Decolonising UK Earth Science pedagogy - from the hidden histories of our geological institutions to inclusive curricula
Lead Research Organisation:
University of Hull
Abstract
The dominance of western Earth Sciences (i.e. geology and geosciences) discourses continues to (re)appropriate the contributions of the 'Other-indigenous' populations. At the end of the 18th century rocks, minerals and ores were considered part of the broad domain of natural history. Geology's status as a discrete academic activity remained underdeveloped but became fashionable as a scientific pursuit amongst European elite classes. Geology as an academic discipline emerged as a specialised branch of science by the colonial state, as a distinct scientific and exploitative discipline. The foundations of the discipline, and the institutions that arose during this time, benefitted from and perpetuated resource extraction, knowledge extraction and was an essential tool for Imperial expansion.
The historical utilitarian identity of geology over the years remains and reinforces an ongoing bias for the subject. The narrative of geology is one that is still a science for extraction - of mineral resources, of rare fossil specimens, of data and knowledge. This is amply demonstrated in the prioritisation of practice, production, and profit across all its reports. While detailing extraction processes, documenting quality of products, and describing the search for new deposits, and other geological phenomena (e.g. fossils) what remains absent from the discourse is the contribution of nameless and more importantly faceless individuals who were the key interlocutors and explorers in this Imperial enterprise. A look at the documents and reports to promote geological education reinforces this airbrushing of engagement of local or indigenous participants and their knowledge.
This form continues even today. The colonial legacy of Earth Science is not known or understood by many practitioners of the discipline today - that we cannot study colonialism without geology, nor geology without colonialism. The influence of this hidden history on university curricula adds to the perception (and reality) of Earth Science as a white, western dominated subject and enhances the hostile environment often cited for the continuing lack of diversity in the discipline. Thus, tackling these two key issues are essential for improving the diversity of those entering and being retained within Earth Science education, research and work.
This project aims to work towards resolving these issues by (1) collaboratively exploring the unrecognised knowledge upon which the foundational institutions of Earth Science is built and how this legacy creates modern day inequity in our discipline and (2) to begin dismantling this inequity by taking a decolonising Earth Science pedagogy and curriculum approach. We partner with the British Geological Survey, the Geological Society of London, the Royal Geographical Society - IBG, and include representatives from Diversity in Geoscience-UK and Black in Geoscience in order to co-create knowledge and resources to drive sector-wide change. Our interdisciplinary team comprises expertise from history, geology, geography, pedagogy and historical geography. We are a team that also is gender diverse and centres two early career researchers from historically excluded groups, who have intersectional identities. The project will train these ECR in new skills and support their career development.
The historical utilitarian identity of geology over the years remains and reinforces an ongoing bias for the subject. The narrative of geology is one that is still a science for extraction - of mineral resources, of rare fossil specimens, of data and knowledge. This is amply demonstrated in the prioritisation of practice, production, and profit across all its reports. While detailing extraction processes, documenting quality of products, and describing the search for new deposits, and other geological phenomena (e.g. fossils) what remains absent from the discourse is the contribution of nameless and more importantly faceless individuals who were the key interlocutors and explorers in this Imperial enterprise. A look at the documents and reports to promote geological education reinforces this airbrushing of engagement of local or indigenous participants and their knowledge.
This form continues even today. The colonial legacy of Earth Science is not known or understood by many practitioners of the discipline today - that we cannot study colonialism without geology, nor geology without colonialism. The influence of this hidden history on university curricula adds to the perception (and reality) of Earth Science as a white, western dominated subject and enhances the hostile environment often cited for the continuing lack of diversity in the discipline. Thus, tackling these two key issues are essential for improving the diversity of those entering and being retained within Earth Science education, research and work.
This project aims to work towards resolving these issues by (1) collaboratively exploring the unrecognised knowledge upon which the foundational institutions of Earth Science is built and how this legacy creates modern day inequity in our discipline and (2) to begin dismantling this inequity by taking a decolonising Earth Science pedagogy and curriculum approach. We partner with the British Geological Survey, the Geological Society of London, the Royal Geographical Society - IBG, and include representatives from Diversity in Geoscience-UK and Black in Geoscience in order to co-create knowledge and resources to drive sector-wide change. Our interdisciplinary team comprises expertise from history, geology, geography, pedagogy and historical geography. We are a team that also is gender diverse and centres two early career researchers from historically excluded groups, who have intersectional identities. The project will train these ECR in new skills and support their career development.
Publications


Rogers S
(2022)
Geology uprooted! Decolonising the curriculum for geologists
in Geoscience Communication
Description | Extension of Decolonising UK Earth Science Pedagogy |
Organisation | British Geological Survey |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | To work specifically on work revealing the hidden histories of the BGS and provide infographics on decolonising the BGS. |
Collaborator Contribution | n/a |
Impact | n/a |
Start Year | 2023 |
Description | Talk for the Lapworth Museum |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A talk or presentation |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | Local |
Primary Audience | Third sector organisations |
Results and Impact | Title: Hidden Histories in the Lapworth Archive Date: Thursday 26th January Location: The Lapworth Museum of Geology, University of Birmingham |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
Description | Wilberforce Institute Blog |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | National |
Primary Audience | Other audiences |
Results and Impact | Telling Stories of the Hidden Colonial Histories of Our Geological Institutions published on Wilberforce Institute at the University of Hull blog site |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2022 |
URL | https://wilberforceinstitute.uk/2022/10/20/telling-stories-of-the-hidden-colonial-histories-of-our-g... |