, MPS has completed extensive testing of the single float WaveSub WEC at 1:30 scale, validating the computational simulations of power generation. MPS is currently embarking on the fabrication of a 1:4 scale WaveSub, with testing at FaBTest in 2016 / 2017. Initial techno-economic modelling using Carbon Trust Levelised Cost of Energy (LCOE) methodology shows WaveSub delivering a LCOE lower than existing WEC devices and competitive with conventional generation, with transition from single float (1.5MW) to multi-float (Multi-MW) device.
This 12 month project with MPS and University of Bath (UoB) delivers the modelling, design, manufacture, test & validation of a 1:30 scale multi-float WaveSub device, with outputs informing the LCOE model that will unlock WaveSub's true commercial potential. Within the project, UoB will design and build the Power Take Off system for the multi-float device. Building on previous experience from a 1:30th scale single float device, the PTO for the multi-float concept will consist of multiple independently controlled electro-mechanical units designed in conjunction with other WaveSub systems (e.g. winching) for proper integration. The independent control of the units will provide the greatest flexibility for exploring
different operational regimes. The unit will be controlled in real time and will allow motion, power capture and loading measurements. A range of control schemes will be implemented in order to validate numerical models and to evaluate whole system performance in all conditions. This could include linear damping, adaptive damping, and advanced nonlinear
schemes such as latching and declutching control.
This 12 month project with MPS and University of Bath (UoB) delivers the modelling, design, manufacture, test & validation of a 1:30 scale multi-float WaveSub device, with outputs informing the LCOE model that will unlock WaveSub's true commercial potential. Within the project, UoB will design and build the Power Take Off system for the multi-float device. Building on previous experience from a 1:30th scale single float device, the PTO for the multi-float concept will consist of multiple independently controlled electro-mechanical units designed in conjunction with other WaveSub systems (e.g. winching) for proper integration. The independent control of the units will provide the greatest flexibility for exploring
different operational regimes. The unit will be controlled in real time and will allow motion, power capture and loading measurements. A range of control schemes will be implemented in order to validate numerical models and to evaluate whole system performance in all conditions. This could include linear damping, adaptive damping, and advanced nonlinear
schemes such as latching and declutching control.
Planned Impact
National perspective:
The project objectives directly address all three aspects of the energy trilemma:
1) Reducing emissions - The project resides within the Renewable Energy technology challenge area, contributing to the 2020 and 2050 UK emissions targets.
2) Improving security of supply - Wave-energy is a reliable, predictable renewable source with high energy density. The World Energy Council estimates that wave generated power could deliver 2,000 TWh/year, but this will not happen until the technology achieves large reductions in £/W. With 15% of the 2020 estimated 85GW UK requirement to be delivered by renewable sources, this project directly tackles the security of supply issue.
3) Reducing cost - Initial techno-economic modelling using Carbon Trust Levelised Cost of Energy (LCOE) methodology shows WaveSub delivering a LCOE lower than existing WEC devices as a single-float and competitive with conventional generation as a multi-float device.
International perspective:
MPS expects to be 1 of 5 successful global Wave Energy Converter companies, with sales exported internationally from the UK.
Economic:
Multi-float project provides crucial LCOE evidence to unlock investment for next-stage full scale Demonstrator (c2018) and secures pathway to commercialisation (c2020). On full commercialisation, UK PLC and international export sales are £500m+ after 5 years.
Social:
WaveSub manufacturing supply chains will create c1000 UK jobs after 5 years of commercialisation, with up-skilling and high value jobs created in coastal areas subject to traditional maritime industries recline, thus creating wealth and sustaining communities. WaveSub devices can be transported over large distances at sea from a single coastal manufacturing base. In addition, the project supports and promotes renewables research at UoB and future undergraduate and PhD research across the UK.
Environmental:
WaveSub helps to unlock the UK's abundant wave energy resource (best in EU), with emissions reduced through displacement of high carbon energy generation. Using DECC's Impact Assessment, annual CO2e savings to UK from WaveSub sales are 250,000t with after 5 years of commercialisation with 215MW installed.
Commercial Private Sector:
The research will result in more efficient designs and reduced development time. It will accelerate the large scale deployment of wave energy devices and the expansion of the emerging wave energy sector, providing employment and associated economic benefits.
The project objectives directly address all three aspects of the energy trilemma:
1) Reducing emissions - The project resides within the Renewable Energy technology challenge area, contributing to the 2020 and 2050 UK emissions targets.
2) Improving security of supply - Wave-energy is a reliable, predictable renewable source with high energy density. The World Energy Council estimates that wave generated power could deliver 2,000 TWh/year, but this will not happen until the technology achieves large reductions in £/W. With 15% of the 2020 estimated 85GW UK requirement to be delivered by renewable sources, this project directly tackles the security of supply issue.
3) Reducing cost - Initial techno-economic modelling using Carbon Trust Levelised Cost of Energy (LCOE) methodology shows WaveSub delivering a LCOE lower than existing WEC devices as a single-float and competitive with conventional generation as a multi-float device.
International perspective:
MPS expects to be 1 of 5 successful global Wave Energy Converter companies, with sales exported internationally from the UK.
