How do light and temperature affect lifecycle, development and pathogenicity in Verticillium?

Lead Research Organisation: National Institute of Agricultural Botany
Department Name: Centre for Research

Abstract

Soil-borne, broad host range vascular pathogens that exist on both weed and crop species, such as Verticillium dahliae, are a significant challenge to crop production across the world. The banning of soil fumigants such as methylbromide and the limited use and impending withdrawal of current actives, such as chloropicrin mean that control measures are now extremely limited. In this proposal we aim to use bioinformatic and experimental approaches to understand the lifecycle of the pathogen and regulation by environmental cues such as light, temperature and location within the host, with the intention of using the outcomes to develop new understanding which may lead to novel control measures. Our research seeks to answer three fundamental questions: First, how are key developmental processes such as coniditation and microsclerotial formation controlled; these are the mechanisms by which the pathogen can disperse and survive in the soil? Second, how does disruption of light-regulation of gene expression affect pathogenicity and lifecycle of V. dahliae in planta? Third, how and why is circadian clock-like behaviour not observed in V. dahliae (from our preliminary data) despite the conservation of all major clock components and the major role of the clock in the lifecycle of related Sordariomycete fungi such as Neurospora crassa? To address these questions, we will draw on a body of resources and techniques and strains we have developed over the past three years. These include a suite of rapid pathogenicity tests, whole genome, structurally resolved genome sequences of Verticillium for a number of highly pathogenic V. dahliae strains, a series of gene knockout lines for major clock components and RNAseq gene expression timecourse data. We will address how key developmental processes are controlled by carrying out a detailed timecourse of gene expression after a light pulse and subsequent analysis of transcription factor binding sites in differentially regulated genes. The same experiment will be carried out in response to a temperature pulse in the wildtype and other knockout lines and comparisons will be made to identify regulatory pathways involved in light and temperature signalling to address how how evolutionarily derived phenotypes, such as microsclerotial production have been 'wired into' existing signalling networks. Using single and multiple gene knockout strains we will then explore how the known and other novel temperature responsive transcription factors, affect lifecycle stages and pathogenicity in planta. We will carry out infection tests and gene expression analysis of mutants in planta to determine the effect upon effector expression and life cycle changes during infection, using confocal microscopy of fluorescently labelled V.dahliae, to compare developmental stages of the pathogen within the plant. We will also attempt to disrupt the pathogen's lifecycle in both strawberry and raspberry plants using host-induced gene silencing of a crucial developmental, light regulated gene. We will then address the fundamental question of whether the clock has been lost in Verticillium and the implications on adaptive fitness? We will test whether rhythmic oscillation has been lost due to promoter binding site evolution in the gene frq and whether oscillation can be restored to V. dahliae through promoter swap luciferase readout experiments. Taken together this work will provide fundamental insights into how pathogenic fungi respond to environmental cues within the host and how advantageous traits (such as resting body production) are regulated by genes implicated in circadian clock function in other related model fungi.

Technical Summary

The project seeks to understand how the fungal pathogen Verticillium dahliae (Vd) responds to environmental signals such as light and temperature using knowledge gained through study of the model fungus Neurospora crassa. The molecular components that have been described as playing a central role in the circadian clock in Nc appear to be key to light and temperature signalling in Vd. The combination of RNAseq in fluctuating environmental conditions over time in wild type and mutant backgrounds along with bioinformatic prediction of co-regulated gene sets with common promoter motifs, will be used to generate hypotheses about the regulatory pathways controlling conidiation and microsclerotial production in response to light and temperature. Genetic analysis by single and double knockouts and promoter binding assays will lead to elucidation of these regulatory networks in Vd.
Following this, pathogenicity screens with mutants, confocal microscopy and gene expression profiling of plant-specific stages of fungal growth (using cell sorting) will be used to assess the role of 'clock' components in infection and development within plants, leading to a greater understanding of how the fungus responds to the environment in the roots and xylem. Using a hairpin WC-1 construct transformed into strawberry and raspberry we will test whether inhibition of condidial and microsclerotial production is possible using host-induced gene silencing. In order to assess the role of the clock in planta and to understand the regulatory changes that have led to the apparent loss of clock-like behaviour in Vd, promoter and gene swap experiments will be carried out and LUC-PEST constructs will be used to read the status of rhythmic oscillations. Taken together this will lead to novel information that could be used as the basis for novel disease control through disruption of environmentally modulated developmental transitions important for pathogenicity.

Planned Impact

While this work is of a fundamental nature, there are several routes to achieving impact. In the UK alone the UK strawberry industry is worth £1bn per annum (up from £500m in 2012) and the raspberry market around £150M. Large amounts of production have moved out of soil and into expensive and sometimes hard to source substrates. In many regions there is a desire to return to the soil as costs are lower. The primary problem in soil-borne production is Verticillium, which in the UK is also a problem on potatoes and globally on lettuce, hops and tomato. In time, this is a potential area in which this research could have a meaningful impact.

Direct beneficiaries:
Breeding companies- the use of HIGS against core fungal developmental genes.
Many studies have now shown that trans-kingdom RNAi-mediated gene silencing is possible. The trialling of HIGS in two important soft fruit crops is important, not only for the control of Verticillium, but also as a tool in its own right.

