PYRAMID: Platform for dYnamic, hyper-resolution, near-real time flood Risk AssessMent Integrating repurposed and novel Data sources

Lead Research Organisation: Loughborough University
Department Name: Architecture, Building and Civil Eng

Abstract

Flooding has been identified by the government as the number one priority and risk to the UK. Flooding already causes millions of pounds worth of damage to people's homes, infrastructure and the economy every year, and is projected to become even more severe under climate change. Being able to plan for, respond to and manage flooding effectively is therefore essential.

We are lucky to have a tradition of flood management in the UK led by the Environment Agency. Operational flood models use meteorological data combined with elevation data to show us where flooding will occur. These models produce flood risk maps for planning and forecasting purposes and have helped us design flood defences for many areas.

However, flooding is not only dependent on the topography of an area. There are many other factors at play that evolve over time: culverts can get blocked, flood gates are left open and flood walls can fall into disrepair. This can dramatically alter the extent and depth of a flood. Not only that, but our exposure to flood risk changes too. Far less disruption occurs from a flood overnight than during rush hour traffic. A prime example of this is the flooding of Boscastle in 2004. During the event, 116 cars parked in a carpark were washed downstream, blocking a bridge, causing water to back up and flood unexpected areas. If the rain had fallen in the evening, the cars would not have been in the carpark and the impact of the flood would have been smaller. Could we have predicted this? Can we reduce the impact of flooding for similar future events? We think that with the right data and tools, we can.

We will build a tool that will change how we respond to flood risks as they evolve. The tool will allow flood risk managers to deploy just-in-time maintenance and alleviation measures, such as clearing critical blocked culverts or setting up mobile flood defences. To achieve this, the tool will incorporate brand new types of data and cutting edge flood models into an easy-to-use online platform that allows users to visualise evolving flood risks. The platform (called PYRAMID) will be developed in conjunction with the Environment Agency, local authorities and community groups to ensure that it delivers relevant information for critical decision-making in near-real time. The platform will have toolkits to make it easy for communities to incorporate their data, providing essential local information.

The new data driving this modelling will be key. The data that we need are available but sit fragmented across a range of organisations in difficult-to-use formats. We will use artificial intelligence to extract this useful information from hidden datasets, such as old reports, flood asset registers and various types of satellite imagery. In addition, we want to incorporate brand new information from novel sensors that are being deployed as part of Newcastle University's Urban Observatory. These sensors monitor things like soil moisture and rainfall at very high resolutions, as well as other factors like traffic and congestion. We can also monitor the condition of specific factors affecting flood risk, such as whether particular culverts are blocked or whether certain flood walls are in poor condition. These factors can be monitored by looking at a combination of satellite remote sensing and sensors deployed on lorries and other vehicles. We will also harness data collected communities and citizens.

All of this information will be put into our flood models. We have a hyper-resolution hydrodynamic flood model that can accurately simulate the movement of debris in flood flows at a centimetre scale. This model will work in conjunction with a broader catchment model, which will provide information on the hydrological conditions in the wider area. The platform will be trialled in Newcastle to take advantage of existing government investments in the Urban Observatory and a legacy of flood research conducted here.

Planned Impact

We categorise beneficiaries into two main groups.

Practitioners, regulators and policymakers: beneficiaries include organisations such as the Environment Agency, who are responsible for managing flood risk, forecasting and warning the public of floods and who still have gaps in their understanding of other data that may help strengthen their understanding of flood risk, as well as provide evidence for decision making; the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra), with overall policy responsibility for flood and coastal erosion risk in England; the Department for Communities and Local Government (DCLG) with responsibility for coordinating UK resilience to major floods through the coordination of regional and local organisations and emergency planning.

This research would also be of interest to the Committee on Climate Change, to inform the next UK Climate Change Risk Assessment and subsequent action. Other users with potential benefits from this research are Category 1 and Category 2 responders as laid out in the Civil Contingencies Act 2004 (e.g. emergency services, transport and highways agencies, utilities) and the general public. To date citizen science data are less readily used by professionals to support real applications, despite offering new and different types of data which can fill data gaps at a local level.

Our proposed approach would also help support local Environment Agency Community Engagement Officers, who work with residents, public groups, land owners, businesses and schools to help them plan and prepare to reduce the impacts of a flood event. They will also help to build trust between community groups and our partner organisations, and raise awareness through education.

Community, charity and local interest groups, and citizen scientist networks: by working with a community group directly as a project partner (Action 4 Acomb), and indirectly through the facilitation of various groups by our environmental charity project partners (Tyne Rivers Trust) the project focuses on live flood risk challenges and issues in the citizen science pilot: sustainable data collection; data organisation, analysis and visualisation tools; accessible data integrated with 'traditional' sources of data.

When it comes to understanding flood risk and management, our stakeholders and beneficiaries face common issues with regards to: lack of data, or sustainable data collection to understand complex environmental issues and pressures, or to provide the evidence-base to make decisions or to lobby for interventions; ability to analyse and visualise data, either as a single data source or integrated with 'traditional' or national sensor networks, or sources of data that are often siloed, inaccessible, or archived after project completion in different organisations; tools and platforms that readily assimilate the most useful and applicable data and state-of-the art modelling to understand flood risk in near real-time.

This project will address these issues by:

Collaborating with a range of stakeholders (including citizens, government agencies and industry) to co-design, co-produce, co-evaluate and co-promote a web-application tool, and to extract, 'hidden data' that may inform understanding flood risk and management.

Creating a dynamic flood risk component dataset which will extract multi-scale information from fragmented heterogeneous datasets, integrate, and structure the data needed to model cascading failures important for flood risk.

Assimilating the new datasets into cutting-edge, physically-based hydrological and hydrodynamic models to predict plausible mechanisms and outcomes of flooding from rainfall to inundation.

