Did hydrothermal vents push the frontiers of habitability on the early Earth?
Lead Research Organisation:
University of St Andrews
Department Name: Earth and Environmental Sciences
Abstract
Nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) are essential nutrients to all life on Earth. Scarcity of these nutrients can limit biological productivity while unrestricted supplies can lead to bacterial blooms with severe environmental impacts. Investigating the N and P cycles is therefore critical for topics ranging from life's origins to modern environmental change. The aim of this research programme is therefore to (a) create a new analytical centre for N and P geochemistry, including experimental facilities, (b) apply these tools to investigate underexplored pathways of N and P cycling, and (c) incorporate bioinformatic data to reconstruct the biological utilisation of rare P species. The proposed project will represent the first set of applications of the new analytical facilities.
The major thrust of this project is the fundamental question how early life was sustained. Several lines of evidence suggest that primary productivity was severely suppressed throughout the Precambrian, because phosphate and nitrate - the two major forms of P and N in the modern ocean - were much less soluble in ancient oceans. We hypothesise that submarine volcanism, which sets off hydrothermal convection cells through oceanic crust, generated reduced forms of nitrogen and phosphorus and thus created important point sources of nutrients for early life. To test this hypothesis, we will develop a new hydrothermal reaction chamber that allows us to conduct experiments under elevated pressures and temperatures, reminiscent of deep-sea hydrothermal vents. Different gases (N2, CO2, CH4), fluids (saline, fresh), phosphate phases and catalytic minerals (magnetite, sulphides) will be added to the reactor under a range of conditions. The products will be analysed for nitrogen isotopic ratios (15N/14N) and phosphorus speciation.
The main objectives are:
* Measure the isotopic fractionation associated with abiotic hydrothermal N2 reduction to ammonium and organic amines. These results will allow us to re-visit the existing N isotopic record (including organic-rich sedimentary rocks and hydrothermally influenced strata) and determine if hydrothermal N sources played a significant role in Precambrian biogeochemical cycles.
* Quantify the yield of hydrothermal phosphate reduction to phosphite. Phosphite, a reduced form of P, is significantly more soluble than phosphate. Previous experiments have shown that phosphite can be produced from the reduction of simple phosphate salts. We will conduct new experiments with natural phosphate minerals to derive reaction efficiencies for hydrothermal scenarios. We will also measure how much phosphite is taken up into minerals to create a calibration for geochemical measurements of phosphate in the rock record.
* Reconstruct the radiation of phosphite-using enzymes across the tree of life. Phylogenetic data and molecular clocks will be used to infer the birth, loss and transfer of relevant genes. This analysis will reveal if phosphite utilisation did indeed scale with the extent of hydrothermal activity on early Earth, which would support our hypothesis of hydrothermal phosphite sources.
The results from this work will advance our understanding of how early life was sustained. If we can show that hydrothermal vents are significant sources of bioavailable phosphite and reduced nitrogen, this would have major implications for the habitability of other volcanically active planets. The analytical setup that will be developed and optimised under the umbrella of this project would open up further possibilities for future studies of ancient and modern nutrient cycling. For example, the experimental setup will allow investigating the behaviour of critical metals under hydrothermal conditions, and the analytical suite will create new opportunities to study N and P cycling in modern polluted settings. The facilities would thus create a new analytical centre in the UK and place the PI at the frontier of biogeochemical research.
The major thrust of this project is the fundamental question how early life was sustained. Several lines of evidence suggest that primary productivity was severely suppressed throughout the Precambrian, because phosphate and nitrate - the two major forms of P and N in the modern ocean - were much less soluble in ancient oceans. We hypothesise that submarine volcanism, which sets off hydrothermal convection cells through oceanic crust, generated reduced forms of nitrogen and phosphorus and thus created important point sources of nutrients for early life. To test this hypothesis, we will develop a new hydrothermal reaction chamber that allows us to conduct experiments under elevated pressures and temperatures, reminiscent of deep-sea hydrothermal vents. Different gases (N2, CO2, CH4), fluids (saline, fresh), phosphate phases and catalytic minerals (magnetite, sulphides) will be added to the reactor under a range of conditions. The products will be analysed for nitrogen isotopic ratios (15N/14N) and phosphorus speciation.
The main objectives are:
* Measure the isotopic fractionation associated with abiotic hydrothermal N2 reduction to ammonium and organic amines. These results will allow us to re-visit the existing N isotopic record (including organic-rich sedimentary rocks and hydrothermally influenced strata) and determine if hydrothermal N sources played a significant role in Precambrian biogeochemical cycles.
* Quantify the yield of hydrothermal phosphate reduction to phosphite. Phosphite, a reduced form of P, is significantly more soluble than phosphate. Previous experiments have shown that phosphite can be produced from the reduction of simple phosphate salts. We will conduct new experiments with natural phosphate minerals to derive reaction efficiencies for hydrothermal scenarios. We will also measure how much phosphite is taken up into minerals to create a calibration for geochemical measurements of phosphate in the rock record.
* Reconstruct the radiation of phosphite-using enzymes across the tree of life. Phylogenetic data and molecular clocks will be used to infer the birth, loss and transfer of relevant genes. This analysis will reveal if phosphite utilisation did indeed scale with the extent of hydrothermal activity on early Earth, which would support our hypothesis of hydrothermal phosphite sources.
