Alleviating the "Sample to Sequence" Bottleneck Using Novel Microfluidic Lab-on-a-Chip Nucleic Acid Extraction Technologies

Lead Research Organisation: NATIONAL OCEANOGRAPHY CENTRE
Department Name: Science and Technology

Abstract

This research will develop and evaluate a new system, based on pre-existing technology and expertise within the UK and Japan, which will improve the way in which we can detect, measure and study ocean biology based on species-specific genetic sequences. Current, best methods for the identification, enumeration and analysis of genetic sequences in the ocean rely upon the collection of water samples, which are returned to a centralized and highly resourced laboratory where they are processed and analyzed by highly trained technical staff. This takes time, delaying potentially important results (e.g. the presence and quantity of harmful species), and is expensive, limiting the number of samples that can be processed and ultimately reducing the resolution with which we can monitor ocean biology. This is now more important than ever as the oceans respond to changing climatic and anthropogenic influences. A key limiting step in this endeavor is the process of removing genetic material from the sample, whether it be whole cells, organisms or their remnants, and purifying it to the point at which it can be measured accurately; the 'extraction bottleneck.' Existing, automated sample processing robots are typically bulky, complicated, power hungry, prohibitively expensive, and not widely available.

Microfluidic Lab on a Chip (LOC) technologies reduce the scale of analytical processes traditionally performed on a lab bench. For example, miniature pipes (typically one tenth of a millimetre across) together with miniature pumps, valves and optics are used to take in sample, and manipulate it along with a suite of reagents to undertake a relatively complex laboratory process in a fraction of the time with minimal sample / chemical consumption and robotically, thus obviating the need for a specialist. In this project, we will capitalize upon the advantages of LOC technology to address the extraction bottleneck with a novel device that will interface with 'front-end' samplers and 'back-end' analyzers to form an integrated, genetic sensor platform. This will be tailored for the detection and quantification of a range of target organisms of high importance to human health, ocean ecology and ocean-centric industries. The project will demonstrate proof of concept that the integration of LOC genetic extraction with existing samplers and analytics can significantly improve the resolution and ease with which we can monitor fundamental biological variables.

Planned Impact

As a user-friendly, compact, high-throughput, and contamination free DNA and RNA extraction platform, the proposed Extraction and Purification System (EPS) will alleviate the current 'extraction bottleneck' that requires time-consuming manual sample processing by specialist molecular biologists. We anticipate that the EPS will catalyse the uptake of DNA and RNA analytics, saving time and money across industries. This project therefore has the potential to inspire innovative approaches and open new industrial arenas for the application of nucleic acid analytics, thus stimulating economic growth.

An extensive Knowledge Exchange Programme is proposed, to benefit governmental, regulatory, and industrial stakeholders interested in microbiology or environmental DNA (eDNA) technologies. We propose to work directly with the energy industry, fisheries, as well as regulatory and governmental bodies interested in the detection of Harmful Algal Blooms (HABs), Faecal Indicator Bacteria (FIB), conservation (invasive or endangered species), nuisance (gelatinous) organisms and biogeochemically important species detection.

The EPS will expedite the development of broadly applied, robust, miniaturised in situ DNA and RNA sensors. Therefore it has the potential to provide sensor technology to address most of the identified "Essential Ocean Variables" by the Global Ocean Observing System and regional priorities of members of the United Nations Convention of Biological Diversity.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description We found that bead-based extractions resulted in much lower DNA recovery than solid phase extraction or free-flow electophoresis. These results will be published as they are relevant to researchers aiming to recover quantitative data from extraction protocols. We found that the recovery was not only lower, but it had a large uncertainty between sample replicates.
Exploitation Route We aim to compare the extraction methodology developed in this project to a second methodology developed as part of another project, for suitability for integration into lab-on-a-chip microfluidics and nucleic acid detection. If successful, user manuals and protocols will enable adoption by other labs for point-of-sample analytics.
Sectors Aerospace

Defence and Marine

Environment

Healthcare

 
Title Development of Standard Operating Procedures for the extraction and purification of important organisms 
Description We are in the process of writing standard protocols for optimal extractions from harmful algae and invasive species. 
Type Of Material Technology assay or reagent 
Year Produced 2019 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact We hope this will streamline the process of selecting extraction methods for the purposes of eDNA or harmful algae molecular monitoring. 
 
Title IP SENSITIVE: Free Flow Electrophoresis (FFE) microfluidic chip for the concentration and purification of nucleic acids 
Description An extraction chip and agarose gel moulding tool were fabricated in PMMA with micro-milled channels. In order to keep fabrication costs to a minimum, PMMA chip fabrication was carried out in-house in the Ocean Technology and Engineering Group. The initial idea was to use a moulding tool to form the agarose strips, which could then be transferred to the FFE chip. However, after a number of trials it has been found that it is easier to form the agarose strips directly onto the chip. In order to accommodate this modification, a new chip with enclosed agarose channels with multiple connecting microfluidic holes have been incorporated into the design. 
Type Of Material Technology assay or reagent 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The concept allows for the concentration and purification of nucleic acids from any source in a single step, with samples separated in multiple parallel microfluidic channels that can be purified simultaneously. 
 
