Trait-mediated density-dependence and community level eco-evolutionary dynamics
Lead Research Organisation:
University of Oxford
Department Name: Zoology
Abstract
Scientists achieve good understanding about a system through a mixture of observation, experimentation and mathematical modeling. If biologists can build a model that can be used to accurately predict the behavior of populations and communities in the wild, they have a good understanding of the system. Unfortunately constructing such models is a real challenge for most free-living populations and communities. There are several reasons for this. First, it is time consuming and expensive to collect a sufficiently large quantity of observational data to robustly parameterize models. Second, most natural systems do not easily lend themselves to experimental manipulation that are invaluable in gaining insight that cannot be reached from observation alone. Third, multiple aspects of populations and communities often change together when the system is perturbed, including the dynamics of population size, average body size of juveniles and adults, gene frequencies and life history traits like life expectancy at birth. It is only recently that biologists have worked out to simultaneously model the dynamics of populations, genes and traits. These models are called integral projection models.
Although integral projection models offer enormous potential for understanding the dynamics of natural systems, their development is still in its infancy. In particular the treatment of competition between individuals of the same species is treated naively. In addition, there is considerable work to be done to use these models to explore the way species within a community interact. In this proposal we will start by taking already published integral projection models that include competition between individuals of the same species and will use novel methods to analyze them to gain general insight into how different types of competition between individuals simultaneously impacts the dynamics of population size, body size and life history.
Next, we will use some exceptional detailed experimental data from a freshwater fish community in Trinidad to build models of interacting species. We will use these models to predict the dynamics of natural streams where dynamics have been observed for many years. The proposed work is consequently exceptionally good value for money because we will use such extensive existing data. Through a series of analyses of our models, and potentially some additional experiments, we expect to build models that accurately capture the dynamics of the natural stream community. By the end of the work we expect to have achieved a better understanding of the dynamics of this system than of any other free-living community under study.
Although integral projection models offer enormous potential for understanding the dynamics of natural systems, their development is still in its infancy. In particular the treatment of competition between individuals of the same species is treated naively. In addition, there is considerable work to be done to use these models to explore the way species within a community interact. In this proposal we will start by taking already published integral projection models that include competition between individuals of the same species and will use novel methods to analyze them to gain general insight into how different types of competition between individuals simultaneously impacts the dynamics of population size, body size and life history.
Next, we will use some exceptional detailed experimental data from a freshwater fish community in Trinidad to build models of interacting species. We will use these models to predict the dynamics of natural streams where dynamics have been observed for many years. The proposed work is consequently exceptionally good value for money because we will use such extensive existing data. Through a series of analyses of our models, and potentially some additional experiments, we expect to build models that accurately capture the dynamics of the natural stream community. By the end of the work we expect to have achieved a better understanding of the dynamics of this system than of any other free-living community under study.
Planned Impact
Who will benefit?
Anyone interested in predicting how populations or communities will respond to changes in the environment will be interested in this research. This is because the approaches we will develop will allow the ecological and evolutionary consequences of environmental change to populations and communities to be investigated in greater detail than ever before. Beneficiaries will include anyone interested in managing a population or community, including governmental departments like DEFRA, non-government organizations including Flora and Fauna International and companies like MRag.
How will they benefit?
These organizations will benefit from the research because the novel modeling methods we will devise are likely to improve the predictive power of population- and community-level models. The PI has already shown how the development of methods in structured models can benefit non-academic organizations. He has previously used structured models to predict the future population size and structure for China for Rio Tinto, to advise Scottish estate owners on red deer management, and he has recently been in discussion with medics on ways to improve modeling the social, healthcare and economic consequences of the continuing obesity epidemic. The modeling advances we will realize in the work described in this application will improve the flexibility of structured models to make predictions.
Anyone interested in predicting how populations or communities will respond to changes in the environment will be interested in this research. This is because the approaches we will develop will allow the ecological and evolutionary consequences of environmental change to populations and communities to be investigated in greater detail than ever before. Beneficiaries will include anyone interested in managing a population or community, including governmental departments like DEFRA, non-government organizations including Flora and Fauna International and companies like MRag.
How will they benefit?