An ultimately, to develop a web platform demonstrator to interrogate observations and model outputs, and visualise dynamic flood risk maps with (near) real-time updates.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description So far, the key research findings from PYRAMID include:
1) the complex flow dynamics induced by flood waves and floating debris interacting with building structures can be simulated using a physically based modelling framework developed through the project;
2) the simulation efficiency of the model can be substantially improved using the modern graphics processing units based high-performance computing technology
3) the new model can be applied to assess surface water flood risk by directly considering the influence of large-scale floating debris
4) by integrating with new remote sensing data to identify the source and type of potential floating objects, the model can be used to simulate the whole-process of debris dynamics from initiation, transport and interacting with structures/infrastructure.
Exploitation Route The project is still ongoing. Clearly the new urban surface water flood modelling capacity developed through the project will be of interests to Newcastle city council, EA and a range of other stakeholders. Engagement events have been planned to interact with these stakeholders. In addition to practical impact, the scientific value of the new modelling methods is clear. The model will be finally open-sourced for different users.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Education,Environment,Government, Democracy and Justice,Transport

 
Description The project is active. The research has led to the delivery of a new modelling suite for simulating the detailed physical process of floating objects induced and driven by highly dynamic surface water floods and their interaction with building structures/infrastructure. The new model provides new capability for surface water flood modelling, capturing an important flow phenomenon that is often observed during such events. The new model has potential to improve the current flood modelling and risk assessment practice which is based on 'clean' water assumption, and can potentially provide more reliable flood risk information to inform urban planning and flood risk management. Project engagement events have also been planned to disseminate the research outputs. The resulting modelling tools will be made open-source for different users and up-take.
First Year Of Impact 2023
Sector Communities and Social Services/Policy,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Education,Environment,Government, Democracy and Justice,Transport
Impact Types Societal,Economic,Policy & public services

 
Title High-Performance Hydrodynamic Model for Surface Water Flooding and Floating Debris 
Description A new modelling component for simulating the dynamic movement of floating objects initiated by flood waves has been developed and coupled with the Loughborough High-Performance Integrated hydrodynamic Modelling System (HiPIMS) to predict the full-process dynamics from initiation, transport to interacting with building structures. This represents one of the core research deliverables of PYRAMID. 
Type Of Material Computer model/algorithm 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Currently, surface water flood modelling only considers 'clean water'. But a dynamic surface water flood event may initiate and transport floating objects, e.g. cars, tree logs, bins, and exacerbate flood impact. The new model will allow direct consideration of the extra risk/impact of these floating debris imposed to people, property and infrastructure, which better reflects reality and can potentially produce more reliable risk information to inform urban planning and flood risk management. 
URL https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0029801822008435
 
Title New high-performance real-time flood modelling/forecasting tool 
Description Through PYRAMID, an innovative high-performance computer model has been further developed to simulate in real-time the flood hydrodynamics induced by intense rainfall, taking into account floating debris. In the current practice, 'clear water' assumption is normally made. But it is observed that floating objects are often carried along by transient flash flood flows, exaggerating impact on structures and imposing further threat to people. Coupling an existing hydrodynamic model (HiPIMS) with a new discrete element model to represent floating debris, the new model can simulate the complex interactive debris enriched flash flood flow and impact on structures. 
Type Of Material Computer model/algorithm 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact This will provide a new modelling approach that may step change the current flood risk assessment practice. The model is still being refined and more pathways to impact will be explored in the later stage of the project. 
 
Description Collaboration with Prof Cathryn Birch from University of Leeds in Surface Water Flood Forecasting Research 
Organisation University of Leeds
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The partnership was established through PI Liang's attending the iCASP enhanced SWF forecasting workshop organised by Prof Birch from University of Leeds. Liang contributed to discussion of surface water flood forecasting technologies at the workshop, subsequently discussed with Prof Birch and representatives from the EA and Flood Forecasting Centre about future research opportunities in this topic. This has led to new partnership to engage future research to address current technical challenges in surface water flood forecasting, initiating new ideas for future funding opportunities.
Collaborator Contribution Prof Birch introduced their research and discussed ideas for future collaboration, as well as introducing EA and Flood Forecasting Centre into the collaboration network.
Impact The partnership has directly led to the development of a large grant application submitted to NERC.
Start Year 2022
 
Description PYRAMID Workshop 1 (online): Project launch & stakeholder perspectives 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact This was the first stakeholder engagement workshop for the project, which took place online in April 2021 with the following objectives: 1. Launch PYRAMID project; 2. Familiarise partners and stakeholders with aim, objectives & vision; 3. Understand stakeholder perspectives and needs; 4. Understand how partners and stakeholders can support the project.

The workshop was attended the project team and representatives from the government agencies (e.g. EA, Met Office, Flood forecasting Centre), local council (Newcastle Council), industry (Network Rail, JBA) and Tynes River Trust, etc. Whilst it was organised online, the workshop created useful discussion and outcomes that helped refine PYRAMID research plan and focus.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description iCASP enhanced SWF forecasting workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The iCASP enhanced surface water flood forecasting workshop was organised by the University of Leeds in November 2022 as part of a project funded through the Yorkshire Integrated Catchment Solutions Programme (iCASP). The workshop aimed to engage with government agencies including the Environment Agency, Met Office and Flood Forecasting Centre, local government users of flood forecasting products and academics to disseminate research outputs and receive feedback.

Attending the workshop resulted in new collaboration partnerships with Leeds, Oxford, Met Office, EA and Flood Forecasting Centre, which has contributed to the development of a NERC large grant proposal.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://icasp.org.uk/enhanced-surface-water-flood-forecasts-summer-2022-yorkshire-testbed/