Chemical and biocontrol companies- developing new inhibitors of light/environmental sensing pathways. Just as chemical disruption of mating has been successful in insect pests, it could be possible to disrupt the lifecycle of soil borne pathogens, by disrupting responses to light and temperature. This may lead to the development of new control strategies, based upon the findings from this research. While actively studied in humans and a large area of medical research, chronobiology is in its infancy in fungal/crop sectors and merits further research.

Indirect beneficiaries
Growers and farmers- The likely complete withdrawal of the main soil fumigant in the UK could ultimately lead to annual crop losses between £60-125M with the existing susceptible varieties if chloropicrin is not re-approved. This could be avoided if resistant varieties are developed and even if chloropicrin remains available in the short term, the fumigation costs of £4,000 per hectare could be saved, representing a national saving of c. £10M.

Government, public and policy benefits

Food security- Novel, technology-driven approaches to addressing agricultural problems are a key component in the drive to improve food security and self sufficiency. Research at this level into novel technologies and areas are important, as the form the first part of the value chain that eventually ends up in the hands first of industry, then ultimately the consumer

Less toxic chemistry leading to greater environmental conservation- The wider environmental impacts of alternative control strategies that remove the need for traditional chemical control are also central to improving the environment, quality of soil, water and produce. Chloropicrin is a necessary but harmful chemical- if alternatives could be found the environmental benefits would be large.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description This work is now reaching publication. Key findings are:

1. The circadian clock is disrupted in Verticillium but not related pathogens, allowing narrowing down of the loss event in evolutionary time.
2. Light and temparature have linked but redundant control mechanisms on key developmental processes
3. Pathogenicity is disrupted in 'clock' mutants in multiple species.

2020 update
Work has been challenging on this project, but work is continuing. We have done detailed timecourses that reveal that although the white collar complex is clearly not playing a role in circadian rhythms in the same way as in neurospora. Other photoreceptors are playing a role, which are undergoing functional characterisation.

HIGS constructs have been transformed and are being pathogenicity tested in 2021.

2021 update
HIGS constructs were analysed and unexpected results were obtained, as our control vectors displayed quantitative differences (increased resistance) to Verticillium despite not targeting any pathogen genes. This effect was repeatable, but illustrates that HIGS methodology many not be suitable for analysis of trans-kingdom silencing in all plant species. Our results are therefore inconclusive.


However, we were able to carry out bioinformatics analysis of existing circadian clock gene mutants and time course data RNAseq experiments, which will be developed for publication during 2022. These findings reveal no evidence for a functional circadian clock in Verticillium. We are awaiting results of a final experiment, in which we have hetrologously expressed the Verticillium frq promoter in N. crassa which will act as confirmatory data for our RNA seq experiments.
Exploitation Route New control approaches could be designed.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink

 
Description Biological clocks, strawberries and disease 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact I gave a talk with the title "Circadian clocks, strawberries and disease". I described the facillities and research carried out at East Malling Research, why new varieties of strawberry are needed, and the role of circadian clocks in regulating pathways that impact on plant disease. Due to lockdown the talk was given online, but it was interactive with both students and teachers asking questions. The final discussion centred on the role of circadian clocks in crop productivity.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Food secutiry for vulnerable populations: the fungal threat 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Oral presentation and group discussion under the Researcher Links scheme. This was a joint meeting funded by the British Council and FAPESP in Ribeirao Preto, Brazil on 11-14 September 2018. The workshop was coordinated by Simon Avery (Univ. Nottingham) and Gustavo Goldman (Univ. Sao Paulo), and had contributions from other experienced researchers. My presentation covered work on Fusarium, Phytophthora, Verticillium and Alternaria at NIAB EMR, raising the profile of the institute and of the funded genomic research that we have been performing. This led to discussions on future research projects and possible new joint-funded grants.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description Poster presentation at BSPP conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Poster presentation at the British Society of Plant Pathogens presidential conference to a specialised audience, which resulted in interesting discussions and new ideas.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL http://www.bspp.org.uk/meetings/bspppres2018.php
 
Description Poster presentation at Clock Club UK 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Poster presentation at the Clock Club meeting (Manchester) which focuses on the studies of the circadian clock.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016,2018
 
Description Poster presentation at South East RNA Network Meeting at University of Kent 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact South East RNA Network meeting is sponsored by the RNA Society and brings together researchers from many different disciplines to share knowledge and expertise in working with RNA. As the only representatives from a plant and fungal science background we raised the profile of research in this field. The presentation led to discussions on new directRNA sequencing methods and other technologies.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description Speaker at SoapBox Science Canterbury 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Engagement event in an open garden in Canterbury where general public (including children, postgraduate students, and general public) heard about the work we carry out. The main purpose was engaging with young people into studying sciences and promoting women in science and the science they do.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL http://soapboxscience.org/soapbox-science-2018-canterbury/
 
Description Talk to year 11 students 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact I gave a talk with the title "Circadian clocks, strawberries and disease". I described the facillities and research carried out at East Malling Research, why new varieties of strawberry are needed, and the role of circadian clocks in regulating pathways that impact on plant disease. Due to lockdown the talk was given online, but it was interactive with both students and teachers asking questions. The final discussion centered on circadian clocks and on the pros and cons of gentically modified organisms.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020