Migrant women's practices of survival and resistance in the UK's hostile environment - the necropolitics and everyday violence of the 'subject to imm

Lead Research Organisation: Birkbeck, University of London
Department Name: Psychosocial Studies

Abstract

"The people who died after their boats sank in the English Channel are refugees NOT migrants. They ARE men, women
and children fleeing from persecution from countries like Syria, Afghanistan, Iran, Yemen [...] People fleeing these
countries are refugees not migrants." (Positive Action in Housing Fundraiser, 2021: unpagented, emphasis original)
This quote is from a recent fundraising appeal by a national refugee charity, in response to the death of 27 people who
attempted to cross the English Channel in November 2021. It illustrates how solidarity with refugees is increasingly appealed to
in terms of them being '#RefugeesNotMigrants'. The problematic implication behind such appeals is that the rights, presence
and lives of those who are not perceived as genuine refugees - the 'economic' or 'illegal' migrants - are constructed as less
worthy or legitimate, feeding into postcolonial racist constructions of 'ungrievable lives' (Butler, 2016). Scholarship on
migration in the UK also disproportionately focuses on the experiences of refugees and asylum-seekers. While critical analysis
of the asylum regime is much needed, the lack of academic engagement with other forms of precarious 'leave' (permission to
remain in the UK) can be seen to reflect and reproduce dominant conceptions of un/worthy presence implicated in this
hierarchical framework. Overall, many aspects of the hostile environment that do not relate to asylum remain overlooked in
public, political and academic discussions, though their effects are no less insidious. The 'No Recourse to Public Funds' (NRPF)
policy is exemplary of this, impacting anyone who is legally 'subject to immigration control' including people without any valid
leave. My project seeks to problematise exclusionary forms of refugee solidarity and address the paucity of academic work on
non-asylum immigration matters, by focusing on the experiences of predominantly African migrant women in London with
NRPF. I examine NRPF as a gendered and racialised technology of 'slow violence' (Nixon, 2011), which disproportionately
pushes Black, female, single carers into conditions of homelessness and destitution by denying them access to any welfare
support (Smith et al., 2021). Drawing on Mbembe's (2003) concept of 'necropolitics', I situate NRPF as a contemporary
expression of the UK's colonial enterprise, highlighting how it reproduces the disposability of Black women's lives and their
exclusion from "wealth accumulated via colonial dispossession" (El-Enany, 2020:35). To explore alternative forms of migrant
solidarity that challenge racialised and hierarchical categories of migration, this PhD will emphasise migrant women's strategies
of survival and resistance. I employ Black Feminist and intersectional analysis (Collins, 1990; Nnaemeka, 2003) to look not
only at the various discriminations that migrant women face, but also their varied everyday responses. In particular, I emphasise
the critical role that access to information about legal rights and support services plays in a deliberately hostile and unnavigable
legal system. Consequently, this PhD will pay attention to knowledge-sharing as a key aspect of women's resistance to racist and
discriminatory legal systems. It will explore women's counter-spaces of activism, solidarity, collective learning and care, and
how these can be better understood and promoted.

Publications

10 25 50

Studentship Projects

Project Reference Relationship Related To Start End Student Name
ES/P000592/1 01/10/2017 30/09/2027
2704971 Studentship ES/P000592/1 01/10/2022 30/09/2026 Rebekka Hoelzle