These organizations will benefit from the research because the novel modeling methods we will devise are likely to improve the predictive power of population- and community-level models. The PI has already shown how the development of methods in structured models can benefit non-academic organizations. He has previously used structured models to predict the future population size and structure for China for Rio Tinto, to advise Scottish estate owners on red deer management, and he has recently been in discussion with medics on ways to improve modeling the social, healthcare and economic consequences of the continuing obesity epidemic. The modeling advances we will realize in the work described in this application will improve the flexibility of structured models to make predictions.
Publications
Brouard MJ
(2015)
Analysis on Population Level Reveals Trappability of Wild Rodents Is Determined by Previous Trap Occupant.
in PloS one
Coulson T
(2017)
Modeling Adaptive and Nonadaptive Responses of Populations to Environmental Change
in The American Naturalist
Coulson T
(2014)
Population biology: fur seals signal their own decline.
in Nature
Cubaynes S
(2014)
Density-dependent intraspecific aggression regulates survival in northern Yellowstone wolves (Canis lupus).
in The Journal of animal ecology
Cusack JJ
(2015)
Random versus Game Trail-Based Camera Trap Placement Strategy for Monitoring Terrestrial Mammal Communities.
in PloS one
Cusack JJ
(2015)
Applying a random encounter model to estimate lion density from camera traps in Serengeti National Park, Tanzania.
in The Journal of wildlife management
Gamelon M
(2014)
Influence of life-history tactics on transient dynamics: a comparative analysis across mammalian populations.
in The American naturalist
Gamelon M
(2015)
Linking demographic responses and life history tactics from longitudinal data in mammals
in Oikos
Godsall B
(2014)
From physiology to space use: energy reserves and androgenization explain home-range size variation in a woodland rodent.
in The Journal of animal ecology
Griffiths JI
(2020)
Individual differences determine the strength of ecological interactions.
in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America
Kanda RK
(2015)
The effect of life history on retroviral genome invasions.
in PloS one
Ozgul A
(2014)
Linking body mass and group dynamics in an obligate cooperative breeder.
in The Journal of animal ecology
Plard F
(2015)
Quantifying the influence of measured and unmeasured individual differences on demography.
in The Journal of animal ecology
Plard F
(2013)
Long-lived and heavier females give birth earlier in roe deer
in Ecography
Plard F
(2014)
Mismatch between birth date and vegetation phenology slows the demography of roe deer.
in PLoS biology
Schindler S
(2015)
Sex-specific demography and generalization of the Trivers-Willard theory.
in Nature
Simmonds E
(2014)
Analysis of phenotypic change in relation to climatic drivers in a population of Soay sheep Ovis aries
in Oikos
Smallegange IM
(2014)
Correlative changes in life-history variables in response to environmental change in a model organism.
in The American naturalist
Songhurst A
(2014)
Exploring the effects of spatial autocorrelation when identifying key drivers of wildlife crop-raiding.
in Ecology and evolution
Steiner UK
(2014)
Generation time, net reproductive rate, and growth in stage-age-structured populations.
in The American naturalist
Traill LW
(2014)
Reply to Hedrick et al.: Trophy hunting influences the distribution of trait values through demographic impacts.
in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America
Traill LW
(2014)
Demography, not inheritance, drives phenotypic change in hunted bighorn sheep.
in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America
Travis J
(2014)
Eco-Evolutionary Dynamics
Wilson K
(2013)
The times they are a-changin': evolution and revolution in animal ecology publishing
in Journal of Animal Ecology
Description | We have discovered that the way competition occurs within species and between species can have a substantial impact on life history and population dynamics. We developed general theory to demonstrate this. |
Exploitation Route | The methods we developed will likely be applied by other biologists to provide insights into population and community dynamics. This could feed into management and conservation plans. |
Sectors | Environment |
Description | Collaboration with FSU and UCR |
Organisation | Florida State University |
Country | United States |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | We have worked together on modelling, setting up experiments in the field, and in applying for additional funding. |
Collaborator Contribution | We have worked together on modelling, setting up experiments in the field, and in applying for additional funding. |
Impact | see publications |
Start Year | 2009 |