TIME - GLUING CROSS-MODAL MEMORIES VIA SYNCHRONISATION

Lead Research Organisation: University of Glasgow
Department Name: College of Medical, Veterinary, Life Sci

Abstract

When we remember past events we often find that these events are multisensory. For instance, when you think about your favourite camping holiday, you might recall the flickering light of the campfire and the crackle of the wood as it burned. This proposal addresses the fundamental question of what the mechanism is that holds all these different elements together so that we can have these integrated memories. This question is not trivial given that decades of brain research has taught us that different aspects of a multisensory stimulus are processed in different brain regions. A possible mechanism that our brains might use to link the different elements that make up a memory has to do with the abundant rhythmicity of human brain activity. Specifically, groups of neurons discharge synchronously, rather than chaotically. These rhythms allow neurons to engage in collaborative processing of incoming information, processed in different parts of the brain. Furthermore, neuroscience studies in animals showed that such synchronised activity is more likely to result in modifications of connections between neurons, which is the "hardware" underlying all memories. It therefore appears only logical that synchronisation is the key mechanism that turns a transient experience into a memory. Surprisingly, however, evidence for this fundamental role of synchronisation in building memories is scarce.

This project capitalises on a recent discovery that was made by the applicants shedding a first light onto the critical role of neural synchronisation for multisensory memories. Using a novel way of controlling the synchronisation between auditory and visual brain regions via rhythmic sensory stimulation (i.e. a flickering video/sound) the applicants demonstrated that a multisensory stimulus is more likely to be remembered when the two modalities were synchronised compared to when they were not synchronised. We refer to this effect as the Timing Induced Memory Effect (TIME). The aim of this research is to build on these initial exciting findings and to provide a range of empirical behavioural and neural data on how TIME impacts on human memory under different conditions. To this end, five work packages are proposed which will use variants of an experiment where the volume of a 3-s sound clip and the luminance of a 3-s video clip are modulated at different frequencies. Animal studies predict that TIME should only work at particular brain rhythms, i.e. a slower 4 Hz rhythm and a faster 40 Hz rhythm. A prediction that will be tested in the first work package. The second work package addresses the exciting question of whether synchronised presentation of stimuli increases memory performance beyond its natural limits. This result could have strong implications for improving memory in healthy and non-healthy populations. A third work package tests an important boundary condition, namely whether attention is required to obtain TIME. In a fourth work package we will unravel the brain regions at which TIME exerts its effects on memory. In a final fifth work package we will test whether it is possible to boost the capacity for audio-visual memory associations by delivering rhythmic stimulation to the right index finger. This experiment, has a strong translational potential as it could spark the development of cheap stimulation devices to improve memory in healthy students, older adults, or patients.

Together, this proposal tests the relatively simple but elegant idea that the ability to form memories for events which contain different elements depends on the synchronisation of the brain regions processing these elements in the first place. Using an innovative newly developed approach this project could therefore illuminate the critical component that holds our memories together, i.e. synchronisation.

Planned Impact

The proposed research project aims to resolve the core question in human episodic memory of how synchronised neural activity underlies the formation of episodic memories. The main impact of the research project will be on the fields of cognitive psychology and cognitive neuroscience. The research findings of this project will contribute to the mechanistic understanding of human memory, methodological development and application in the memory research field.

This research project will also have a potential impact on industry by developing innovative low-cost home healthcare devices or applications to non-invasively entrain oscillations in the service of improving memory in the human brain. Memory disorders are a dominant feature of numerous and pervasive mental health problems including depression, anxiety, schizophrenia, etc. with 1 out of 4 people in the UK experiencing a mental health problem each year (McManus et al, 2009; The NHS Information Centre for Health and Social Care). Similarly, memory deficits are a key problem for healthy ageing and a pronounced issue for dementia. We are therefore in need of finding affordable and effective ways to address these cognitive problems. The large amount of data collected by the device or application could be used by the researchers in return to perfect the device by individualising the stimulation program for each user. The home healthcare device could be developed as a potential intervention for clinical or ageing population to enhance their memory performance.

In addition, the proposed project will enhance career development for the postdoctoral researcher (Dr Wang) and related masters and undergraduate students doing projects in the lab, thus helping to build UK capacity in this area of cognitive psychology.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description We made significant progress on two fronts. First, we conducted a computational modelling study in order to investigate how known synaptic plasticity principles link with our observed memory effects. In particular, we wanted to answer the question how theta-phase dependent plasticity and spike-time-dependent plasticity contribute to the empirically observed memory differences between synchronized and desynchronized audio-visual stimuli. We found in this study that only a combination of both mechanisms sufficiently accounts for the behavioural effects. The results of this computational modelling paper have been published in the open access Journal eNeuro (https://doi.org/10.1523/ENEURO.0333-22.2023).