Title International intercomparison effort 
Description In this study, we evaluated and selected nucleic acid (NA) extraction protocols for automated gene extraction devices that can be used for genomic analysis of marine environmental samples, studied the specifications of practical NA extraction devices, and built and evaluated prototypes of the NA extraction devices in a joint Japan-UK framework. As a result, prototypes of automated NA extraction devices that can be integrated with various types of in-situ samplers were completed, and its performance was demonstrated using actual marine samples. In this study, both Japan and UK research teams were able to proceed the development and evaluation of NA extraction devices effectively by collaborating on R&D by utilizing our respective technological seeds toward the clear goal of automating NA extraction. It has resulted in the completion of the development and evaluation of practical and versatile NA extraction devices both on Japan and UK side based on the microfluidic technology which can contribute to future miniaturization of the in-situ instrument. By organizing and managing the international collaboration team which shared the clear research objectives based on the exchange of information through workshops and other means of meetings, we were able to promote development with a particular focus on integrating each other's technologies with those of the other side. 
Type Of Material Technology assay or reagent 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact We completed 2 prototypes (one on UK and one on Japanese sides of the partnership) for automatic NA extraction devices that can be integrated with in situ genetic analysers, and compared them. We aim to improve extraction efficiencies and simplify the design for commercial production in the next prototype. 
 
Description International eDNA intercomparison study 
Organisation Alfred-Wegener Institute for Polar and Marine Research
Country Germany 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution This group is exchanging samples in order to perform an intercomparison activity on extraction, DNA purification and DNA sequencing methodologies. Each group (including us) has collected 20-30 marine samples for this work.
Collaborator Contribution This group is exchanging samples in order to perform an intercomparison activity on extraction, DNA purification and DNA sequencing methodologies. Each group (including us) has collected 20-30 marine samples for this work.
Impact Intercomparison activities will result in a manuscript and standard operating procedures.
Start Year 2019
 
Description International eDNA intercomparison study 
Organisation Dalhousie University
Country Canada 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution This group is exchanging samples in order to perform an intercomparison activity on extraction, DNA purification and DNA sequencing methodologies. Each group (including us) has collected 20-30 marine samples for this work.
Collaborator Contribution This group is exchanging samples in order to perform an intercomparison activity on extraction, DNA purification and DNA sequencing methodologies. Each group (including us) has collected 20-30 marine samples for this work.
Impact Intercomparison activities will result in a manuscript and standard operating procedures.
Start Year 2019
 
Description International eDNA intercomparison study 
Organisation Monterey Bay Aquarium Research Institute
Country United States 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution This group is exchanging samples in order to perform an intercomparison activity on extraction, DNA purification and DNA sequencing methodologies. Each group (including us) has collected 20-30 marine samples for this work.
Collaborator Contribution This group is exchanging samples in order to perform an intercomparison activity on extraction, DNA purification and DNA sequencing methodologies. Each group (including us) has collected 20-30 marine samples for this work.
Impact Intercomparison activities will result in a manuscript and standard operating procedures.
Start Year 2019
 
Description International eDNA intercomparison study 
Organisation National Center for Scientific Research (Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique CNRS)
Department Biological Station, Roscoff
Country France 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution This group is exchanging samples in order to perform an intercomparison activity on extraction, DNA purification and DNA sequencing methodologies. Each group (including us) has collected 20-30 marine samples for this work.
Collaborator Contribution This group is exchanging samples in order to perform an intercomparison activity on extraction, DNA purification and DNA sequencing methodologies. Each group (including us) has collected 20-30 marine samples for this work.
Impact Intercomparison activities will result in a manuscript and standard operating procedures.
Start Year 2019
 
Description International eDNA intercomparison study 
Organisation University of South Florida
Country United States 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution This group is exchanging samples in order to perform an intercomparison activity on extraction, DNA purification and DNA sequencing methodologies. Each group (including us) has collected 20-30 marine samples for this work.
Collaborator Contribution This group is exchanging samples in order to perform an intercomparison activity on extraction, DNA purification and DNA sequencing methodologies. Each group (including us) has collected 20-30 marine samples for this work.
Impact Intercomparison activities will result in a manuscript and standard operating procedures.
Start Year 2019
 
Description GLOMICON (Global Omics Observatory Network) intercomparison effort (i.e. ring testing) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact An international group of researchers have collected and exchanged samples for an intercomparison study. We all processed and sequenced the samples according to our typical lab protocols and will compare and publish the results. This ensures our data across the globe (Canada, US, UK and Europe) are comparable. It also gives us confidence that we can work with other labs' data for large scale analyses, when they use these same published protocols.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021,2022,2023,2024
URL https://github.com/GLOMICON