The results from this work will advance our understanding of how early life was sustained. If we can show that hydrothermal vents are significant sources of bioavailable phosphite and reduced nitrogen, this would have major implications for the habitability of other volcanically active planets. The analytical setup that will be developed and optimised under the umbrella of this project would open up further possibilities for future studies of ancient and modern nutrient cycling. For example, the experimental setup will allow investigating the behaviour of critical metals under hydrothermal conditions, and the analytical suite will create new opportunities to study N and P cycling in modern polluted settings. The facilities would thus create a new analytical centre in the UK and place the PI at the frontier of biogeochemical research.
Organisations
Publications
Baidya A
(2023)
On-line chloride removal from ion chromatography for trace-level analyses of phosphite and other anions by coupled ion chromatography-inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry
in Rapid Communications in Mass Spectrometry
Barth P
(2021)
MOVES - IV. Modelling the influence of stellar XUV-flux, cosmic rays, and stellar energetic particles on the atmospheric composition of the hot Jupiter HD 189733b
in Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society
Barth P
(2023)
Isotopic constraints on lightning as a source of fixed nitrogen in Earth's early biosphere
in Nature Geoscience
Boocock T
(2023)
A primary magmatic source of nitrogen to Earth's crust
in Nature Geoscience
Boocock T
(2023)
Equilibrium partitioning and isotopic fractionation of nitrogen between biotite, plagioclase, and K-feldspar during magmatic differentiation
in Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta
Hutchison W
(2021)
Mantle sources and magma evolution in Europe's largest rare earth element belt (Gardar Province, SW Greenland): New insights from sulfur isotopes
in Earth and Planetary Science Letters
Jones S
(2023)
Fluid Flow, Alteration, and Timing of Cu-Ag Mineralization at the White Pine Sediment-Hosted Copper Deposit, Michigan, USA
in Economic Geology
Liao T
(2022)
Phylogenomic Evidence for the Origin of Obligate Anaerobic Anammox Bacteria Around the Great Oxidation Event.
in Molecular biology and evolution
Liu Y
(2022)
A potential linkage between excess silicate-bound nitrogen and N2-rich natural gas in sedimentary reservoirs
in Chemical Geology
Lumiste K
(2021)
Constraining the conditions of phosphogenesis: Stable isotope and trace element systematics of Recent Namibian phosphatic sediments
in Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta
Mateos K
(2023)
The evolution and spread of sulfur cycling enzymes reflect the redox state of the early Earth.
in Science advances
Meixnerová J
(2021)
Mercury abundance and isotopic composition indicate subaerial volcanism prior to the end-Archean "whiff" of oxygen.
in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America
Mifsud DV
(2021)
A preliminary study into the use of tree-ring and foliar geochemistry as bio-indicators for vehicular NOx pollution in Malta.
in Isotopes in environmental and health studies
Moreras-Marti A
(2021)
Volcanic controls on the microbial habitability of Mars-analogue hydrothermal environments
in Geobiology
Moreras-Marti A
(2021)
Quadruple sulfur isotope biosignatures from terrestrial Mars analogue systems
in Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta
Nielson G
(2024)
Estuaries house Earth's oldest known non-marine eukaryotes
in Precambrian Research
Ossa Ossa F
(2022)
Moderate levels of oxygenation during the late stage of Earth's Great Oxidation Event
in Earth and Planetary Science Letters
Shields G
(2021)
A template for an improved rock-based subdivision of the pre-Cryogenian timescale
in Journal of the Geological Society
Stueken E
(2023)
An isotopically light nitrogen reservoir in the ocean: evidence from ferromanganese crusts
in Geochemical Perspectives Letters
Stüeken E
(2021)
Sedimentary exhalative venting of bioavailable nitrogen into the early ocean
in Earth and Planetary Science Letters
Stüeken E
(2021)
Prebiotic Chemistry and the Origin of Life
Stüeken E
(2023)
Evaluating the biosignature potential of nitrogen concentrations in graphite and associated K-silicates
in Chemical Geology
Stüeken E
(2023)
Hydrothermal Regeneration of Ammonium as a Basin-Scale Driver of Primary Productivity
in Astrobiology
Stüeken E
(2021)
Hydrothermal recycling of sedimentary ammonium into oceanic crust and the Archean ocean at 3.24 Ga
in Geology
Stüeken E
(2021)
Transient deep-water oxygenation recorded by rare Mesoproterozoic phosphorites, South Urals
in Precambrian Research
Stüeken E
(2021)
Reconstructing Nitrogen Sources to Earth's Earliest Biosphere at 3.7 Ga
in Frontiers in Earth Science
Stüeken EE
(2023)
Exploring the Effects of Residence Time on the Utility of Stable Isotopes and S/C Ratios as Proxies for Ocean Connectivity.
in ACS earth & space chemistry
Tao J
(2022)
A stable and moderate nitrate pool in largely anoxic Mesoproterozoic oceans and implications for eukaryote evolution
in Precambrian Research
Tino CJ
(2023)
Are Large Sulfur Isotope Variations Biosignatures in an Ancient, Impact-Induced Hydrothermal Mars Analog?
in Astrobiology
Xia L
(2022)
Linkages between nitrogen cycling, nitrogen isotopes, and environmental properties in paleo-lake basins
in GSA Bulletin
Xu D
(2021)
Feedback Between Carbon and Nitrogen Cycles During the Ediacaran Shuram Excursion
in Frontiers in Earth Science
Title | Linkages between nitrogen cycling, nitrogen isotopes, and environmental properties in paleo-lake basins (dataset) |
Description | |
Type Of Material | Database/Collection of data |
Year Produced | 2022 |
Provided To Others? | Yes |
URL | https://risweb.st-andrews.ac.uk/portal/en/datasets/linkages-between-nitrogen-cycling-nitrogen-isotop... |