Organometallic Synthesis of Reactive Nanoparticles for Radically New Solder Materials
Lead Research Organisation:
King's College London
Department Name: Engineering
Abstract
Most conventional electronics works reliably at operating temperatures of around 100C or less. However, high temperature electronics needs to function at temperatures of 125C or higher. In the past, solders consisting mainly of lead (Pb) have been used for connecting components to printed circuit boards (PCB's). However, EU environmental legislation eliminated lead from most electronics, and is set to remove lead from even high temperature electronics by 2010. This presents a problem for oil and gas drilling equipment manufacturers in particular, as oil and gas wells are getting deeper and hence hotter (150-200C). Schlumberger, a key equipment manufacturer for oil and gas drilling, and Dynex Semiconductor, a key producer of high power electronics equipment for transport are keen to collaborate with Henkel (a supplier of solder material) and King's College London to find an alternative to lead based solders.One method of improving the reliability of lead free solder joints is to add a reactive component, such as aluminium to the solder. The aluminium reacts strongly with the surfaces on the electronic component and the PCB that are to be joined. Once the aluminium has reacted to form an intermetallic compound (IMC) layer between the solder and the joining surfaces, this IMC layer remains stable. By contrast in a normal solder joint, the IMC layer continues to grow at high temperatures and, being brittle, becomes the weakest link in the solder joint. So why not just add aluminium to the solder to form a new alloy? Many groups have tried, but all have failed until now. It turns out that the very properties that make aluminium attractive as an additive to solder, make its practical use in solders difficult. The high reactivity of aluminium causes the solder to oxidise before the solder joint can form during the soldering process. This means that the solder does not wet and adhere to the circuit board at all. What is needed is a method of releasing the aluminium into the solder after the solder has wetted the joining surfaces. The key innovation of this project is the use of nanoparticles of aluminium, coated with a metal which is easily wetted by the molten solder during soldering (e.g. silver). The coating will dissolve in the molten solder, and rapidly release the aluminium into the solder after the solder has wetted the joining surface. Only then will the stable aluminium based IMC be formed. Producing and coating the nanoparticles before the aluminium oxidizes will be challenging but should be possible with the organometallic synthesis routes chosen. This project will determine the optimum composition and morphology of the particles and will assess their impact on reliability. If the project is successful, then there will be a sizeable market for the nanoparticles engineered in the project. Henkel have already stated their wish to buy in the nanoparticles rather than to produce them in-house so the formation of a spin out company to produce the nanoparticles is one of the key project objectives. There may also be applications outside of high temperature electronics, especially in the mobile electronics area where miniaturisation of solder joints is causing reliability concerns.
Publications
Hiren Kotadia (Co-Author)
(2010)
High temperature solders containing Aluminium
Hiren Kotadia (Co-Author)
(2012)
Reliability of electronics assembled using SAC+Zn solder pastes
Hiren Kotadia (Co-Author)
(2010)
Effect of Al and Zn alloying elements on Sn-3.8Ag-0.7Cu and Sn-3.6Ag solder reaction with Cu and Ni(P) substrate
Kotadia H
(2013)
Electronics Assembly and High Temperature Reliability Using Sn-3.8Ag-0.7Cu Solder Paste With Zn Additives
in IEEE Transactions on Components, Packaging and Manufacturing Technology
Kotadia H
(2012)
Massive spalling of Cu-Zn and Cu-Al intermetallic compounds at the interface between solders and Cu substrate during liquid state reaction
in Journal of Applied Physics
Kotadia H
(2014)
A review: On the development of low melting temperature Pb-free solders
in Microelectronics Reliability
Kotadia H
(2019)
Influence of Zn Concentration on Interfacial Intermetallics During Liquid and Solid State Reaction of Hypo and Hypereutectic Sn-Zn Solder Alloys
in Journal of Electronic Materials
Kotadia H
(2010)
Reactions of Sn-3.5Ag-Based Solders Containing Zn and Al Additions on Cu and Ni(P) Substrates
in Journal of Electronic Materials
Kotadia H
(2012)
Intermetallic compound growth suppression at high temperature in SAC solders with Zn addition on Cu and Ni-P substrates
in Journal of Alloys and Compounds
Description | We have found that it is possible to produce solders incorporating reactive elements as hypothesized in the proposal. We determined the optimal particle size for maximizing uptake into the solder and found that surface contamination on the powders played a crucial role into whether the particles were absorbed into the solder. We found however that our original choice of reactive element, aluminium, did not work as intended as the protective barrier layer spalled away. By contrast we found that zinc did form a suitable barrier layer and did act as a protective layer as we had hoped, increasing the reliability of solder joints at high temperatures. |
Exploitation Route | The papers arising from the project are quite highly cited; especially "Intermetallic compound growth suppression at high temperature in SAC solders with Zn addition on Cu and Ni-P substrates" cited 45 times. This indicates that this type of solder has potential for use in industry. Henkel, one of the project partners, has been working on a rival technology and have promoted that solder brand in preference to the zinc based solders that they produced for the project. However, there is a possibility that they return to the zinc based solders in future. |
Sectors | Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Electronics,Energy,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Transport |
Description | This study on the interactions between nanoparticles, micro-scale particles and solder materials during solder processing have led to a new type of improved solder material that could enable one industrial partner, Henkel, capture a larger share of a £60M high-temperature solder market while potentially increasing the reliability and performance of oilfield drilling and monitoring tools for another, Schlumberger. Henkel have successfully manufactured the new solder paste and confirmed that it can be processed using conventional electronics manufacturing techniques. Schlumberger have trialled the new solder paste for high temperature performance resulting in confirmation that at high temperatures, the main cause of failure in solder joints, intermetallic compound growth, is reduced by a factor of two or higher. Beneficiaries: Henkel, Schlumberger, Dynex Semiconductor Contribution Method: Henkel now has an additional solder paste based on technology unlike that of any of their competitors which they are able to offer to customers with special needs in high temperature electronics. |
Sector | Aerospace/ Defence and Marine,Electronics,Manufacturing/ including Industrial Biotechology |
Impact Types | Economic |
Title | Zn+SAC solder paste |
Description | Solder paste based on industry standard Sn-Ag-Cu (SAC) solder but with zinc addition created and tested. |
Type Of Technology | New Material/Compound |