Economic:
Multi-float project provides crucial LCOE evidence to unlock investment for next-stage full scale Demonstrator (c2018) and secures pathway to commercialisation (c2020). On full commercialisation, UK PLC and international export sales are £500m+ after 5 years.
Social:
WaveSub manufacturing supply chains will create c1000 UK jobs after 5 years of commercialisation, with up-skilling and high value jobs created in coastal areas subject to traditional maritime industries recline, thus creating wealth and sustaining communities. WaveSub devices can be transported over large distances at sea from a single coastal manufacturing base. In addition, the project supports and promotes renewables research at UoB and future undergraduate and PhD research across the UK.
Environmental:
WaveSub helps to unlock the UK's abundant wave energy resource (best in EU), with emissions reduced through displacement of high carbon energy generation. Using DECC's Impact Assessment, annual CO2e savings to UK from WaveSub sales are 250,000t with after 5 years of commercialisation with 215MW installed.
Commercial Private Sector:
The research will result in more efficient designs and reduced development time. It will accelerate the large scale deployment of wave energy devices and the expansion of the emerging wave energy sector, providing employment and associated economic benefits.
Organisations
Publications
E. Faraggiana
(2020)
Computational modelling and experimental tank testing of the multi float WaveSub under regular wave forcing
in Renewable Energy
Faraggiana E
(2020)
Computational modelling and experimental tank testing of the multi float WaveSub under regular wave forcing
in Renewable Energy
Hillis A
(2021)
Wave energy converter platform stabilisation and mooring load reduction through power take-off control
in IET Renewable Power Generation
Hillis A
(2020)
Real-time wave excitation force estimation for an experimental multi-DOF WEC
in Ocean Engineering
Hillis A
(2020)
Active control for multi-degree-of-freedom wave energy converters with load limiting
in Renewable Energy
Hillis A
(2020)
Model predictive control of a multi-degree-of-freedom wave energy converter with model mismatch and prediction errors
in Ocean Engineering
Description | The project required the development of a highly complex power takeoff and control system. Because of the complexity of the device a large number of sensors and actuators was required. Additionally very low friction and very precise control were required for the validation of numerical models. This was highly challenging but has led to a number of important findings relating to the performance of a multi-float device. As a result of this the multi-float platform is being explored for full scale deployment as a commercial possibility. Furthermore the experimental scaled PTO system will be utilised in 2018 to explore the potential for advanced control systems that have already been studied in simulation exercises. |
Exploitation Route | The control techniques developed as a result of this work and the ongoing collaboration are not specific to a particular device and could potentially significantly reduce the cost of energy for a wide range of wave energy converters, bringing wave energy closer to commercial reality. |
Sectors | Energy Environment |
Description | The project was highly successful and demonstrated potential cost savings compared to other Wave Energy Converters and alternative renewable energy sources at grid scale. The findings validated numerical models which are key to rapid and cost-effective design of full scale systems. The outcomes have unlocked further investment and informed the design of multi-Megawat wave and new combined wind-wave platforms which are to be deployed at multiple grid connected test sites. If successful these tests will lead to commercial deployment with associated societal and environmental impacts (e.g. up-skilling and high value jobs created in coastal areas subject to traditional maritime industries recline, thus creating wealth and sustaining communities, CO2e savings, international exports). The project has also led to new advanced control methods aimed at achieving an optimal balance between power capture and fatigue lifetime to maximise economic return. These are being developed not just for Wave Energy Converters, but for all forms of renewable energy. |
First Year Of Impact | 2020 |
Sector | Energy |
Impact Types | Societal Economic |
Description | Adaptive Control of the WaveSub WEC using a Romax Electromechanical PTO |
Amount | £41,850 (GBP) |
Organisation | Wave Energy Scotland |
Sector | Private |
Country | United Kingdom |
Start | 09/2017 |
End | 01/2018 |
Description | 20th World Congress of the International-Federation-of-Automatic-Control (IFAC) |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
Results and Impact | Presentation of research at the 20th World Congress of the International-Federation-of-Automatic-Control (IFAC) in Toulouse, France. The purpose was to convey the latest findings to academic peers and industrial end users. Discussion continued following the session and potential new collaborations have been initiated, but not yet formalised. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2017 |
URL | https://www.ifac2017.org/ |
Description | Presentation at EWTEC2017 |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
Results and Impact | Presentation at the 12th European Wave and Tidal Energy Conference 2017 in Cork, Ireland. The purpose was to convey the latest research findings to academic peers and industrial end users. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2017 |
URL | http://www.ewtec.org/ewtec-2017/ |
Description | Press release |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Public/other audiences |
Results and Impact | Press release describing scaled tank testing at the Plymouth COAST lab. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2016 |
URL | https://subseaworldnews.com/2016/08/04/mps-completes-scaled-tank-testing-of-wavesub/ |
Description | Wave Energy Scotland Annual conference 2017 |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
Results and Impact | Poster presentation of ongoing research work at 2nd Annual Wave Energy Scotland Conference, 28th November 2017 in Edinburgh. Provided opportunities to discuss the work with technology developers and policy makers. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2017 |
URL | http://www.waveenergyscotland.co.uk/ |