On the second front we finished our study on the role of gamma synchronization after resuming testing once the COVID restrictions were lifted. In short, in this study we are able to confirm critical and highly non-trivial predictions by the spike-timing-dependent-plasticity model by showing that short latency between putative pre and postsynaptic information streams is most beneficial to audio-visual memory formation. The paper has been submitted to Current Biology and received very positive reviews. We are currently in the process of revising the paper and should be in a position to re-submit in 4-8 weeks.

Finally, we have also successfully concluded data collection for the TIME (i.e. Theta Induced Memory Effect) longevity project. In this project we investigated the effect of a 24 hour time delay between learning and retrieval on the effect of audio-visual synchrony. In this study we were able to replicate the beneficial effect of synchronicity on memory (i.e. synchronously presented audio-visual clips were better remembered than asynchronously presented clips) when there was only a short gap between learning and test (e.g. a few minutes). Interestingly, a 24 hour delay between learning and test seemed to have 'flipped' the effect such that asynchronous audio-movie clips are better remembered than synchronous ones. This is a highly interesting, and completely unanticipated result! We are currently analysing this data to understand what the reason for this flip might be. In any case, the results are relevant for Neurotechnology that seeks to increase long-term memory via sensory rhythmic simulation.
Exploitation Route Start-up companies such as Clarity Healthcare Technologies are incorporating our findings into their devices to improve memory in patients with neurodegenerative disorders. In academia, memory researchers can use our developed paradigms to study synaptic plasticity mechanisms, such as Spike-Timing-Dependent-Plasticity in humans non-invasively, which was not possible before. For instance, using this technique we can now begin to investigate how plasticity changes across the lifespan, an area we know next to nothing about. Indeed, we have reached out to leading developmental psychologists in the field who are fascinated by this opportunity.
Sectors Education,Healthcare,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology

 
Description Our findings are being used by a neurotechnology start-up company, Clarity Health Technologies, Inc. to improve memory in patients with neurodegenerative disorders.
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Healthcare
Impact Types Societal

 
Description Input on Neurotechnology report for the Information Commissioner's Office
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Contribution to a national consultation/review
 
Description Collaboration on theta induced memory effect with partners from Osnabrueck (lab of Prof U. Stockhorst) 
Organisation University of Osnabrück
Country Germany 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Martin Antov, a postdoc in Ursula Stockhorst's team, and Danying Wang received a Lower Saxony - Scotland Tandem Fellowship Programme funded by ECAS. The fellowship pays for travel costs and allows Dr Wang and Dr Antov to visit each other and conduct collaborative experiments. In these experiments we will be using the theta induced memory effect to study fear conditioning.
Collaborator Contribution The partners from Osnabrueck successfully used our theta induced memory paradigm to study fear conditioning. Fear conditioning is something my lab has no expertise in but it is an area of great significance, especially in the animal studies. Therefore I very much welcome the opportunity to extend our findings to this new topic.
Impact Apart from the Fellowship mentioned above there are currently no outputs from this collaboration.
Start Year 2021
 
Description Workshop - Shaping Human Memories Via Sensory Entrainment 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact In this workshop we discussed recent findings on using sensory entrainment to shape memories and their implications for human memory research. In particular, we explored potential oscillatory and synaptic plasticity mechanisms which contribute to these effects. We also discussed how these techniques can be used to improve our understanding of the development of memory across the lifespan, as well as considering possible clinical implications (i.e. neurodegenerative diseases). The workshop had an exciting line-up with several leaders in the field contributing talks relevant to the topic (e.g.
Prof Li-Huei Tsai (MIT; https://tsailaboratory.mit.edu/li-huei-tsai/), Prof. Huib Mansvelder (VU Amsterdam; https://inf.cncr.nl/people/mansvelder_hd), Dr Philippe Albouy (Université Laval; https://cervo.ulaval.ca/en/philippe-albouy), Prof. Moritz Köster (University of Regensburg; https://www.uni-regensburg.de/human-sciences/developmental-cognitive-psychology/team/prof-dr-dr-moritz-koester/index.html), Dr. Kyung Min An (https://www.birmingham.ac.uk/staff/profiles/psychology/an-kyungmin.aspx). The audience included members from a Neurotechnology Start-up company, Clarity Technologies, who aim to build a memory enhancing device for treatment of dementia based on findings from our research and others showing that sensory rhythmic stimulation improves memory. One outcome of the workshop was that it established links between this start-up company and researchers to work towards a common goal of improving memory via sensory rhythmic stimulation (SH is about to sign a contract with Clarity to become a scientific advisor). The workshop also brought together scientists, and students from various disciplines (e.g. developmental psychology, neurology, molecular biology) which sparked very interesting questions and discussions. The workshop also highlighted important future areas for research, such as the development of synaptic plasticity (as studied with rhythmic sensory stimulation) in children.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022